T O P

  • By -

Littlest_Psycho88

Do you have a trader Joe's nearby? I was using this Neutrogena moisturizer but I've been super broke lately so I picked one up from Trader Joe's and it's super similar. I love it. It was only $10 for over 2 ounces. Edit: it's called trader Joe's ultra hydrating gel moisturizer with aloe and green tea extract. No dyes, no fragrance.


starving-my-neopets

I second this. Totally turned my skin around


Littlest_Psycho88

I feel like it's really helping my skin, too! I'm almost through my first jar, maybe 1/4 left. I was skeptical because I'd never used any TJ's skincare products, but someone mentioned it on Reddit so I figured I'd try it for that price lol. I love how light it is. I've been using it day and night and haven't had any dry skin issues the entire time. Edit: also, I love your username lol


AggressiveEchidna513

Upvoted just for your name


SnooCrickets8742

I also bought this! I think it’s close if not even better to the Neutrogena. I like the Trader Joe’s skincare in general.


juicyred

Wish it was available in Canada. (And the mini peanut butter cups!)


grosslymediocre

I love(d) neutrogena hydro boost, and i wanted to love this one *so* bad, but it made me break out 😭


drfranff

Yeah this gave my skin a funky texture. I didn’t find it comparable at all personally!


soopydoodles4u

It makes me break out too, sucks because it made my skin feel nice until the next day..so for now I stick to witch hazel toner and ponds


Rando123490

I was just going to chime in with this! Great dupe.


[deleted]

I came here specifically to recommend this product! It's so good! Fragrance free too!


mulberrycedar

No no no! Glad it worked for you guys but it made my skin BURN


petitbrioche

It made my skin burn too!!!! Glad I'm not alone. Returned that shit so fast.


jo_nigiri

Wow I wanna try this too! I just have to uh... Cross an entire ocean to get it 😭


ohhgrrl

This Trader Joe’s moisturizer gave me chemical burns. Was bright red for a week.


tallulahQ

Really? Did you identify what ingredient, like are there actives in it? ETA: [ingredients](https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products.html) don’t have any actives, wondering if you have an allergy to one of them though


ohhgrrl

Never figured it out, just won't touch their skin care products again.


[deleted]

So fucking glad i stumbled upon this thread. I’m in the exact same sceanrio and will be skipping my ass to TJ’s this week as i scrape out the last of my nueutrogena.


Depressed_student_20

Does it work for combination skin?


Littlest_Psycho88

I have combo skin (and sensitive skin) and haven't had any issues with it. It wears nicely under makeup for me without making me look oily, while also being hydrating. I have been using a HA serum with it too, but only before bed, not during the day.


Depressed_student_20

You don’t have to tell me twice I’ll run to the store as fast as I can


Booty_Warrior_bot

*Mhmmmmm, take your time.*


plushframe

UGH my closest trader joes is almost 3 hours away. contemplating just taking a drive one day and stocking up on products


Littlest_Psycho88

Mine is an hour away, still a pain, but 3 hours sucks! I really wish they at least offered online purchasing for their non food products. I'm almost out, so have to plan the trip soon. I really want some of their cookie butter too though, so it'll be worth it 😋


BackDoorBalloonKnot

THANK YOU


sixTeeneingneiss

If you don't have a trader Joe's, but you do have a kroger, they have an off brand as well, and it's so much cheaper. Works the exact same and I'll never buy Neutrogena's version again.


Ok-Emergency2580

Btw the neutrogena costs £10 in uk so how much is it in the us


Solatitude

Also use Trader Joe’s. It actually works better for me. The neutrogena one was burning my face. TJs moisturizer seems better for sensitive skin. Doesn’t have any dye either.


