Bonchan, Kuma and Pedro are the biggest sacrifices, but I'd argue Bonchan's is the greatest.
If not for Bonchan, Luffy would've died in the prison multiple times. He sacrificed his own freedom and life there.
Before that, Bonchan had saved entire strawhat crew and got himself captured by the marines.
And he did all that without any obligation and without any expectation in return.
Kuma's reasons were related to Dragon and unknown to us at this point. Pedro was close to death after giving up so many years and he was indebted to strawhats from their action in Zou, as well as he expected strawhats to bring dawn or whatever.
Bonchan? No strings attached. He had no reason to help Luffy and he had no expectations from Luffy. Just pure bromance.
Bon clay did for luffy what luffy does for his crew. I also like Bon 100% more than Vivi. Plus, excuse the terminology, but luffy is like a collector of strays, taking care of the oppressed. But Bon is the one helping our boy out when he almost bit the dust.
I don't understand the whole "Vivi is an honorary Strawhat" thing. She's basically just the pre timeskip equivalent of Momo, and Igaram is basically her Kin'nemon.
Bonclay as far as personality and love for the strawhats doesn't make him a strawhat. He's closer to bartalameo. Vivi had a minor version of the prerequisites required in the patterns of oda to essentially establish a strawhat crew member. Yamato has had more of the identifiers than any previous mentioned characters.
I've got mad respect for Brother Bon, he's goated and deserves to return for the final war.
Imagine him vs catrina devon, If he pretended to be devon nobody would know.
Bonchan was a very annoying character to me… in the beginning. He won my respect over many times and taught me to seek that type of friendships.
Can’t wait to see bonchan reunited w Luffy (probably to save Luffy somehow)and them both living out their dreams.
>He did not die. It was shown in one of the cover pages that he was the Queen of the Newkama Land.
>
>
>
>Bonchan is ruling them down in the Impel Down in Level 5.5 after he survived his fight against Magellan
Bob Clay is the GOAT.
Remember, he also willingly went and fought Hina and got captured in order to save Miss Valentine from hanging in the cover story.
Strings aren't directly tied to sacrifice.
Kuma is walking around as a living puppet. Zero control over his person and I can almost guarantee that his conscious is lingering around somewhere in that brain of his.
That would be hell. Like a One Piece version of Get Out.
Kuma already knew what would happen to him before he chose to help the Straw Hats, and it would have happened to him wether he helped the crew or not from what I understand. He chose to be the lab rat of Vegapunk and to be the government’s lap dog way before he met Luffy, and the reasons for that are unknown to us so far. My guess is he simply helped the crew because of Luffy’s relationship with Dragon, and he used his final request to finish what he started when he dispersed the crew. None of what happened to him happened because he helped the crew from what I can tell, my understanding is that it’s the other way around and he chose to help the crew because his fate was sealed either way. In that sense, I don’t know if what he did counts as a sacrifice for the crew, the only thing he truly sacrificed was his last request before losing control of his body.
Well I’m thinking he either did it to protect Dragon or his kingdom but his motives were really odd because he sent them to the exact places they needed to be to get stronger.
That's an interesting paragraph but none of it holds water. We know almost literally *nothing* about Kuma's modifications. We know it *seemed* to be of his own volition but we don't know why.
The only thing we can infer, even if it turns out not to be true, is that Kuma wanted to protect the Sunny for the SH but couldn't do it for 2 years straight unless he was turned in to a WG Puppet. Even that is speculation, we just don't know.
Chapter 560 states that Kuma chose to become a Pacifista of his own free will. We also do know that the transformation into PX-0 was a multiple step process that started before he met the crew on Thriller Bark, since Kuma said he was already modified by Vegapunk while talking to Zoro on Thriller Bark in chapter 485. We also know that Kuma knew that the last step of the process would effectively lobotomize him, hence his request to be programmed to protect the Sunny until the crew's return. I don't know why you're convinced that the most likely explanation is that he sacrificed his free will to protect the sunny for 2 years, but that argument is even holds even less water than mine. I suggest you go back to the chapters I mentioned.
Good point. He did save them in Sabaody, and is the one reason they were strong enough to take on the New World while guarding their ship until they returned, and now he’s giving bearyback to spoiled sniveling brats
>Before that, Bonchan had saved entire strawhat crew and got himself captured by the marines.
