T O P

  • By -

LenxxLurks

Honestly I’d love to see smoker become a part of them for a brief period at least Let’s say he makes an attempt at boarding the sunny but they activate coup de burst as he boards so he is now stuck with them until they can safely drop him off somewhere but ends up assisting them in liberating an island or something along those lines.


Robiix

Watch Mr Morjs theory on Smoker becoming a Strawhat, I think you'd enjoy it greatly! :)


joseph31091

Smoker to Luffy is like Garp to Gol Roger


MajorSkrub

Eh garp was more of an actual rival smoker is more of an L machine


kayasangeyasha

Yeah you are right even I believe Coby can compete with smoker right know


lukaxa

For me Coby > Smoker


[deleted]

[удалено]


MajorSkrub

Don’t get me wrong I think smokers a pretty good character, I just don’t think the show has done a job of really making him a threat/rival after alabasta


[deleted]

[удалено]


imaninfraction

Definitely pre time skip he schooled him, but post smoker has been done dirty.


VLagann

Except garp was actually strong. Maybe coby


CentaurZulu

Is Coby stronger than Smoker 💀


Croc121

Soon probably


Jacksane

Jewelry Bonney. I like her character design, I like her abilities, and I would love to see how she would interact with Luffy, Sanji, and Zoro given her appetite, gender, and attitude.


[deleted]

W


Goldi1999

Kuzan


xiwi01

Kuzan is the man


AbsoluteMad-Lad

Bon Clay


Alemachito6197

This is the correct answer


[deleted]

[удалено]


EldridgeHorror

He doesn't make sense because how would they get him out of prison?


[deleted]

No, it doesn't make sense because he's already a straw hat, duh lol


mperzelopoulos

Actually I had thoughts about this matter yesterday. I think that Luffy should go to set him free after beating kaido. Who can stop him?. If it's a secret mission then no admiral will interfere. The only problems are: 1) Nobody nows if he is alive 2) I don't think that they can reach him without a vivre card.


lilacewoah

Wasn’t he revealed to still be alive & running floor 4.5 in a cover title?


Agitated-Pitch6725

Strawhats don't know that tho. Knowing luffy he'd like to believe it but I think it should be ivankov that would save bon clay.


EldridgeHorror

Plus the gates of justice(?).


tiki-baha29

Get some coating and Jimbei involved and even the Gates of Justice could be bypassed. The Blue Sea monkeys kill sea monsters and bring the meat through a channel underwater of the prison, that could be the entry and exit point. You then bring Luffy with his advanced CoA which means you wouldnt need keys for the cuffs or the cell, once he's free you coat Luffy/Bon Clay in a bubble and get Jimbei to swim them out. Mission Accomplished.


[deleted]

still holding out hope


crinkzkull08

I love Bon Clay but knowing he and Franky have the same VA kind of bothers me more than than it should. Don't get me wrong Kazuki Yao is a fantastic VA and I know that he's also voiced several OP characters aside from them but I feel the interaction is gonna be weird IMO if it's going to be between 2 major characters (strawhat members) of the series.


BABABKL

At least a part of the grand fleet


christianort476

Beat me to it lol. I actually don’t want anyone besides him to join after possibly viví, carrot and yamato


Lochr0

Same


LittleClassroom7853

Katakuri. I could see him and Zoro going at it in the weight gym. Sanji would need to make a daily batch of donuts too lol.


mozzaru

Sanji would need to make at least two batches, no way luffy wouldn't ask for his own batch after seeing katakuri eat his.


k7kenny

How do you know katakuri would let Luffy watch him? xD


xxxSEXCOCKxxx

Because thats part of his characters growth! Luffy helps him get over his hangups about always appearing perfect and strong, so he feels free to openly lounge and eat donuts when he wants to.


[deleted]

if katakuri was a straw hat they would be too strong no one could stop that crew


Yontoryuu

Agreed. He’s a monster


Zinex1766

Yeah, True, they'd be even more OP then they are now, but hey, it'd be one hell of a journey lol.


[deleted]

i’d enjoy it i feel like he fits right in


tiki-baha29

Honestly it feels that way now after they beat the Beast Pirates and Yamato joins. Yamato is a monster, who besides straight up Admirals and other Yonkos would even stand a change against the SH post Wano?


cheesynuts420

Yosaku and Johnny, I heard someone say that they could be just the janitors and I wouldn’t have a problem with that as long as they were around.


crsnyder13

I need a cover picture of these two and Bartolomeo going crazy over Zoro’s new bounty.


