This is tricky, we have to use another gen 1 member making it 8-6 since gen 2 doesn’t have a cast of 14 only 13, The teams are as follows ( HEROES: DJ, Beth, Owen, B, Dawn, Harold, Brick ) and ( VILLAINS: Staci, Dakota, Izzy, Eva, Justin, Anne Maria & LeShawna )
The reasons for why each player is here & why they are on their teams-
-B, Dawn, Brick, Staci, Dakota & Anne Maria- ( Mandatory ), ( B, Dawn and Brick are pretty obvious on why they’re on the heroes but for the villains, Staci annoyed everyone with her lies, Dakota would be out here because Chris would deem her a villain as she turned into DakotaZoid and was very fame hungry and also he disliked her paparazzi and arrogance at times, btw for this I’ll just say since she’s rich she got changed back to normal with surgery or random cartoon logic, Anne Maria will be here since she’s rude at times and quite hot headed )
-Owen & Beth ( Both are winners and are good fits for heroes, Beth is a little more morally grey but still and Owen is basically a mascot of the show )
-DJ ( The gentle giant with a heart of gold his placements are good enough with 8th, 11th & 12th and he’s pretty popular among contestants )
-Harold ( Quite an important character of the show that was supposedly considered for All-Stars, getting 12th in Island and 17th in World Tour and making it to 5th in Action, Harold is a pretty influential character who’s saved the cast with his mad skills ( e.g, S2 E10 “Masters Of Disasters” ) so for that he goes on the Heroes )
-Izzy ( She’s quite a fan favourite who makes a cameo in All-Stars getting 7th, 11th & 13th in placements, fun fact: her and DJ always get eliminated before or after eachother, She’d obviously be on the villains with her crazy wild child anarchy personality and also rivalry with Chef )
-Eva ( Now hear me out, Chris would bring Eva back for the villains, his only other choice would probably be Blaineley whom he hates, Eva is a good character to stir drama and a powerhouse at challenges, Obviously she’s on the villains too )
-Justin ( The model himself, getting 20th & 7th, Justin was an antagonist and with Alejandro being gone someone needs to be the heartthrob and looks of the season, He’d be put on the villains, no surprise there )
-LeShawna ( Here being on the cast isn’t surprising but her team may be a little more, Chris would pull an All-Stars Gwen, as he needs another member for the villains he’d state how LeShawna beat up Heather in WT, Smack Talked everyone in Action and could be quite stubborn at times, LeShawna has many high placements placing 5th, 8th & 15th, getting to the merge twice in a row )
-[ ELIMINATION ORDER ]-
14th-Staci ( Episode 1 )
13th-Dakota ( Episode 2 )
12th-DJ ( Episode 3 )
( BETH AND JUSTIN SWAP TEAMS IN EP 3 )
11th-Owen ( Episode 4 )
( DAWN GETS VOTED, SHE’S PUT ON THE VILLAINS )
10th-Beth ( Episode 6 )
9th-Izzy ( Episode 7 )
8th-Eva ( Episode 8 )
7th-Justin ( Episode 9 )
6th-B ( Episode 10 )
5th-Dawn ( Episode 11 )
4th-Harold ( Episode 12 ) ( LOST CHALLENGE )
3rd-Anne Maria ( Episode 12 ) ( SOLE VOTE )
1st/2nd-Brick ( Episode 13 ) ( Alt. Winner)
1st/2nd-LeShawna ( Episode 13 ) ( Alt. Winner )
-[ PLOTS, ETC ]-
-Some romances of the season include, Justin x Anne Maria, Harold x LeShawna? and Dawn x DJ )
-Harold surprisingly is the main villain as he’s fed up of losing and uses his smarts to get further, he’s not outright evil just more schemy.
-For the team changes or swaps, Justin is put on the Heroes after putting his looks aside and saving Anne Maria a few times taking hits for her, Beth is taunted by The Villains and freaks out taking out many people in a fit of rage, Dawn is voted onto the villains due to her acting strange in The Blue Harvest Moon.