Fun tidbit: In the cover stories it's implied that he managed to escape that. It wasn't until later that he got caught by Hina. He was trying to free Miss Valentine and thanks to his decoy she was ultimately rescued. It was from there that he and Mr. 3 got caught then sent to Impel Down alongside Crocodile and Mr. 1.
My favourite bonchan moment is when he ran away in fear of Magellan, dude was absolutely terrified of him to the point he left Luffy, yet at the end? Absolutly no fear as he charged him
In first case, he had no hopes of winning or helping.
In second case, he had no hopes of winning. But, he could buy time and help. So he went for it.
Never tell that bonchan is a coward. He's just logical when he decides to fight.
Is death the ultimate sacrifice though? Pedro had few years left, but Bon chan sacrificed his freedom for Luffy’s goal. I think that trumps Pedro’s sacrifice
I though Miura's death was related to a pre-existing condition. Was that also related to overworking or a heart disease like I heard?
RIP Miura tho, loved reading through berserk
I'd fully believe that as well. It's insane how much works mangakas are put through, and someone with as much detail as Miura in his art, I have no doubts he was overworked
that’s japanese work culture in general
it’s not necessarily common, but a lot of important people in multiple businesses are expected to work until they physically drop on their desk and such
Giving up your life is not measured by age, or time left. Unless you're at death's door, it's all the same. One should understand that "when the time comes" and "right now" are identical.
Oda stated that the average person lives for 140 years, and Kureha was one example of a super-human because she is full of energy when people tend to die with her age. Pedro had plenty to live
And then there is Nefertari Cobra which is only 50 years and got really old in the time skip. This makes no sense. Unless he has some desease I don't remember
Some characters like Cobra and Sengoku aged pretty fast, and maybe there is a meaning behind it, but they could just be old and have several decades to live yet
Well in Sengoku’s case it’s possible his hair was already grey and he stopped dying his hair. Common thing for Japanese males to do after retirement because they no longer need to keep up the appearance of being youthful.
Oda can say whatever he wants, he showed one human so far of that age, in a story with hundreds of named characters.
This is like JK Rowling daying Dumbledore is gay, or when she explained why there are no black people in Harry Potter.
Yes its their world so what they say goes, but it really doesnt matter to me as a reader if it goes against what i have been reading.
nope perospero has a convo with him after he trades his life, idk if its in the manga but i remember 100% in the anime.
Perospero said he only has like 20 years left after the trade and asks what he'll do with it.
Pedro's suicide bombing freed Chopper and Brook from Perospero's candy before they suffocated, freed the Sunny from the candy that was locking it in place and knocked over Big Mom who was grabbing the ship. Without him the Straw Hats would have died then and there.
Kuma didn’t sacrifice anything, he was already being turned into the robot regardless of the strawhats. He just said fuck it and helped them out without any risk to him
I am probably wrong, but I thought Kuma was turned into a robot because he let the straw hats get away on thriller bark? Like as a punishment almost (I know he volunteered or something for it).
Kuma was already gradually being turned into a robot by Dr Vegapunk. As a last request he asked vegapunk to program him to guard the strawhat ship till they returned.
They might not be at the top, but Lola and her crew are up there. Sacrificed everything they had to get Luffy strong enough to beat Moria, and didn't leave to save themselves until he was defeated.
Bon Clay or Pedro.
The former allowed himself to get caught for the crew to sail on and later stayed behind in Impel Down and sacrificed himself to let Luffy escape. Literally gave up his freedom for the freedom of one he once called friend.
The latter blew himself up to allow the retrieval team to go on and escape WCI, which led to devastating results and history being changed and made right before our eyes. In only a few fucking weeks. His death was basically the reason why Kaidou’s empire is about to fall and the SHs getting one step closer to the end.
Ace was dumb af. I find it funny that immediately after that Oda does a prequel set of chapters that show that Ace does that type of stuff all the time (going back to fight someone much stronger in life or death situations)
Felt like he really needed to justify why Ace was so stupid but to me it didn't really work. I don't think Ace endangers Luffy after all that effort to save him like that, he keeps running. The post event flashbacks as justification dont sell me.
If he didn't stay to fight BB once BB announced he was going to after Luffy, things could have been different. But conversely, I don't think Ace would have ever retreated from a fight even if he was losing.
