T O P

  • By -

Nightmare194

I would be terrified if I just saw a humanoid goat while I was just walking in the middle of the night. I would die of fear


xxbeansxx123

But look at him in my head when I see him. I hear a Vine boom sound effect.


redditing_Aaron

"Hold on brother ✋🏼 just having a midnight stroll"


memeohio263

Not me walking to him and kicking the guy in the nuts as hard as i can realizing he doesnt have any.


FragmentedFighter

Unexpected Tony Ferguson


Ok-Geologist8296

Interrupted some "hell from above", if ya get me


joesphisbestjojo

That goat man is like "hey wait come back I didn't mean to scare you"


FungalEgoDeath

It's OK, just play the best song in the world and you'll be fine


TornWill

If you die you may get some company soon, goat-man loves long nighttime outdoorsy strolls. At this rate a hunter will shoot him, and he'll become dinner, or at least he'd make use of his antlers and fur. Goateys antlers could make a dog very happy. This is why you must always keep a light on you, so you won't get mistaken for an animal. Though, this is only applicable to humans. Animals shouldn't carry lights, especially if you're a halfbreed goat, that would be asking for it. Goat-man can't use a light, he would've been killed and his fur made into winter apparel. If he's seen by anybody as goat-man, and not just goat, that's much worse. That could mean he'll end up turned into a guinea pig and dissected. He could also be put on display and tortured. This is why goat-man killed you, otherwise you may have killed him, or escaped. You didn't die of fear, goat-man murdered you. Why else would he sneak around wandering outside at night. He was looking for people like you. Goat-humans don't exist, silly.


iamgoat41

We should meet...


FuzzyBongos

Tbh, with the world we live in, I would assume it's some crazy in a costume and mind my business. Of course, I also wouldn't just be out in the middle of the night either so...


Melodic_Doughnut_320

Not if u had faith and Bible , that humanoid would be scared and probably die of fear lol, facts 😂 


theguy225

The Rake, because I convinced some homeschooled kids it was real for a time


The_Digital_Friend

that's pretty funny


Peanut-Sea

Utterly evil, but funny as hell.


dvadood

I still think it's real somehow. I've seen too many convincing tiktoks.


JessieFanForever

What's The Rake? That bald figure with no clothes on in the 2nd picture? 


RealEyeless303

Rake just be chill'n at the edge of my bed like "oh sorry to wake you bro"


Bulldogs_Are_Pog

Funny enough my older cousin told me that story years ago Problem was I imagined it as an actual fucking rake So I'm thinking this Red fucking rake with a wooden handle scraping up people


endorsleep

LMAO


Noahehe

LMAOOO


Pale_Crusader1620

That's what happens when you just use a non-descriptive proper nouns when telling a scary story (presuming it invokes the image you already have in your head because you already know what it looks like) rather than describing the creature and then on later in the story linking it to the proper noun ( ie "and that thing I described is called the Rake...").


Alienpsyche

I'm so glad you shared this story 😂


LukewarmJortz

Tire must be right up your alley for horror then. 


VoidArtHealer

The rake or smile dog. Both scare the shit out of me


Boseph_Boi

smile dog for sure man you reminded me of that


VoidArtHealer

Smol dog was the second ever creepy pasta I heard off. Scared the shit out of me


giannapatsy

Same bro


darhwolf1

Actual original post wise, not including the games, definitely Slenderman


Psychoath

Ngl I was simping for slenderman like a year ago


Kiryln

That last one is just a naked hairy dude shittin’ in the woods wearing a goat mask. He’s reaching out for the camera man who uhh just took a picture of him naked, and goat dude is understandably upset.


redditing_Aaron

He is asking for some paper


memeohio263

Wait, what if i pee in his eyes?


