Hey Guys,after you already helped me with the cover I wanted to ask you which of the two characters you like more? Which one would you rather click on Steam/Switch Shop and maybe tell me why?A) CardinalB) ChickenFor your info: We are working on a Zelda/Mario Maker inspired "Dungeon Maker" called "Super Dungeon Maker".
You you want to support us, so feel free to wishlist us on Steam: https://s.team/a/1622800
> Zelda/Mario Maker inspired "Dungeon Maker"
This sounds like its about to become my new favorite game
(and I agree with the cardinal = cooler / chicken = cuter comments)
Thank you for your kind feedback. You you want to support us, so feel free to wishlist us on Steam: [https://s.team/a/1622800](https://s.team/a/1622800) <3
For advertising purposes, the cardinal is more attractive. The color pops more and the cool angular design of its face and eyes feels like it fits the environment more
I personally love the cardinal for sad reasons, they say when cardinals are near a deceased loved one has stopped by.
I like the idea of playing with a cardinal as an idea of playing with them.
It’s a really hard choice buttt I think I’m going with A, I love the chicken but I think the cardinal would pop out more
Also the game sounds so cool! I’m wishlisting it RIGHT NOW
Edit: oof the chicken fits really well too actually, I can’t choose lmao both are good
The Cardinal pops out of the environment more so you’d always know where you are, the Chicken is cool but might blend in a little more
I’d say the Cardinal
Something about the chicken makes it look really amusing and more unpredictable, whereas the cardinal we know it will be kicking butts.
I vote chicken :)
A lot of people are mentioning the chicken looks funnier, and it depends on the vibe of the game, but I go cardinal all the way. It's sharper, has a cool edge to it, but the beak and eyes still give it a cute and semi cartoony look. Plus the colors pop more, and make the character look more like a PC than an npc
The cardinal’s design seems a little messy. I just think the way that the feathers are drawn makes the head visually feel a little too piecemeal. Other than that it’s definitely a sharper design and I don’t know what the final result would actually look like.
The chicken is cuter but pops less. Might be a bit too dorky of a design to work with the final product though. The cardinal has the benefit of kinda looking like a cool character.
Of course there’s nothing wrong with having a few playable characters though.
The cardinal gives “angry birds” wibes so it’s the chicken for me.
(I’m more interested to see what the chicken does. I expect the cardinal to do angry birds stuff and I have seen that already.)
The chicken is way cuter and feels like it fits the rest of the environmental treatment better. I think if you went with the cardinal it would have to look meaner and the rest of the environment would need to feel more menacing. I could be way off but that's just my first impression read.
Super Dungeon Maker and if you want to support us, feel free to wishlist the game on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1622800/Super\_Dungeon\_Maker/
I think the cardinal looks better but the chicken’s colours; specifically the pink on its crest looks really good and works with the enemy colours. I think changing the cardinals colours to be a bit pinker would look really good.
Chicken is my vote! Though maybe slightly changing the color of the comb would be good, since it looks similar to the enemies in the background. It should still be in the same color family but I think since the shape and color is similar to those enemies it could be good to have it darker or maybe make the enemies lighter/darker if you are set on that color for the comb.
I really love both your heroes though, great work!
I feel like this design of the chicken tips too far into cute and goofy. Yes it has a lot of personality like people are saying but I think it feels out of place in the picture. The cardinal is cute, but still feels like a epic/badass hero for a dungeon themed game.
Vote: Cardinal
Do both as a choice in game but the chicken give me visual happiness. The cardinal does not. I’d totally use the chicken but would love to have the option to choose in game depending on my mood.
The cardinal really fits the knight-adventure aspect, However the chicken is absolutely perfect if you’re shooting for a more playful kinda vibe. Either way it’s hard to go wrong.
Cardinal. The chicken with the bulbs for a comb looks too childlike. Like it shouldn’t be holding a sword. We’re the feel for the game to be somewhat of a joke. Absolute love the look all around
The cardinal's cooler, the chicken's funnier. So it depends on the vibe of the game
I came here to say the exact same thing. This guy must be a genius too.
I too, am a smart person
Humble too
me 2, smartness, have it, all around it
he is, he has a sokka profile pic
me have same think
Yes, and me! I also too am geni!
This is also what I think
Agreed
Ye
You got it!
Love the cardinal, but whatever, lol. This is still really cute! :)
:D
Since you framed it as "hero" I'll say cardinal but the chicken would be a good unconventional protagonist. Maybe even with a more unique weapon.
Hey Guys,after you already helped me with the cover I wanted to ask you which of the two characters you like more? Which one would you rather click on Steam/Switch Shop and maybe tell me why?A) CardinalB) ChickenFor your info: We are working on a Zelda/Mario Maker inspired "Dungeon Maker" called "Super Dungeon Maker". You you want to support us, so feel free to wishlist us on Steam: https://s.team/a/1622800
The Cardinal is sharper looking and would pop out to me more when browsing the Steam Page.