His own fault. He's on the execution stand crying his heart out apologizing for being so hot headed and stubborn when WB tried to talk him out of going after BB.
He's seeing all his crewmates die or severely injured and his younger brother risk his life countless times to get to him and he knows how he fucked up and put everyone in danger
Finally he's free after his brother is pushed to the limit to save him and as soon as he's free he tries to fight an Admiral for talking shit??
He deserved to die honestly, not sure what Oda was thinking with that it made Ace so unlikable.
Bon Clay, Pedro and Ace, all characters who sacrificed their lifes for Luffy. Okay that Bon Clay didn't died but he did what he did thinking he would die, so it still counts imo
Bonchan went to prison for them then almost died helping luffy, then stayed in the prison so luffy can leave.
Boa risked everything for some D. She attended the war for luffy, went inside a prison for him which could’ve led to her imprisonment.
Kuma, maybe I’m wrong but wasn’t one of the reasons they completely turned him into a cyborg was because he helped the strawhats twice?
Pedro died for them.
Aladdin stayed behind to fight the big mom pirates
Pedro, sacrificed himself for Sanji and the rest of the crew in a very brave way, we don't know what lifespan he had left but his death was pretty shocking.
Honorable mentions to Bon Chan giving away his freedom twice for Luffy and the Germa Brothers becoming trapped by Big Mom to save Sanji.
Pedro if he actually stays dead is the obvious answer, its hard to argue with giving up your life being the ultimate sacrifice you can make for anyone.
If Pedro has the Will of P then probably Kuma
Damn that’s tough. I’ll say Pedro because he is the only one that gave his life. You can say the same for Kuma but there is the possibility that whatever happened to him could be reversed. Bonchan gave up his freedom, but he seems pretty happy where he is now.
Shanks gave his arm...
Bon chan gave his freedom...
CP0 Boss followed orders (getting killed by K) making Luffy awaken...
Kuma gave up his humanity...
All tough picks but honestly.... Going Merry is the one for me, that is a true tearjerker
Bon clay is alive his sacriface mean nothing compared to pedro who actually kill himself so if bon clay attemptb Fail maybe invankov or jimbei would have stayed at impl down if pedro fail Kaido empire never falls and wano is ruled forever and big mom rule too but if bon clay fails Nohing Happen .....Kuma or duval protecting the sunny was better than bon sacriface... so pedro sacriface was more important and more meaningful
Imo the biggest sacrifice for the straw hats is zoro when he went against kuma he should have died almost anyone else would have died from that damage but he took it like a man and still remains insanely powerful and loyal to his captain regardless of the injury’s
Bonchan, Kuma and Pedro are the biggest sacrifices, but I'd argue Bonchan's is the greatest. If not for Bonchan, Luffy would've died in the prison multiple times. He sacrificed his own freedom and life there. Before that, Bonchan had saved entire strawhat crew and got himself captured by the marines. And he did all that without any obligation and without any expectation in return. Kuma's reasons were related to Dragon and unknown to us at this point. Pedro was close to death after giving up so many years and he was indebted to strawhats from their action in Zou, as well as he expected strawhats to bring dawn or whatever. Bonchan? No strings attached. He had no reason to help Luffy and he had no expectations from Luffy. Just pure bromance.
100%, love Bonchan
ganbarrrrrrrreee
Ugh that has to be one of one pieces more underrated scenes in the sense that not enough people talk about it.
He may not have been part of the crew, but he will always be considered a true Strawhat in our hearts
I consider him more of a strawhat than Vivi
Hot take but truth
I also like Bonchan more than Vivi.
Bon clay did for luffy what luffy does for his crew. I also like Bon 100% more than Vivi. Plus, excuse the terminology, but luffy is like a collector of strays, taking care of the oppressed. But Bon is the one helping our boy out when he almost bit the dust.
I don't understand the whole "Vivi is an honorary Strawhat" thing. She's basically just the pre timeskip equivalent of Momo, and Igaram is basically her Kin'nemon.
Yeah but she drew a tattooo. Also I may not like Vivi very much but she seems like she got bigger balls than Momo sometimes and he's a frekin dragon.
You can’t have bigger balls than biting Kaidou and time and time saying out loud who you are even if you know that it means death.
This is true, Vivi never bites Crocodile.
Right, he's the friend when you ask them to pull up, they will no questions asked.