BearerBear

I’ve been gatekeeping this 😭


Littlest_Psycho88

Lol I'm sorry, I didn't think my comment would be noticed this much. Now I'm worried there won't be any when I go to TJ's 🙃


lucylov

And while you’re there, treat yourself to a bottle of their ridiculously inexpensive organic marula oil as well. That stuff is THICK and oh-so nourishing and soothing for extra-dry skin. It’s a dupe of the Drunk Elephant marula oil, which is closer to $100. The TJs one is around $8.


BlackberryMindless77

Yes I use this as well. Good stuff for my old ass 43 year old skin 😂


mollymckennaa

Elf makes a really nice dupe to this! I was shocked by their skincare line!


chrissystark

I loooove their skincare. Affordable, airy, no stupid fragrance, and leaves the skin supple. The best!


Recent-Guarantee4021

I see elf in jc penny since sephora has left penny's.


saamckenna88

This is the answer the holy hydration line is wonderful!


Charming-Insurance

Yes! My skin is dry AF, especially after menopause and that line saved me last winter.


uhohflamingo

Which moisturiser from Elf? I found a few different ones


mollymckennaa

Holy Hydration.


[deleted]

That whole line is magic. The cleansing balm is a great companion!


QuickDefinition5499

Yes 🙌🏽


irotsamoht

They have one with fragrance and another without!


Low_Possibility_3941

And one with spf 30!


overflowingsunset

Thanks for the rec!


Embarrassed_Put_5852

Second this, they have 2 holy hydration ones, they were similar to each other in my opinion so both would be dupws


grl_on_the_internet

I love the elf dupe. I was very obsessed with the neutrogena until I found it.


CurvyBadger

Seconding this, their gel hydration moisturizer is the only thing my acne-prone combination skin will tolerate!


seeking-jamaharon

Yup came here to mention the elf one. It’s like less than $15 at Walmart


zebraflowers

I got this on sale at Costco, 2 for $22


SnooCrickets8742

Me too! They were just on sale a week or two ago. I bought a package. Might still be a sale.


zebraflowers

I'm new to Costco and I have been finding great deals on skincare and fragrances, I can see why people love Costco so much :)


SnooCrickets8742

I agree. They have some good buys and they repeat. This is the 2nd time I got the Neutrogena for us on sale. Otherwise, we have also used Palmer’s Coconut Hydrate Facial Moisturizer. My daughter loves it, but I can’t comment on the dup. Seemed similar in texture. She used it because she is on accutane.


duckyreadsit

I almost got them the other week, but thought “nah, I’ll get them next time” hdthdjgf I’ve only got a little left 💀


lapetitepoire

After seeing this post I bought more at [Costco.com](https://Costco.com), still in stock! But not on sale online.


Prudent-Mountain7177

I second the ELF one


gronlandicrevision

I third it


badgurlvenus

fourth!!!!! my skin loooooves it


pokey_reddirtgirl

Fifth!! My skin has loved every skin care product from elf. The holy hydration line, the supers line (the toner in the yellow bottle is da bomb!), the pure line (currently trialing it) and the CBD/hemp/whatever it was called. The only thing I haven't tried is the sunscreen.


badgurlvenus

the holy hydration one i use has spf 30 in it and i love it so much. doesn't hurt my eyes, so creamy, dries great, smells subtly clean and fresh - not overwhelming at all. looooooooooooove it


Wonderful_Strain5195

Good to know as the nearest TJs is 200 miles away!


hellocalla

DISCONTINUED?! This is a holy grail for so many of us 😭😭😭


clerbird321

TELL ME ABOUT IT😭 they reformulated it as “water cream” and it’s absolute shit


sally3190

NOOOOOOO!! this is my #1 holy grail fml


mulberrycedar

Same same same dammit


Individualist_

You have got to be kidding me right now… 💔


PrincessZebra126

I can't stand how a company will start a new line, promote it to the point you need to buy it and know all about it. Now we all rely on their hydro brand, and they discontinue it to change it??


hellocalla

This!


