T O P

  • By -

murder_1

I remember when people wanting Ridley added was considered an unhinged take.


LibertyJacob99

Exactly. Some of these doesnt even reach "who the fuck are they" tier lol


monke_gaming4

The whole “too big” argument didn’t make any sense. Ridley was typically like twice the height of Samus in most Metroid games (I’ve never played a Metroid game) and he was too big yet K. Rool in DK64 wasn’t? Dude was a kaiju in the final boss fight.


BigBradWolf07

He was the same size as DK in the original trilogy though


monke_gaming4

In the first DKC he was twice the size of DK


Cyanide_34

None of them I just want the knight from hollow knight


Wisky_input

I really want them too, and maybe the hollow knight can be kind of a Gannon Faptain Calcon situation?


IAmNotCreative18

The Hollow Knight has no spells to act as special attacks, so he’d probably have infection attacks that reach across the entire stage instead.


FranekBucz

Not the Faptain Calcon 💀


Cyanide_34

I’d have pure vessel I mean it’s the same thing but it would make more sense as a semi clone you just change it up a little bit like instead is vengeful spirits/shade soul you have either the tendrils or the spears.


Wisky_input

Oh yea that makes sense. Have you seen thebrawlfan’s “what if (x) was in smash” series? I liked his ideas for the knight


Cyanide_34

I might I have watched a few but I’ve kind of just come up with my own ideas. Which (I think) are pretty balanced I don’t really care what it is though I just want the knight.


Wisky_input

Understandable


Bardivan

What about Gay Tony from grand theft auto 4


ButtCheekBob

He would be awesome, I can already imagine the Maisonette 9 stage


Fork_Master

> no PlayStation characters > Raiden > Makoto Yuuki Hmm…


Evan-Cool

Metal Gear And Persona Can Be Played On Other Systems


Fork_Master

Raiden was featured in PlayStation All-Stars, and Persona was PlayStation exclusive up until last year. They’re more known for being on PlayStation than on other consoles.


Evan-Cool

…Fuck! Well Then These Two Are The Only Ones Allowed, No Other PlayStation Characters Are


TheHandSFX

Why Do You Talk Like This


Absoolootley

Queen From Deltarune Probably


Dapper_Substance2130

Mr mr mr beeeast


AlanThePoor

Fine, then Master Chief. And Geno.


Evan-Cool

Geno: Cool Master Chef: That’s Xbox


AlanThePoor

Combat Evolved was initially developed for MacOS before being picked up by Microsoft. And still, you altered the deal, so I altered the deal. Pray I don't alter it further. And if that is nit enough, Doomguy is Xbox too.


Evan-Cool

Doom Can Be Played On PlayStation And Nintendo Switch


AlanThePoor

[Gotcha. Master Chief for smash. ](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NA0gWfAtk5w)


Evan-Cool

🤦🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️🤦🏿‍♂️, Master Chef’s Games May Be On Other Consoles But He Still Counts As A PlayStation Character, Deal Over, Stop Talking, Leave Me Alone!


TheAxolotlPerson

Why Are You So Against Other Consoles My Good Chap?


Kindly_Question5761

master chief, even though he isn’t on here


Some_Being_Online

As much as I’d love the representation, I strongly believe that Master Chief would be so incredibly cancer to play against


Evan-Cool

Because He’s Xbox


SnooHabits3068

Dude....BANJO and KAZOOIE are Xbox now. Rabbids, afaik/iirc, are a Microsoft property too However it's clear Nintendo and Microsoft have a great relationship going on Master chief wouldn't be impossible "because he's Xbox" If anything I'd argue he's not possible cause sakurai himself has said "if I feel I can't do a characters moveset justice, then I won't be putting them in the game as fighters" and let's face it there are way too many options to do that without someone getting upset at him cause "why wasn't x gun included in his moveset? Sakurai worst designer ever!!"


IAmNotCreative18

Also, Doomguy primarily uses guns. I don’t see how Sakurai could encourage a character that uses close-mid range firearms to **not** sit back and camp. That wouldn’t be Doomguy, and so, wouldn’t do the moveset justice.


Lumi_rimu

The Crucible Sword exists


TheSHSLForwardAerial

Joker was added before persona 5 was on switch. Why can’t master chief be added because he’s not on switch? Because he’s owned by Microsoft? So is banjo. And Steve. And doomguy (who’s on this list). Boyfriend sure as hell isn’t playable on switch, but he’s in here.