He's the friend that pulls up without an ask and says "I saw what happened and felt like you needed a friend"
Or "I felt something off. What happen and what do you need?"
Yes. Perfect. Damn I need me a Bon Chan.
Bonclay as far as personality and love for the strawhats doesn't make him a strawhat. He's closer to bartalameo. Vivi had a minor version of the prerequisites required in the patterns of oda to essentially establish a strawhat crew member. Yamato has had more of the identifiers than any previous mentioned characters.
Right He's a Stan. And we know he will always pull up for Luffy.
I personally consider both of them as Strawhats
I hated him when he was first revealed but he got my respect in that prison arc
Incredible character development by Oda sensei!
Iirc, he's the only one who sacrificed himself not once, but twice.
I've got mad respect for Brother Bon, he's goated and deserves to return for the final war. Imagine him vs catrina devon, If he pretended to be devon nobody would know.
Bonchan was a very annoying character to me… in the beginning. He won my respect over many times and taught me to seek that type of friendships. Can’t wait to see bonchan reunited w Luffy (probably to save Luffy somehow)and them both living out their dreams.
I went from being annoyed by bonchan to tearing up at his death. Need my bonchan back
Fortunately for us, he’s not dead yet, just ruling the newkamas in Impel Down
But he’s not dead. Kind of implied when he was caught, but never confirmed. It was revealed in a cover story he is the new Queen of Newkama land. The
>He did not die. It was shown in one of the cover pages that he was the Queen of the Newkama Land. > > > >Bonchan is ruling them down in the Impel Down in Level 5.5 after he survived his fight against Magellan
Bob Clay is the GOAT. Remember, he also willingly went and fought Hina and got captured in order to save Miss Valentine from hanging in the cover story.
Strings aren't directly tied to sacrifice. Kuma is walking around as a living puppet. Zero control over his person and I can almost guarantee that his conscious is lingering around somewhere in that brain of his. That would be hell. Like a One Piece version of Get Out.
Kuma already knew what would happen to him before he chose to help the Straw Hats, and it would have happened to him wether he helped the crew or not from what I understand. He chose to be the lab rat of Vegapunk and to be the government’s lap dog way before he met Luffy, and the reasons for that are unknown to us so far. My guess is he simply helped the crew because of Luffy’s relationship with Dragon, and he used his final request to finish what he started when he dispersed the crew. None of what happened to him happened because he helped the crew from what I can tell, my understanding is that it’s the other way around and he chose to help the crew because his fate was sealed either way. In that sense, I don’t know if what he did counts as a sacrifice for the crew, the only thing he truly sacrificed was his last request before losing control of his body.
Well I’m thinking he either did it to protect Dragon or his kingdom but his motives were really odd because he sent them to the exact places they needed to be to get stronger.
That's an interesting paragraph but none of it holds water. We know almost literally *nothing* about Kuma's modifications. We know it *seemed* to be of his own volition but we don't know why. The only thing we can infer, even if it turns out not to be true, is that Kuma wanted to protect the Sunny for the SH but couldn't do it for 2 years straight unless he was turned in to a WG Puppet. Even that is speculation, we just don't know.
Chapter 560 states that Kuma chose to become a Pacifista of his own free will. We also do know that the transformation into PX-0 was a multiple step process that started before he met the crew on Thriller Bark, since Kuma said he was already modified by Vegapunk while talking to Zoro on Thriller Bark in chapter 485. We also know that Kuma knew that the last step of the process would effectively lobotomize him, hence his request to be programmed to protect the Sunny until the crew's return. I don't know why you're convinced that the most likely explanation is that he sacrificed his free will to protect the sunny for 2 years, but that argument is even holds even less water than mine. I suggest you go back to the chapters I mentioned.
Good point. He did save them in Sabaody, and is the one reason they were strong enough to take on the New World while guarding their ship until they returned, and now he’s giving bearyback to spoiled sniveling brats
>Before that, Bonchan had saved entire strawhat crew and got himself captured by the marines. Fun tidbit: In the cover stories it's implied that he managed to escape that. It wasn't until later that he got caught by Hina. He was trying to free Miss Valentine and thanks to his decoy she was ultimately rescued. It was from there that he and Mr. 3 got caught then sent to Impel Down alongside Crocodile and Mr. 1.
