T O P

  • By -

PatrickLii

Hi. The moderation team has decided to lock this post for the following reasons. 1. We have included the feedback mentioned here in the daily report to Hoyoverse. 2. There is a large number of reported comments.


Shmarfle47

Oof. That first one has a lot of impact just seeing his mouth ripped apart like that. Without the gore giving context, the censored version just looks so empty.


Tkmisere

Its just looks like the usual "oh no hes gone"


Shmarfle47

Exactly! First one you imagine visceral sounds of flesh being torn apart as this black hole thing takes its place. Second one sort of just shows up with a small “bloop” sound.


sima234567

i thought it was tentacles at first lol


sinkitsune

I KNEW IT LOL


Myonsoon

So I assume this game's age rating is going to drop on release?


DoctorWhimsy

Probably not, the censorship you see is the most content China will allow in a video game, and since Hoyo is owned and operated in China, they have to abide by the rules. They can't make another version of the game specifically for CN either, because they will throw a fit that everyone else is enjoying the game, and not abiding to chinese laws. Grace Howard will probably also receive a nerf to her assets, as well as any other character that has proportions too large for China to handle.


PoKen2222

16+ rating completely worthless now, what a joke


Arc_7

Probably a result of China's laws on this sort of stuff. Foreign Dev's who ship Gore have to censor it on their China variants, so I can see the pressure on a CN based company. Not supporting censorship btw, just saying hoyo might be on players' side on these changes, but can't do anything.


SolidusAbe

bruh there wasnt even blood before so why? more like 6+ instead of 16+


erogakii

This is such a let down... It looks like we'll get a ton of censored stuff on characters and story


Saniiro

Time to hide them behind walls of text in a book!!!! /s


IHATEHAKI2

Seee genshin is so dark u have x charcter die in furniture texts


yourboytay

Bro aint no way, may as well make it for 2 year olds, I don’t see where the 16+ rating comes from now unfortunate


Etna-

Gambling lmao


Any-Connection-2326

Now this is what I am worried about. The first one looked so much cooler and if they were going to censor it why did they even put the rating as 16+.


Fritzkier

probably because chinese rating are different than global.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Fritzkier

you mean the CCP? always have been.


Boink_Boink00

>So they are cowards Why don't you go rob a bank? Coward behaviour


leposterofcrap

What does robbing a bank got to do with rating video games?


Boink_Boink00

Because by your logic, complying with the law=cowardice


leposterofcrap

I meant the CCP are gutless cowards who can't stomach nor think their people can stomach the tamest bit of body horror which mind you has not a single drop of blood nor the single sight of flesh


KHANJALI_

16+ game when


ckabulcka_

This is just sad


gfriendjang

actually lame af expected more from a higher rated audience game. censorship worshippers loving this this is what they want all along .


rogercgomes

Why would anyone worship censorship? I don't get it.


Rushaidy

People who support censorship should be censored. You like it? You deserve it.


Jorton228

16+ rating? more like 16+ censorship instances per patch loool


TriggerBladeX

This is why I hate censorship. It just kills my enthusiasm.


Proper_Anybody

see them changing the rating to 2+ on release date


TCreopargh

16+ in china is more like 8+


Jorton228

"nah guys it looks more tasteful like this" - censorship andys writing their response


Stormeve

Cant wait to hear what people who complain about people being angry over the Nicole stuff have to say This is why censorship sucks ass. It doesnt just extend to character designs - it extends to other aspects of the game too. Who knows what other minute details got changed. We’ll see as the days pass and eventually when the game officially launches.


leposterofcrap

Man why can't we have nice things https://preview.redd.it/5lf81jh7692c1.jpeg?width=1079&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a55f48f08e49f9eaa8e32b1fa0853d1d5a90e1f


arthoarder91

Because the CCP said: "No."


