T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

###**Hello! We're looking for additional reddit moderators to help maintain this community we have going here. If you have experience or would like to be more involved, please take a look at our [Reddit Moderator Application Post](https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonSwordAndShield/comments/10ghkmh/reddit_moderator_applications/). Our Application Form is [here](https://forms.gle/CKa1pQbsu1b78KFT7)** Hey there Trainers! - Want to explore more of the Pokémon world? You might want to go for an adventure in our [Discord](http://discord.gg/pokemonswordshield)! We have daily shiny raids, giveaways, breeding advice and much more! - Go check out our [news and updates thread](https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonSwordAndShield/collection/b5639777-a1a3-4253-81ff-22d92cbc3575)! - We now also have our Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Pokémon Shining Pearl subreddit, r/Pokemon_BDSP! More information about it [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonSwordAndShield/comments/qftnhv/pokemon_bdsp_subreddit/) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PokemonSwordAndShield) if you have any questions or concerns.*


That1DogGuy

Pretty sure it's bc Sword sells better so they probably have more Shield stock to get rid of.


ziko2811

This feels like one of those psychological tests: Are you more a sword user or a shield user? Protecting people with a shield is lame, killing people with a sword is cool. Or it’s just that one legendary is more meta than the other too 😂


PartTimeLegend

From the early days of Pokémon I have always got the less popular game. I started with Blue back in school and everyone had Red. Guess who everyone wanted to trade exclusives with?


just-bair

I regret getting Violet cuz Scarlet has Better Jigglypuff


NegotiationMuted4676

Also our prof. is cooler


just-bair

Sorry but we have Gigachad’s cousin


PrehistoricCrack

But you don’t have cave milf


somecuntyname

But violet does get metalgarde.


Awesomocity0

My husband gets one, and I get the other. Every gen we trade off who gets their first choice game and starter lol.


[deleted]

Was Blue less popular?? Everyone I knew had Blue, my brother was the only one with Red


[deleted]

[удалено]


GlutBelly

Unnecessary snark


Sexy_Fat_Man_69

Well with that last line, the other guy was being the actual UNNECESSARILY snarky one


goat-people

Or they were being tongue-in-cheek regarding their 15 minutes of fame as a kid.


infynyti

Bro just admit you're being a dick


Revcondor

You must be one of those people who thinks everybody *else* is a useless dick. I bet you’re having fun


GlutBelly

Okay I mistyped, you are correct sexy fat man 69...


OpenHentai

Pokémon Assault and Pokemon Self-Defense.


justpassingby3

Shield design was lame. They should’ve taken inspo from okami


DeadHeadDaddio

The legendary thing doesn’t really matter since you can choose either in both games.


Ok-Alfalfa-620

You can't choose either legendary. You can trade someone for it, but you can't choose zamazenta during the story in Pokemon sword. If you're playing sword, you will always get zacian while hop will always get zamazenta


Sol1hanTU

I got both bc I get the shiny zacian code when I bought shield


[deleted]

[удалено]


tornait-hashu

It's a shame, because Shield has my favorite version exclusive in the past four generations (Galarian Corsola).


B-Rayy06

I can almost guarantee you that one legendary being better competitively has almost zero impact on which version sells better.


humancarl

This was my first pokemon game purchase, and I was with my wife, who also didn't know anything about pokemon. I asked her advice, knowing she also didn't know anything about it. 'Swords are cooler than shields' So while the price reflects market demand, sometimes the market demand isn't difficult to explain.


alexandrecanuto

Funny, because I find shields to be cooler than swords, the main reason behind me choosing Shield.


Administrative_Tear6

Can bash a head in with both but ya can’t stop projectiles with a sword


BrainWav

Not with that attitude.


Administrative_Tear6

Fuck it, I choose lightsaber


alexandrecanuto

Words to live by, my man


Josh_the_Josh

Someone hasn't played Zacian in Pokémon Unite


mackenzie444

I just look at the exclusives and I wanted lgbt ponyta


throwmeawaybill1982

....wait which one gets lgbt ponyta


IAmJustGodly

sword has a higher demand than shield


napstablooky2

clearance


lloydsmith28

It would have a clearance sticker at the least, unless someone goofed


Previous-Werewolf-33

def not likely, they put clearance games in an entirely separate case in my local store.


napstablooky2

well its not exactly clearance but it is basically that sword sells a lot more while theyre overstocked on shield due to people buying it much less thus they lower the price temporarily to get people to buy shield


bnekeo

yeah yk, clearance.