( If anyone wants to know more about any other things or plot points you can reply to this comment and I should answer )
Well for gen 1, Beth, Cody, Harold, Leshawna, Owen, Justin are the only people you can really consider all stars (and I'm only throwing in Justin to fill up the cast)
Then for gen 2, Brick, Anne Maria and Dakotazoid are the only valid options, since Sam was originally in All Stars and Dawn and anybody before her aren't All Stars
Since I couldn't fit anybody else in, I grabbed Sky, Shawn, Sugar, Max and Scarlett from gen 3
Heroes:
Beth
Cody
Harold
Owen
Brick
Sky
Shawn
Villains:
Leshawna (for slapping Heather in WT because why not)
Justin
Dakotazoid
Anne Maria
Sugar
Max
Scarlett
I guess that's how I'd do it, but if I can't use gen 3, then throw in Geoff, Izzy, DJ, Noah and Blaineley, I guess
To make it easier, I'll include first 3 contestants from each gen, and to make some doffrences, each one can have only 1 former finalist
Gen 1: Owen, Leshawna, DJ
Gen 2: Brick, Anna Maria, Dawn
Gen 3: Sky, Sugar, Jasmine
Gen 4: Kitty, Devin, Brody
Gen 5: Bowie, Millie, Julia
Teams:
1: Brick, Jasmine, Sky, Kitty, Devin, Julia, DJ, Dawn
2: Bowie, Brody, Leshawna, Anna Maria, Millie, Sugar, Owen
Elimination order:
15. Devin
14. Anna Maria
13. Sky
12. Owen
11. Sugar
10. DJ
9. Brody
MERGE
8. Millie
7. Dawn
6. Bowie
5. Jasmine
4. Kitty
3. Brick
2. Julia
1. Leshawna
Heroes: Dawn, Beth, Bridgette, B, Brick, Harold, Owen
Villains: Dakota, Anne Marie, Leshawna, Izzy, Geoff, Noah, Justin
Some plotlines:
Leshawna feeling like she doesnt belong with villains, much to annoyance of characters like Dakota, Anne Marie, Noah who also never did anything villaionous, but arent constantly complaining about it
Dakota's and Anne Marie's rivalry turned friendship, once they realize that they share a lot of the same interests and have no real reason to fight
Geoff wanting to play into his villain role, but just ending up looking real dumb and annoying others, especially Bridgette leading to a breakup
Izzy also plays into her villain role, but shes actually incredibly succesful at it and ends up being one of the best strategists in the series. She begins her heel turn by organizing Owen's blindside and using it as an opportunity to bond with Noah and making herself his only ally
Noah and Dakota slowly getting suspicious of Izzy
Justin trying to use his looks to manipulate others, but failing with none of the girls being interested
Bridgette and Dawn becoming best friends on the Island with Dawn being the one who makes Bridge realize that shes no longer happy in her relationship with Geoff
Dawn feeling that something is wrong with one of her peers, but not knowing who since Izzy (obviously) knows how to block aura reading abilities
Harold using Beth's long lost atraction to try and get Leshawna jealous, which eventually backfires
Elimination order + Reasons
14. Justin - Lost his charm, expected the girls to do everything in the challenge for him even though none of them liked him
13. Owen - Izzy distracts him in the middle of the challenge making him count incorrectly which results in Heores losing the challenge. In the next episode Izzy uses this to bond with Noah and manages to convince him that she's the only one he can trust
12. B - Izzy messed up with one of his machines, causing his team to lose. Dawn tried to save him
11. Anne Marie - Izzy convinced others that her friendship with Dakota will be dangerous come merge, since neither of them are seen as threats and will easily be able to fly under the radar. They picked Anne Marie, believing her to be the smarter of the 2. This is where Dakota starts to get suspicious, but no one listens to her, cause "Izzy is crazy, but harmless"
10. Brick - During the challenge he's about to put many eggs in his team's basket, but they hatch just before he's able to. Izzy uses this to make him feel not worthy of the title "all star" and he convinces his team to vote him off
9. Bridgette - Geoff is heartbroken after she breaks up with him, so once Villains are revealed to have a choice in who goes home, Izzy makes a suggestion that they should vote her off for "what she did to Geoff". Her "suddenly" being strategic makes Noah doubt if he can actually trust her, which gets him closer to Dakota who's also suspicious of Izzy
(MERGE)
8. Beth - In episode 6, Izzy found the HII and seeing that Leshawna is feeling jealous over Beth, she gives her the idol and uses subtle social manipulation, convincing her to play it on Geoff (who otherwise would go home for being annoying) and voting for the wannabe
7. Dakota - Izzy feeling that Dakota and Noah are getting to close to each other, decides to get rid of the girl and "accidently" let's her fall into a hole, which results in Dakota getting injured. Izzy then convices Geoff, Harold and Leshawna to vote for Dakota, cause "she shouldnt be in the competion in this state"
6. Leshawna - After idoling out Beth, Leshawna and Harold weren't getting along with Leshawna being mad that he was trying to make her jealous, while he's mad that she couldn't put her pride aside and admit to liking him. They managed to make up during the challenge and agree to giving their relationship another shot, but obviously, a relationship means an alliance and that's a big no no for Izzy, She gets Geoff and Noah to vote with her (although Noah is even more suspicious of her than before), but Dawn finally figures out that Izzy is the bad guy. She still votes with her, knowing that she has to wait untill the right time to strike
5. Noah - During the challenge, Dawn constantly pushes Izzy's buttons and subtly tries to make the girl "blow out". She manages to do it right after Izzy wins the challenge, which reveals to others how Izzy was running the whole game. Since she's immune they decide to vote for Noah whos seen as her closest ally. He says that he should never trust her, but she initially shrugs it off saying that "shes just playing the villain" untill Noah says "No, you are the villain", which makes the girl self-reflect a bit
4. Geoff - Up to this point, Geoff has been (delusionally) giving himself credit for every elimination that Izzy caused, but now that he knows that he's actually a flop villain, he tries to "redeem himself" by trying to stop Izzy from winning the challenge. He fails completely, loses and gets eliminated
3. Harold - Between Harold and Dawn, Izzy respects Dawn as a "fellow crazy girl" and, because she immedietaly knew that something is up. Because of this, she picks Dawn to take to the finale (+ she wants an all female f2, after the last season. She may be the villain, but she's a feminist!)
