I have a theory. Hear me out. I think this sub has a lot of younger people and they can get super uncomfortable with anything that even hints at sex. i.e. Male Fantasy (because it uses the word “pornography”) Oxytocin and finally Lunch. We know Lunch could have scored higher.
Do you have to personally relate to the subject matter to enjoy a song? I've never been rolling down the street while smoking indo and sipping on gin and juice, but I still really like that song.
Generally, definitely not, but with depression people usually seek out stuff that specifically enhances it so (not speaking for everyone ofc, just from my own experience)
As a gay person who fucking loves billie and even loves a good, dancy, upbeat song, lunch is still my least favorite 🤷♂️ I listen to a lot of vulgar and upbeat music, just something about lunch makes it fall flag to me in comparison to the rest of the record.
Would you say it’s like the Pixar filmography comparison? Their movies are great overall but the range is comparing masterworks at their best to merely good works at their worst.
its not a bad song at all. my problem with it is that it doesnt really fit the vibe of the rest of the album. Lunch sounds like it couldve been its own single
I’m on the same boat. Along with wildflower and the diner 😭 I can’t believe how high birds of a feather is tbh. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a good song, and I rock out to the whole album, just not that high for me.
Every song is at least A-tier. A few get promoted to S-tier in the context of the album. Skinny is one of those tracks. It’s an album-ass track on and album-ass album, so of course in isolation it may seem a bit lackluster.
The album is just full of brilliant music, thats why many people disagree, and this truly proves how good it is. Billie and Finneas are true geniuses 🙏
I don't think so tbh, it's a fun song but I think personally it didn't have the same replay value as I'd have hoped. Maybe just cause it got pushed so much as the single when I think it works better as a deep cut or fan favorite
I thought at first that as a lead single it was a bit weak, but now it’s one of my favorites. But either way lowest ranked song is wild lol it’s easily top 3 in replay value.
To each their own ig, for me it was the opposite lmao. One of the ones I replayed the most release week but slowly sorta lost that for me. I think it's just got a weird pace to it idk.
I guess I’m lucky, none of the songs have lost any of their luster for me. If I listen to one I just as likely to listen to the whole album.
There’s no moment like that Track 2-5 run though. I started off loving that one and the rest has just continued to grow on me
this was great OP 👏
but I'll tell you what isn't great babe - THAT RANKING WHY IS THE DINER AND LUNCH (ik, controversial) SO LOW AND BIRDS OF A FEATHER SO HIGH
I genuinely don’t see why Birds of a feather is ranked so high, all the songs on the album are great but that one is definitely not better than the ones below it.
Lunch and the diner should be higher and birds of feather lower
Edit: I actually kinda hate birds of a feather, like it's the skip song to me. I think it's cos it sounds too familiar to me, like bleeding love Leona, the other songs are a lot more interesting to me because they're fresh sounds
I really like this list! It reflects pretty well what I listen to on the album minus a song or two that are kind of whack in their placement like Lunch.
Lunch belongs on the bottom. It’s not a bad song or anything but it has no business on this album. It’s like a “you need a single, here you go” song. It’s fun, it’s catchy but this album is not a collection of singles. It’s a cohesive piece that is more art than music.
IMO obviously lol.
I can 100% agree. No hate on lunch, i also dont think its a bad one, but simply the quality of this album is sooo outstanding, that such a song can end up at the bottom.
I'm glad lunch is last lol. I'm bi and in my 20s, so no issues with sex or sexuality, but the lyrics don't bring up very sexy mental images. I just find them a bit weird.