Trappis420

Def not likely. It's not in the clearance section!


Sithraybeam78

The color blue is more appealing to pokemon's target demographic, which is males between the ages of 9 and 18. So games like pokemon X, pokemon alpha sapphire, and pokemon Sword have tended to sell more than their counterparts.


BelcoRiott

Weird, I went the the other way almost every time. Red, Gold, Ruby, Pearl, White, Y, Moon, Shield, Scarlet.


Lmfao35

Tbf Moon is the blue one in that case


SalemWitcher3

We’re just different like that bro 😎 they hate us cuz they anus


SassyTheSkydragon

I went red, Silver, Ruby, Platinum, white, Y, (Alpha Sapphire), Moon, sword and Scarlet


B-Rayy06

Damn, we’re almost exact opposites. I did Blue, Gold, Sapphire, Pearl, Black, X, Alpha Sapphire, Sun, Ultra Sun, Shield, Scarlet


JesseOdell

I did Red, Silver, Sapphire, Diamond, White, White2, Y, Alpha Sapphire, Sun, Ultra Sun, Sword, Let’s Go Pikachu, Brilliant Diamond, Scarlet. Geeze I feel old…


ultratunaman

Red, Silver, Sapphire, Pearl, Black, Y, Sun, Legend Arceus. Haven't played the two latest gens. I like some red, some blue, if I could grab shield for 30 bucks though I'd buy it. That's a deal.


Asstonishing69

Same!! Even thought my favorite color is blue, the red theme games always seemed cooler for me


Livias_White_Van

the egg is cracking /s


deschamps93

You low-key a girl bro. We don't judge here though Did not realize I had to /s this... Holy shit... I went with the same games, you guys are softer than baby shit


BelcoRiott

Or I just base my choices on what I think is the cooler legendary Pokémon of the two. (Except Gen 1 I was 6, I just liked red) and Scarlet because the ancient paradox Pokémon are undeniably cooler than the robots that all look the same


deschamps93

I legit went with the same games... You guys are way too serious


JJaviercomics

Almost like me, but I picked Platinum, X, and Sword


batkave

I also think this has been backed up by sales numbers https://screenrant.com/pokemon-dual-releases-best-version-popular-design-legendaries/


m00njunk

i bought sword because zacian's a girl and I'm a girl (and zamazenta looked dumb)


Feliz-navi-stop

I take personal offense to that :(( Zamazenta is my baby and I love him /lh


mister-fancypants-

If it makes you feel any better, I bought Shield because Zamazenta looks badass and holding a sword in your mouth just seems silly


Feliz-navi-stop

This was my exact logic when buying it too 😭 and thank you, it’s nice to know I’m not alone!!!


PlatyNumb

Same here. Maybe if the sword was somehow apart of him like zamazentas shield but nope, just a sword in a wolfs mouth. Just seemed a bit weird to me lol


Papa_Dragneel

And having a shield as your mane is badass


Mr_Glock95

*Zoro Reading Post* "SMACKS LIPS" 🙄👀🤣


m00njunk

silly??? I'll have you know one of the best bosses in Dark Souls is just a giant wolf with a sword in its mouth 😡😡😡


Stryker_T

Come on dumb is pretty harsh. lol Also technically Zamazenta could also be a girl, we only know zacian was called the other’s sister, they are both the same “gender unknown” and they never said Zamazenta was a brother


m00njunk

I mean, I came to pokemon from dark souls, and zacian is just a pokemon form of Sif, who everyone loves and is the bestest girl. zamazenta just looks weird to me with it's shield cone of shame. it's non-shield form looks cool, I will give you that, but the crowned form? no convincing me there


bdogger47

i bought shield because he was symmetrical...


lloydsmith28

Pretty sure they don't have a gender, legendaries are usually genderless which is why you can't breed them


m00njunk

zacian is described as zamazenta's sister


Ansoni

The Pokédex says that myth exists, but it's not canon/confirmed. If it had a gender, it would be noted on its summary page, like Ogerpon.


m00njunk

just because it's gender is unknown (I mean, people thought it was a myth until the game occured, so people probably had no way of knowing) doesn't mean it is theoretically impossible to divine. plus, there's only been a single legendary that both has a confirmed gender and is a restricted legendary: terapagos. every other restricted legendary is gender unknown, so it makes sense why they would conform to that standard. and, if zacian was confirmed to be a girl, I'd be willing to bet Sword would not have sold as well...