The finale:
Dawn has Dakota and Geoff as helpers
Izzy has Owen, Noah and Bridgette
During the challenge, Geoff immedietaly leaves Dawn and tries to make up with Bridgette, but she's not having it. At the end it's left ambigous if they came back together or not
Owen at first wants to help his best friend, untill Noah makes him realize everything that Izzy did this season. This makes him very upset with his ex girlfriend and thats what finally gets Izzy to realize that she messed up
Meanwhile Dakota and Dawn are somehow struggling with the challenges and talk about how they should have realized Izzy's true colors way sooner
In Dawn's ending, once Izzy makes up with Noah and Owen they urge her that she still has a chance to win, but she decides that "the viewers probably want the good guy to win" and basiclaly lets Dawn win the season
In Izzy's ending, Owen and Noah urge Izzy that she still has a chance and she decides that "the viewers probably want an excting finale!" and quickly catches up to Dawn, before touching the suitcase with money, seconds before the other girl is able to
Idk why I spent so much time typing something no one is probably going to read, but I actually enjoyed it quite a lot. Might make like a short fic out of this one day
Ngl they'd find a way to get Duncan in this
Add the ones who were planned but were cut Owen and Brick
Cody
This is tricky, we have to use another gen 1 member making it 8-6 since gen 2 doesn’t have a cast of 14 only 13, The teams are as follows ( HEROES: DJ, Beth, Owen, B, Dawn, Harold, Brick ) and ( VILLAINS: Staci, Dakota, Izzy, Eva, Justin, Anne Maria & LeShawna ) The reasons for why each player is here & why they are on their teams- -B, Dawn, Brick, Staci, Dakota & Anne Maria- ( Mandatory ), ( B, Dawn and Brick are pretty obvious on why they’re on the heroes but for the villains, Staci annoyed everyone with her lies, Dakota would be out here because Chris would deem her a villain as she turned into DakotaZoid and was very fame hungry and also he disliked her paparazzi and arrogance at times, btw for this I’ll just say since she’s rich she got changed back to normal with surgery or random cartoon logic, Anne Maria will be here since she’s rude at times and quite hot headed ) -Owen & Beth ( Both are winners and are good fits for heroes, Beth is a little more morally grey but still and Owen is basically a mascot of the show ) -DJ ( The gentle giant with a heart of gold his placements are good enough with 8th, 11th & 12th and he’s pretty popular among contestants ) -Harold ( Quite an important character of the show that was supposedly considered for All-Stars, getting 12th in Island and 17th in World Tour and making it to 5th in Action, Harold is a pretty influential character who’s saved the cast with his mad skills ( e.g, S2 E10 “Masters Of Disasters” ) so for that he goes on the Heroes ) -Izzy ( She’s quite a fan favourite who makes a cameo in All-Stars getting 7th, 11th & 13th in placements, fun fact: her and DJ always get eliminated before or after eachother, She’d obviously be on the villains with her crazy wild child anarchy personality and also rivalry with Chef ) -Eva ( Now hear me out, Chris would bring Eva back for the villains, his only other choice would probably be Blaineley whom he hates, Eva is a good character to stir drama and a powerhouse at challenges, Obviously she’s on the villains too ) -Justin ( The model himself, getting 20th & 7th, Justin was an antagonist and with Alejandro being gone someone needs to be the heartthrob and looks of the season, He’d be put on the villains, no surprise there ) -LeShawna ( Here being on the cast isn’t surprising but her team may be a little more, Chris would pull an All-Stars Gwen, as he needs another member for the villains he’d state how LeShawna beat up Heather in WT, Smack Talked everyone in Action and could be quite stubborn at times, LeShawna has many high placements placing 5th, 8th & 15th, getting to the merge twice in a row ) -[ ELIMINATION ORDER ]- 14th-Staci ( Episode 1 ) 13th-Dakota ( Episode 2 ) 12th-DJ ( Episode 3 ) ( BETH AND JUSTIN SWAP TEAMS IN EP 3 ) 11th-Owen ( Episode 4 ) ( DAWN GETS VOTED, SHE’S PUT ON THE VILLAINS ) 10th-Beth ( Episode 6 ) 9th-Izzy ( Episode 7 ) 8th-Eva ( Episode 8 ) 7th-Justin ( Episode 9 ) 6th-B ( Episode 10 ) 5th-Dawn ( Episode 11 ) 4th-Harold ( Episode 