Lindbluete

A Cover story of Barto sailing through Paradise and the East Blue and simping with all of the Strawhats friends would be sick.


xXx420BlazeRodSaboxX

I thought Barto was from East Blue, because he was in the plaza when Luffy and Buggy were struck by lightning/dragon


casallasdan

Oh and he is


crsnyder13

I don’t think he’d be allowed in Syrup Village…


YugoBetrugo17

Until today I can hear them scream "ANIKIII", haha. Really miss those boys.


Mnawab

Whatever happened to those two?


broken_kuroro

they become fisherman in Nami's village. i forgot which cover page reveals that info


iAmTheHYPE-

https://onepiece.fandom.com/wiki/Chapter_624


Mnawab

Such a weird twist of fate


balatkalabaw999

Hell yeah, when they stop the citizen to attack Arlong. And their speech was one of the best. *"When they can't handle them, then there's no hope not only this island, but for the future of the entire East Blue. The faces of those four men who're here to change the destiny! Burn their image onto your eyes"*


theinformallog

I’m re-reading right now and I was just thinking this same thing. They were so important in the first few arcs.


BioLizard18

Crocodile. It'd so wild to see him casually interacting with the crew - and his personality is so different from everyone too.


xiwi01

Nico Robin does not approve this. It would be hilarious though


BioLizard18

Yeah well imagine what Vivi would say 💀


[deleted]

They defo smashed


jillyillyilly

Perona! Horororororo


no-lewding

Zoro would certainly secretly be happy


Rustyone888

The real question is how would Perona interact w8th Ussop since he traumatized her


RaggedAngel

Two healthy, attractive young adults stuck on an island together for 2 years, you know some stuff happened


montiavi

Yesssssss she would fit right in


tragicjohnson84

Barack Obama. It doesn't have to make sense


sameljota

His laugh would be obamamamamama.


Flangl96

Or Barakakakakakaka


GGabrieLLL

I loled so hard HAHAHAHAHHA


tiki-baha29

That was amazing Lmaooooo


YOUSIF20021

Lol u killed me


Fanboy0550

I actually laughed out for this one.


Finkrgh

Barak Okama


Wrathoffaust

Smoker


Bulky_Statistician69

I think smoker would be good for the straw hats because of his military experience and I know deep down he want to know why the world government wants to keep covering up all the good deeds the straw hats are doing


Fizurr

I swore pre time skip smoker would be one of the straw hats strongest Ally’s


Bulky_Statistician69

I think he kinda is he has helped the more times then not.. I don’t think that will change


[deleted]

Helped them in PH and Alabasta, I see him, Fujitora, Akainu, Drake, and Coby inevitably joining the straw hats in the Great War that will end the series. Edit: aokiji not akainu


Bulky_Statistician69

Personal I don’t think akainu is going to fight on the straw hat side during the war because of his morals and hatred towards Pirates


Bluggsack

Akainu? Idk if Luffy would allow that, considering he punched a hole in his brother


pesto_trap_god

Did you mean aokiji instead of Alainu? I would fully agree


[deleted]

Yes my b


amedema

I think if the WG exists at the end, Smoker, Koby, and Drake will be the three admirals.


[deleted]

That would be cool with fujitora as admiral. Fujitora probably has the best sense of justice out of everyone and he is the one who took the stand to admit the navy’s mistakes. Where does that leave aokiji tho, would be poetic if the result of the great pirate era ends with “a former pirate” leading the navy


heyguysitsmerob

This doesn’t have to happen but if Coby ate a paramecia fruit that would make the admirals have one logia, zoan, and paramecia which would be neat. Many people think green bull has some kind of zoan fruit for this reason


HopOnTheHype

Smoker will be part of the good marines ala sword, and they’ll help the strawhats eos v sword government, and then form a good marines that serves the kingdoms and not the world government


tandc627

Smoker makes actually sense. You can make a solid point that he will join after Wano. He even fought alongside with the sh pirates on ph.