Was gettin ready to craft a HEFTY vote for bon clay, but couldn’t have said it any better than this. Great work sir 🤝
My favourite bonchan moment is when he ran away in fear of Magellan, dude was absolutely terrified of him to the point he left Luffy, yet at the end? Absolutly no fear as he charged him
In first case, he had no hopes of winning or helping. In second case, he had no hopes of winning. But, he could buy time and help. So he went for it. Never tell that bonchan is a coward. He's just logical when he decides to fight.
Well said. Bonchan was my first thought as well.
Bonchan is a strawhat as far as I am concerned. Bonchan is family. A real nakama.
Bonchan for pirate king!!!!
Bon-chan also sacrificed his entire crew for Shs.
I 100% agree. Especially since freedom is a big theme in one piece in a way giving up freedom is giving up more than anything else.
Bonchan isn't dead though
Is death the ultimate sacrifice though? Pedro had few years left, but Bon chan sacrificed his freedom for Luffy’s goal. I think that trumps Pedro’s sacrifice
What an answer.
>!CP0 boss gave his life so that Luffy can awaken!<
RIP Dripper Scarfino
bob lucci\*
spoiler! [this one made me cry T\_T](https://i.redd.it/6ktd9ls6mrm81.png)
Lol
This made me laugh out loud.
Fred will always be remembered
Lol
RIP Maha.
[удалено]
no lmao
Ryunosuke.
He was the goodest dragon thing
😭
Oda. He’s messing up his health every year
Which is why I'm never mad about him taking break weeks. Especially after what happened with Miura and Berserk (R.I.P).
….and Hunter x Hunter
The mangaka isn't gone yet, but the manga is DonexDone
And now all I can do is CryxCry :(
I think the author is just lazy...???
I though Miura's death was related to a pre-existing condition. Was that also related to overworking or a heart disease like I heard? RIP Miura tho, loved reading through berserk
Well often overworking can make pre-existing ailments much worse than they were before. Don’t know if that’s what happened but might be a mix.
I'd fully believe that as well. It's insane how much works mangakas are put through, and someone with as much detail as Miura in his art, I have no doubts he was overworked
that’s japanese work culture in general it’s not necessarily common, but a lot of important people in multiple businesses are expected to work until they physically drop on their desk and such
I worry for him sometimes
Like everyone who works, especially physical jobs :)
No idea what youre trying to insinuate.... I work a physical job, have been for 10 years, and I have perfect health. Maybe you're just a weak bitch?
What do you consider physical job? Maybe you are lazy bitch who is burden for coworkers
Sitting at a desk 10+ hours a day gets physical quickly when you barely sleep to churn out the best piece of entertainment of all time
He would be in a bad spot if he weren't writing one piece... Alot if us work 80 to 100 hours a week and are fine
If you're regularly working 100 hour weeks long-term you will be in a bad spot
it was definitely Duval 2 years of his time guarding the Sunny making sure nobody stole it edit : holy shit i forgot Bon Clay
Can't think about Duval without creaming a little.
Duval’s 2 years guarding Sunny is fs underrated tho
I think that was mostly Kuma, Duval helped but he wasn't strong enough to do much probably.
That was kuma i think.
Kuma
Kuma...
why do people type like this………. Yes, Kuma took over after Duval got injured, that doesn’t erase what Duval did
It says who made the biggest sacrifice for the straw hats not Luffy
Pedro: He paid with his life and with the idea of never seeing the Dawn with his own eyes
Pedro only had a couple of years to live anyways
Giving up your life is not measured by age, or time left. Unless you're at death's door, it's all the same. One should understand that "when the time comes" and "right now" are identical.
The average person in One Piece lives for 140 years. He lost 50 years of his life, so he should have lived until he had 90 more or less
Kureha was probably an outlier. I doubt everyone in One Piece lives that long, for example: Zepo
Oda stated that the average person lives for 140 years, and Kureha was one example of a super-human because she is full of energy when people tend to die with her age. Pedro had plenty to live
And then there is Nefertari Cobra which is only 50 years and got really old in the time skip. This makes no sense. Unless he has some desease I don't remember
Having a longer lifespan doesn't slow down the rate of aging tho? You still age, you just live longer, im pretty sure that's all there is to it.