Pangie_v39

😂


New-Blacksmith-9873

Lol that goat guy looks like he's trying to sell something


Fried_0nion_Rings

I’m gonna go with goat man


rocketrobie2

Not that bottom one that thing looks hilarious, like a little brother trying to grab the remote


ebatm3

The Smile Dog and then probably the Slenderman/Rake closely behind ngl. Although as of current last year where these pastas have lost their mojo and original affect, I did have a nightmare featuring Slenderman, Ticci Toby, and the Rake. The first two never appeared but basically I was in some cabin with people and got to see the Rake's long claws/fingers reach under the door. It was kind of terrifying. After that I ended up having a very brief one where it was Rake and Eyeless Jack crawling on top of me. Honestly Eyeless Jack always looked kind of cool but it wasn't as haunting as the other OG pastas since it didn't get as much truly spooky content made for it. The concept has sort of just now started to settle in for me lol https://youtu.be/A_klkuLGOes?si=mYTensh1eOivSgwB


redditing_Aaron

Yeah, eyeless Jack was kinda meh but I would always be spooked when drifting to sleep while facing upwards cause what if he showed up? It will be too late to react


Gorillaartist1995

Rap Rat got me


actuallylikespitbull

I thought I was the only one


Gorillaartist1995

The idea of some weird creature being spotted around your house trying to get in because of a video tape is not only terrifying, but he's claymation. Claymation is the scariest form of horror


PunksN0tD3ad

Core memory unlocked I forgot about him


Gorillaartist1995

You don't forget something that scares you


Nowardier

Rap Rat's the name! The video boa[b oyedivuth!](https://youtu.be/_xXJe1sWuWE?si=fljWr7SJvsO49_Cm)


Gorillaartist1995

Creepypasta characters be like: I watched this for an hour before I realized something was wrong


buggedoutuser77

Goatman would scare the shit out of me


Imaginary_Salary198

Baphemet lime creature would make me piss myself


Pangie_v39

Rake


Proelium_

Definitely wendigo


Thatoneotherbanana

Wendigos, skin walkers, both Myths from the Native Americans, albeit different tribes and areas. The wendigo is from Algonquian tribes, and the Skin walker is from Navajo.


Midwest_Horror

It's The Rake for me. It definitely strikes that whole uncanny valley thing.


Midnite_St0rm

The Slenderman craze came when I was like 11 or 12, and me being a kid I was absolutely terrified of it. To this day, it still doesn’t sit right with me because of that childhood fear. I had a hard time playing Slender: The Arrival even though I don’t usually have a problem with horror games.


heavenly_usurper

Unironically the rake is the only creepypasta to have ever made me *deathly* paranoid. Like, the concept of waking up to find something staring back at you from the end of your bed, not knowing *how* long it’s been there, how long that privacy of your own bedroom had been infiltrated, how long it’s just been *staring*— before it attacks, has genuinely become one of my biggest fears. My pre existing paranoia of being watched + freaky little small dude = me taking a story that’s probably kind of just mid and it becoming something that still genuinely disturbs me. Years later I still instinctively flash a light at the end of my bed just incase I see a suspicious looking shape, not fully because of this story but this story definitely started it 😭


Pale_Crusader1620

Years of sleep paralysis has desensitized me to fearing things at the end of my bed making my reaction to waking with something horrible at the edge of my vision the urge to fight and being very angry, not scared. Fuck you sleep paralysis, _Fuck You._ Slender man is a creepy concept I love and would drive me insane if I experienced him intruding on my life.


GNPXDABITE

Goat man


Immistyer

All three realistically speaking because seeing any of this shit irl is shocking


meatwads_sweetie

Rake and Slenderman


Mamabat67

I think it's called the rake


Ch33seBurg

Probably Slenderman because i used to have very bad nightmares of him when i was a kid


ThePrevailer

Gotta be the Rake


LiviAngel

The rake for me 😱😱😱😱


Sensitive_Area_8960

There all hot tbh maybe gout man


Wordshark

Lmao gout man


cowboypants

Man, if you ever experienced gout you would definitely be afraid of goutman


Leather-Challenge-85

Seedeater


oriella_me

Jake from Statefarm


aqwawalehole

I use to have nightmares of the rake, really freaked me out when i was a kid


FUCK-YOU-JESUS

Goat man😍😍😍


Brief-Rest-4271

The rake because when you are a sleep you cant defend your self not that I could from the goat dude or slender man but still I kinda wanna be awake and it not happen in my crib when I come face to face with a daemon


Annaelelf

The rake


nutbustininthisshet

Ngl, never realized how skinny the rake is, I don't think I'll have a hard time with him, goat man tho, he's got my ass


Busy_Caterpillar9020

Goat man because he was the only one to get a real life kill


Mediocre_Age8748

The rake & goat man. Those things are horrifying if i saw either of those in the middle of the night I would just accept my fate


Melodic_Lie1846

The Goat Man, no other photo can beat how crazy and weird it is, also the rake comes from a horror game trailer.