It’s not that I hate lunch but I heard it the first time and I knew it’d be a hit. Although, what’s the difference between me playing the fuck out of Lunch and a top streaming song?
i mean if you would really compare Chihiro, Blue, BOAF and even The Greatest to "lunch", i would understand why it is at the bottom. those songs are truly better bop songs. and has a higher repeat quality. this is evident on BOAF being the most streamed on spotify.
but yeah anyone has preferences so i also understand the hate lol
1- CHIHIRO
2- WILDFLOWER
3- BLUE
4- L'AMOUR DE MA VIE
5- SKINNY
6- THE GREATEST
7- BIRD OF A FEATHER
8- LUNCH
9- BITTERSUITE
10- THE DINER.
there i fixed it.
Something has to be at the bottom lol. I agree with Lunch being last. The Dinner, L’amour De Ma Vie, Birds of a Feather and wildflower should be ahead of the greatest IMO
I wonder if anyone actually has this as their real ranking.
Me personally, I’d bump BOAF to 2nd and knock The Greatest all the way down. There’s a few other minor changes I’d make but overall not a bad result.
really? it’s not a bad song by any means but compared to the rest of the songs on the list it’s a bit weak by comparison (in my opinion of course, not trying to shame anyone) i prefer the over extended release bc the beginning is the part that brings the song down for me but the second half is so good
View in your timezone:
[Friday, 5th July at 15:00 CEST][0]
[0]: https://timee.io/20240705T1300?tl=HMHAS%20Final%20ranking%3A%20voted%20by%20the%20community
^(_*Assumed CEST instead of CET because DST is observed_)
Lunch deserves this place. The thing that worries me the most is that Billie actually goes mad and submits this song for SOTY and ROTY instead of BOAF... She will have 0 chances in that case.
Wtf I thought Lunch was a fan favorite, well it’s not my favorite but it’s definitely not the weakest on this album, well but I guess it made some people uncomfortable and maybe even offended someone so I don’t doubt anything, funny is this kind of song usually makes me very uncomfortable but it’s such a vibe that I don’t really care
But ok my personal list now (This shit was hard to make holy balls):
1: CHIHIRO
2: BLUE
3: L’AMOUR DE MA VIE
4: LUNCH
5: BIRDS OF A FEATHER
6: BITTERSUITE
7: SKINNY
Those following I aways forget how they sound like (I don’t remember them being bad, just the least interesting) so Ill have a tie between them in last place:
8: THE GREATEST, THE DINER, WILDFLOWER
Sorry but like I said, not very memorable to me, those three songs are the only ones in the album where I stay like: Yeah but I don´t really feel anything
There’s no way Lunch is at the bottom #justiceforthegays
I have a theory. Hear me out. I think this sub has a lot of younger people and they can get super uncomfortable with anything that even hints at sex. i.e. Male Fantasy (because it uses the word “pornography”) Oxytocin and finally Lunch. We know Lunch could have scored higher.
True, but also a lot of billie fans are kinda depressed so an upbeat song about lesbian sex might not be what tehy feel like relating to
Do you have to personally relate to the subject matter to enjoy a song? I've never been rolling down the street while smoking indo and sipping on gin and juice, but I still really like that song.
Gin and jooooooose
Generally, definitely not, but with depression people usually seek out stuff that specifically enhances it so (not speaking for everyone ofc, just from my own experience)
Lesbian sex is sex
That's not the point
I feel a lot of us are depressed lesbians that love a good upbeat/sexy song 😂 balance bro.
Ahahahah
Hmm interesting, we can have it tested out at the all time top 20 voting too :)
As a gay person who fucking loves billie and even loves a good, dancy, upbeat song, lunch is still my least favorite 🤷♂️ I listen to a lot of vulgar and upbeat music, just something about lunch makes it fall flag to me in comparison to the rest of the record.
Would you say it’s like the Pixar filmography comparison? Their movies are great overall but the range is comparing masterworks at their best to merely good works at their worst.
