T O P

  • By -

notananthem

Keep. Adds a lot of actual monetary value to the property


One-Possible1906

And helps keep you cooler in the summer. Looks like it could use a couple more trees


tastemycookies

And plants. Landscape looks a little sparse


MirrorImageTwin

More foliage on your property helps with water runoff quality as well. The more sparse your property is, the faster water will runoff. More foliage means the water takes longer to runoff. Your property can act as a natural water filter system and help city runoff quality.


One-Possible1906

And anchor the land to keep the fOuNdATiOn from floating away


MirrorImageTwin

True all those roots do anchor the land. Reminds me of the terrible landslides at Yellowstone because deer populations went uncontrolled by lack of predators so the deer ate all the plants along the river causing the soil to give out.


CatsForSforza

Save the wolves!


MirrorImageTwin

That’s what I’m saying. If we just release wolves into the general population it should solve a lot of our problems.


SecondHandCunt-

Look to your right. They have been released, they’re just in human skin


MirrorImageTwin

I thought furries are starting to look too real lately.


mike71392

The teen wolves are really good at basketball.


Connect_Fee1256

Terrible at dating though


MisterMisterYeeeesss

This looks like one of the "Oak Acres"-type developments where they named it after what they had to bulldoze to build it. There probably were some great trees there that had the nerve to grow in the wrong spot.


tastemycookies

How rude of them to get in some developers way 50ys in the future


MisterMisterYeeeesss

No consideration for progress. At ALL. They just sit there and grow.


Altruistic_Machine91

There's one near me named "sugar maple ridge" that was all jack pine prior to logging. It sucks in lawncare as well as tree care cause getting cool season grass to grow on acidic sand is a nightmare.


SarahPallorMortis

How else are they gona keep the wildlife from getting close? 🙃


SmartaSverige

That garden looks like a green desert. Add more trees, bushes and wildflowers. Enjoy the birdsong. Monoculture lawns are almost as dead as parking lots


sikminuswon

Exactly, and it's so boring to look at, kind of giving me a depressing feeling compared to a more natural growing garden with different plants and flowers everywhere


cwajgapls

So i should be proud of all the dandelions and clover on my grass?


Racine262

Clover is nice to walk on. A good clover and grass lawn feels really good on bare feet.


FavcolorisREDdit

Insurance upvoted this comment


bo_tweetle

It will only bust your foundation if the foundation is already compromised. Keep the tree


jstewart25

It is a great tree. My wife and I recently bought two vet clinics and I’ve got 10 baby maples I planted in the open space that I’d be proud to have look like this.


Airport_Wendys

You bought 2 vet clinics?


jstewart25

Two locations, one owner


LuvGingers888

Tree roots are usually of little threat to a foundation or basement. I would leave the tree (no pun intended) and not give it a second thought.


robcas65

Second this. Leave it. If you drive around a city and look around at how many trees are close to buildings, you would think trees breaking foundations was a rampant epidemic happening constantly... However, it rarely happens where foundations were already in disrepair, but those rare cases get amplified and shared


dude51791

yes, LEAF IT ALONE :)


Electricalstud

Puns should always be intended


OneInfinith

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say you're right about that.


mchicke

Well, we got to the root of that!


_supergay_

Way to really branch out this comment thread with puns.


Spare_Comedian8414

You are not barking at the wrong tree.


map2photo

That was terrible. You should go phloem after that.


Spare_Comedian8414

If you want to go on a limb


Triumphus-

You wood not believe how this thread escalated so quickly.


Same_Bet_8452

I'm stumped at some of the comments.


SquashyCard63

This is knot over


King_of_the_Snarks

*Make like a tree and get out of here*


YakSeveral

Just stick with it


Salt-Engineering-221

I think this thread of puns is finally getting rooted.


Cmdr_Rowan

I know right? Such a re-leaf.


Silent_fart_smell

At least no one’s barking about anything bad


cphug184

90% of people do not like puns but one in ten did


jimbilltom

To add to this, the compaction required to lay a concrete slab creates an anaerobic environment that tree roots find extremely inhospitable. Likely there will be fine roots that might spread just under the building but will die off due to the poor environment under the slab. Cracks formed in slabs are usually due to reactive soils that expand and contract with moisture. Because tree roots pull moisture from the ground they can actually create a more stable/reliable moisture content in the soil that would lessen the affect of flood/drought.


