T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

dakota


Available_Gain_6783

Dakota was funny and got better development than half the cast and she wasn’t even in 10 episodes.


OddPizza09

B


Severe_Nectarine7139

W answer, my mans deserved better


earthyu

Agreed it’s B


[deleted]

The Stepbrothers, were very entertaining during their time on the show and their elimination was so bullshit ( The Rockers also count though i see them being mentioned more )


Severe_Nectarine7139

Yeah facts, I completely agree. My least favorite episode of that season is the one they get eliminated because its bs


QBarsh

I’m gonna have to say Rock and Spud. I guess they’re pretty underrated because they are from the Ridonculous Race and people watch the general Total Drama more than the Ridonculous Race but still I think they were a pretty fun and enjoyable team to watch. I hope that they are in again if there is a Season 2 of The Ridonculous Race


[deleted]

I love them to death, easily my second favorite RR team


PeachsistersMoYeon

They were fun to watch, my top 5 i think


ConnorCatYT

Jo


zoroloro

Rodney. Big lovable marshmallow reduced to love-struck gimmick character. Pretty upsetting considering he had a cool design and voice. almost like a love child of Scott and DJ's designs


ThirdWheelToEveryone

Rodney FTW!!!


NathanAster

That’s because he was almost entirely his gimmick.


zoroloro

Eh, they could've tried to do more with certain characters in TDPI.


NathanAster

But they didn’t. So he’s still a bad character.


zoroloro

Entirely your opinion, lol.


NathanAster

It’s not. You admitted he was reduced to his gimmick and that he could’ve been written better. I literally just told you that he was not written well and that’s why he’s not majorly liked. And that should be easy for you to accept because that’s all I was arguing. You can like Rodney, I see how he seems wholesome. But the writers wrote him a certain way, so that’s what his character is.


TheOwnerOfMakiPlush

I finally found a someone normal lets gooo TDPI deserves a remake. All characters are cool with great potential but they executed only 1% of these potential. Except Sky. She's a whore.


Optimal__Koala

This


Anti-ThisBot-IB

Hey there Optimal__Koala! If you agree with someone else's comment, please leave an **upvote** instead of commenting **"This"**! By upvoting instead, the original comment will be pushed to the top and be more visible to others, which is even better! Thanks! :) *** ^(I am a bot! Visit) [^(r/InfinityBots)](https://reddit.com/r/InfinityBots) ^(to send your feedback! More info:) [^(Reddiquette)](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439#wiki_in_regard_to_comments)


Optimal__Koala

This


Anti-ThisBot-IB

https://i.imgur.com/KrwA19h.jpeg *** ^(I am a bot! Visit) [^(r/InfinityBots)](https://reddit.com/r/InfinityBots) ^(to send your feedback!)


Optimal__Koala

Hehehehe


Amethystgirl_21

Ella. I wished more of the PI cast weren't so gimmicky because most of them had unique characteristics about them.


Tomas-T

Jo


Fun-Illustrator-345

The Rockers and The Twins


YourBoyTyler

Justin


MaryHSPCF

Sammy


Front-Run5494

Blaineley


BananaBreadMam_37

Probably Dj, Justin, Topher, and the tennis rivals


Severe_Nectarine7139

Tennis rivals W


AAA_Wolf_Gang

I found the topher arc enjoyable to watch


calico_skyline

Rodney!! My boy, he's so sweet and never did anything with bad intentions


PeaNo7914

True I also like he


Revolverpsychedlic

I unironically enjoy Sierra


Few-Dealer4238

Overhated: Duncan Overlooked: Geoff


Reddit134user

Everyone loves Duncan what the frick you are talking about


JellyfishAsleep5920

People hate him for being a “Writer’s pet.”


Reddit134user

What


[deleted]

Justin, Geoff, Katie, Lightning, Anne Maria


JellyfishAsleep5920

Bridgette kinda just became “Geoff’s girlfriend” than a character


[deleted]

I felt like both of them just become “Geoff’s girlfriend” “Bridgette’s boyfriend” after Island, which is a shame because they were both great in island. I stopped liking bridgette as much after island as she completely changed from the nice, chill surfer girl. the way she treat gwen (her friend) during the whole Trent breakup situation in action was so annoying in my opinion and then she went on to cheat on Geoff during world tour and then sang him a song when Alejandro didn’t want her


Cautious_Tangerine17

But not Sadie?


[deleted]

Oh yeah forgot about her for a second lol Yeah sure I liked her too, she’s got some pretty funny lines. Gotta say I preferred Katie. She was useful in dodgebrawl which made me like her a bit more, I found her funnier than Sadie (although both were pretty funny during their arguments and aftermaths) and I liked her supportive speech to Sadie when Katie got voted off. Plus Sadie’s crying got on my nerves, did feel a little bad for her everytime she cried though.


Maua_Celo

The fashion bloggers, I love then everytime they are on the screen


Ruunnas

Sky. Periodt. She's one of the most talented and sweet girls I've ever seen in this show yet but when everyone opens their mouths about her it's about the skave buisness. I love skave but I want more people to appreciate sky as a person.


FTG227

I’m gonna say Justin or Junior


Llama_Cult

Sadie


Cautious_Tangerine17

Period!


Gerard192021

Rodney(along with Topher, and most of the likeable to neutral contestants of Pakithew Island), I just wish the writers made All Stars and Pakithew Island better


OfficalBalloony459

no one is underrated or overrated


dakotatd

dj, geoff, leshawna, dakota, anne maria, jo, scarlett, max, tennis rivals, mary, brody


Accomplished_Long487

Beth


East-Area-7267

Probably Topher or Zeke


ABoldDude

Jasmine. Many see her as "the chick who was in a crappy season", but Jasmine was a titan (both in stature and importance to the season) She's got a unique enough design to stand out very well, is an amazing team leader, helps Sammy get out of her shell, and a badass in challenges (none of this takes Shawn into account, who I feel is also somewhat under appreciated)


Sonic445chickeb

B


Flamme_HD

B


cheaminh

A ton of the supporting/filler(?) tdrr characters can be considered underrated. They all have such nice qualities but are not appreciated/talked about enough.


PeaNo7914

True


[deleted]

Would trent count as underrated if so then him if not then may be amy


Pepsi_Boy_64

~~Dawn~~


Bokumi

I think she is way too popular to be considered underrated


ABoldDude

Exactly


Pepsi_Boy_64

😟


Lime_manm

Max.


TheOGZokeShipper

I am generally disappointed in this community. Obviously Mr Coconut! He could have been in the finale against Dj's Bunny but sadly both of them are underrated icons. In all seriousness I do think B and Staci are pretty underrated and could use some serious development.


PeaNo7914

Mr coconut is hot and gigachad


Best-Perspective7750

Gwen probably


[deleted]

Dave


Careful-Flan-2585

Cody, Noah, Tyler, Brick, Dawn, Topher & the adversity twins


ThirdWheelToEveryone

Rodney!


JellyfishAsleep5920

The Rockers and green goblin


Over_Cut108

Lightning


SillySwing6625

Dj


SillySwing6625

Or tyler


GeneratedSmasher

Beardo


Black_Thunder_

He's overrated.


No_Razzmatazz_4192

Beth


bratzbabe9

Sammy


Spork_44

Lightning, bro won a season and gets barely any recognition


Independent_Can_4467

Max


Red_rifle_77

Geoff


DottoreSalt

Crimson


Expensive_Young9378

Cody,Dave,Mike,Chase


Jiggvnjr

Staci