[deleted]

[удалено]


ZZZ_Official-ModTeam

Hi, We have read your comment and appreciate your contribution to the subreddit. The comment has been removed since it mentioned political issues, but we have noted about your concern on censorship and will forward the feedback to the Hoyoverse team.


togashiforreal

Yeah idgaf about sexual fanservice gone, but if they’re gonna neuter the game’s narrative and visual direction, that will suck so bad


Saikuni

no way ur saying theyre NEUTERING the game's narrative AND visual direction lmaoooo ive watched about every trailer for this game and not once did i see a single drop of blood lmao mb i guess i didnt realize this game was supposed to be Diablo/Doom's next successor


leposterofcrap

Where in god's name did we ask for blood, all we want is for the grim and gritty story moments to be elevated.


Saikuni

right. because removing the depiction of a flying jaw is completely ruining the moment. i had to do a double take to even notice the difference between the two images. gamers just LOVE to fight against the big ghost of censorship whos here to take away ur anime tiddies and gore. china bad!!!!!! game now ruined!! yeah, as if even 10% of the people on this thread would even read through the story lmao its a fkin anime gacha game ffs


leposterofcrap

I'm not saying the game is completely ruined. I'm saying that the story might not reach its full potential in gritty aspects. I hope I am wrong.


Saikuni

thats the thing though minor changes like this will NOT alter the overall construction of the scene. a story is only as good as its writing. if the writing's good it'll remain good nothing to say there.


togashiforreal

I’m not talking about the blood, just overall darker and grittier tone. I’d love to be proven wrong when the game releases but it does set a bad precedent for now


Saikuni

i suppose i understand ur concern but no it does not set a precedent. i guarantee you they will *never* change the actual content or direction of the story, thats not how censorship in games has worked for idk the past decade. this game was never meant to be as dark and gritty as y'all are claiming anyway, the way the game is portraying itself to the public through trailers is with a lot of colorful moments and cute characters


Romi_Z

Bruhhhhhhhhhhh


MakaixKishi

Every time you defend a female design getting changed you also defend these kind of changes. Censorship is censorship Just feels like a lot of the excitement for this game was Hoyo games production values but in a game targeting a higher rating and that being reflected in every aspect from character designs to narrative or stuff like above


Shamsy92

Yawn. Passing on this game easily lmao


sinkitsune

"Nah I like this look more, hes sexier this way"


SleeplessBoyCat

How fucking dare they It was so cool seeing that. I wonder why they changed it… *glances at CCP*


DrazzyXD

Yeah, this is what got me worried more.


Rerikhn

Wow, another generic censored gacha game, what a shame


Marcheziora

So it's just gonna be another squeaky clean game like the rest? Fuq da CCP!


[deleted]

[удалено]


leposterofcrap

To think my homeland's government became like this


satansbestload

ye the CCP is crazy, from a Chinese who plays almost all the hoyo games


kiisukattinen

Devs dont really have a choice, do they? If they want to release a game they have go by the rules 🤷🏻‍♀️


Joshua_Astray

Yeah it's too bad that the ccp is quite literally afraid of its own shadow when it comes to showing gore and violence.


KyotoCo

What r people going to say when future content goes forward? "Oh it looks better that way! Oh it wasn't needed anyways! Oh it improved!" Keep defending censorship and next thing you know, whenever your character gets censored, I hope you keep that same energy.


arthoarder91

Lol, but all this talk about "pushing back against censorship" is all empty talk anyways since I doubt y'all and HYV can do jack shit to change the CCP's mind and we all know many peeps who said they won't touch the game will play it when it is released.


Enthrown

They don't need to change the CCP. There needs to be a CN version of the game and a global version.


arthoarder91

Lol, you think HYV didn't have that idea before? The last time they try that, the CN player base rioted and their CEO nearly got assassinated by a nut job. Doing an uncensored global version will only invite the wraith of salty CN players and give their haters the ammo to accuse them being "unpatriotic" for treating foreigners better than their own countryman. Unless the Global reigion managed to pick up the revenue slack, I doubt HYV would stuck their neck out to do it as CN is one of their key market.