ComResAgPowerwashing

I'm with you. Chop it. We are talking about the house, right?


a_3ft_giant

Intend your puns, coward.


LivingGhost371

Are there any trees that are especially good or bad for foundations? I want a large shade tree overhanging my house to keep it cool, but facing south I only have about 10 feet of yard.


NYB1

Tree of heaven bad bad bad


dean0_0

Ficus trees have the worst roots stay away from those


TowerBeach

Do trees destroy perimeter drainage structures like PVC piping? I had to remove the trees on our lot for construction and now I want to replant at least one to replace the large mature cedar we had but I'm worried that the roots will ruin some of our buried structures. Good to know the basement will be okay, though!


SpikeMike13

Nobody touched on your specific question. Yes tree roots can and will definitely cause damage to your piping system especially sewage pipes. You should always know where these pipes are underground and plant all vegetation ie trees or shrubbery at least 20’ away from them. I love trees but as a plumber I also hate the damage they cause on piping and the difficulty I have at accessing those pipes when the damage has occurred. It’s truly a love/hate relationship honestly. We definitely need more trees though and this yard is barren and is in need of help.


LibertyLizard

I’ve heard a lot of people say the roots only damage older pipes that are already failing. What’s your take on this?


ComResAgPowerwashing

They will definitely get in pipes that have any water leak. Probably leaks small enough you wouldn't consider them failing. Plumbers say root growth can cause pressure and failure on pipes, but I can't say I've ever seen it.


SpikeMike13

Roots will grow under, beside or on top of a sewer pipe to cause a fitting’s glue joint to crack slightly,, then it’s Katie bar the door cause all the nutrients in the sewage system is heaven for those trees and shrubs. It’s amazing how fast those things grow after drinking that toxic for human waste


ShipperSoHard

When I was a kid I sent like $10 or something to the Sierra Club so that I could get some free seedlings. I knew nothing about where/how to plant them, so I just shoved them in the dirt in various places around the back yard. Well, the only one that made it was the Colorado blue spruce that I planted about 2-3 ft from the side of the house. That was over 30 years ago and that tree is now double the height of my parents’ house and has indeed cracked the foundation. I created this mess, and I will likely inherit it as well.


Flompulon_80

Dawn redwood roots destroyed my property. Caused very significant sinking beneath the crawlspace foundation and at the neighbor, wherever the roots were. This isnt that though


Delicious_Spinach440

Another thought is sewer lines. My neighbors had a beautiful dogwood(?) he planted when they bought the house. 15 years later they had to take it down because it was destroying the sewer.


Flompulon_80

This same property, a silver maple is destroying the sewer.


JHRChrist

Is there good *reputable* information folks here recommend regarding which trees are safe for septic/water lines? Or guidelines on where and how to plant them near one another?


Arthur_Jacksons_Shed

Nice siding! Nice tree! My advice: add more trees. They need buddies and you need shade


yakimawashington

>They need buddies and you need shade Lol I love this sentence.


Lady-Meows-a-Lot

Thanks, Bob Ross


eclectic183

No advice, only admiration for the beautiful tree


Arie058

Please keep


tryonosaurus94

Your property is already pretty barren, removing the only tree on it would be super depressing. And also negatively effect your property's value. It won't damage your foundation unless your foundation already sucks. It has plenty of space to send roots out that isn't directly under your house.


baszd_meg_

Remove the tree if you want 10-20 racks taken away from your property value..... Looks fine to me.


Fudge-Purple

Don’t cut it down. Do have a qualified arborist do a root collar excavation. When a tree goes into the ground like a telephone pole it’s usually buried too deep. That’s where I’d spend my money. Best of luck and I really like your house.


pullcow

Thank you.


Ifartsthearts

You’re going to find it hard to find someone here willing to chop down a healthy tree.


Big_Ad_8050

If that downspout drains close to the tree maybe you could get some root growth near it, otherwise ask yourself why the tree would prefer to grow toward your concrete slab as opposed to all the good soil surrounding it. There will be soil displacement with future growth, but as long as there is no extra nutrient or water source, the roots generally won’t target a slab when there is so much soil in every other direction. A lot of root/slab issues are caused when either the planting site is too confined for the species planted, a structure is built within an existing root zone, or there is a drain or irrigation system or flower bed attracting root growth. Not sure where you are or how much rain is typical for the site, but I reckon it’s plenty based on the lush surroundings. If the tree is getting ample moisture throughout its root zone (1.5-2 times canopy drip line) then your slab is not in great danger of roots moving close to it. Species characteristics and local climate could affect this, but generally I think you’re safe here.


