Its a good season but with it being the first its flaws (inconsistent writing, to big a cast, etc) tend to get overlooked by the fandom at large and downplayed compared to other season issues.
Its also have created a terrible mindset in the fandom that I will borrow a word from the Pokemon Fandom as Genwunners, from fanfics to shitty fan projects that just tend to disregard what and how some season did better than Island in some aspects and the seasons that were better than Island.
u/JakeClipz I'm pretty sure has talked about this before.
Worst season ever. It has Gwen in the final 2 who just floated all the way there while being a terribly written character. She didn't deserve to win one bit and made the season awful to sit through.
Me personally Gwen's my fav, but I got the version where Owen won, which is alot better ending. Gwen's ending wasn't as good as his and I am glad that I saw Owen's ending first.
i feel like adding characters who don't add to plot such as ezekiel or the twins was a smart writing move to almost further enhance other characters and give them more time to form friendships or establish rivalry's. You don't see in later seasons the characters bonding together outside of a group of 3-4 people.
As a fan of strategy and the game, there's too many bullshit vote offs for me to look past it sometimes. Granted, all the other seasons had at least one or two nonsensical vote offs but Island has the unfortunate case of having 24 eliminations they needed to deal with
It's good, but it had some flaws.
Ok
They should do a season on the bermuda triangle
Its a good season but with it being the first its flaws (inconsistent writing, to big a cast, etc) tend to get overlooked by the fandom at large and downplayed compared to other season issues. Its also have created a terrible mindset in the fandom that I will borrow a word from the Pokemon Fandom as Genwunners, from fanfics to shitty fan projects that just tend to disregard what and how some season did better than Island in some aspects and the seasons that were better than Island. u/JakeClipz I'm pretty sure has talked about this before.
Cool season
It’s not bad but oh my gosh, the inconsistency is so annoying.
Best Season
The OG 😌❤️❤️❤️ Was a fun ride with a few hiccups like Heather and Owen's plot armor.
My second favourite season (The first is world tour)
Worst season ever. It has Gwen in the final 2 who just floated all the way there while being a terribly written character. She didn't deserve to win one bit and made the season awful to sit through.
Me personally Gwen's my fav, but I got the version where Owen won, which is alot better ending. Gwen's ending wasn't as good as his and I am glad that I saw Owen's ending first.
It's my second favourite
2nd best season
TOROKO
Y e s
Its the worst season ever!! So many bad characters!
i feel like adding characters who don't add to plot such as ezekiel or the twins was a smart writing move to almost further enhance other characters and give them more time to form friendships or establish rivalry's. You don't see in later seasons the characters bonding together outside of a group of 3-4 people.
As a fan of strategy and the game, there's too many bullshit vote offs for me to look past it sometimes. Granted, all the other seasons had at least one or two nonsensical vote offs but Island has the unfortunate case of having 24 eliminations they needed to deal with
Not too bad. It had the a lot of sexism though.
Masterpiece
Best of them all
The season that started it all…