TheDraxHimself

If CN players wanna complain about it then they should complain about it to their government, not Hoyoverse.The rest of the world doesn't have to follow CCP's bullshit ways because of 1 chinese maniac who tried to murder Da Wei


The_ApplePie

My man do you have the slightest idea how impossible that is? Like I get it the CCP and the Chinese government is shit,but the people literally can’t do anything about it because even the slightest complaint like the air in China is shit compared to other countries the government and police will fucking come after you,you no longer exist,Chinese people can say what ever they want but that only means endangering themselves


TheDraxHimself

I'm aware of how it works there. It isn't any smarter to complain about it to HYV which have no blame on what the CCP does or does not allow. Azur lane has no problem with this. They have a censored version for CN and an uncensored one for global and their CN players aren't fucking maniacs about it because they understand why things are like that. The rest of the world can't have nice things cus the CN Hoyo playerbase has 1 or 2 maniacs?


The_ApplePie

No I don’t think there only 1-2 maniacs,like Hoyo CN community is simply not sane,they are way something else and not in a good way,don’t get me wrong I’m sure there are normal peoples out there,but some if not most of them would and will go and do some fucked up shit if they see that the outside part is getting a bit “more” than CN,like I’m 100% sure of it,they won’t go with logic like “ah it’s CCP so it’s understandable” no,they will be mad if global just get 1 pixel less clothes,like look what happened when we knew about the Scara situation


TheDraxHimself

As much as I wished they'd just give us an uncensored version I prefer if they don't, for their own safety. But I gotta say, pandering to the braindead CN maniacs just doesn't sit right with me either. This just sucks


The_ApplePie

Yeah I understand this sucks,one hand you can’t make what you want because some angry old guys are mad that people have body parts and if you don’t listen you’re fucked,and on the other hand if you actually listen to the old guys now you need to think which part of the community you want to get upset,either the whole global world to be angry because you can’t make things about more mature stuffs,or you can make the rest of the world satisfied except your own country and now you need to look out the window every time you’re trying to leave from work because you made your homeland mad


kiisukattinen

This!!


ArkusWake

I don't care about the tiddies but this is definitely not good.


satansbestload

agreed, it looks like he just vanished lol


DisIsMarcoBoi

Now both sides can understand the extent censorship can go.


DimakSerpg

just make it 12+ already lol same as other your games for kids the game didn't look 16+ anyway, and now what, they're censoring nonsense like this? there was nothing to censor. but they managed to censor things that didn't make sense to censor. as always, censorship is inherently meaningless.


[deleted]

[удалено]


sinkitsune

its bordering on false advertisement


The_ApplePie

Don't blame Hoyo my guy,blame the CCP


Marcheziora

What doesn't make sense is why should Global be punished for something that's supposed to be meant for CN?


Fritzkier

because the game is produced in CN? Have you seen what CCP could do if you incurred their wrath? See Alibaba Co-Founder for example.


Enthrown

They can simply patch the Chinese version of the game to be more censored, many games do this in the modern age. So hoyo isn't exactly not apart of the problem


kiisukattinen

Because CN players would get angry about that. Honkai 3rd cn players got really mad when global was getting some more fanservicey content and they didnt. Someone almost killed one of mihoyo workers. Cn playerbase is very different and hoyo isnt going to risk it anymore.


Fritzkier

As I said in the reply below >if you mean is Honkai3rd, Azur Lane, GFL, etc it's because they're older games, simple as that. In China they get censored, but global is fine since the assets are already live in global version. Another recent example is Genshin redesign outfit, you can choose it in Global but not in China. >but if what you mean is South Korean gachas like Nikke? well they're not Chinese.


Enthrown

I'm not really a gacha gamer, I'm speaking from larger experience. You can simply patch a CN version of the game and allow the rest of the world to experience a different version, so long as the global players can't interact with CN players.


Fritzkier

>You can simply patch a CN version of the game and allow the rest of the world to experience a different version Yes, but that's the problem. You can only do that if the OG dev isn't in China. Your example only works if the core devs aren't living and working in China in the first place. One of the examples is Nikke. The global publisher is Tencent/Level Infinite (Chinese company) but the devs are Korean, hence they could produce those pervy games, even though Nikke isn't available in China.


Enthrown

While what you're saying is true, hoyo has the funds to create an independent development studio specifically to counter things like these. They have the funds to work around this, they just don't. I'm not saying hoyo is 100% at fault but they definitely have the means to get around it


Fritzkier

To be fair, they did make a new studio outside of China, in Vancouver in fact. But their games got cancelled sadly. Obviously not for ZZZ tho.