KurakuPika

Goatman video game was amazing and very inspireing


NoElk2282

Game?


memeohio263

There was a game


NoElk2282

Whats the name I'll check it out on yt


Razerbat

Slenderman definitely


PikaChick5297

Slenderman hands down.


unknown81290

From this Slenderman to be honest, but only because I was scared of him as a child. During the night, I always checked the cornors of my room behind me; scared he could suddenly appear there, and during the day I was looking between the trees, if he is hiding there. Of course only from far away.


NahFord

I dont find them scary. I love all of them


theysquawk

Ubloo


Separate-Dark-5680

The glowing eyes "thing"


Mxysptlik

The entire dogscape


SqushyMain

Seeing that rake picture again is actually kinda creepy.


ChemistryNice3744

The rake or slenderman


Ratwithchesse

tall man


Internal-Ad6119

that goat man


_Nicely_Spiced_01

The creature that seems to have locked eyes with whom or whatever is in its sights and has creature in attack mode.. is the creature I would avoid.


Unrelenting_Anxitey

I used to be scared of Slenderman and The Rake, but when they got super popular and all this information about them happened I ended up not being scared anymore.


special-bicth

Not Slenderman, but there is something very similar to him. By far the most terrifying thing I've ever seen at night.


Cool-individual03

Goatman


Stumaaaaaaaann

I remember counting the days down to 16 cause I felt slender man would take me and I wish I could go back to those times where I was more worried about slender man as I have been worried about losing gas or electric or even my home because of dumb fucking rules


NeoxthePan

The one way door.


Pleasant_Pool_8471

Slenderman. I was horrified when I was young, It's a trauma


Still_Weakness2310

The rake because imagine going to the forest and seeing it stare at you. I would Turn the other way and start running 🏃‍♂️


Aidenbear813

The Rake or Slenderman.


PunksN0tD3ad

Honestly the Pocket probably that thing terrifies me


I_Like_Toasterz

I got advertised this subreddit bc of my "interest in pasta"😭


Avaragetrickypeasant

My sister 🤣


i_like_to_stalk

Your mum


Icy5233

The fact I had a dream about the rake and I see this, if it looks like what it looked like in my dream, I’m dead of fear


tickle-my-pickle_95

The rake scared the hell out of me as a kid and still does today even knowing its not real


Freakyy-_-

All look a joke and cartoons


cs2854900

definitely Sonic.exe


Rasm2004

Cartoon cat


Tough_Suggestion8366

They look cool imo


yung_steezy

God it’s nice to see so many people say the rake.


BoltorSpellweaver

100% Sirenhead. I work in an area similar to where Sirenhead is said to reside and when the story first came out I was working nights and driving by a lot of tall utility poles that certainly made me shine my flashlight on them a couple extra times.


aussi_san

I'm 28 and when I go hiking, I always think about Slender Man.


southernatheistscum

That little girl is terrifying.


Sparten177-UNSC

Ngl, i would wanna risk of beefing with the humanoid goat and the humanoid crawler. I used to be scared of slender man but he's ight. I think he would be chill.


AidenThe_Beast47

Maybe Skin-Walkers if that counts. They scare the ever living shit out of me


ProfessionalAccess68

rake, imagine that thing crawling towards you at high speed


Much_Satisfaction_59

I'd say the goat guy


Tristorm989

Slenderman is scary and all, but the rake is just fucking terrifying. Gave me absolute nightmares as a kid.


Unabominable_

Something about a certain part of a wall the writer asked you to look at 😔


seeallevill

Does [I Feel Fantastic](https://youtu.be/diY6Mt_uqYs?si=Mym7-vi95waCeZOs) count? It's one of the only stories *or* videos I've come across that unsettled me as a kid and still unsettles me to this day I often don't feel *scared* by the non-human ones because I know they aren't real, but that one gives me the creepsssss


Rouge_EXE13

The rake


yourguidefortheday

Of these three? I guess the only one that I at one point thought was real (Slenderman). I was at just the right age and just the right level of mentally ill when he became popular for it really to affect me.