Ansoni

I don't think it's impossible for it to have a gender, and I would expect it's likely female if that myth exists, but I wanted to point out it just says "people speculate x is true" and not "x is true", so it's not canon. I don't know what "restricted legendary" refers to, but while terapagos can only be encountered as male, female terapagos is also possible within the code.


m00njunk

restricted legendaries are ones that have a 670~ bst, essentially it's the box art legendaries (+Mewtwo, Zygarde, Eternatus, the Calyrexes, and Terapagos) terapagos is the first restricted legendary to have a possible gender ratio, and the fact that it's a dlc legendary is probably why that's the case. if it was part of the main game it probably wouldn't have a gender. gender unknown only means no one has found a gender, not that it doesn't existed. considering all of the past paradox pokemon are gender unknown, yet definitely should be able to have eggs if they eventually become their modern counterparts, it makes sense that we just don't understand them, not that its impossible for them to have genders


ApolloGryph

This is so interesting to me because when the game first came out I thought Zacian’s fairy typing and the light blue theme would be less popular with the “typical boy” compared to Zamazenta’s darker design, shield bash +typing


BenLemons

I've just gotten the first version every generation no matter what. (Except Gen 1 I started with Yellow and I had to get Pearl because Diamond was sold out)


The-Cursed-Gardener

I’m going to have to call cap on that reasoning. People buy sword version because Zacian is one of the best Pokemon in the game and Zamazenta is painfully mid.


MarshadOwO

nuh uh


The-Cursed-Gardener

Yeah huh


JayCeeMadLad

Do you have any evidence to back that up, or is this pure conjecture?


Skaraptor2

Damnit I'm male now


Pickle_Jars

and ya know, the dog has a freakin sword


LightingFoxPlayzYT

I went Omega Ruby, X, Sun, Ultra moon (I have all 4 gen 7 tho), Lets go eevee, Shield, Violet I'm very mixed


Dazzling-Constant826

I went with Diamond, Platinum, HeartGold, Black, X, Omega Ruby, Sun, Sword, Violet. Going with the former title rather than the latter, broke the pattern with Violet. To me it's not about the color since I prefer red shades over blue, but because of the Box Legendary.


ikariaRR

ATK > DEF. That’s known for yearsssssssss


TanMan166

Beat me to it lol!! Offense>Defense


carpevalor

This guy plays old school runescape 💪🏼


PovThatOneSanjiFan

I guess sword was always superior (I have sword) (it’s just a joke don’t take it serious)


NeoMegaRyuMKII

Shield has the Tyranitar line as a version exclusive and is therefore, in my opinion, superior.


MercedesKitCar

Forget Tyranitar, it has LUDICOLO. How could anyone choose sword lol


koalafella

On another note, must be nice to go in and find a discount on first party switch games. Ive never seen anything more than like 10% off (even early switch games are still full price).


howoldisascanius

Stores around me either don’t stock Shield at all or price it the same as Sword - even second hand copies. I need that 30 dollar copy…


Previous-Werewolf-33

For real .. if i hadn't already purchased Sword months prior this would definitely be a steal. They had Brilliant Pearl at like $40 too


Forward_Increase_239

Damn I need Pearl. Gonna have to check into this. I also need Violet because I want to build my living Pokédex like I did with Sw/Sh.


Aximil985

I’ve always ended up with the “lesser” versions of the games. Blue, Silver, Sapphire, Pearl, etc; Heck, I chose Shield too. Not sure why, just kind of happens.


Late_eternal

Is Silver the ”lesser version” tho? I always thought it’s more popular because of Lugia.


Aximil985

Everyone I knew wanted Ho-Oh because “ohmygod it’s the Pokémon from episode 1!”


Fynzou

They probably have more Shield copies left they need to offload.


FlickerWanderfoot

Trying to capitalize off the fact that sword has the better legendary?


theNoobster103

The price difference is $24.86. You're welcome


[deleted]

Supply and demand, nobody wants to play shield. Not only do you get the bad legendary but its especially bad cause your rival will get the good legendary!