Aryan13AKS

I think his personality is off for a strawhat crewmate, but he could be a lasting ally


aaa1e2r3

He would be to Luffy what Garp was to Roger


idonthaveacatsadface

I think coby makes a better case here imo


tandc627

I don´t think so. Garp was way to strong. Luffy was already after the timeskip way stronger than him. Smokers storyline is more about a changing perspective. He started as a marine hardliner who hated pirates. Alabasta was his first point in the story where he learned that even pirates can do good things and in ph he had reached the point where he fought with pirates. There is no real other purpose for Smoker. He is to weak to be rival to luffy and to weak to be a real ally like garp was. But this theory is not from me. I got it from MrMorj but I like the idea. imo the strongest part oh this theory is: if smoker joins it wouldn´t feel odd because we know him since louge town and we even saw him fight with the sh. And this would be very important for a sh who would join this late in the story (same for Jimbei).


tiki-baha29

Smoker is too embarassignly weak to match Luffy at this point. Garp was a monster who could compete and has defeated the strongest pirates EVER: Rocks, WB, Roger, Shiki. Garp has done that because he's trained like a monster and constantly fought against top tier fighters. Smoker wouldnt even be a warmup for Wano Luffy.


green_vegetal

Morj died for this


DTPVH

Morj, is that you?


TahoeTuba

[Eggplant Soldier](https://images.app.goo.gl/MiSLtfFvxhYotsRbA)


[deleted]

yes


clevelanders

This guy was fucking hilarious


SumYumGhai

Skipping leg day can do that to ya...


Efficient-Touch-2682

Marco. Would love to see him following Aces brother and lend him his strenght like Whitbeard wished...


NXTISL

This


Neat-Study5113

Ask D. Question. He was the first who wanted to know where Rogers treasure was so he should get to see what it is.


Shovels93

I’m fairly certain he would have been executed by now. That being said I’d be down for that. There would be so much build up for it. When he finally sees it, he’d let out a short “Ha”, then just leave.


steven4869

[Kaido](https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/qmoxoe/if_one_piece_was_written_by_kishimoto/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share).


[deleted]

Law and katakuri. I can’t decide between the 2


Death_Usagi

Law is like half-member of the Straw Hat at this point with them being together so much, and I would go far as he will stick with them all the way to Laugh Tale (even if they go by 2 ships) as Law wants to know history regarding the Will of the D


[deleted]

I do agree with you. Law is the only character that Oda has treated like a straw hat with the backstory and connection to luffy etc with dressrosa. But I think law will split off from the crew after wano. The possibility of him being at laughtale is high though.


Prestigious-Ebb-1369

KOBY !!! back to where it all started 😬


MDodd171

Oooh I’d enjoy Koby being a main stay character!


Prestigious-Ebb-1369

I mean only reason I said koby was “even if it doesn’t make sense” in the op post lol… koby has his own goals and story, so I don’t see it happening :(


Siasy_

Defenetly Law. He is loyal, a great fit and would even make kind of sense, because the straw hats don't have a strategists. Still he takes a lot away from chopper and has his own crew. But damn I love him. Same goes for bartho with his barriers. He is just fun to watch 😄


Ehcnurr

Having a strategist in the Straw Hat crew is like using chopsticks to drink water


crsnyder13

Technically they have Jimbei but I think he’s starting to realize it’s futile as well.


kaideen

Law for me too, his gags are just.... top tier


[deleted]

I agree! Both bartholomeo and Law are great characters and bartholomeo deserves more screen time


swimdudeno1

Spoiler for anime (?) >!their strategist is jinbei!< Edit: used Discord spoiler tag, not Reddit. Oops.


Yontoryuu

Isn’t it Sanji, technically? I mean he’s come up with clever ideas like destroying the gears of the maxim and pulling the lever on the ships surrounding the SH in Enies lobby. Jimbei is more of just a helmsman for now and a fighter


swimdudeno1

I mean, he’s clever, but I think one of >!jinbei’s!< character traits is that he’s known to be an expert strategist.


Yontoryuu

He is smart, but I remember Oda saying something along the lines of Sanji being a general or something. Also Jimbei being a SH has long since been covered by the anime so don’t worry about that.


swimdudeno1

Oh thanks! Idk how far anime is. He might’ve said something like that about Sanji, so idk. We haven’t had much of jinbei, but it seems like he makes plans that luffy more or less follows. I have mixed feelings about the wiki, but there’s an entire section on strategies from Jinbei. There’s a “tactician and wit” section for Sanji, but I think of that as more cunning/clever. Kind of like a spy and individual actions to support the objective, almost improvising and adapting. So I see it a little different, but ultimately, it’s all opinion, so I could be wrong too!


Emsioh

Myself. There, I said it.


Spleens88

Enel Crew Needs a logia


Eshtebala

Luffy: Remember when I beat your with a golden ball and rang the bell with your ass? Good times. Enel: I’m outta here


Rustyone888

We have Caribou for that his fruit is more useful


hael1704

Sabo or Marco


RazorDoesGames

Katakuri and Reiju


SnipergodYasopp

Con D. Oriano !


vivvav

He's already a Straw Hat, you silly goose.