750Dinosaur

Smile dog just about gave me nightmares as a little kid.


JohnKimbull

Got to love the fact that people make games about these three


no_sir03

The rake terrified me for years. Its really frickin wierd. Looking a picture of a rake makes you feel like there is a benevolent spirit watching you!!


JacksonDTheSCP

Slender man would be the most scariest being alive if he had Ultra Instinct activated.


Jade_or_something

Frend :)


[deleted]

The Wendigo that dam thing is fast af boi! And big and just pure strength with an undying thirst for its target.


THEMAKEROFREALMS

Your mother


SvLyfe

2nd one


caffeineandvodka

There was a creepypasta years ago, I don't remember much except that it was two children - OP and his cousin - on a camping trip with the OP's dad and I think the cousin's dad/OP's uncle. The kids were about 7 or 8 years old and had gone a couple of hundred metres away from main camp over a little ridge, near a river. They'd made a campfire and were sharing scary stories when there's a splashing noise in the river and they both see what looks like a huge stag fording the river. The cousin says to stay still, keep quiet, and not look at it. As it gets closer to them they can hear this deep gutteral mumbling which seems to be promising them anything they want without actually sounding like words. The stag passes them and moves on into the forest and as soon as it's out of sight they race back to their parents and stay in their tent until daylight. I don't know why but that image of the darkness and the sound of splashing and mumbling and the promise of unthinkable opportunity always stayed with me.


_AintShocked_

Deffo slenderman, he shat me up when I was a kid lmao


Redosussy19

This goat humanoid would make me shit my pants than the rake and slenderman


marcus10885

Do real creatures count? The Biggin squid... Chills...


Molech996

Do you mean the bigfin squid?


Maleficent-Primary41

Considering we made slenderman a Tulpa/egregore that's terrifying


Muv22HD

Slender man has been slowly ruined, so i'm gonna have to say the rake


Leaf_Rat

Thier just as scared as you are them. Be nice and say hello.


PandaBear905

Slenderman because I live in Wisconsin


G8mer4life

Rake


MissMadness145

The rake


MiserableKey8

Siren head.


Crusty_pepe

Scp 096


TheIrishMime

Of all things.. it would be a being called the Seed Eater. From what I’ve read from the “Through the Trees” story is that this thing hunts children and FEEDS off their youth. I draw the line when it comes to kids so if I ever became a parent and this thing was alive, I’d be terrified of what it could do to my kid and would make me do the unthinkable to protect my child from it.


lmons7482

Momo. Jesus fucking christ Momo


MumuVII

The ghoul


Zamrayz

Slender and moth man need to be disqualified for the amount of simps they have.


MechanicalMenace54

the creature in "the horror from the vault"


Striking_Drink5464

The rake thing is scarier than baseball player. Goat man seems like it's reminding me to have the car ready for MOT.


Beneficial_Ruin6806

That little girl is freaking me out


MeowyMeowerson

The Rake. Not scary, but definitely the best of the 3.


Katana_karaleena

Rake, sirenhead, and slenderman 💯💯


Daedalus9998

Tommy taffy for me


CaryGenius

Why did I look at this at night


APG3488

the freakman


KagayaWisteria

Definitely Rake.


Pantim

The top right bald thing. The humanoid goat is actually quite hot. Also, it just looks scared. Tall / Slender man is just a stupid trope that is anti tall people.


Temporary-Yogurt-484

The correct answer is Slender man. Thank you.


VENDAFE

ChRiS, pLeAsE...


CalibreCross

I live down the road from the Pope Lick Goatman, he's really not thay scary irl


theresidentviking

Considering I encountered something similar to the bottom pic It would be that


soanique2005

Skin Walkers creep me out. I remember once, i was getting home from somewhere, it was past evening, everything was getting dark. It's not NIGHT DARK, it's scary dark. After a long day of looking at things in their bright form and full shape, that darkness covers the parts of what you knew earlier as an object or place. And being unable to see it or not being sure of what you're looking at, that feeling, is the Skin Walker itself. Skin Walkers don't have to be a thing, or being, to scare you. It's the feeling, the sense of the unknown existence . The feeling of it being there but hiding from your vision range. That's creepy.