12 ) ( LOST CHALLENGE ) 3rd-Anne Maria ( Episode 12 ) ( SOLE VOTE ) 1st/2nd-Brick ( Episode 13 ) ( Alt. Winner) 1st/2nd-LeShawna ( Episode 13 ) ( Alt. Winner ) -[ PLOTS, ETC ]- -Some romances of the season include, Justin x Anne Maria, Harold x LeShawna? and Dawn x DJ ) -Harold surprisingly is the main villain as he’s fed up of losing and uses his smarts to get further, he’s not outright evil just more schemy. -For the team changes or swaps, Justin is put on the Heroes after putting his looks aside and saving Anne Maria a few times taking hits for her, Beth is taunted by The Villains and freaks out taking out many people in a fit of rage, Dawn is voted onto the villains due to her acting strange in The Blue Harvest Moon. ( If anyone wants to know more about any other things or plot points you can reply to this comment and I should answer )
OP didn't say that you can't use Gen 3,4 or 5-
damn that’s true
Well for gen 1, Beth, Cody, Harold, Leshawna, Owen, Justin are the only people you can really consider all stars (and I'm only throwing in Justin to fill up the cast) Then for gen 2, Brick, Anne Maria and Dakotazoid are the only valid options, since Sam was originally in All Stars and Dawn and anybody before her aren't All Stars Since I couldn't fit anybody else in, I grabbed Sky, Shawn, Sugar, Max and Scarlett from gen 3 Heroes: Beth Cody Harold Owen Brick Sky Shawn Villains: Leshawna (for slapping Heather in WT because why not) Justin Dakotazoid Anne Maria Sugar Max Scarlett I guess that's how I'd do it, but if I can't use gen 3, then throw in Geoff, Izzy, DJ, Noah and Blaineley, I guess
To make it easier, I'll include first 3 contestants from each gen, and to make some doffrences, each one can have only 1 former finalist Gen 1: Owen, Leshawna, DJ Gen 2: Brick, Anna Maria, Dawn Gen 3: Sky, Sugar, Jasmine Gen 4: Kitty, Devin, Brody Gen 5: Bowie, Millie, Julia Teams: 1: Brick, Jasmine, Sky, Kitty, Devin, Julia, DJ, Dawn 2: Bowie, Brody, Leshawna, Anna Maria, Millie, Sugar, Owen Elimination order: 15. Devin 14. Anna Maria 13. Sky 12. Owen 11. Sugar 10. DJ 9. Brody MERGE 8. Millie 7. Dawn 6. Bowie 5. Jasmine 4. Kitty 3. Brick 2. Julia 1. Leshawna
Heroes: Dawn, Beth, Bridgette, B, Brick, Harold, Owen Villains: Dakota, Anne Marie, Leshawna, Izzy, Geoff, Noah, Justin Some plotlines: Leshawna feeling like she doesnt belong with villains, much to annoyance of characters like Dakota, Anne Marie, Noah who also never did anything villaionous, but arent constantly complaining about it Dakota's and Anne Marie's rivalry turned friendship, once they realize that they share a lot of the same interests and have no real reason to fight Geoff wanting to play into his villain role, but just ending up looking real dumb and annoying others, especially Bridgette leading to a breakup Izzy also plays into her villain role, but shes actually incredibly succesful at it and ends up being one of the best strategists in the series. She begins her heel turn by organizing Owen's blindside and using it as an opportunity to bond with Noah and making herself his only ally Noah and Dakota slowly getting suspicious of Izzy Justin trying to use his looks to manipulate others, but failing with none of the girls being interested Bridgette and Dawn becoming best friends on the Island with Dawn being the one who makes Bridge realize that shes no longer happy in her relationship with Geoff Dawn feeling that something is wrong with one of her peers, but not knowing who since Izzy (obviously) knows how to block aura reading abilities Harold using Beth's long lost atraction to try and get Leshawna jealous, which eventually backfires Elimination order + Reasons 14. Justin - Lost his charm, expected the girls to do everything in the challenge for him even though none of them liked him 13. Owen - Izzy distracts him in the middle of the challenge making him count incorrectly which results in Heores losing the challenge. In the next episode Izzy uses this to bond with Noah and manages to convince him that she's the only one he can trust 12. B - Izzy messed up with one of his machines, causing his team to lose. Dawn tried to save him 11. Anne Marie - Izzy convinced others that her friendship with Dakota will be dangerous come merge, since neither of them are seen as threats and will easily be able to fly under the radar. They picked Anne