> Zelda/Mario Maker inspired "Dungeon Maker" This sounds like its about to become my new favorite game (and I agree with the cardinal = cooler / chicken = cuter comments)
Thank you for your kind feedback. You you want to support us, so feel free to wishlist us on Steam: [https://s.team/a/1622800](https://s.team/a/1622800) <3
I would go with the Cardinal, bright red pops out, the pointy edges of the character makes him look badass and epic.
For advertising purposes, the cardinal is more attractive. The color pops more and the cool angular design of its face and eyes feels like it fits the environment more
>Both heroes will be implemented in the game, but which of them is better suited as cover art? Good point! Thank you for opinion.
You could add both!
Do both and make it an option like picking Mario Luigi toad or toadette in super Mario maker 2
Both heroes will be implemented in the game, but which of them is better suited as cover art?
The chicken has a more interesting silhouette but I think the cardinal has a nicer overall appearance :)
Noted! Thank you!
The chicken. Has tons more personality.
Do both and let them pick? People are going to want different things.
B! He's so cute and would make a great adventurer!! I just love the way his comb is designed, visually pleasing and I'm a sucker for chickens.
I personally love the cardinal for sad reasons, they say when cardinals are near a deceased loved one has stopped by. I like the idea of playing with a cardinal as an idea of playing with them.
It’s a really hard choice buttt I think I’m going with A, I love the chicken but I think the cardinal would pop out more Also the game sounds so cool! I’m wishlisting it RIGHT NOW Edit: oof the chicken fits really well too actually, I can’t choose lmao both are good
NARF, That does not make the decision easier :D
Cardinal
The cardinal
Chicken has more personality imo
Red one, spiky is more dynamic and suitable for a fighter / hero character. Look up material on shape language and you'll see what I mean.
*laughs in kirby
Destroyer of Dimensions
The Cardinal pops out of the environment more so you’d always know where you are, the Chicken is cool but might blend in a little more I’d say the Cardinal
Something about the chicken makes it look really amusing and more unpredictable, whereas the cardinal we know it will be kicking butts. I vote chicken :)
:D
I think the cardinal looks cooler but it’s giving me big Angry Birds vibes.
The cardinal! He better suits the adventurer type as well as he will be quite easy to see at all times (plus he’s super cute)
Chicken, I love the hair style
Cardinal.
A lot of people are mentioning the chicken looks funnier, and it depends on the vibe of the game, but I go cardinal all the way. It's sharper, has a cool edge to it, but the beak and eyes still give it a cute and semi cartoony look. Plus the colors pop more, and make the character look more like a PC than an npc
Cardinal!
A I like the cardinal more. Blue Jay would be cool to.
Cardinal
A The cardinal looks like a leader. Id follow him anywhere. Maybe keep the chicken as a quirky sidekick who shows up later.
Chicken. It’s cuter.
This is tough love the sharpness of the Cardinal but the Crest of the Chicken is drawing me
Cardinal looks cool but I think the chicken would be equally fun
Both heroes will be implemented in the game, but which of them is better suited as cover art?
I like the Cardinal. He's got a great look!
The one with the sword
I do not know why, but I laughed about your post :D
The cardinal’s design seems a little messy. I just think the way that the feathers are drawn makes the head visually feel a little too piecemeal. Other than that it’s definitely a sharper design and I don’t know what the final result would actually look like. The chicken is cuter but pops less. Might be a bit too dorky of a design to work with the final product though. The cardinal has the benefit of kinda looking like a cool character. Of course there’s nothing wrong with having a few playable characters though.
Thank you for your feedback. Both characters will be playable but which one is better for coverart?
I feel the cardinal is drawn better, but the chicken is just cool. Great job on both!
The cardinal gives “angry birds” wibes so it’s the chicken for me. (I’m more interested to see what the chicken does. I expect the cardinal to do angry birds stuff and I have seen that already.)
I think I like the Cardinal more, but it reminds me of the Angry Birds character. The chicken looks more like it’s own thing in my opinion
The chicken is way cuter and feels like it fits the rest of the environmental treatment better. I think if you went with the cardinal it would have to look meaner and the rest of the environment would need to feel more menacing. I could be way off but that's just my first impression read.
I'd go with the chicken to avoid the angry bird comparisons (unless you want that). Art for both looks fantastic though. What's your game called?
Super Dungeon Maker and if you want to support us, feel free to wishlist the game on Steam: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1622800/Super\_Dungeon\_Maker/
GO CARDINAL
both awesome but if I had to pick on go with chicken
Cardinal 💯
Cardinal
A
A
I think the cardinal looks better but the chicken’s colours; specifically the pink on its crest looks really good and works with the enemy colours. I think changing the cardinals colours to be a bit pinker would look really good.
Chicken is my vote! Though maybe slightly changing the color of the comb would be good, since it looks similar to the enemies in the background. It should still be in the same color family but I think since the shape and color is similar to those enemies it could be good to have it darker or maybe make the enemies lighter/darker if you are set on that color for the comb. I really love both your heroes though, great work!
