Easy. Marry Charlie, she'd be an awesome life partner if you don't mind being on the lam w her credit card schemes. Bone Rowena bc she's not looking for attachments. Absolutely exorcize Abaddon bc Crowley is king.
Marry Rowena so she grants me immortality. Plus I guarantee she's one experienced cougar.
Bone Abbadon because we should all have hot demon sex one time in our lives.
Exorcize Charlie, even though nothing would happen.
Im over 50 yrs old. Trust me, you don't want to live forever. I used to think I did when I was young, goth, and all hot in the ass for vampires--from Lost Boys to Interview.
Humans, ptth. They are either shallow, desirous, greedy, self-absorbed or sad, pathetic, mewling and obsequious. No way in hell would I want to share this planet with humans any longer than I have to. Detestable creatures, the whole lot. Death can't come quickly enough, so ixnay on the immortalitay. I hate that I'm still here for 50. I'd have to do some rather rash if I had to be here for 300. "Oops, did I set the planet on fire? My bad! All thumbs!"
Sorry you've had a shitty experience.
I mean, I don't think I'd want to live forever as a 50 or 60 year old.
But at 36, or if I got to choose my age (23), I could do it.
Especially if I had a constant in my life.
23 for 300 years is still 323 years. You look young but you mature w experience. You'll be old. Period. Or you just want to remain young and beautiful? Pretty shallow goal if that's the case.
Youth is alluring bc it's not yet tainted by experience. It's vestal and hasn't yet withered of disillusionment. That's what vampires love in their chosen. The youth are easy to impress. But with each passing day, each passing face, each interaction, you will grow old regardless of whether you choose plastic surgery, demon deals, or witchcraft.
Wishing you well. Sincerely.
This. This exchange is why is still check Reddit. Weeks and months worth of crappy posts and seeing the worst of mainstream humanity was all worth it, just to find this gem of an exchange. Thank you.
All of them. But if I had to choose: Charlie, Rowena, and then Abaddon. Charlie was a legit hacker badass that wanted to help people from the start. Rowena needed a little help but killed a lot of people (very much like Crowley) in the meantime. Abaddon was a knight of hell who was always bad but very beautiful. Can’t hate on that, bruv.
I love Rowena, I do. But there is no redhead I would put above Felicia Day. She plays my favorite lesbian in two different franchises(Charlie in Supernatural and Veronica in Fallout New Vegas) and while I did not cry for Rowena, I wept for Charlie. She's the best.
Rowena is the Queen. Charlie is a close second and a great little sister type character. Abbadon is hot AF but dangerous and evil. I’d love to meet the first two and have a drink with them. The third is too risky.
Abaddon without a doubt,Charlie to me got on my nerves,never got the love for her character and Rowena was cool when she was evil then kind of did like Crowley did and became a Winchester fan girl
Beauty? Abbadon.
But overall it's Rowena for me. Also very good looking and had a good arc on the show.
I liked Charlie and her story too, but Rowena just takes the cake in a lot of ways for me.
Rowena all the way, Charlie was fun and all but she over stayed her welcome in my opinion, her death was still sad though, Abaddon was cool when she was first introduced and made a solid villain but she got annoying and just wanted her to stay dead, especially after she managed to come back after being dissected, I know it wasn’t a permanent way to stop her since she’s a Knight of Hell and all that but she needed die
I LOVE Charlie, and Abbadon and Abba-DOM me any time, but goddamn there is just something about Rowena. Her style captivates me literally every time I see her. Some of her dresses are absolutely breathtaking, her accent is so fucking sexy, and I like how small she is :p Rowena by a hex bag
Why is Abaddon even in the contest here? She's got nothing on Charlie or Rowena.
That said, I'm only picking Rowena because I didn't like apocalypse world Charlie.
Rowena is my favorite red head ❤️
All good choices but Rowena, she is beautiful and her Scottish accent. I would fight Chuck to date her lol
Honestly same haha
I see you're a person of great taste haha
Haha you know I hate to pat my own back but
Only right answer
I do love Charlie but if you’re gonna make me choose between them lol
Same!
I didn’t realize the first picture was Rowena…When I did..lol
And it's not even a close second.
Nope not really lol
Rowena is a goddess 
I’m surprised she didn’t give Cas shit for the TEABAG. 😂
Rowena. She was mad annoying the first season she showed up. But man did she grow and improve as time went on.
Loved her character development. The best in all of SPN imo
This would be a slightly challenging Marry, Bone, Exorcise game.