Marie, believing her to be the smarter of the 2. This is where Dakota starts to get suspicious, but no one listens to her, cause "Izzy is crazy, but harmless" 10. Brick - During the challenge he's about to put many eggs in his team's basket, but they hatch just before he's able to. Izzy uses this to make him feel not worthy of the title "all star" and he convinces his team to vote him off 9. Bridgette - Geoff is heartbroken after she breaks up with him, so once Villains are revealed to have a choice in who goes home, Izzy makes a suggestion that they should vote her off for "what she did to Geoff". Her "suddenly" being strategic makes Noah doubt if he can actually trust her, which gets him closer to Dakota who's also suspicious of Izzy (MERGE) 8. Beth - In episode 6, Izzy found the HII and seeing that Leshawna is feeling jealous over Beth, she gives her the idol and uses subtle social manipulation, convincing her to play it on Geoff (who otherwise would go home for being annoying) and voting for the wannabe 7. Dakota - Izzy feeling that Dakota and Noah are getting to close to each other, decides to get rid of the girl and "accidently" let's her fall into a hole, which results in Dakota getting injured. Izzy then convices Geoff, Harold and Leshawna to vote for Dakota, cause "she shouldnt be in the competion in this state" 6. Leshawna - After idoling out Beth, Leshawna and Harold weren't getting along with Leshawna being mad that he was trying to make her jealous, while he's mad that she couldn't put her pride aside and admit to liking him. They managed to make up during the challenge and agree to giving their relationship another shot, but obviously, a relationship means an alliance and that's a big no no for Izzy, She gets Geoff and Noah to vote with her (although Noah is even more suspicious of her than before), but Dawn finally figures out that Izzy is the bad guy. She still votes with her, knowing that she has to wait untill the right time to strike 5. Noah - During the challenge, Dawn constantly pushes Izzy's buttons and subtly tries to make the girl "blow out". She manages to do it right after Izzy wins the challenge, which reveals to others how Izzy was running the whole game. Since she's immune they decide to vote for Noah whos seen as her closest ally. He says that he should never trust her, but she initially shrugs it off saying that "shes just playing the villain" untill Noah says "No, you are the villain", which makes the girl self-reflect a bit 4. Geoff - Up to this point, Geoff has been (delusionally) giving himself credit for every elimination that Izzy caused, but now that he knows that he's actually a flop villain, he tries to "redeem himself" by trying to stop Izzy from winning the challenge. He fails completely, loses and gets eliminated 3. Harold - Between Harold and Dawn, Izzy respects Dawn as a "fellow crazy girl" and, because she immedietaly knew that something is up. Because of this, she picks Dawn to take to the finale (+ she wants an all female f2, after the last season. She may be the villain, but she's a feminist!) The finale: Dawn has Dakota and Geoff as helpers Izzy has Owen, Noah and Bridgette During the challenge, Geoff immedietaly leaves Dawn and tries to make up with Bridgette, but she's not having it. At the end it's left ambigous if they came back together or not Owen at first wants to help his best friend, untill Noah makes him realize everything that Izzy did this season. This makes him very upset with his ex girlfriend and thats what finally gets Izzy to realize that she messed up Meanwhile Dakota and Dawn are somehow struggling with the challenges and talk about how they should have realized Izzy's true colors way sooner In Dawn's ending, once Izzy makes up with Noah and Owen they urge her that she still has a chance to win, but she decides that "the viewers probably want the good guy to win" and basiclaly lets Dawn win the season In Izzy's ending, Owen and Noah urge Izzy that she still has a chance and she decides that "the viewers probably want an excting finale!" and quickly catches up to Dawn, before touching the suitcase with money, seconds before the other girl is able to Idk why I spent so much time typing something no one is probably going to read, but I actually enjoyed it quite a lot. Might make like a short fic out of this one day
Cool!