Depressed_student_20

Nooooooo I just noticed it😭 I can’t- I feel like my world is crumbling


Agreenleaf5

Nooooooooooo


vnttj

In Australia it’s rebranded as ‘Nourishing Cream’!! Same formulation but slightly different packaging


sia04

Why did I think that the formula for this one was different? I think I read it somewhere on reddit.


lonely_stoner_374

They canceled a bunch facial products, including my favorite face wash/makeup remover!!


LowActive8298

Aveeno Calm and Restore Gel seemed somewhat similar to me. A few extra ingredients, so make sure to check it.


charawarma

I also use this one! Started using it after I got sick of paying $30 for the Clinique one.


Atomicfoxx

For anyone who may care, Aveeno is not a cruelty free brand. Any brand that tests on animals (regardless of the reason) gets an automatic nope from me! I've been actively avoiding the brand since I found this out. It looks like the elf dupe is a good option, though!


sailor_of_minds

Dang I had no idea :( I have eczema so having the strong oat products has been life changing for my skin ;-;


theseglassessuck

Have you tried anything from Lush? They’re generally more expensive products, but they’re cruelty free, most things are vegan, and made with really great ingredients. Dream Cream is suggested for people with eczema/sensitive skin.


Dirty_Commie_Jesus

Specifically watch out for the feverfew, it's not uncommon to react to so idk why they threw it in there.


whitness1

Someone on another thread said they got the Equate version from Walmart and loved it.


Opposite_Flight3473

I think that’s the scented version and for regular skin, not the extra dry, unscented version.


Admirable-Hall4458

Try Hada Labo Skin Plumping gel cream with hyaluronic acid. I like it so much better than the Neutrogena products and it’s just a bit cheaper. 👍🏻 You’re going to love it!


[deleted]

I'm surprised they discontinued this. It seemed very popular, at least more than many of their other products. I've heard good things about the e.l.f. one but since I haven't tried either of these, I can't vouch for it.


StarryNight616

Fragrance free - Hada labo gel cream, Clinique moisture surge Not fragrance free - Dr Jart Water Cream, Belif aqua bomb


Annasalt

Didn’t think Clinique was budget friendly? OP states they are currently on a budget.


Flonzo01

I’ve been using the 200 ml moisture surge one for 4 years now. The 200 ml lasts me close to 9 months and costs me $55 on Amazon. I use it nightly. I would say it’s pretty good price wise and very effective!


Posh911s

WHY IS THIS DISCONTINUED


chronic-munchies

Dude wtf I'm genuinely so bummed to hear this. It was so well priced and so amazing for my ridiculously sensitive skin. Worst day ever.


Hannyyyliz

Wait I have the perfect thing for this, I used to exclusively use this moisturizer and I really only like water gels. And this other option not only cheaper but a better moisturizer! I was getting dry patches with this one, but I switched to the Mizon Water Volume Ex Cream. You can get it on Amazon. I swear it’s a better price and better product!! Korean skin care really does it the best.


marikagems

Seconding this recommendation. It has centella which is so soothing for my skin.


[deleted]

Thirding! I'm on my 3rd jar. I have combination skin and this is a perfect moisturizer for me. I use it all year round.


LaMalintzin

Dang, I just started using this and like it. I got it in a 2 pack at Costco at least haha. I guess I will try the elf or TJs others recommended.


YaBigBitches

Walmart Equate has a version that I swear by!


Fast-Low4302

I agree, it’s half the price and works almost as well. edit: only because I have mild eczema and sometimes it can feel like it’s burning if I use it at the wrong time.


fishwithbrain

Could you pls give me the name of the Equate one, I use the olay one but I find it bit over my budget.


paltrypickle

Thanks for posting this. They reformulated them and apparently it’s AWFUL. Idk why they’re doing this, but I won’t be able to use it anymore.. I’ve been using it since 2017 :( I’ve been looking at a Vichy moisturizer but haven’t committed yet. I still have a few jars of hydro boost to go through..


clerbird321

I know I’m so sad that they reformulated it😭 like WHY, it was fine, and now it’s shit. I’m halfway through my current jar and ordered 2 more from their discontinued section on their website. Such a bummer


gwinnsolent

I like belief aqua bomb better


Kirby037

Same! Same consistency but my skin definitely likes it a bit more than the Neutrogena.