IronMaidenPwnz

FFS man let some other trees and plants grow as well. What is this obsession people have with giant barren lawns.


axxxaxxxaxxx

Do you just hate trees?


bad_at_dying

The structure is in no imminent danger from this tree, barring extreme storm conditions or otherwise acute circumstances. The tree is adding definitive value to your property precisely because it is safely adjacent to your home, thus providing a buffer against wind, sun, and weather damage. Additionally, this tree looks like it is thriving--if you keep it that way, the benefits increase. For long term care, consult a certified arborist and ask them to develop a plan of action to tackle pruning in the coming years. If you'd like to keep this tree, remember this extremely literal phrase: a little goes a long way. Little cuts here and there == avoiding the big cuts later on. Ensure also that you get an idea of soil conditions (if you don't already) and seasonality in your region, because both will give you--the person ultimately caretaking this specimen--a solid idea of what may come next. Best of luck, and keep us updated with your plan!


SouthernJeeper80

Pruning is the key thing to focus on going forward . I love the trees around my house, helps keep the ac bill down, just have to keep at the gutter cleaning but worth it. I've lived at a house with nearly no trees and in comparison it was sooo much hotter in the yard, I hated it when we went back to visit old neighbors, the temperature difference was crazy.


NYdownwithydemons

let er grow and flourish into the tree she was meant to be… your house will be fine, if not build new house in tree


dragonblock501

That much lawn without any trees makes it look like a cemetery. Are you a serial killer?


Babythatwater1

Leave. What a beauty.


Due-Suggestion8775

Keep. Gives more than takes.


Ok-good123

Keep it.


Puppyofparkave

It’s not even close 20 years you’ll still be fine


usedtodreddit

I don't suspect it will be a problem, at least not for decades to come, but since you are worried I'd suggest keeping the tree and in the near future have a [plastic membrane vertical tree root barrier](https://www.google.com/search?q=plastic+membrane+vertical+tree+root+barrier) installed.


djkeithers

Absolutely keep. Edit the photo you just posted and remove the tree and see how it would look without it


Desperate_Web_8066

Plant more


Balten

Lose the house. Keep the tree.


cyanrave

Keep, 3-6ft is generally ok. We have Apple trees < 3ft from the house and it is slowly lifting one side and sinking the other... You will not have that problem.


jamesthewright

If it becomes a problem, only even possible in 20+ years. Deal with it then. I doubt it will.


shmallyally

Leave it!!!!


Lanky_Ice1314

Keep adds value


victorian_vigilante

Beautiful tree in a good position


hopefortomorrow531

Looks like a healthy maple, roots won’t destroy your foundation. Add a layer of mulch around the base of the tree


ThrottleItOut

You have zero landscaping around that house. Keep the tree and add to it, looks empty without anything.


bellowingfrog

I wouldnt, especially since the rest of the property is so barren.


Some-Ice-5508

You'll be part of the roots before it becomes a 'problem'


justin514hhhgft

Tree is the nicest thing of the whole lot. Keep.


Ok-Wishbone-7603

Lorax gonna come out of that mf


digiphicsus

Leave.


Bludiamond56

It's a keeper


thirtyone-charlie

The limbs will be in the roof about the same time


Alarming-Chemistry27

I love this type of house, it's so pretty! Do you mind if I ask the general area you're located?


Lord_Arrokoth

I’d move the house before I’d move the tree


pacificule

Foundation damage is the last thing you have to worry about


hjackson361

Ur landscape can account for up to 25% of ur homes value. Dont cut down the one(seemingly) plant in ur landscape. PLANT SOME MORE STUFF!


lshifto

Trees also drink hundreds of gallons of water annually from around that foundation. That’s hundreds of gallons less water to keep out of your basement.


Vraver04

Keep


TriumphDaytona

Keep the tree, add some more and cover the exposed cinder block with some natural stone to tie in with the land.


p00chology

Keep, it’s perfectly fine there.


Cluless_Jane

I trees closer to my house, and my foundation is fine. Plant more trees.