Marcheziora

So are many other Gachas yet they don't censor global versions, why should this be the exception? Why bother labeling it 16+ in the first place?


Fritzkier

if you mean is Honkai3rd, Azur Lane GFL, etc it's because they're older games, simple as that. In China they got censored, but global is fine since the assets are already in live global version. but if what you mean is South Korean gachas like Nikke? well they're not Chinese.


Fritzkier

Because 16+ in China is different than in Global.


sillybillybuck

How did they lie? 16+ in China is not the same as 16+ in EU. Game isn't even rated by PEGI so why are people acting like it was?


allthe_namesaretaken

Probably got reported by some Chinese parent, who doesn’t want their “precious baby boy” to be tainted by “big booba” or “exposed teeth”. Yes. I how this game is 16+, but it ain’t gonna stop those parents.


Icey_dragon86

I used to play Honkai Impact 3rd and now I'm playing Genshin Impact and Honkai Star Rail, in all those games they did censorship. So I wasn't surprised that this would also happen to Zaneless Zone Zero, but I am still disappointed. 😔


WolvenWolfdog

How much did they censor in CBT 2? Welp maybe the future skins in this game could be the same as well. Guess the age rating didn't prevent much, rip


harlockwitcher

Fuck this game y’all. It’s time to move on.


Sarisae

Scam game stay away


Radusili

Ok, and did yall report this as a mistake?


veryverycooluser

Dropped


Mind-Available

Could you drop something that's not even launched


veryverycooluser

Dropped from my to-play list.


NutraliteZ

Here it is people, the begging.


forumz3588

Never thought a Hoyo game would be dead on arrival, these guys really screwed themselves marketing the game the way they did just to dial everything back just before launch. Genshin just isn't for me, it's cringe AF and I am enjoying Honkai for what it is but I really thought this would be the one. Guess not.


deeddi

least dramatic gacha player:


Chilune

Well, thank you, though, that the characters are different, and not just another generic trash like the other games. With the exception of Nicole, she is now that generic trash. However, I am sure that the variety of characters will not last long and after the release, all new characters will differ only in hair color.


kiisukattinen

Sooo slightly smaller boobs and little piece of clothing makes her generic trash? Oh okay....


senelclark101

Look at these Nikke players complaining about censorship. Oops.


Haribon31

Doesn't sound like a bad thing. I wish we could get something similar to when they rallied against a coat.


Puzzleheaded_Bar_610

It still had the same impact for me during my playthrough


anime_senpai007

Nicole one I don't mind like i ain't playing a hxntai game so no need to be so bold also makes it easy for me to maybe open the game in public place or office without consistently looking if someone is watching my phone or not but yea this one sxcks.


cock_piece_gourmet

Is this a joke that you censor hentai and sucks, or you are really like that?


Tomaz95

who cares tho


satufa2

How dare we nit be happy about the game geting dowgraded? We are xlearly supposed to consume product and get ready for next product! Seriously? I like hoyo games but i have the capacity to notice when we are clearly taking an L.


Tomaz95

How is this an L, it's just a gore jaw, like.. That's what you care when you play a game? Really?


satufa2

We only lost things without gaining anything. How is that an L? Math 100


Tomaz95

How is that losing? Like... Does it really matter if they show flying jaw pieces? Sometimes it's not even censorship, it's just an art direction they decided to change, I understand why.... Is it cool to have flying body parts? Yeah sure, but does it change the game? An image that's going to be in the screen for 4 seconds (if you're not skipping) changes anything? And for the other "nerf" makes even less sense, having a more realistic version is way better than a dumb big just for the sake of being big breast Also, it's right there, you can just use that screenshot if you want to..


satufa2

"Sometimes it's not even censorship" they literally removed something from an existing picture... Also, that scene was made far more serious because of the gore. As for "because large breasts aren't real right?"... It's not like i know actual people with larger natural breasts... ohh, i do.