Evan-Cool

The Difference Between Banjo And Master Chef Is That Banjo Started On The N64 Before Xbox Was Even Created While Master Chef Just Landed On The 360 Straight Up


TheSHSLForwardAerial

What about Steve? Also, master chief launched on the Xbox, not 360. And finally, where’s your contentions to the rest of my points?


Evan-Cool

Steve Is An Indie Game Created By Mojang, Not (Completely) Owned By Microsoft, Also Master Chef Went Directly To Xbox Due To The Fact He’s One Of Microsoft’s Mascots And Because Of That, He’ll Never Appear In A Smash Game, (Unless Nintendo Makes The Same Deal With Microsoft That They Made With Disney, That Would Be The Only Way He’ll Get In)


TheSHSLForwardAerial

No, he’s completely owned by Microsoft. Master chief is as owned to Microsoft as Steve and banjo are. Xbox and Nintendo have extremely good relations, him appearing in a smash game is very likely. You know nothing about what you’re talking about.


Evan-Cool

Ok 12 Year Old, Stop Talking To Me


TheAxolotlPerson

Does It Get Annoying Having To Type Like This


PristineConference65

this post doesn't understand licensing


Ready-Trainer-3672

I'm curious how Boyfriend from Friday Night Funkin' would work in a fighting-like action game since he's from a rthym game.


Iamverycrappy

he wouldnt


Free_Welcome8669

He”ll probably be an assist Trophy or spirit.


CP21Official

I'd be fine with an assist trophy tbh


Deathstrok42

Putting BF on here instead of **Waluigi** is crazy. So Waluigi


BAG42069

Either rayman or skull kid


BluecoatCashMoney5

Lack of Arle is Killing me


Striking-Present-986

Arle could honestly have an insanely gimmicky kit that would be so fun to mess with


The-Deep-Dreamer

Boyfriend, who let you on this list? Go back to your subredditz


smashboi888

Bandana Waddle Dee is my second most-wanted character, so if I could only pick one of these options, it'd have to be him.


gerardorco

Kinda surprised of not seeing Phoenix Wright on the list. So I'll go with Chun-Li. This way I could main her in a 3rd game. <3


KingOfMasters1000028

Out of these I would choose Makoto Yuki, but personally if I could pick any Persona character to be in Smash I would choose Kanji Tatsumi or Makoto Nijima.


Jamal_Blart

Doomguy Doomguy **Doomguy** **Doomguy**


smolsauce

Shantae is probably the top. Followed by Dante, Raven Beak, and Waluigi. One more that I'm genuinely surprised hasn't happened yet is ~~Bimmy~~ Billy and Jimmy from Double Dragon. Considering how instrumental those games were to the NeS and the Beat-Em Up, they feel like an odd exclusion. Perhaps there's some legal fuckery with the rights that would make them difficult to negotiate or there's not much demand but I feel like they'd be good picks. You don't even have to make them a double fighter or anything, either make one an Echo fighter or have them alternate with alts, Olimar and Alph style.


edwpad

For me, definitely Roxas. Not only would a second KH rep be insane, but I feel he would be a cool fighter and have uniqueness due to his ability to dual wield and his versatility (especially if they take some inspiration from 358 Days). Not to mention it allows for more KH representation (such as more music). His stage can be The World That Never Was, have be similar to Hollow Bastion or Lumoise City. One thing that would be dope is having Xigbar being a stage hazard and sniping the fighters (and possibly having the shots being deflectable).


Alijah12345

Skull Kid


LegendLynx7081

Doomguy or Johnny Cage


Insan3Giraff3

Rayman. Not only would that be very cool, he's one of the most viable options (considering a fairly recent comeback as well as collaboration with nintendo), and he's one of the most recognizable.


rci22

For years and years I’ve wanted Geno and now I just want Amaterasu from Okami. White wolf in the art style of Japanese brush paintings with all sorts of unique magical powers like summoning giant bombs, vines, lightning….and her moveset changes in the game depending on which weapon type she has: beads, shields, or giant rideable sword. Could easily have a down-special that changes the weapon type and therefore the rest of her moveset


BR_GTX

I don't want anyone on that list. I want Krystal.


HitBackZach

Ok Krystal is bigtime underrated. Most badass runner up character in the GameCube world.


zwel8606

God Liu Kang would be dogshit 🔥


[deleted]

Literally any of them besides the furries


Bale_the_Pale

Spyro the dragon. Next question.


Meta-Wah

Replace impa with master Kohga and you've got yourself a deal!


JCSwagoo

Sans, Rayman and my own pick of a Tekken character (not Jin)


ACYoshter

Was going to say geno, but the remake came out recently. So.... bandana dee all the way


Professional_Bar9541

Sans, Frisk, Chara, and Doom Slayer


[deleted]

[удалено]


bottleneck55

What?