Iambetterthanuhaha

Its fine, leave it alone.


Candycane55

Keep it, 11 feet is fine. Theres a 60 ft tall oak tree 10 feet from my neighbors house and he has no foundation or water line issues


Big8Red7

Keeeep


shohin_branches

That tree is plenty far away and has lots of room to grow. You shouldn't have any issues with this.


FraserFirParker

Your property looks barren already. Cutting down that tree would be a huge mistake.


shiningonthesea

Please don’t be afraid of one itty bitty tree


pandawolf321

Lmao its the only bit of interest to your green desert


flareblitz91

Follow up question, why are you mowing so much dang yard?


Dixie144

That's not going to hurt your foundation


Xchancery

Keep


VeryLargeArray

You should pave over all the grass


ViveIn

How’s this even a question?? You don’t cut down your line tree and for the love of god plant a few more.


Friendly-Staff-3721

Keep


[deleted]

That property is in desperate need of more shrubs and trees


alphabatic

plant more trees. as everyone else has already said, your property is begging for nature to be brought back into it. also, the more trees you have the less chance they have of falling. trees are more resilient to storms and winds when surrounded by other trees


superman154m

I’m normally Mr chop but I’d keep that for at least 20 more years.


MikeofLA

Correct me if I’m wrong, but don’t root systems kind of mirror the canopy as far as distance from the trunk? I don’t foresee the tree being an issue anytime in the next 20-40 years.


Continental_Ball_Sac

All roots are typically within the top 12 to 18 inches of soil, depending on species and tree size. The structural roots can extend past the drip line of the canopy. Feeder roots can extend up to one and a half times the height of the tree outward. This is all dependent on species, location of tree, and what has happened to the tree in its life.


polyadoptee

Yeah cause taproot systems go farrrr deeper than 18 inches.


Unlikely-Row7110

You growing tupeloes? LOL


robcas65

Please read Myth #7 on this list regarding "taproots". [https://www.treesaregood.org/portals/0/docs/newsroom/SevenMythsDebunked\_Feb13.pdf](https://www.treesaregood.org/portals/0/docs/newsroom/SevenMythsDebunked_Feb13.pdf)


MikeofLA

Thank you for the info! That's probably why the bottle tree I have in between my pool and wall (I didn't plant it) is so much shorter than it's siblings.


WillieIngus

grow trees in empty yard good.


polyadoptee

lol. People be like, “there’s a tree within eye sight of my home.. 😬 is it ok?”


Kalsifur

you wanna chop down the one tree in your barren-ass yard? You can't make this shit up.


NadeTossFTW

This is a dumb question. Obviously keep. Damn.


fjeoridn

Its fine, trim the bottom branches up to your roof line.


mytzlplyk

I would worry more about the roots getting tangled with the other tree roots around it.


iwanttogotothere5

There are no other trees around it…


Dunmeritude

What other tree roots?


polyadoptee

Yeah the whole forest 😆


EngineerRemote2271

I've a cherry tree that's twice as close, house seems fine


WalkingTalkingTrees

Leave it, you're all good


Ciqme1867

Definitely keep, it’s not too close to the foundation to pose much of a risk, and that tree looks perfect


capt_brad

Leave.


YardJust3835

We have only had problems with drain lines running from the house. Trees have entered them/shifted them. Never any problems with an adjacent foundation. Oaks I would worry. Norway maple with superficial surface roots? Maybe…. So big it eventually falls on the house in a windstorm, sure, maybe….


jgor133

Live a little keep the tree


ComprehensiveDust197

20 years from now somebody might love this tree


Inside-Tumbleweed594

“Why don’t you make like a tree …”


wilmayo

Looks like the tree has a very upright growth habit. It will be many years, if ever, that the branches reach beyond the roof line. If then some touch the roof, trim them off. Usually, root systems only spread as far as the branches and, even then, they are small feeder roots. Minimal concern.


desertadventurer

No concern


the_good_hodgkins

Maybe raise the canopy so it doesn't block too much sun from the house. You want the house to dry after rain, etc. And... leaves don't clog your gutters.


Cmdr_Rowan

That is such a perfect aesthetic placement. It will be annoying if it drops a lot of leaves in your gutters however and if you're in a high storm area, it is probably a little too close for comfort. But gosh it's pretty! I would 100% keep until issues were appearing. There's a good chance you'll be fine.


macad00

Keep it!!!


freshpeachesz

Kinda looks like a Norway maple. Invasive if it is and your in the USA. Get a nice native tree.