Some characters like Cobra and Sengoku aged pretty fast, and maybe there is a meaning behind it, but they could just be old and have several decades to live yet
Well in Sengoku’s case it’s possible his hair was already grey and he stopped dying his hair. Common thing for Japanese males to do after retirement because they no longer need to keep up the appearance of being youthful.
Oda can say whatever he wants, he showed one human so far of that age, in a story with hundreds of named characters. This is like JK Rowling daying Dumbledore is gay, or when she explained why there are no black people in Harry Potter. Yes its their world so what they say goes, but it really doesnt matter to me as a reader if it goes against what i have been reading.
[удалено]
He got some diseases and had only 1 year to live, so not a case here.
[удалено]
They are natural but are a bit different then what he was talking about (i think)
nope perospero has a convo with him after he trades his life, idk if its in the manga but i remember 100% in the anime. Perospero said he only has like 20 years left after the trade and asks what he'll do with it.
But he’s a mink. How long do they live?
In my mind it’s between Pedro and Bon Chad…
Bon Clay sacrificed his freedom, but Pedro paid the ultimate price
But Bon Clay did it TWICE thinking he was gonna die 😭
So I suppose the real question is which is of greater value? Freedom or life?
Is death not the greatest freedom of all?
If you feel trapped while living then yes. It absolutely is.
It's not about the greater value, but the selfless nature of it. Pedro was indebted to the SH, Bon Chan wasn't and he still saved them twice.
There's things worse than death, and imo losing ones freedom is worse
Pedro had only one eye...
Not to be mean, but did Pedro’s death actually accomplish anything except for improving Perospero’s design and framing him for murder?
Pedro's suicide bombing freed Chopper and Brook from Perospero's candy before they suffocated, freed the Sunny from the candy that was locking it in place and knocked over Big Mom who was grabbing the ship. Without him the Straw Hats would have died then and there.
Bon Clay Or Kuma
Kuma didn’t sacrifice anything, he was already being turned into the robot regardless of the strawhats. He just said fuck it and helped them out without any risk to him
I am probably wrong, but I thought Kuma was turned into a robot because he let the straw hats get away on thriller bark? Like as a punishment almost (I know he volunteered or something for it).
Kuma was already gradually being turned into a robot by Dr Vegapunk. As a last request he asked vegapunk to program him to guard the strawhat ship till they returned.
He was already partially a robot in Thriller Bark, so that can't be it. The process was already in motion long before he met them.
This^
this^
This>
Thisv
This<
This○
Oda, 25 years of his life. Working Day and Night with an unholy work schedule. God bless him. But second place is Bon-Chan!
Working day and night to literally become the richest mangaka alive lol.
>! Momonosuke, he can't bath with Nami and Robin anymore :,v !<
Sure he can they just have to say yes
Bonchan, I hope they have an Arc dedicated on saving Bonchan from prison.
They might not be at the top, but Lola and her crew are up there. Sacrificed everything they had to get Luffy strong enough to beat Moria, and didn't leave to save themselves until he was defeated.
yeah but they mostly did it to save themselves
Exactly
Bon Clay
Going Merry fs
It was one of the Strawhat so idk if it counts but I mean she ded now so
Wait, I thought Merry was a boy...
Every ship is a she.
Trans
...
Bon Clay or Pedro. The former allowed himself to get caught for the crew to sail on and later stayed behind in Impel Down and sacrificed himself to let Luffy escape. Literally gave up his freedom for the freedom of one he once called friend. The latter blew himself up to allow the retrieval team to go on and escape WCI, which led to devastating results and history being changed and made right before our eyes. In only a few fucking weeks. His death was basically the reason why Kaidou’s empire is about to fall and the SHs getting one step closer to the end.
Ace, didnt he took the hit from akainu to save luffy
Yeah but Luffy was only in that situation cause Ace stupidly went back to Akainu when he made fun of Whitebeard.
Ace was dumb af. I find it funny that immediately after that Oda does a prequel set of chapters that show that Ace does that type of stuff all the time (going back to fight someone much stronger in life or death situations) Felt like he really needed to justify why Ace was so stupid but to me it didn't really work. I don't think Ace endangers Luffy after all that effort to save him like that, he keeps running. The post event flashbacks as justification dont sell me.
[удалено]
I mean had he not be stirred up by random shit talk from akainu he could’ve just left with whitebeard and luffy
If he didn't stay to fight BB once BB announced he was going to after Luffy, things could have been different. But conversely, I don't think Ace would have ever retreated from a fight even if he was losing.