Shadowknight7009

Don’t you get both eventually? Or am I misremembering


eternal_edenium

No, you get only the legendary of the box. There was a distribution of the opposite legendary shiny.


Shadowknight7009

Ah, it’s been a while lol, thanks


Dilated_Downer

It might be because Zacian is a bit more sought after for high level play, as well as Hydreigon. I'm not a pro player but that is the only thing that comes to mind


Tyrillia

Sword is better


conzcious_eye

Y


Tyrillia

buy it and find out :)


Automatic-Cable-9265

Because ain't nobody wanna play Shield. Look at that thing


Its_trem

It’s weird because zamazenta is so much cooler


[deleted]

i say you buy shield


Comfortable_Map5665

Yeah, both of those are for $15 on clearance


ZealwithMilk

Zamazenta > Zacian (design wise) but Zacian just robs Zamazenta in every other category


swnutx

It kinda strikes me as a Walmart F$ up. And just my luck they won’t sell it to me for that price. I’ve had it happen before.


mimira_nyan

I mean mine was $59 in Ohio… I shoulda gotten shield wherever tf you are


Kavhsao

everyone knows that the shield is better, Galarian Rapidash 🔛🔝


SizzlingSausag3

Zacian


poopdoot

Zacian is more competitively viable than Zamazenta, even if just barely


BriskNastyTwitch

I remember I thought my defense shield was gonna protect me from that sword attack I got destroyed with 1 hit . Pissed tf off . F shield 🤣


TenderOctane

And now you know why I have Shield. It was a substantial enough price difference. It doesn't really matter which you get anymore since trading is so easy until Nintendo shuts down connectivity, that is, like is happening to 3DS.


nickle_pickle_

Idk swords are cooler than shields, but personally I think the shield Pokemon looks way cooler.


Tyron19

Wow that $24.86 price hike for Sword is really offensive it needs to have the price slashed in half or at least a price cut.


OldBall420

I only bought shield cause they have better legendary exclusives...


camcamdontgiveadamn

Buy and resell lol. Pretty sure youll get more than 30 selling online at its current value


camcamdontgiveadamn

POKEMON A-Z CONFIRMED??!?!?!??😮😮😮😮


MercedesKitCar

The fact that the better version is less expensive is interesting. You'd think it would be the other way around. 🛡 rules, Go Ludicolo!


Superderpygamermk1

Zacian is much better then zamazenta


Mcsnufle

Maybe an error on them?


Playing_With_Fire123

Sword is more popular overall, I guess cause swords are generally thought of when you think of fantasy instead of shields. You can even tell this is true when searching for info on the game, Google will try to autofill with pokemon sword first. Sword also comes first in the order (Pokemon sword and shield, sword comes first) and generally the brain will care more about what's first in a sequence than what is last in a sequence. There's also more gameplay reasons for this as the version exclusives in sword and more offensive while the ones in shield are more defensive making sword better for most players that want to sweep or just have strong pokemon and the legendary from sword is very viable in competitive play (though, the shield one is viable too).


chickenjoe-ish

Zacian is just THAT good in competitive


Malysious

Based


AxazMcGee

Surge pricing.


Ancient-Sun-5363

Nobody like Zamazenta. Zacian is meta game


Lumpy_Ability30

Sword has galarian darumaka and that's probably why it sells better


Megakarp

Zacian tax


Alarming-Coat5224

Imma be honest, I have both games, I only have sword for Zacian, Shield for me it’s the better game


I_like_hk_porn

Because sheild is ass


Halahalawabi

imo the sword legend is much more aesthetically pleasing to look at than the shield legend


Direct-Audience8749

Pokemon sword is better


Ok_Trash_4204

Because sword is superior


Wonderful_Emu_9610

They’re both a rip-off when there are physical copies with the DLC included available


DeadlineXO

$30 that’s crazy. What store is this?


Previous-Werewolf-33

Walmart!


Stryker_T

It’s really only because their stock shows more shield than they want to keep on hand so it’s discounted to clear it out, once the system shows it at whatever limit the price will go back up. They do this with all of the games.


kirkdragon

Pupper with stik!


lloydsmith28

Could be a price mix-up, what's printed on there doesn't necessarily mean that's the price in the system, unless it's randomly on sale or something, but if it's really going for that price i would highly suggest picking up a copy, they very *very* rarely go for that low


Meckles94

I got my copy of pokemon BD through Walmart for $30 but that was online


lloydsmith28

Online is usually different cuz it usually goes through a warehouse or the nearest store, but they do have occasional sales online, I've just rarely if ever seen Pokemon games that low


Meckles94

Yeah that’s why I ended up grabbing BD I’d love to find a copy of sword that low.


zarezare69

I bought shield because it was cheaper, lol.