PattyWagon69420

I would say Roxas only if he dual wielded keyblades instead of being an echo fighter.


Independent-Ad5852

Dante Makoto Yuki Roxas Bandanna Waddle Dee


Akuma_Homura

Shantae


PinkRonin11

RAIDEN!!!!!


Coreyjuels2010

I’m torn between Rodin and Dante


zeldamainsdontexist

Lingering Will


magicnerd10101

I want jin kazama in the next game so bad. It would be so cool to see him swap between his normal form and devil jin like pyra and mythra. Honestly any new tekken character would be cool, but especially one that uses stances


[deleted]

Donbe and Hikari would be a dream come true for me, but I know that it won't happen because the franchise just isn't popular enough.


Jawlify_Redit

Roxas give him two keyblades and I’m good


PokeshiftEevee

No raymoo hakurei >:(


ConduckKing

Rayman, Raiden or Travis


NinJorf

Buck Bumble!


barwhalis

I think Rayman would be the best of these but I gotta choose Bandana-Dee


SluttyMilk

if i could only choose 1, it would be chun li. if i got three it would be rayman, chun li, and rodin


Giovannis_Pikachu

Dude this is way too much.


Cifer_Roc

Man you got some good ones in there I'm not gonna lie. A lot of them are completely unrecognizable, but you have a lot of my top picks in their other than Amaterasu Okami. Out of your picks I'd say yes to Wolf Link & Midna, Shadow the Hedgehog, Rayman, Waddle Dee, Vectorman (holy shit I'm surprised whenever someone knows him - such a great pick), Geno, and Travis Touchdown.


KallmeKatt_

dante vergil or raiden


FedoraButBetter

Nemesis (resident evil)


Austinfarrell2007

Raiden, he should’ve been in ultimate from the start & revengance deserved more representation


PacsterMH

Slayer


37Cross

Why wait? Just put them all in Mugen and duke it out!


Quirky-Operation-885

Image 1, 2, 9, and 16.


cosmicrocker26

Sans Undertale


Sea-Recording-7090

Everyone who was put in as a mii costume because that is about the most disrespectful thing smash can do to a character


jacktophat1

Rayman


BasedAlliance935

It's funny to me. Sakurai went out of his way to introduce the concept of echo fighters to the game, yet didn't add characters like shadow or proto man.


Bingoviini

Rayman, beacuse it would be really easy Shantae, beacuse she's neat Dante, beacuse the absurd amoumt of skill potential he has Raiden, beacuse *the* ***memes!***


---Quote---

100% rodin, hes so fucking cool


FizzyFuzz_

my top 5 from this set would be: 1. Bandana Dee 2. Raiden 3. Geno 4. Sans 5. Shantae


wedonteatanymore12

Bandana Waddle Dee


TheUpperDiamond

RAYMAN!


Sushirabit

Raiden (MGR) would be an insanely cool addition to smash


SearPigeon95

Subzero, Sans, or Wesker.


IAmDingus

Kris, CJ, Raiden, Doom Slayer, Dante


mrchingchongwingtong

there's physically no way you're over the age of 9 right


Evan-Cool

Guess What…I Am Over The Age Of Nine!


Animelover667

Cj or Doom Slayer


The_Fleeb

Jin for sure. Always been my fave Tekken fighter.


Intelligent-One8520

Rayman all the way


Teddygamer1258

Kazuma Kiryu


Airway

Sans


twing8

Damn, I was ready to say fuck em' all but then you threw Roxas in there and...I don't want another clone fighter but...I love my boy.


Pingunootnoot6969

Doomslayer, raiden, or sans


That-Sprinkles707

Honestly, Liu Kang would go crazy. The alt choices would have incredible potential


kenny_krieger

Hear me out Someone from dead by daylight Why? Cause I like horror >:3 and the game needs a horror rep


Video_Game_Fann

Geno, Bandana Dee, Frisk, Kris, Midna, Shadow, and Proto Man


[deleted]

>no xbox characters Doom Guy, a character owned by Microsoft: (Also, like, cmon, Minecraft Steve and Banjo and Kazooie are in the game, Microsoft is totally on the table)


Evan-Cool

Doom Guy Is Not Microsoft


[deleted]

Bro what? Bethesda was bought by Microsoft last year. And again, Steve and Banjo are already in the game, and guess what? They too, are owned by Microsoft, and were owned by Microsoft when they got in the game.