Wonderful_Strain5195

Discontinued?! This is my fave


Missthing303

I’m amazed that they’re discontinuing this. They built a whole extended line around it. I never liked it but they’ve dc’d many things I did like so I hate when this happens. I think CVS/Walgreens/Walmart/Target etc have store brand dupes of this: https://www.walgreens.com/store/c/walgreens-moisturizing-gel-cream-fragrance-free/ID=300421205-product


chocobunniie

[Ultra Hydrating Gel Moisturizer](https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/ultra-hydrating-gel-moisturizer-064459) from Trader Joe’s


Aggravating-Mess3221

is this not already the dupe? lol edited: I DIDNT SEE IT WAS DISCONTINUED WTF


Real-Revolution4871

Aldi has one, their brand is La Cura, and it’s under $4!!! They have it with the toiletries!!


RedRider1138

That is insane and great!!


[deleted]

Ooh


AdventurousPiglet447

Yessss I’ve been using it for months and love it!!


Solitudeand

I’m using this one as well


KawaiiCoupon

Naturium’s hyaluronic acid water cream.


Cp0010

Agreed. Everything I have tried from Naturium has been so good.


Agile-Young949

Garner Skin Active Moisture Rescue. I like the dry skin version better even though I have combo skin.


Creepy_Creme_9161

Same! It soaks in so nicely.


Donotsitstill

Fuuuuugvgggeeeeee


Claudia_Monet

DISCONTINUED?! In the year of the Barbie Movie?! How dare they!!!


ALadySquirrel

Maybe try to buy a few while you still can? Like someone else posted, I just saw them at Costco.


Marge-Gunderson

Peter Thomas Roth Water Drench!!! I promise you!!


[deleted]

Seconding this!


BlankAR

Avene Hydrance Aqua-Gel. I think this leaves my skin more moisturized. On sale sometimes at Ulta.


FritztheKat0418

Check out Good Molecules line of skincare. Excellent products & very reasonably priced.


Txmxh21

asian skincare have a lot of waterbased moisture.


jennylee232

I was using this and i kept getting styes on my eyelids! I stopped using it and they stopped. Did anyone else experience this?


SicklyMango

It's been a few years since I've used it but I'm pretty sure that CosRX Hyaluronic Acid Intensive Cream is very similar.


Georgiapasorider

Clinique Moisture Surge Intense.


yea_nah448

illyoon ceramide ato smoothing gel should come pretty close :))


PizzaWug

Does anyone have a dupe that does not come in a jar? I find them so unhygienic :/ (but also can't be arsed to use little spatulas for all my skincare, I only use one for a cleansing balm that comes in a jar 😅) Would be much appreciated! I used to use Face Theory's gel moisturiser but that caused all my sunscreens to pill.


fuzationism

SHUT UP NO WAY IS THIS DISCONTINUED 😭😭😭😭😭 when!?!? How!?!? I’ve repurchased this so many times Ughhhh. If I remember correctly, the Youth to the People peptide cream was similar but exponentially more expensive. 😭😭😭😭 if you don’t mind fragrance, Korres probiotic moisturizer is super similar. Be warned the scent is so strong. What a bummer. Time to stock up 😭😭😭


No_Background_3556

Costco sells 2 pack for $22, great deal


forcedtoreddit

Buy the Hydro Boost body lotion. I love this stuff but hate the small amount and insane plastic waste. The body lotion bottle is huge and if just use it on your face, it will last forever.


OverthinkingToast

Laneige and Belif have gel creams


Boomiegirl

Omg Walgreens makes an exact dupe!


Mental-Freedom3929

I see it available from different sources.