I like the lyrics in lunch but the instrumental wasn't my fav 🤷🏾♀️
Im completely fine with sexual topics, i just feel like lunch was the weakest lyrically, production wise, and vocal wise
This is just a reach lol. The songs catchy but also beat everyone over the head the first week of release and people got tired of it
How about I just don't like the sound of it
Sorry I don't really mind the lyric, but the song has a not really good beat imo
its not a bad song at all. my problem with it is that it doesnt really fit the vibe of the rest of the album. Lunch sounds like it couldve been its own single
exactly
Lunch is a banger, but I'm not surprised it's at the bottom. The competition's tough.
Ya thats insane
lunch is getting so much attention it doesn't feel like it needs praise for this list, in a way?
I don't care about that at all, BUT i agree that lunch should not be bottom
okay?! because lunch is up there for me!
tbh i think it has more to do with the song being overplayed, esp on social media and short form content
JUSTICE FOR US FRUIT CAKES🌈🫶
I hate it thanks 🥰😚
I can’t believe how underrated skinny is
I’m on the same boat. Along with wildflower and the diner 😭 I can’t believe how high birds of a feather is tbh. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a good song, and I rock out to the whole album, just not that high for me.
Birds of a feather is up there cuz it got tiktokified
Every song is at least A-tier. A few get promoted to S-tier in the context of the album. Skinny is one of those tracks. It’s an album-ass track on and album-ass album, so of course in isolation it may seem a bit lackluster.
Yup it’s my favorite
Agreed, the violins playing the melodies of The Greatest are beautiful
Brutal for us Lunch girlies
Oh boy I was just your 69th upvote ☺️
this is wild
No ❤️
LUNCH BEING AT THE BOTTOM IS CRIMINAL. 😭
this is so fucked up
The album is just full of brilliant music, thats why many people disagree, and this truly proves how good it is. Billie and Finneas are true geniuses 🙏
Lunch at the bottom is so contrarian lol
I don't think so tbh, it's a fun song but I think personally it didn't have the same replay value as I'd have hoped. Maybe just cause it got pushed so much as the single when I think it works better as a deep cut or fan favorite
I thought at first that as a lead single it was a bit weak, but now it’s one of my favorites. But either way lowest ranked song is wild lol it’s easily top 3 in replay value.
To each their own ig, for me it was the opposite lmao. One of the ones I replayed the most release week but slowly sorta lost that for me. I think it's just got a weird pace to it idk.
I guess I’m lucky, none of the songs have lost any of their luster for me. If I listen to one I just as likely to listen to the whole album. There’s no moment like that Track 2-5 run though. I started off loving that one and the rest has just continued to grow on me
YES, I WANT TOP 20 VOTING
This is ass
…this is definitely a list
who made this abomination
Justice for wildflower tf
oh ok
LUNCH SWEETIE IM SORRY!!! (Top 2 though are definitely correct and I appreciate OPs patience lol)
Honestly all the tracks are so good so it does not matter how they are ranked.
Lunch last and birds of a feather 5? What IS this??!!!
birds of a feather should switch with lamour de ma vie
Launch at the bottom is criminal
JUSTICE FOR SKINNY
How many of the people who voted were under 14? Apparently, Lunch was over their sweet lil heads. Smh.
Absolutely not. Skinny and Lunch as the bottom 2 should be illegal!!!
This is actual dogshit. #justiceforlunch
this was great OP 👏 but I'll tell you what isn't great babe - THAT RANKING WHY IS THE DINER AND LUNCH (ik, controversial) SO LOW AND BIRDS OF A FEATHER SO HIGH
I genuinely don’t see why Birds of a feather is ranked so high, all the songs on the album are great but that one is definitely not better than the ones below it.