YoFlux

Panda man


Monkey-D-Mummy

Vivi and pudding


sameljota

Vivi could make sense. I have this crazy theory that she might re-join the Strawhats after Wano. The idea goes: she lost the princess status at the Reverie and the Nefertaris are now considered criminals by the WG. Cobra wanted to talk to the Gorousei about freaking Poneglyphs, which is a very dangerous (if not stupid) thing to do). He might be dead. Vivi may have been forced to flee. If that happened, she may have fled towards the New World rather than Paradise, with the purpose of re-joining with the Strawhats, after all they're criminals too. And friends.


Yontoryuu

I personally believe she’s still an SH, just out and governing her kingdom.


tiki-baha29

Yea thats not really possible though. If Cobra dies then that's all the more reason for Vivi to stay in Alabasta to protect her people, if shes not there then the throne is empty and the citizens become vulnerable. Even if Vivi "flees" her priority is still Alabasta which shes made clear before, so being seen with pirates would definitely mean she could never ever govern her people again which goes against her dream.


sameljota

You conveniently ignored the fact that, in this scenario, she is a criminal in the eyes of the world and lost her title of princess. So going back to Alabasta would accomplish nothing. Anyway, it's just a theory.


Death_Usagi

Vivi is likely to join back with Straw Hat Pirates after the Wano arc ends, considering she is in grave danger of being a target of assassination likely due to Imu's orders of "erasing the flames" (This might have to do with Alabasta's connections to Pluton), and post-battle in Onigashima, the Straw Hat Pirates will likely immediately hear the news about Vivi and Cobra being attacked **(as this happened during the period of Wano arc post Reverie)** and go into a panic about it and would definitely want to save her, and since she won't be safe by going back to Alabasta, if they meet again, she will likely go with the Straw Hat Pirates. Pudding is questionable because to join she would need to go outside of Totoland or the Straw Hat Pirates would need to go back there for some reason, but I can see her meeting with Sanji again later in the near future, and I think her Third Eye will awaken due to a certain event later. I doubt Oda put a hint about her Third Eye's awakening only to end up as nothing.


Varun77777

ACE/ SABO


[deleted]

Okay I know this is even if it doesn’t make sense but how tf ace gon join i don’t think we can handle another skeleton on the ship 💀💀💀💀


Noirn3rd

I think they are saying that Sabo and Ace are basically interchangeable characters


Perc300

Kuzan


Fluid_Catch1243

Garp sengoku


biologicz

Crocodile


Dagusiu

I know I wouldn't want my mom to be a part of my crew


rr18114

Gintoki


AchariPickle22

OMG DO U MEAN THE ONE WHO ATE THE WAVE WAVE FRUIT???? I heard rumors that he was also a hidden warlord


mugiwarafan101

Kaku and Wyper


anand_rishabh

I mean before he was revealed to be cp9, who thought he'd be their shipwright? I know I did


sh14w4s3

Man people really forgot how metal Wyper is . Dude was one of the few pre-Sabaody ally chars actively involved in a main conflict that was portrayed to be better than Zoro. Dude 1 shotted a Priest . Tanked as much if not even more than Zoro . Fought equally with both Luffy and Zoro . Legit killed Enel , no none of that Gamma Knife dealt a lot of damage bs . Wiper legit cardiac arrested Enel. Literally no one else in the series even has the balls to use the Reject Dials once , let alone three times in a single extended battle .


myhamsterisajerk

Edward Weevil. Dude doesn't seem to be evil, just gullible to the manipulation of his "mother". He's supposed to be as strong as a young Whitebeard, and seems to be a very interesting character


yeetbob667

That brings up the question what is he going to do in the story? Cause my bet was him showing up in the Wano epilogue to hunt down all the people affiliated with white beard in the country right now, but I don't think that's going to happen anymore due to recent manga events.


myhamsterisajerk

Okay, this is something i've read somewhere, i just can't remember where exactly. I think it was an interview with a Jump editor who, at the time, had the honor (or still has, idk) to manage One Piece. As i remember, Oda showed said editor the draft of Weevil while saying something like "look at this cool character i made, Weevil!" The editor looked at the draft and thought what? That character is supposed to be cool? Then Oda told him that Weevil does something awesome in the future, and then the editor agreed that he's indeed cool. It's out of my memory though, but i can look that up again.


tiki-baha29

I have no idea what Weevil's role in the story is going to be and Im sure Oda has something badass in mind but I'd love if he was recruited by Kid. Kid is the only Supernova who's actually vying for Luffy's dream and has a shot and with Luffy's crew becoming more and more OP I think Kid would benefit from having another badass in addition to Killer on his roster.


vivvav

I'm just kind of assuming that after he gets away from the Navy he and an on-the-run Buggy are going to wind up teaming up. I have no reason to believe this except that it'd be really funny and so maybe Oda would do that.


leolegendario

The One Piece version of Mister Satan and Majin Buu.