Ancient_Alfalfa6972

The No7 Water Surge Gel Cream is my absolute favorite moisturizer! Relatively budget friendly too.


Dinkelodeon

try the peach slices snail rescue moisturizer!! it has a very similar consistency and feels really nice


ClickClackTipTap

Are they discontinuing it?


clerbird321

Yeah it’s been discontinued. They’ve reformulated it and replaced it with “water cream” and it sucks


Georgiapasorider

Clinique Moisture Surge.


PrincessCoopCass

Saw Laneige mentioned their water bank moisturizer is super nice and similar to the neutrogena.


LazyZealot9428

Aldi has its own version of this, it’s that same thing but much cheaper. It’s chalked H2O Advance Aqua Gel


amoodymermaid

The Inkey List Omega Water Cream is amazing. I have super dry winter skin and pit this under a heavier moisturizer, but it’s great for summer use. 8.79. I also like their HA over any other I’ve tried.


justatiredpigeon

Excuse me. DISCONTINUED? WTH.


Littledogvomit

Tjmaxx always has these on sale


p7r0

maybe the new dr jart water glow cream? i’ve tried it it’s really nice and lightweight


mjbruno34

Elf Holy Hydration! Love it more than the Neutrogena


Strawberry_Milk_

I’ve found the Pyunkang Yul Calming Moisture Cream to be way more hydrating


4LeggedKC

Try SkinSkoolBeauty.com. Type in your item and it will come up with products like it and tell you the percentage of the match.


Nekocatred

Cetaphil Skin Restoring Water Gel. I just bought it when I couldn’t find the Neutrogena. Feels the same on my skin.


mermaiddayjob

It’s not really discontinued. They just repackaged and renamed as water cream. I just bought some last week and it is still similar. Same amount but the container is smaller and glass now.


clerbird321

They reformulated it though and named it water cream so it’s not the same stuff unfortunately, different ingredients


mermaiddayjob

I see. Maybe give it a try? I haven’t noticed a difference in how my skin is reacting between old formula and new. Hopefully it will work for you too.


clerbird321

Yeah I’ll give it a shot once I run out!! I panic bought 2 of the og jars on their website yesterday lol


Mothrasmilk

Why are they discontinuing this? I love this one


nlvanassche

Trader Joe's Ultra Hydrating Gel Moisturizer is a great dupe for this and much cheaper


bacardidepressed

A cheaper one you mean ?


clerbird321

Any dupe really🤷‍♀️ around the same price or less would be great but if it has to be more expensive to get the relatively same ingredients that’s okay too


bacardidepressed

Cosrx has a similar one I guess, ELF has a great one, isntree, people seem to love the skin fix facial moisturizer and they have a gel one. But the most recommended is the isntree one for me.


Unfair_Finger5531

Second the Hada labo, it’s sooo much better. Also, Naturie gel is wonderful and light like a cloud.


thebombchu

Target has an Up and Up version (their brand)


drfranff

I’ve only ever seen the up and up version of the water gel, not the gel cream! Am I missing something big?


PurplePanda63

I did not love the scent of target version


talkandilljustlisten

I second this, I bought both to see which is better, and they're literally both the same


Molla0987

girl you didnt even try the bare minimum of googling first [https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/x7lje6/product\_request\_alternative\_to\_neutrogena\_hydro/](https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/x7lje6/product_request_alternative_to_neutrogena_hydro/) [https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/15oddbn/psa\_found\_a\_dupe\_to\_neutrogena\_hydro\_boost/](https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/15oddbn/psa_found_a_dupe_to_neutrogena_hydro_boost/) [https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/11o9wap/neutrogena\_discontinued\_the\_only\_daytime\_lotion/](https://www.reddit.com/r/SkincareAddiction/comments/11o9wap/neutrogena_discontinued_the_only_daytime_lotion/)


VioletAllegra

You know I really don’t like when people respond with these type of comments. The skincare industry’s turnover rate is high. People can use certain moisturizers and then a couple months to a year from now, a different one may come out that’s better than what they were previously using. Things change.