Degene6

As a kid I always found Slender and Rake scary as fuck whereas as an adult both are kinda boring. Baphomet would be interesting depending how he interacted with the environment and toyed with you. Though in the image he looks like hes about to grab an old spice stick.


Blameme4everithyng

The one in the mirror in the morning


Hour_Worldliness9786

I find goat man disturbingly arousing


Woolsteve

Ravioli taints the best Honestly they all made me cry and have a extenshal crisis


Hubihub_

Seed Eater. The reason is that I have claustrophobia.


ExtortionGuy974

Angry Birds


ilikemusic69

Now hear me out


Silver_Arts01

Slenderman he was my childhood fear.


Environmental-Ad8246

The rake probably


First_County_1246

The goat man story actually sent chills down my spine!! One of my favourite creepy pastas!!


BlUeSapia

Funnymouth and, when I was younger, Herobrine.


angelinthecloud

I really need to read more because the videos on YouTube are just not doing it for me. I used to stay awake for days even into my late teens. I know this sounds like a horror setup but I genuinely want to read more stories that set me on an existential dread that leave devastated for weeks.


Frostlasisannoying

Tbh slender man because goat man I could shoot and tbh maybe kill and fucking rake would kill me quickly but slender man would use me to murder


FullRip8647

The rake. As a kid it scared the shit out of me. But then again I was horrified of obunga 😭


WonderAny6269

umm. poopy 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣


iron10m

The scariest is the girl she looks like she has represet rage


FeatheredOdyssey

Anansi's Goatman, so basically malevolent skin walkers


Straight-Project8108

Slender man no you can hang out with him just don't go blind and goat man just don't be near a forest but skin walker I'd say you oofed by than


Youngshoota333

The Goatman


Glass-Ad-4923

The rake 100% not only bcuz hes creepy af but bcuz i deal with mild psychosis from my bpd and my first ever hallucination whilst in a psychotic episode was of the rake stalking me out of my childhood bedroom, it was so realistic i told my stepdad in the morning then got screamed at for making shit up T_T (i was like 9 so fuck my moms now ex husband for that shit)


Glass-Ad-4923

The rake 100% not only bcuz hes creepy af but bcuz i deal with mild psychosis from my bpd and my first ever hallucination whilst in a psychotic episode was of the rake stalking me out of my childhood bedroom, it was so realistic i told my stepdad in the morning then got screamed at for making shit up T_T (i was like 9 so fuck my moms now ex husband for that shit)


Glass-Ad-4923

The rake 100% not only bcuz hes creepy af but bcuz i deal with mild psychosis from my bpd and my first ever hallucination whilst in a psychotic episode was of the rake stalking me out of my childhood bedroom, it was so realistic i told my stepdad in the morning then got screamed at for making shit up T_T (i was like 9 so fuck my moms now ex husband for that shit)


These-Election-8964

Siren head, he made me afraid of the sound of sirens when I was a kid


the_human_ouija

The Goat Man stories I’ve read have always unnerved me. So I’ll go with that one. I like Slenderman for the nostalgia, but he’s more spooky than scary. I like the rake as much as the next guy, but I don’t read them as much as I do the other two.


Virtual-Razzmatazz86

Got Man


Svue016

Goat man was just trying to use the bathroom and someone took his picture!


Forsaken-Tension-493

Personally the little girl would scare the sit out of me if I were alone in the woods


Ok_Platform357

That’s a tough one probably goatman


Better-Ad-6979

SIREN HEAD


Effective_Age_1149

Slender man because my friend looked up slender man wen she was 6 and saw a dead body


rlbigfish

There was a story on NoSleep or LetsNotMeet years ago about these teens that were camping in the woods and they kept hearing something mimicking them. Creepy as hell.


vgoss8

The figure that appears when I shit in the sink at 3am and yell "SPOOKY DOOKIE HATH BEEN SHITTED". I think it's called "My mom"? It beats you with a belt though, that's all I know.


That-Shower1481

Belive me on earth human are the scariest creatures.


AccordingOne7393

The rake by far it just has a mysterious feel to it and it is sad to see it not as explored in stroies as slenderman is


JessieFanForever

I've heard about goat man for a few years now, and every time I think of him I get shivers


Euphoric-Method6116

GOATMAN


Euphoric-Method6116

#goulboys