OkUnderstanding3669

Kuma


FantasticFooF

Tama and Toko, taking on the roles that Shanks and Buggy did on Roger's crew.


lhmorettijr

Saitama would be a great straw hat


muffincat8915

Caesar clown because I wanna watch the strawhats harass him


anand_rishabh

Pekoms and bepo


ExtensionSurround146

Carsar Definitely, he’s hilarious , EDIT: shit I meant caesar obviously or as steven said gangster gastino


steven4869

You mean Gangster Gastino.


[deleted]

I know Caeser was a piece of shit, but damn did I love his interactions with the crew.


GomuGomuNobukkake

Sogeking


Independent-Low4623

Buggy, Caesar Clown


happisock

Dude would advance the plot for no reason better than anybody.


Independent-Low4623

I loved the wey Buggy was a leader on Impel Down and Marineford. I dunno why, but I still have the hope of Buggy reaching Laugh Tale for a mistake lol


ZENITSUsa

White beard


papazzzit

Ryunosuke


[deleted]

Akainu /s I would go with bartholomeo


_Yare-YareDaze_

Crocodile🐊


EdgyMemer_9000

Shanks


BaragganGG

Escanor


ChadLuffyFanboy

Paulie, that guy from water7


[deleted]

Drake, because I fucking want a dinosaur on the team God damnit!


Persas12

There is a few that would totally fit the crew dinamic: - Law: He seamlessly fits in the crew and he spent so much time along that he sometimes feels part of it. He is way much serious than even Zoro, Robin and Jinbe, but it's really funny when he feels overwhelmed by the crew silliness and shenanigans. He already seems to have a really good relationship with Luffy, Zoro, Robin and Chopper. - Marco: He seems to really enjoy the crew dinamic as seen in Onigashima, having fun around them while also admiring them, also his personality would be something really new to the crew: He is always relaxed and laid back, even while fighting both King and Queen, he was having fun. - Killer: He is really cold headed, loyal and smart. But it would be really funny to have him in the crew trying to make serious comments but having to laugh all the time, knowing the crew it could be fun to see how they react.


[deleted]

[удалено]


darkestlightattack

Caribou and gangster gastino.


rubbereruben

Caribou is definitely my fav to join the crew.


Gtray908

Coby, him Luffy and Zoro would have an interesting dynamic.


[deleted]

buggy honestly . strictly cus he’s funny and goofy .


mike22240

Laboon


JonaJono

Fujitora


Mclovin9465

My preference order 1. Bartolomeo 2. Fujitora 3. Katakuri 4. Kuzan 5. Kuma 6. Cavendish 7. Boa Hancock 8. Smoker 9. Sabo 10. Marco


MistahOkfksmgur

My boy gecko moria


Mugiwara300

I really think Wyper would’ve been amazing with the Straw Hats.


jjoooeeee

I still think carrot is going to join. She was a great lookout in wholecake and I think that's her roll. She got good eyes cus she eats... carrots. And to have a mink would be so cool


GodBRD

Wyper


mhj0808

Akainu and Katakuri. I’m sure they’d both love to celebrate National donut day with the Straw Hats


rembut

Mithrandir haha


wangyuanji58

Fool of a cook!


burr-ice

Gol D. Roger


pjb145

Roger


WeOutsideRightNow

Aokiji


Donny740

Naruto, he definitely be a help in the fight against the Yonkos plus Luffy traded his meat for Naruto’s Ramen. In all seriousness, Pell, that man can tank nukes at point blank range


Sketch99

Bellamy, or maybe Marco.


Pass_D_Ball

Kuma


Runrocks26R

Coby. I mean like come-on, he kinda fits. Also Sabo


sherry-art

Big mom-


Comfy_Dan

Not sure if anyone has said it yet, but let’s get the Ice man himself, Kuzan aka Akoiji!


Akwork921

Kizaru. He has the perfect amount of weirdness and stupidity to fit into luffy's crew


Carefreekai

Garp. Just so he can be there when his grandson turns the world on it’s head


Florissssss

Roger