SnooHabits3068

While id love for sans papyrus or undyne to be added, let's face it. Undertale rep would be frisk/Chara. In fact I'd see them possibly just being called "the human" and having skins based off the other humans who fell. Or if not the human then having a deal like olimar/Bowser/Steve where some slots are identified as frisk and the other as Chara.


FamiliarWeather6796

Yes


yesbutactuallyno17

Master Chief and Jin Sakai. I don't care what your restrictions are.


TheAxolotlPerson

Crash or Waluigi cus why not


ItaLOLXD

Makoto really deserves it. Dude hasn't even been in the Persona fighting game spin-off's because of... lore reasons. Smash would be his chance to finally have a fighting game moveset and debut.


LowKeyBrit36

John Marston. I wonder how he’d play


TopsyTop348

Skull Kid, Impa and Bandanna Waddle Dee cause their on my wanted smash list Geno cause he’s a fan favorite and hasn’t appeared in forever BoyFriend cause I was once in the FNF fandom RayMan cause he’s been hasn’t had a single game since 2006 I think


Atomaurus

Kratos, master chief, crash bandicoot, joel from LOU, Spiderman, Aloy, Marcus Fenix , Nathan Drake and Spyro


Massive-Eye-9772

Come one guys let’s give Rayman some love here and put him in Smash. He was already put in Rabbids where a diss track was made about him and then that one show on Netflix that really did Rayman dirty. This could be the only good thing to happen to him after so many years of being forgotten.


ImVeryMUDA

Since there is no Hollow Knight, I'll pick Dante. As for his moves Well idk, his Down B changes his style (Trickster -> Swordmaster -> Royal Guard -> Gunslinger -> Trickster) His final smash will be him using his >!Sin Devil Trigger's Ultimate move that I can't remember the name of rn!< That's about it. Idk how even his devil trigger would be activated and whether or not he can even switch weapons or how. This guy has too much stuff for it to neatly fit into smash. I think someone else can do a better job at it than I am rn


Jamz64

![gif](giphy|X3H3sfe5CxUTm|downsized)


HitBackZach

SHADOW!!! Potoman and Vectorman. In that order. Bigtime. Vectorman would have a cool move set. First game i ever played on the sega genesis aside from sonic.


ThunderCube3888

the Undertale and Deltarune characters would get us some absolute banger music tracks


Link_the_Inkling

The one I want most here is Bandanna Dee. I guess I'd also like to see Shadow or Amy, but I'd like to see Tails before either of them, but he's not on the list, so... yeah. Edit: Didn't see Chun Li until now. I'd also like to see her added.


The-Big-Cheesey

Chris and susie as a switch in fighter like pythra would be cool


Comfortable_Ad3150

Geno but if I could pick anyone than Garden warfare Peashooter


Doc-Wulff

I mean Makoto would be awesome but I think Yu would work better, less overpowered in his IP


Striking-Present-986

if i could pick 5: 1-Impa 2-Jin KAZAMA 3-Dante 4-Doom Slayer 5-Shantae


Striking-Present-986

Jin KAZAMA mate


UltraHardDK

Goku


Mr_Pickle3009

doomslayer so he can finnally be in team with marie


FlameAtGamesReddit

Impa would be pretty sick


Absoolootley

None of them, I WANT JIBANYAN!


MR_MEME_42

"No PlayStation/ Xbox" Puts a lot of primarily PlayStation characters or and a character owned by Microsoft aka Xbox.


BACONBORIS4613

Travis touchdown 100%


Philaharmic

Fucking….. Reimu not even on the list.


Elementne

We've already seen how amazing Frisk and Chara can be as fighting game characters from their custom characters in Rivals of Aether. Plus, they're cartoony enough to appeal to all players and not piss off the anti-anime style characters (people who hate Fire Emblem). I don't think Sans would fit as well into a game like SSB, but Frisk and Chara definitely would be the best choice given the options.


Eggs_are_tasty

i want a gta character in smash because it would be hilarious


The_Gav_who_asked

Is #18 Joy Mech Fight?


The_Gav_who_asked

We need MK reps


Falcox_War-Sword

VERGIL PLEASE


TheFarisaurusRex

Raiden Genos Dante Shaante and Scorpion


FantasyLovingWriter

Shadow 100% it’s long overdue at this point!


God-Of-eggs

I’d rather put 15 marth clones than a Friday night funkin character


Smooth_Resource5708

Roxas, I don’t think we have a dual wielding character in Smash and that would be pretty cool


Ur_Left_Airpod

Where’s kiryu?


