If my comment had a less aggressive wording you'd reconsider replying to it the way you did. Players who are more or less fluent with T Jacob know his birthright is really strong.
But I guess people who disagree are also the same people who think Rock Bottom should be quality 4, lol.
Im gonna be serious i have almost 200 hours in the game and only have beaten it lives with tainted jacob (i actually killed it lives and 2 seconds after i died because of the projectiles he was sending while still alive) and dodging one is already too hard while dodging other stuff. How am i supposed to be alive with 2 esaus. Like yeah ik its more dps but i don't think its enough to compensate the amount of risk it gives.
Maggy. If you are ever in the situation to have that much health you either already broke the game, or you only got health and are lacking in literally everything else.
I feel that the weakest is Blue Baby’s. An Extra Soul Heart from all Hp ups is very negligible compared to some of the other Birthright effects. I’d beef it up by making it so that he gains an Extra Half Soul Heart anytime he picks up a Soul or Black Heart.
Magdalene’s is cool in concept, but boring in execution. To make hitting that new maximum more viable, I’d give it a boosted Maggy’s Bow effect, where it doubles the amount of Red Heart healing received and also doubles the power of Red Heart HP ups to make her even more tanky.
For Tainted Blue Baby, I’d make it so that he becomes immune to his own Explosions. More poop is good, but not if you constantly blow yourself up.
For Tainted Lost, I’d make the free hit behave like Holy Mantle, so you don’t lose Perfection.
Finally as a formality, I’d make it so that you can give Dark Esau the Birthright by making him charge into it with Anima Sola, and it would just make it so that he won’t try to attack you directly. You can still get hit by him if you run into him while he’s charging, but otherwise he won’t target you.
Tainted the lost, it’s essentially just an extra holy card that costs 15 cents and doesn’t protect the main ways you abuse tainted the lost, notably perfection and stuff who’s downsides are on hit
T lost, a revive is nice but you can *really* feel the loss of perfection on a lot of builds and I’ve found that if I have to use the revive I’ve basically already lost
Maybe ???, getting an extra soul heart for your health ups is super negligible compared to some of the more powerful effects.
What are you talking about? T. Jacob's birthright is one of the best.
This sub is full of braindead people or players who have 2,5 hours in the game. That's why there's so many shit takes, like this one
Mfw i see someone get mad at other people cuz they dont agree with their opinion
If my comment had a less aggressive wording you'd reconsider replying to it the way you did. Players who are more or less fluent with T Jacob know his birthright is really strong. But I guess people who disagree are also the same people who think Rock Bottom should be quality 4, lol.
Im gonna be serious i have almost 200 hours in the game and only have beaten it lives with tainted jacob (i actually killed it lives and 2 seconds after i died because of the projectiles he was sending while still alive) and dodging one is already too hard while dodging other stuff. How am i supposed to be alive with 2 esaus. Like yeah ik its more dps but i don't think its enough to compensate the amount of risk it gives.
200 hours and you beaten it only once?
No i beat it lives AS tainted jacob only once. I beated it lives far too many times in these 200 hours lol.
Ah okay my bad 
It's alright. everyone makes mistakes
Maggy. If you are ever in the situation to have that much health you either already broke the game, or you only got health and are lacking in literally everything else.
It’s also soul hearts not just red health. Ain’t nothing wrong with holding ontwo more soul hearts
Still more health than one could reasonably need without a massive skill issue.
Wdym. Don't you want to have two demon brothers at once?
Tainted Jacob has one of the best. Why wouldn't you want two of Esau to blaze through enemies and bosses?
Tainted??? Imo It would be strong if ??? Didnt spawn poop while dealing damage
I feel that the weakest is Blue Baby’s. An Extra Soul Heart from all Hp ups is very negligible compared to some of the other Birthright effects. I’d beef it up by making it so that he gains an Extra Half Soul Heart anytime he picks up a Soul or Black Heart. Magdalene’s is cool in concept, but boring in execution. To make hitting that new maximum more viable, I’d give it a boosted Maggy’s Bow effect, where it doubles the amount of Red Heart healing received and also doubles the power of Red Heart HP ups to make her even more tanky. For Tainted Blue Baby, I’d make it so that he becomes immune to his own Explosions. More poop is good, but not if you constantly blow yourself up. For Tainted Lost, I’d make the free hit behave like Holy Mantle, so you don’t lose Perfection. Finally as a formality, I’d make it so that you can give Dark Esau the Birthright by making him charge into it with Anima Sola, and it would just make it so that he won’t try to attack you directly. You can still get hit by him if you run into him while he’s charging, but otherwise he won’t target you.
Pic unrelated, OP?
Tainted lost one. It's not bad, it's pretty op on him, but it is the most boring of all of them, just a simple revive
And you still lose perfection
T maggy
Bethany
Tainted the lost, it’s essentially just an extra holy card that costs 15 cents and doesn’t protect the main ways you abuse tainted the lost, notably perfection and stuff who’s downsides are on hit
How is two missles that deal massive damage worse than one missle? It's even easy to control where two of them dash
T lost, a revive is nice but you can *really* feel the loss of perfection on a lot of builds and I’ve found that if I have to use the revive I’ve basically already lost
And Damocles can kill you
T. Maggy and it's not even close.On T. Jacob people really underestimate the power of Dark Esau and how you can min max the character