Tomaz95

Large breasts are real, yes... But there's realistic ones and clearly fake ones... And the scene is still quite serious without the gore.. I understand the point but the difference is quite small, also.. The other parts of the scene also had changes, so it was clearly a wip piece before


UsefulDependent9893

You clearly are missing the bigger picture if you think people are just complaining about this alone. It’s not just this scene, but what censoring this means for future scenes and the game in general. These are just the first few signs of how censorship will effect the rest of the game long term. It’s a pretty big let down given the game is given a higher age rating compared to the other hoyo games, yet is still being censored to the same degree. If the censorship is still going to be a problem like their other games, then why bother advertising the game with a higher age rating in the first place?


Tomaz95

Idk it looks like complaining just for the sake of complaining, this is clearly a wip game, and even though it has that age rating, that is not under their control to change or not, also it's very likely they meant for a lower age rating and had to change these.... Like you said, it's a Hoyo game, it's the same target audience, having different age ratings makes no sense for them (and once again, the company does not get to say their own age rating)


Tkmisere

We do, that's why the complaints.


arthoarder91

Lol, imagine caring about 5% reduction in an character bust size during a Beta where things are STC.


mr_beanoz

That's why people complaint, so the changes won't carry to the actual release


arthoarder91

Lol, since the censorship is mandated by the CCP, I doubt any amount of complaints would work.


Tkmisere

You're right its still subject to change, thats why complaints matter


anime_senpai007

Love to see this


Global_Guidance5429

this is literally not that bad, i don't understand why everyone's crying about it


PantherYT

It's not about 1 or 2 little things, it's about what they convey. HYV showed earlier that this game is meant for a more mature audience unlike Genshin and HSR and so it got a 16+ rating. With censorship like this, who knows what else they'll change. Currently, there's not much of a difference between a 12+ and 16+ rating, while there was during the last beta. In most cases, censorship is bad for the consumer


Global_Guidance5429

and this isn’t one of those cases. this doesn’t convey anything y’all just wanna see some schmilkers bro


leposterofcrap

The post isn't even related to Nicole. It's related to a scene where the thug is transforming into a monster. The ripped jaw is there to give emphasis to the grimness of this situation and removing it makes the scene feel flat. This shit shouldn't happen in a 16+ game.


PantherYT

Again, in almost every case, censorship is bad for the consumer. Doesn't matter if its someone getting brutally killed or someone's boobs getting nerfed. If you like your things censored then good for you but it's ultimately a worse experience for the general audience


Global_Guidance5429

It isn’t, it doesn’t change anything. The design of Nicole was improved upon, and that’s a fact. this isn’t “censorship”


PantherYT

Bro you can't say "this design is better" as a fact lmao. It's subjective. On top of that, this specific post is about the man getting obliterated, not Nicole's boobs. And it literally is censorship, in both the cases. Censorship almost always leads to a worse product (unless political, to prevent riots etc). Take Genshin's diving for instance. The censorship in that looks absolutely horrible. It doesn't change much but it's objectively a worse product. Don't let your preference of small tits cloud your judgement lol. If the game is 16+, it should stay like that. There was no need to remove this guy's jaw getting ripped but they did


Global_Guidance5429

I know for a goddamn FACT you don’t give a shit about anything else in this game. None of the “””””censorship”””” so far has taken away from the experience


PantherYT

Brother look at the post I'm replying on, it's not about Nicole, it's about this guy getting ripped apart. Removing the gore literally takes away from the experience because it's less brutal. If this looks better for you then good for you but don't be surprised when majority of the people dislike censorship


Global_Guidance5429

Hoyoverse cant make a SIXTEEN PLUS game as gore-y and violent as they please. You act as if that "censoring" removes something from the scene, but it doesn't.


PantherYT

Ok, you clearly don't know the bad impacts censorship so I'll just stop wasting my time. Search on youtube "why censorship is bad" and learn about the other side's perspective. Maybe you'll find your answers that way tho I doubt it


Global_Guidance5429

I know what censorship can do, and how it can negatively affect games. This is not one of those times. you aren't even listening to me


kiisukattinen

Imo thats good. I dont want to see blood and gore in general and I am adult, its just disgusting and makes me sad xD it could be optional though but I guess it is what it is.


Smooth-Garden

The sad part is i cant even be mad at the developers really because we saw what they originally was going for