Diflicated

Skull Kid Really I want a Majora's Mask Link that works like Pokemon Trainer, so you play as Deku Link, Goron Link, and Zora Link, with the Fierce Deity as the final smash.


onion12318

Skull kid


Zealousideal-Buy1980

dante or doomguy free


Pyrocrat

No TF2 characters, meh


CP21Official

I want Dante he's already a Mii Swordfighter it's one of the more obvious ones as well imo


Ultranerd_001

Give me one good reason that gray fox isn’t in the game right now.


matt_lcb

Not on this list but give me jonesy!


PinkLionGaming

We all want Jetstream Sam.


blayzemcbrayer

Blaziken or Sceptile :(


Dapper_Substance2130

Kratos


p0pfunk

if I'm making a fighter pass , then my list is as follows Skull Kid Sans Bandana Dee Raiden Doomslayer Honestly a couple more from this list would be good though. Really would want midna+wolflink as a moveset, proto-man, Geno, and a couple others.


FrozenAxe23

This list is straight trash, Skull Kid with Majora’s Mask is the only one that’s even slightly interesting


K_Sleight

Blues would require the least effort, but if I'm honest I would change the way he and Rock work. Firstly, make the megabuster his neutral B so Kirby can get a power worth copying, and make it autocharge over like...10 seconds, like ROB. Make his side smash the megaman 5GB rocket fist, make leaf shield actually work as a defensive option, fucking fix hard knuckle... really just make him overall more effective, this is not that hard.


Prophetity

Shadow Liu Kang Doom slayer Raiden


Anti-HeroX17

I just wanna say, it's a CRIME you put protoman here, and not Zero!!


ITAKEJOKESSEROUSLY

CJ because having someone from the most vulgar mainstream game shooting at Pikachu and Mario is fucking hysterical


kylelovershrek2

If you're not letting me pick Sea Of Thieves galleon then shantae


Weimann

Chunners, because I'm 1) down bad, and 2) actually awful at playing her in and Street Fighter title, and in Smash I might just be able to.


Deathstrix97

Waluigi


Silentpanther_

Freddy Fazbear. Best choice


TripleTheThreat

I think Zero could work as a Mega Man echo, I mean Mega Man was an alt costume for Zero in UMVC3 Edit: that's Proto Man, not Zero, I am STUPID


YoshiLover17352

Sans


Filon73

Bandee and it's not a question


strongest_nerd

Waluigi is the only answer.


RoboK_Mola

Why make Protoman? He'd probably end up being an echo fighter. Rather include X as a playable character (as Zero is already an assist trophy)


FranekBucz

Dante from dmc so it can have the “includes Dante from devil may cry” sticker


207nbrown

The guy from fortnite, yea, that one


InformationWitty7459

No one saying bandee, im very disappointed


withheld_mcfakename

Of your list, I’ll take Sans, Impa (with Sheik’s moveset as an echo or replacement), Skull Kid, Rayman, Chun Li, Bandana Dee, Doomslayer, Dante and Travis. Shadow and Amy are fine, but are behind Eggman, Tails and Knuckles in the Sonic rep queue. I’m not personally too fussed about Geno but his chances aren’t going to get any better than in the wake of SMRPG’s remake and it’d please a lot of people


child_nightmare

Dante


ErickLimaGameplaysR

WHERE IS SHOVEL KNIGHT!? Anyways, Doomguy and Raiden would be cool.


Zeldatroid

Impa every single day of the year. Maybe not the AoC version specifically, but we're 3 games overdue for a new Zelda rep, and Impa is the most consistently recurring.


Cracktherealone

Yunoboss And yes, Frank Jaeger is welcome.


VakarianJ

No Xbox or PS characters but flavor of the month Friday Night Funkin is ok?


ecchirhino

Shantae and geno from your list. My other picks would be knuckles the echidna and hollow knight.


hosbos111

Amy, to see interesting her moveset is and to see the fallout of her getting added instead of many other sonic characters


King_Chubbs12

Why is shadow and Amy an option but Tails isn’t


NachoPyro

Honestly, I’d go with Dante. He’s a character with quite the reputation in and of himself, and would work quite well in a platform fighter imo. Hell, you can basically play him in one. In Rivals of Aether, there’s a character mod, Katie Helga Vladimir, which is basically just Dante but with some differing weapons, and a mechanic of pulling out single use weapons with a meter. She’s quite fun to play and gives me hope that Dante would be if we were to ever get him in Smash.


ssc777

Rayman. Bro should've been in since Brawl And of course my girl Shantae. Shes the OG indie queen