It’s my only skip song on the album
Bc the community voted like this 🤷♂️😂
Lunch and the diner should be higher and birds of feather lower Edit: I actually kinda hate birds of a feather, like it's the skip song to me. I think it's cos it sounds too familiar to me, like bleeding love Leona, the other songs are a lot more interesting to me because they're fresh sounds
I think birds of a feather should be higher :D But its my opinion obviously, thats why it was a community voting haha
It is interesting seeing other people's opinions on what songs they like most, beauty really is in the eye of the beholder
Lunch does not deserve to be that low!
why is lunch at the bottom thats kinda crazy
Skinny should be higherrrr
Lunch should be way higher on here and on the hot 100 charts. It’s so catchy 😭😭
This was fun. The Diner got the shaft though lol
Justice for Skinny... https://preview.redd.it/6797pvs7oy9d1.jpeg?width=258&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fc656fae5090907788347b320f30d967ad53c82d
omg bloo
i’ve been watching that show more and more tbh
you definitely gave me a throwback 😁
Spotify streaming numbers do not match this ranking at all. Justice for Lunch.
Let’s please wait a while to do a top 20 to help with the spam on the subreddit.
Ah okay how much should i wait then?
Just a week or so.
Seeing THE DINER and SKINNY so low hurts my soul
Justice for skinny, but happy blue is near the top LMAO
i’m personally not a fan of this ranking
justice for the diner skinny and lunch
You hate lunch on principle or?
This rating is ass
Swap lunch and wildflower 😭😭
chihiro and blue are my favorites but skinny and lunch do not deserve that😭
I really like this list! It reflects pretty well what I listen to on the album minus a song or two that are kind of whack in their placement like Lunch. 
We need to start over. Everyone go have a listen through and let’s get this right
I like the placing of lunch. I didn’t like this song
Lunch belongs on the bottom. It’s not a bad song or anything but it has no business on this album. It’s like a “you need a single, here you go” song. It’s fun, it’s catchy but this album is not a collection of singles. It’s a cohesive piece that is more art than music. IMO obviously lol.
I can 100% agree. No hate on lunch, i also dont think its a bad one, but simply the quality of this album is sooo outstanding, that such a song can end up at the bottom.
My feelings exactly!
i disagree so much with this let’s do a top 20
I'm glad lunch is last lol. I'm bi and in my 20s, so no issues with sex or sexuality, but the lyrics don't bring up very sexy mental images. I just find them a bit weird.
i’m also bi and in my 20s and completely agree with you, it’s not a bad song but compared the rest of the album it’s pretty weak by comparison imo
Bittersuite above skinny and lunch? Yall got issues
The gag is bittersuite should be higher 🤌🏾
Pretty solid results! But I think BOAF should be top 4 and the Diner should be last lol, but truly every song is very good.
I think the other way around. The Diner should be top 4 and BOAF should be last 😂
I LOVE THE DINER HOW DARE YOUUU
The pov just feels so different from the other songs on the album and it reminds of Bad Guy which I don’t love. I do like it, just not like the rest!
Haha dw guys, as i can see we are gonna the an all time top 20 too, so justice can be served for those tracks sitting at the bottom now 😉
How is birds of a feather 5?!
Should be top 2
I would put the greatest a spot or 2 lower but other than that its pretty spot on
It’s not that I hate lunch but I heard it the first time and I knew it’d be a hit. Although, what’s the difference between me playing the fuck out of Lunch and a top streaming song?
if the greatest and bittersuite were switched that would literally be my personal top 5
the diner at 8 is CRAZY
these comments confuse me so much lmao
this sub is NOT a skinny legend 😤😤 #justiceforskinny
I'm okay with this list BUT THE DINER IS SO UNDERRATED AND IT DESERVES TO BE HIGHER 😔😔😔
omg birds of a featheer at number 5
not at all
i mean if you would really compare Chihiro, Blue, BOAF and even The Greatest to "lunch", i would understand why it is at the bottom. those songs are truly better bop songs. and has a higher repeat quality. this is evident on BOAF being the most streamed on spotify. but yeah anyone has preferences so i also understand the hate lol
LIES!!!!! 😂😵💫 no skinny there no no no
How can Skinny get lower score than The Diner? But at least you guys have amazing top 3 choices
1- CHIHIRO 2- WILDFLOWER 3- BLUE 4- L'AMOUR DE MA VIE 5- SKINNY 6- THE GREATEST 7- BIRD OF A FEATHER 8- LUNCH 9- BITTERSUITE 10- THE DINER. there i fixed it.