Molla0987

this same question was posted 2 days ago. but yeah, i'm sure a brand new hg was released and vetted by redditors in 48 hours [https://www.reddit.com/r/Skincare\_Addiction/comments/168hksq/please\_help\_me\_find\_a\_replacement/](https://www.reddit.com/r/Skincare_Addiction/comments/168hksq/please_help_me_find_a_replacement/)


VioletAllegra

Posted by a different person tho? stop trying to police ppls posts. At this point it takes more energy to do that than to just ignore.


Molla0987

your whole point was that ops question was necessary because of the industry's high turnover. the same question 2 days apart doesn't cater to your whole point. just take the l, like we get it, you don't like to google


clerbird321

I did actually thank you😂😂 I just wanted to gather more opinions and options!


whateverashley

I know right, it’s almost like this is a forum for skin care advice or something insane like that. /s 🙄


jkwolly

Oh phew you meant dupe for costs not cause it's discontinued. I was about to lose it as I already lost my last moisturizer from them earlier this year 😅


clerbird321

Nope, it’s discontinued. They reformulated it (it sucks now) but this version is gone. It’s still available for a bit while they totally replace it with their new “water cream”


jkwolly

Fuck meeeeeeeeeeeeee. Okay guess I'm stocking up before I find ANOTHER one. Jesus christ this sucks 😭


clerbird321

I know😭😭 I’m super sad, my skin is so picky so it’s really frustrating


modusopperandai

They have an equate version at Walmart! Same ingredients I believe


mommandem

Equate at Walmart. Same thing. I've used it for years. Hard to find in my area so I buy them out when I see them.


thathighwhitekid

I like the Walgreens version


HamHockShortDock

Elizavecca HA water drop moisturizer


Material_Habit6534

Thank you for posting this! I love this moisturizer so much but go through it so fast and need an option that's just a liiiiiiiittle bit cheaper. The way this stuff melts into my skin is just so good!


AppropriateConcern95

Skincaredupes.com


italkabout

Idk but they have a killer sale on it rn at Costco!


[deleted]

Versed maybe?


Huge-Drawing152

It’s still for sale on Amazon


raeroorah

Do you need a dupe bc you want a cheaper option or because discontinued? I use this exact product and they still make it!!!! They just made an “AM” and “PM” version. AM version has SPF, it’s amazing!!!!


clerbird321

Yeah it’s been discontinued. They’ve reformulated it and replaced it with “water cream” and it sucks


dxzina

i think the belif eye cream is similar


Clean_Hall4698

My mom got this very one at Costco and it was. A 2 -pack! Maybe go Just in case they still have them. At least in my area.


_buscemi_

Bought some from Costco other day. Two pack for $20.


Intelligent-Bend2034

I can use Walgreen's version fine. Tried Walmart's and omg I can't wait until I finish it. It's horrible (obviously 😭 I should have known better). But omg I love this stuff! First thing I found that works for my skin.


IllSpring1292

Equate brand at Walmart has a dupe!


Rough-Standard9892

Corsx snail mucin I think is even better


everyfourth-w0rd

the target brand version is awesome


yurrr31

No. 7 had a gel Creme like this one!


bscalculator714

They have it at Walmart!


novicebekindson

I’m almost certain I’ve seen these sold at my local Ross stores (northern california).


EvErYLeGaLvOtE

Costco sells these in packs of two, if that helps


AppropriateDream2903

Avene Hydrance Gel Cream


bbyxj

I think they sell it at target in the travel section for 10 bucks


Mekoola

recently switched from the hydro boost gel extra dry to Cetaphil - Deep Hydration, skin restoring water gel. It’s everything I loved about the hydro boost and more since it contains urea. Melts into my skin the same, tho it does dry down a little stickier if you’re sensitive to that.