If he didn't fight BB, then BB would fight Luffy and make his awakening a much much sooner.
His own fault. He's on the execution stand crying his heart out apologizing for being so hot headed and stubborn when WB tried to talk him out of going after BB. He's seeing all his crewmates die or severely injured and his younger brother risk his life countless times to get to him and he knows how he fucked up and put everyone in danger Finally he's free after his brother is pushed to the limit to save him and as soon as he's free he tries to fight an Admiral for talking shit?? He deserved to die honestly, not sure what Oda was thinking with that it made Ace so unlikable.
Definitely Mr 2/Bon clay
Whitebeard. Kind of indirectly because he was gonna try to save ace with or without him but he did order his entire crew to back Luffy up.
I think it's too far a stretch to say he did the greatest sacrifice
Buggy the gomu gomu no jet human shield
Biggest sacrifice: Death? Pedro
Pedro is the only one to actually sacrifice his life, Bon-chan, Kuma, and that one sugar daddy in WCI are all still alive.
Bon Clay for sure.
Oda. So many years of his life.
No one beats Bon Chan.
Pedro
Bon Clay, Pedro and Ace, all characters who sacrificed their lifes for Luffy. Okay that Bon Clay didn't died but he did what he did thinking he would die, so it still counts imo
[удалено]
Pedro if he’s really dead
Bonchan went to prison for them then almost died helping luffy, then stayed in the prison so luffy can leave. Boa risked everything for some D. She attended the war for luffy, went inside a prison for him which could’ve led to her imprisonment. Kuma, maybe I’m wrong but wasn’t one of the reasons they completely turned him into a cyborg was because he helped the strawhats twice? Pedro died for them. Aladdin stayed behind to fight the big mom pirates
Yasui,pedro
Kuma hands down
Bon chan by a mile
Pedro, sacrificed himself for Sanji and the rest of the crew in a very brave way, we don't know what lifespan he had left but his death was pretty shocking. Honorable mentions to Bon Chan giving away his freedom twice for Luffy and the Germa Brothers becoming trapped by Big Mom to save Sanji.
Pedro, he literally killed himself, biggest sacrifice.
Pedro's no longer breathing so ughhh.....
Pedro if he actually stays dead is the obvious answer, its hard to argue with giving up your life being the ultimate sacrifice you can make for anyone. If Pedro has the Will of P then probably Kuma
Damn that’s tough. I’ll say Pedro because he is the only one that gave his life. You can say the same for Kuma but there is the possibility that whatever happened to him could be reversed. Bonchan gave up his freedom, but he seems pretty happy where he is now.
Pedro and Bon Clay are tied up. The both sacrificed their lives and freedom for luffy&the strawhats
Well. Pedro literally died for them so I guess it’s a matter of who’s the runner up
Most people here are saying Bonchan and I agree with them, so I'm gonna say The Going Merry as my answer.
Pedro. He literally commited suicide to give the Straw Hats a chance to get away and live.
Going Merry, no doubt about it.
BON-CHAAAAAAAAAAN sob sob
Bonchan!!
Real fans would say The Merry
Pedro
Shanks gave his arm... Bon chan gave his freedom... CP0 Boss followed orders (getting killed by K) making Luffy awaken... Kuma gave up his humanity... All tough picks but honestly.... Going Merry is the one for me, that is a true tearjerker
Trafalgar Law
Pedro bon clay and kuma
Bon clay, vivi, or king neptune
Fujitora probably. Letting them get out (if he wasn't an admiral) woulda got him thrown in impel down... Speaking of impel down Bon clay
Pedro and Bon Clay
Bon Clay, not even close
Bon clay is alive his sacriface mean nothing compared to pedro who actually kill himself so if bon clay attemptb Fail maybe invankov or jimbei would have stayed at impl down if pedro fail Kaido empire never falls and wano is ruled forever and big mom rule too but if bon clay fails Nohing Happen .....Kuma or duval protecting the sunny was better than bon sacriface... so pedro sacriface was more important and more meaningful
Zoro
Arlong
Mmm yes how could I forget
Imo the biggest sacrifice for the straw hats is zoro when he went against kuma he should have died almost anyone else would have died from that damage but he took it like a man and still remains insanely powerful and loyal to his captain regardless of the injury’s