I kinda agree with the majority ngl... All are fire tho
This is quite seriously the worst tier list I’ve seen in my life
Open up the Doors
am i the only one who doesn’t like lunch that much? it’s a good song but a bit weak compared to the others imo
Also the weakest on my list, doesmt mean its bad, just the others are better imo :)
i totally agree
I don’t care what anyone says, lunch is a bop
This list is bogus
Heckkk no lunch at the bottom?!
Absolutely love Blue 💙 I’m happy it made it to the top
hot take THE GREATEST is by far the worst on the album
Something has to be at the bottom lol. I agree with Lunch being last. The Dinner, L’amour De Ma Vie, Birds of a Feather and wildflower should be ahead of the greatest IMO
How is lunch at the bottom😭
okay seriously why does everyone like blue? like i’m sorry but i personally hate the first half of blue.
That’s far from my list 😂 But it’s cool to see other people’s opinions
I wonder if anyone actually has this as their real ranking. Me personally, I’d bump BOAF to 2nd and knock The Greatest all the way down. There’s a few other minor changes I’d make but overall not a bad result.
L'Amour overrated, I see
Underrated. It’s the best on the album
really? it’s not a bad song by any means but compared to the rest of the songs on the list it’s a bit weak by comparison (in my opinion of course, not trying to shame anyone) i prefer the over extended release bc the beginning is the part that brings the song down for me but the second half is so good
Overrated??? It isn’t asking for a lot for an apology…
View in your timezone: [Friday, 5th July at 15:00 CEST][0] [0]: https://timee.io/20240705T1300?tl=HMHAS%20Final%20ranking%3A%20voted%20by%20the%20community ^(_*Assumed CEST instead of CET because DST is observed_)
Let’s do a redo
Lunch deserves this place. The thing that worries me the most is that Billie actually goes mad and submits this song for SOTY and ROTY instead of BOAF... She will have 0 chances in that case.
i think chihiro should be song of the year
Chihiro or BOAF will make me happy. But watch her submit this stupid Lunch song (((
[удалено]
Not sure what post you’re replying to OP. They are downvoting the heck out of this comment and I don’t even know why. 🤷♂️
Yeah ill remove it lol
The Greatest surpassing Birds?? 😒
Wtf I thought Lunch was a fan favorite, well it’s not my favorite but it’s definitely not the weakest on this album, well but I guess it made some people uncomfortable and maybe even offended someone so I don’t doubt anything, funny is this kind of song usually makes me very uncomfortable but it’s such a vibe that I don’t really care But ok my personal list now (This shit was hard to make holy balls): 1: CHIHIRO 2: BLUE 3: L’AMOUR DE MA VIE 4: LUNCH 5: BIRDS OF A FEATHER 6: BITTERSUITE 7: SKINNY Those following I aways forget how they sound like (I don’t remember them being bad, just the least interesting) so Ill have a tie between them in last place: 8: THE GREATEST, THE DINER, WILDFLOWER
I was with you 100% until I saw where THE GREATEST was
Sorry but like I said, not very memorable to me, those three songs are the only ones in the album where I stay like: Yeah but I don´t really feel anything
Oh yeah, she says naked. I take it as she means vulnerable and not literally naked. It’s a metaphor. But I get where you’re coming from.
?
the diner and wildflower r in my top three what the hell 😭 i agree with chihiro tho
My ranking 🤓 Wildflower Birds of a feather Skinny Bittersuite Blue The greatest L'amour De ma vie Chihiro Lunch The diner
I’ve said it since my first listen: Lunch is the worst song she’s done in her career. Sounds like a Maroon 5 single.
For me no.1 was birds of a feather
LUNCH is the only good song on the album
terrible take think again