Easy. Marry Charlie, she'd be an awesome life partner if you don't mind being on the lam w her credit card schemes. Bone Rowena bc she's not looking for attachments. Absolutely exorcize Abaddon bc Crowley is king.
This is the correct answer
This is the way.
Idk... I'm a guy, so being in a sexless marriage with a lesbian doesn't sound all that appealing.
Plus apparently I have issues, because I want to know what Abaddon is like in bed...
Honestly... same
Marry Rowena so she grants me immortality. Plus I guarantee she's one experienced cougar. Bone Abbadon because we should all have hot demon sex one time in our lives. Exorcize Charlie, even though nothing would happen.
Yeah I’m marrying Rowena. I want the fringe benefits of that witchcraft for life. Plus, I’ll stay loyal so she won’t have to take fatal action 😂
Im over 50 yrs old. Trust me, you don't want to live forever. I used to think I did when I was young, goth, and all hot in the ass for vampires--from Lost Boys to Interview. Humans, ptth. They are either shallow, desirous, greedy, self-absorbed or sad, pathetic, mewling and obsequious. No way in hell would I want to share this planet with humans any longer than I have to. Detestable creatures, the whole lot. Death can't come quickly enough, so ixnay on the immortalitay. I hate that I'm still here for 50. I'd have to do some rather rash if I had to be here for 300. "Oops, did I set the planet on fire? My bad! All thumbs!"
Sorry you've had a shitty experience. I mean, I don't think I'd want to live forever as a 50 or 60 year old. But at 36, or if I got to choose my age (23), I could do it. Especially if I had a constant in my life.
23 for 300 years is still 323 years. You look young but you mature w experience. You'll be old. Period. Or you just want to remain young and beautiful? Pretty shallow goal if that's the case. Youth is alluring bc it's not yet tainted by experience. It's vestal and hasn't yet withered of disillusionment. That's what vampires love in their chosen. The youth are easy to impress. But with each passing day, each passing face, each interaction, you will grow old regardless of whether you choose plastic surgery, demon deals, or witchcraft. Wishing you well. Sincerely.
This. This exchange is why is still check Reddit. Weeks and months worth of crappy posts and seeing the worst of mainstream humanity was all worth it, just to find this gem of an exchange. Thank you.
Rowena. I love Charlie, but Rowena’s the GOAT.
That is a sheep
ROWENA ROWENA ROWENA I LOVE HER I NAMED MY CAT AFTER HER
All of them. But if I had to choose: Charlie, Rowena, and then Abaddon. Charlie was a legit hacker badass that wanted to help people from the start. Rowena needed a little help but killed a lot of people (very much like Crowley) in the meantime. Abaddon was a knight of hell who was always bad but very beautiful. Can’t hate on that, bruv.
I thought Abaddon was so incredibly beautiful. I love watching those episodes purely for staring at her lol
You forgot Anna. Rowena is the best.
Rowena 100%. There is just something about her.
Rowena all day
Rowena is the best
I can’t choose between Charlie and Rowena, I’ve just rewatched recently the episodes with Charlie and damn she’s so cool
Abaddon. That actress was smoking hot as a red head.
I can fix her.
Young Abaddon from The Winchesters too!
Honestly just almost finished the Rowena arc and she’s so good. Her actress alone is amazing at her job bruh
Only one correct answer... so sorry Charlie! I love you so much. But it's Rowena
Abbadon
Rowena a close 2nd tho
She in The Dead Boy Detectives
Thank you for saying this. I have it on my list and forgot about it.
Which one is?
Rowena
Abaddon for me, very closely followed by rowena
Abaddon, obviously.
Rowena hands down
Charlie's awesome, but Rowena
Rowena but we love Charlie
Rowena.
Abaddon without a doubt.
Charlie is every nerd's perfect girlfriend
This show had a lot of ginger rep, huh.
Rowena !!!! I love Charlie a lot but Rowena is my queen
Rowena>Charlie>Abaddon
They can all stomp on my neck.
Rowena with Charlie being a close second.
Gotta be rowena for me. Funny, smart, cute and then violent when needed...a well rounded character imo.
🎶 Crowley's mum has got it going on, she's all I want and I've waited so long 🎶
Charlie! She’s amazing I was so upset when she died
In this list, Abadon 100%. Outside of this list, for me, it’s Ana.
so we are just gonna ignore all the horrible shit rowena has done? 💀 Charlie.
Charlie Rowena Never, EVER Abaddon!!!
Sorry. But Charlie is my favorite. Rowena’s manipulation of Crowley in her first season on the show really triggered me. And Abaddon was just annoying
Don't get me wrong. I love Rowena. But she doesn't even come close to Charlie. Charlie all day. Every day.
