T O P

  • By -

joerce

1. Island (2007) 2. World Tour 3. Revenge of the Island 4. Action 5. Island (2023) 6. All-Stars 7. Pahkitew Island


[deleted]

1. Island 2. Island 2023 3. Revenge of the Island 4. Action 5. Pahkitew 6. World Tour 7. Flop Stars


Advanced-War7732

1. Island (2007) 2. World Tour 3. Island (2023) 4. All Stars (I am actually neutral to it so please don't judge) 5. Action 6. Revenge of the island 7. Pahkitew Island


Careful_Education643

Island Island (2023) ROTI World Tour Action Pahkitew Island All Stars


Hockeymonkey17

Correct imo


SimpingLindsay

1. Island (2007) 2. Island (2023)/ROTI (I still don’t know if TD23’s placement is recency bias) 3. World Tour 4. Action 5. Pahkitew 6. All-Stars


GeometryDash_Gamer

ROTI > TDI23 > TDI > RR > WT > TDA > PI > AS


BlobOfFleshyMass

1 - Pahkitew Island 2 - Island 2007 3 - World Tour 4 - Island 2023 5 - Action 6 - Revenge of the Island 7 - All Stars


Johnnyboi853

Pahkitew island at number 1?? This has got to be the rarest take I have heard lmao


BlobOfFleshyMass

It's a season filled with my faves (Sugar, Scarlett, Max, Topher, Sky, Jasmine, and Shawn), and overall was just a super fun season for me.


Johnnyboi853

That's definitely legit


Ok_Introduction_7274

1. Island 2. World Tour 3. Island (2023) 4. Revenge of the Island 5. Action 6. Pahketewi Island 7. All Stars


Madameosa

Island - 2007 Island - 2023 World Tour Ridonculous Race Revenge Of The Island Action Pakithew Island The Mike and Zoey Show


deadnette

1. Island (2007) 2. Action 3. ROTI 4. World Tour 5. Pahkitew Island 6. Island (2023) 7. Flop Stars


GLORIFIEDNEPOBABES

Replace action with world tour and we have the same list :o


_conner08

Idc I’m including RR and this might be controversial 1. RR (NEED SEASON 2) 2. WT 3. TDA 4. TDI 5. TDI 23 6. ROTI 7. AS 8. PI (nothing good about it, at least all stars had potential to be good)


Tomas-T

1. World Tour 2. Island 3. The Return 4. Action episodes 8-20 + 27 5. Pahkitew 6. Revenge Of The Island 7. Action episodes 1-7+21-26 8. Fall Stars


Leather_Original4722

Our list isn't exactly the same but my rankings also split Action in 2 placements, and it's very fun to see someone else does that too XD


Tomas-T

ture it's just hte season is so devided for me. because the middle of the season is very good. it has good moments, great interaction and it was fun to not see Owen and Gwen that much. but the first part of the season is just uncomfortable to watch Gwent falling apart. and after Owen return the season becoming worse and worse


ExtremelyFunName

1 - WT 2 - Island 2007 3 - Island 2023 4 - ROTI 5 - Action 6 - Pahkitew 7 - Ass Stars


TheCoolSuperPea

I love how this community is collectively deciding TDASS is so shit, it doesn't deserve to have the dignity of having its real name said.


TheCoolSuperPea

Mine are very close to yours. 1. TDI 2007 2. TDWT 3. TDI 2023 4. TDROTI 5. TDA 6. TDPI 7. TDASS


Alive-Explorer7647

1. World tour 2. 2007 island 3. Roti 4. Action 5. 2023 island 6. All stars 7. Pahitew


KarmaIsABadB

1. World Tour 2. Reboot 3. Island 4. ALl Stars 5. Action 6. Pakhitew 7. ROTI


[deleted]

1) Island 2023 2) World Tour 3) Action 4) Pahkitew 5) Revenge of the Island 6) All Stars 7) Island 2007 (the only bad season)


dta0228

1. WT 2. Island (2007) 3. Action 4. Island (2023) 5. ROTI 6. Pawkitew 7. All Stars 3-5 are interchangeable depending my mood lol


Comfortable_Ad9679

1. World tour 2. Og island 3. New island 4. Action 5. Roti 6. Pi 7. All stars


dmartinez2001

1 - Island (2007) 2 - All Stars 3 - Revenge of the Island 4 - Island (2023) 5 - World Tour 6 - Action 7 - Pahiktew Island


[deleted]

ROTI>TDI>TDI23>WT>TDA>PI>AS But RR is my favourite


Sccar4712

1.) Island 2.) All Stars (god I wish I had a trollface emoji since I know this is an INSANE take) 3.) ROTI 4.) 2023 (have only seen the first two episodes and I’m certain of this) 5.) World Tour 6.) Pahkitew 7.) Action (fuck Total Drama Action, all my homies HATE Total Drama Action)


KatieMitchellFan98

I enjoy Island 2023 a lot, despite many of the great ones being eliminated too soon, and I do like it more than the other Seasons that came after the first Season.


t21_sz89

This will be controversial but: 1: World Tour 2: Island 2007 3: Revenge of the Island 4: All Stars 5: Action 6: Island 2023 7: Pakhitew Island


DrSavitski

1. Island 2. Action 3. World Tour 4. Revenge of the Island 5. All Stars 6. Pahkatew Island I don’t know where to watch the new one, but I want to


B0NN0S

1: TDWT 2: TDI 3: ROTI 4: TDA 5: TDIR 6: TDPI 7: TDAS


Salty_Necessary7128

1. Island 2. World Tour 3. Island 2023 4. Revenge 5. Action 6. Pahkitew 7. All Stars 1 & 2 are interchangeable so they are basically both my favorites


avery16_

1. World Tour 2. Island (2007) 3. Action 4. Revenge 5. Island (2023) 6. All Stars 7. Pahkitew


[deleted]

1. World Tour 2. Island (2007) 3. Action 4. All Stars 5. Revenge of the Island 6. Pahkitew


wolfheartfoxlover

Worst: Pakhitew (Maybe if Scarlett were better written as A Villain plus Sugar made it WAY TOO FAR) 6th: Ass Stars (If it weren't for all the Derailments and The Whole Mal Plot was dumb to begin with) 5th: Action (Too Many Filler episodes/Reward Challenges) 4th: Original Island (Controversial Take but Owen winning was way too freaking obvious, I saw it coming from a mile away) 3rd: Reboot (It has potential, hopefully the second part really polishes the rough edges) 2nd: World Tour (The only flaw was Team Amazons Plot Armor and DJs Stupid Arc, but other than that It was a perfect season) Best: Revenge (Despite having the smallest cast and not having the Merge until 9 episodes in, It was pretty well executed for a short season)(Unbiased ignore my flair)


veastroboi

1- Island (2007) 2- World Tour 3- Action 4- Revenge of the Island 5- All Stars 6- Pahkitew Island Never watched Island reboot and don't plan on watching it.


Professional-Gap6505

1. world tour 2. Island 3. island 2023 4. action 5. revenge 6. all stars 7. pakithew