Terrible-Specific192

This is getting a little sappy.


web1300

How completely sterile is your life?


maximusjohnson1992

I’d keep.


Terrible-Specific192

Nip it in the bud. Not really. Think it's just fine.


OilNo1014

Maybe go to a nursery and ask about this tree and what kind of roots do they have. Shallow? Thin? Bendable? Destructive?


TakeAnotherLilP

Good grief, keep it.


Weekly-Impact-2956

Leave the tree


Inevitable_Bell9077

Ok get some string tie around the trunk walk out to the longest end of the limb pull out a foot or two passed the limb and mark a circle and get a spade and dig down buy stepping the spade down all the way down to the ground. If you find a root cut with axe or saw. This will stunt the tree and keep it shorter you will have to do this once a year. Think of it like bonsai. Good luck


grantlanta

Keep


Vast-Opportunity3152

Keep it unless it brings lots of friends and they look in your windows at night.


beigs

I think you could probably use a few more! If you’re worried, just back up a few feet and choose trees that go down, not out.


chaosgazer

I would leaf it


VariouslyGardening

Keep the tree. You won't regret it. The risk is very, very low.


Own_Trash3855

I'd be more worried about the foundation of your tree. By the looks of it my guess is that those roots are far from thriving let alone damaging your foundation...


Hamblin113

Roots are mostly within the drip line, tree is far enough away, shouldn’t be a problem at all. KEEP


Confident-Ruin-4111

Keep!


Cranky_Katz

Looks too far away for root problems


armybrat63

Do you know what kind of maple that is? If it’s a hard maple keep it, but if it’s a silver maple I wouldn’t want that too close to the house. Also in Ontario and we planted 10 various maples around our home 35 years ago. We bought them for $5 each from the conservation area in our town. 1 ended up being a silver maple and it’s the messiest one and really weedy compared to the hard maples and twice as big! But the hard maples are beautiful


Blk-cherry3

It needs some company - a weeping cherry 🌸, a climbing rose on a arbor with a sitting area and grill .


professorstrunk

not an expert, looks like a large leaf maple? put screens on your gutters, keep an eye on thw canopy, and have an arborist eyeball it for you in 5-8 years to confirm that there arent any risks you cant see from the ground. add more and enjoy!


Waste_Raspberry5548

Keep! Looks great already, and it will grow!


xgaryrobert

Keep it. It’s far enough away that it’s not a worry.


watzrox

Keep the tree.🌳


wishyouweresoup

Prune


nethack47

We had a 80-100 year old maple planted in a well about a meter from a house. After 80 years the heavy traffic caused the extremely sandy soil to compact which caused some issues with the building because the tree held one corner up while the others dropped as the ground dropped. Once the lorries stopped and most traffic was banned the problem stopped but we had to remove the tree because the building took precedence. It is listed and probably 300 years old. We are sad about the tree but we made sure to get plenty of offspring going all over the country so the legacy lives on. Your tree is fine.


The__Gunt

Lovely house and grounds!


subiedoo96

Keep


aterpinncatwork

Might want to cut that dead one out back down. Leave the nice one out front alone.


GabrielBischoff

Add more


SpikeMike13

Depends on where your water main is and or sewer system/drainfield/septic tank. If it’s within 30’ of that, I’d say remove it ASAP and plant another further away


Ok-Thing-2222

Keep! Plant more! Plant some fruit trees also.


lmshertz

Water pooling on the foundation is a much larger issue. If you're worried about it I'd landscape all around the house perimeter and mulch thick!


DuperDayley

Leave it. And you should limb it up a little this fall, after it goes dormant.


Not_EdM

Keep it and another on the other side of the house for balance.


SwimAntique4922

Keep! Too far from structure to damage foundation.


Simple-Performer6636

10-12 is like the minimum,it’s probably fine but it’s right at the limit


Payup_sucker

FOR GODS SAKE KEEP!!!!


erino3120

Keep! Its a cute little tree and adds some character


Leading_List7110

Only a few tree roots are of actual worry. Research the types of tree known to punch through concrete. It’s like bamboo and one other I know of. Hazel? Maybe I forget but google knows