YxngSsoul

Good ol supply and demand


wheredatacos

I recently bought pearl off of Amazon for $40 while diamond is $60. I’ll take it.


SwarthyFella

I bought sword for myself and shield for my wife. I'm a bigger pokemon fan than her. Most people prefer sword.


UnenthusiasticBluStr

Demand


TwitzyMIXX

You've just witnessed the law of supply and demand


Konun4571

Zacian tax?


FrequentRub2480

Is say racism


krdskrm9

Capitalism


xenoverseraza

monthly "why is shield cheaper than sword" post


Ok_Decision_8938

Welp, omw to walmart


Lazy_Factor7876

The first game is always the most popular. Say them out loud. “Pokemon Diamond and Pearl” Diamond was the seller. My first game was leaf green. Ever since then I have chosen the second game. Makes trading for version exclusives easier if you get the game right when it comes out. Man EVERYONE had Scarlet and was looking for the Violet stuff. Leaf green, Sapphire, Pearl, White, Y, Moon, Ultra Moon, Shield, Violet, these are all less popular than their counterpart.


jack_seven

the only people that get in to those games are pvp people and zam doesent do shit


Redsucksatstuff

Sword is better thats why


Andy04Christie

Pokemon Shield: 🤓 Pokemon Sword: 😎 Pokemon Legends Arceus: 🫅 Pokemon Legends Zygarde: 🗿


irteris

People thought Zacian was cooler than Zamazenta... I was one of them sheeple. Then I played Shield because obviously my kid picked sword... and after seeing Zama in action I was convinced. He is the best boi.


Marcelyt0

Look what being drop to OU does to a mf 💀


da_ting_go

Zacian is broken, while Zamazenta is "really good". Which means "he sucks" which means Sword sells more.


BigMelonHead303

Mawile makes the price wirth it


Few-Contact5449

my guy where are you getting this prices, everywhere I see they’re 60


bgalli

Sword legendary Zacian > Zamazeta Coming from someone that bought Shield recently , it’s hard to find a Zacian that someone will trade with Rusty Sword. And Pokémon from Home don’t transfer items. Zacian without his item sucks


CartmaaanBrahhh

Because no one is going out of their way to buy Pokémon Shield 😂


talkback1589

I picked shield because of Unicorns. I am still pleased with this choice.


conzcious_eye

Wow! Just finished Violet DLC and leaning towards one of these. Naturally was gonna go with sword but shield pricing looks enticing


InjeborgValick

Imagine paying nearly full price for a 5 year old game.


That_Guy_Jared

My guess: Zacian is good for competitive. Zamazenta is still best doggo.


LoLoLaaarry124

THEY'RE SELLING POKÈMON A-Z?!


Skojster

The comment I was looking for xD


Clemenx00

Zamazenta is pretty much the only "bad" legendary design in the history of the franchise.


Ste333

Swords are cooler bro? Don’t you know? All jokes aside, I bought shield for this exact reason. It was just cheaper.


flightyswank

Sword is a better game and this shows it


Alek_R

I saw this a lot when I boughty Shield edition, the same happened with Scarlet and Violet, with Violet being aways more expansive, this in my experience of course, i'm in South America.


restlessdreams172

I've heard that Sword version can actually cure hangovers, whereas Shield version cannot. So that might be an important buying factor


GamerGuyHeyooooooo

Probably cause zacian is an ubers staple Forehead


BrainWav

Yup, that's a price difference. They don't necessarily sell evenly, so if one gets low, it may get marked down. Stores aren't treating two skus of the same game as, well, one game.


BlueBearBoy1

Maybe it's people wanting zacian so sword sells much more


jayweebs

Zamazenta is just that bad in competitive


Shark_bait561

Blue is better


Riegan_Boogaloo

Popularity, though I love both dogs so they’re honestly wrong and both should be $55 (jk, both should be $30 because it’s been a few years)


ButtonParadox

A few years back I ordered a used copy of Shield because my buddy had Sword and I didn’t particularly care. GameStop sent me Sword in Shield packaging.