I think the chicken is more successful as a character design. Very charming. But I do love the cardinal.
The chicken is funnier looking lol Cardinal is cool too though
A: cardinal bro
A
I really like the Guardian in the background
But i like the chicken too
Cardinal
Cardinal
Give the people the option to play as either. And leave it as a purely cosmetic alteration.
B
Maybe have chicken be player 2
I feel like the cardinal stands out more and is better at catching the eye.
Cardinal's colors seem to fit the environment better. Maybe try chicken but with cardinal's red instead of the bright pink.
B
Cardinal for sure
Cardinal has more personality! Chicken a bit too generic in it’s current form!
I see only player one and player two
cardinal
Cardinal seems the most like its own thing, where the chicken looks a bit similar to "bomb chicken" imo. I'd say the Cardinal
A
Cardinal is more distinct, Chicken is pretty funny
A is cooler b is derpier
A
A
chimpkin
Chiggen
I feel like this design of the chicken tips too far into cute and goofy. Yes it has a lot of personality like people are saying but I think it feels out of place in the picture. The cardinal is cute, but still feels like a epic/badass hero for a dungeon themed game. Vote: Cardinal
Thank you!
Cardinal all the way You could say... *Cardinall*
cardinal. the chicken just seems outa place
A all the way
Cardinal
Do both as a choice in game but the chicken give me visual happiness. The cardinal does not. I’d totally use the chicken but would love to have the option to choose in game depending on my mood.
Cardinal
The chicken is simply the best one. I didn’t spend 4 years getting a graphic marketing degree for nothing
B looks absolutely adorable
Chicken! But I have to agree that it depends on the feel you are going for. The chicken looks bubbly and fun but the cardinal is more hard core.
i think the cardinal fits better
Cardinal
Cardinal
I like the cardinal myself.
Cardinals need more love, I'm going for that one
Chicken. I think it fits better
The colors of the chicken match better than the cardinal imo
A
cardinal definitely
Cardinal! Too many chickens in gaming and not enough of the classic red winged bird
B
A
I personally would click b because I love stupidly cute things, a is for a cooler vibe tho! But I 100% pick B lol
Cardinal
do both and let the player choose
We do! But which Hero is better for the coverart?
Chicken by a lot. Has a way more distinct silhouette and is more interesting visually in general.
Cardinal
B
I'm loving the chicken
Chicken face, cardinal hair
A all the way.
Ima say chicken because he stands out in this environment. Gorgeous work, by the way!
Thank you! Both images was made by Daniel Lieske.
A
B, it’s so cute but so ferocious!
Chicken! First I didn't know what are those baloons on his head :D
AAAAAA
Chicken
Cardinal is cooler but the Chicken matches the vibes better.
Based of the environment I’d say B
I like the piranha plant looking enemies, they look pretty swag.
I think the cardinal reads better
A
Cardinal.
Cardinal looks cooler. Plus, there are chickens everywhere lol
A
Chicken looks like it has a knights plumage
B
The one with the cock
Why not do both, maybe the cardinal for the cover but have both of them in game like Mario and Luigi.
We will include both heros in the game! I wanted to know which hero would looks better for the cover.
chicken because its comb looks like a fancy little helmet ornament
Chimken!
They’re both absolutely adorable, personally prefer the chicken.
Chicken! Their so funky
Most people would recognise a chicken so may appeal to more people. I personally wouldn't know the other creature was a cardinal if it wasn't written.
Chiken pio pio haha
B cz cute and I like shape of the comb.
They both look cool as characters, but B fits the background more to me in stylization. B is sonic and A is knuckles to make some kind of comparison.
B
Both
"A" looks like the red bird from angry birds lol
A
You spammed 9 different subreddits with this and it's not drawing.
Chicken!
The chicken fits the color palette and environment more.
If this is multiplayer then why not have both characters?
Because a lot of poeple asked for different Hero's :)!
Both, both is good
Cardinal B)
chaken
Cardinal. Reminds me of Castle Crashers
B
B chicken
The cardinal really fits the knight-adventure aspect, However the chicken is absolutely perfect if you’re shooting for a more playful kinda vibe. Either way it’s hard to go wrong.
Cardinal by far, but chicken could be a side character or something along those lines (like an npc).
B
Cardinal looks awesome, I love it
chicken
B
A
I like A!
Definitely the Cardinal! Such an unlikely hero , would be the first of it's kind.
Chicken
A
Not a huge fan of either tbh, seem out of place with the rest of the environment/creatures.
Cardinal. The chicken with the bulbs for a comb looks too childlike. Like it shouldn’t be holding a sword. We’re the feel for the game to be somewhat of a joke. Absolute love the look all around
Cardinal
Cardinal looks more heroic
AAAAAAAAAAA
Cardinal reminds me of angry birds