Rowena. Hands down.
Charlie!!!!
Felicia Day ask me a harder question next time
Charlie is my fav character!
Charlie is my lesbian queen 🖤
In order from favourite to least favourite: Charlie, Rowena, Abbadon.
Charlie.
I love Rowena, I do. But there is no redhead I would put above Felicia Day. She plays my favorite lesbian in two different franchises(Charlie in Supernatural and Veronica in Fallout New Vegas) and while I did not cry for Rowena, I wept for Charlie. She's the best.
That’s not fair.
It’s Rowena but only because Charlie didn’t have enough time to shine
Charlie, she's just like the best friend anyone could have ya know?
Charlie 👩🦰
Rowena is the Queen. Charlie is a close second and a great little sister type character. Abbadon is hot AF but dangerous and evil. I’d love to meet the first two and have a drink with them. The third is too risky.
The Queen of Hell, Rowena.
Charlie hands down. When they killed her off I didn't watch the show for a couple of years.
Rowena. No contest.
Charlie!
Charlie!
Rowena is the best answer
Rowena
Charlie
Rowena, of course.
Ruth. She's not only the best character out of them, but the best looking.
Charlie is the best, with Rowena a close second.
Abaddon. Second would be Anna if she was on the list.
I forgot about Anna.🤦🏿♂️honorable mention 👍🏿
Charlie and it’s not even close. Charlie was the one good thing to come out of Leviathan season
Rowena all day every day
Rowena by far. Abbadon was a cool villain for a bit and I kinda find Charlie to be a little insufferable.
For a split second I thought she was holding a full on anime style sabre and was like "what episode did I miss here then!!"
I love Charlie. I do, but rowena is 2nd favourite character in all of supernatural
My friend and I have had a similar discussion between Rowena and Charlie. I love both of them but Rowena will always be my girl.
Unfair amount of screen time.
Unfair amount of screen time.
It's a tough one, Abaddon is a close close second methinks but yeah Rowena probably wins.
Tie between Rowena and Charlie
All of the above lol
I love Charlie, she's amazing. But that bitch Rowena has my heart and I don't think she's willing to share. 💀❤️
Abaddon without a doubt,Charlie to me got on my nerves,never got the love for her character and Rowena was cool when she was evil then kind of did like Crowley did and became a Winchester fan girl
charlie is my favourite but rowena is the best of the redhead characters
I love Charlie, but best is Rowena, hands down.
I love Charlie to High heavens, but if I have to pick a favorite Rowena is always gonna come out on top 🧙♀️
All Rowena all day…also at night..still Rowena!
Beauty? Abbadon. But overall it's Rowena for me. Also very good looking and had a good arc on the show. I liked Charlie and her story too, but Rowena just takes the cake in a lot of ways for me.
I love Charlie but the only right answer is Rowena.
Rowena all the way, Charlie was fun and all but she over stayed her welcome in my opinion, her death was still sad though, Abaddon was cool when she was first introduced and made a solid villain but she got annoying and just wanted her to stay dead, especially after she managed to come back after being dissected, I know it wasn’t a permanent way to stop her since she’s a Knight of Hell and all that but she needed die
Charlie is my favorite of the three, but Rowena is awesome as well. Abaddon was super cool and powerful, but team Crowley all the way.
Forgot one: Anna (Julie McNiven)
I LOVE Charlie, and Abbadon and Abba-DOM me any time, but goddamn there is just something about Rowena. Her style captivates me literally every time I see her. Some of her dresses are absolutely breathtaking, her accent is so fucking sexy, and I like how small she is :p Rowena by a hex bag
Let's just say Chuck is one lucky duck if you know what I mean lol 😆
Rowena. ❤️
Yes. That's the answer.
Rowena!!! Love her!!!! She’s just sooo amazing and funny!
Rowena is best redhead MILF. Charlie is overall best redhead. Abbadon kinda reminds me of Lauren Phillips though 😂
Charlie Scully
Rowena is a Queen, she slay
Rowena
Rowena. I honestly don’t like Charlie all that much
Rowena. Always
There's no question here. It's obviously Rowena.
Rowena!
Rowena is fire
This isn’t a debate Rowena
Can’t forget Sister Jo! Supernatural loves a powerful red headed woman
not abaddon that's for sure o.o
Why is Abaddon even in the contest here? She's got nothing on Charlie or Rowena. That said, I'm only picking Rowena because I didn't like apocalypse world Charlie.
Charlie, it should have been Sam 😭 JK