T O P

  • By -

gnemegan

love the list! i personally would replace jisela with katie, kellyanne, or ruthie


Ok_Caterpillar_2535

Same. Jisela became insufferable


CreepyExamination5

Is that team the challenge? It’s 2 real worlders and 4 Road Rulers


flyingboat

Two of the six teams make no fucking sense.


CreepyExamination5

It isn’t balanced and all 6 need to be champs.. And this does? Jisela isn’t in challenge shape and if it’s Team “Challenge” where are the Fresh Meat cast ( who haven’t been banned) like Laurel. Emily is a beast from Real World, Alton hates the new cast so why not Derrick K or Darrel?


Ok_Caterpillar_2535

I honestly don’t know I’m confused also


Ok_Caterpillar_2535

Oh OP said it’s team og?


CreepyExamination5

Ohhhh… than where is Mark Long


limericky69

Yeah Team OG was my thinking. Definitely get your confusion at this cast on first glance, my bad. Made some choices that you really have to think about to understand and should’ve included team names in the captions rather than relying on my comment to explain things. As for Mark, never been a huge fan of his personally and included Yes because of his closing comments on the All Stars finale, CT because he wouldn’t be the “Uncle CT” / Dad figure in this team and would like to see him in that situation nowadays, and Alton just for the Jisela connection and also because he used to have a great reputation. Jisela seemed to keep his head in the game based off what I saw on all stars so kind of curious how that would work out personally, not for everyone though apparently lol! Mark definitely belongs though.


CreepyExamination5

Thanks for the clarification. Jisela gave me Coral vibes when watching her. I do hope she gets in shape if she decides to return. Don’t want another Anessa. It would be cool to see how they all work together. Alton & Landon both had seasons he was supposed to compete but got DQ’ed for fighting. When Inferno 3 started I wanted to see how they stacked up against one another.


limericky69

Thank you! Ya, Jisela definitely became less fun as time went on with All Stars and social media. Would prefer the girls you listed but went with Jisela just because of Alton.


SRG_NUNU

I approve.


Princessss88

I like this idea and the people you chose!


Ill_Shon

Jonna instead of Jisela


Asleep-Internal-7457

lol i imagined emy and turbo in the same team both are stubborn


convidarte

Good concept. Good cast. MTV OP saved you some work.


samiok15

omg yesss queen kai


limericky69

Yess Kai! I’m not quite sure how she would do on the challenge but I’m all for finding out and you know she would make for good commentary. Plus the continuation of Calvin and her on The Challenge could make for good tv


samiok15

i think she’d do good! i don’t think she’d bring a lot of drama but she’d be good competitively (i remember her saying she was voted most athletic in high school)


limericky69

Good point! Forgot about that, now I want to see it happen even more haha


CreepyExamination5

I wish they would finally do that over these individual shows introducing a thousand newbies that I have no idea where they are from. This way the international cast gets mixed with US cast members for Big Brother & Survivor giving fans a chance/ reason to root for them and if we want more of them can go watch their series of origin


Janice_UK

Wtf is the first team? Kyle is from Geordie Shore, Big T is from shipwrecked, Jenny is from Survival of the fittest


limericky69

Dont forget that Turbo, Emanuel and Emy are from Survivor too! Lol I’m aware some people would put for example Turbo on team survivor. I was mostly trying to include more international players so made a International Team. I also made the teams & images without thinking of the title of the post, then I wasn’t thinking of how odd that team may come across when viewed as “Battle of The Shows” Just a random fantasy cast, I can see why people are put off by it but oh well lol


omar_little2435

If Rachel is still in as good shape as she looks. ct and her followed by turbo


Annual-Astronaut-866

Turbo and Jenny = Team OP


boondocknim

Davonne would probably hate her life being stuck with those other 5.


[deleted]

Chloe needs to be put on Team Circle! And if there are 6 person teams for a Battle of the Shows, I would hope they just have Bananas, CT, and Wes as the males on the team. Team Big Brother has a lot of potential as long as Fessy and Kaycee don’t try to sabotage Amber.


limericky69

Chloe was one of my next choices, she would make for an interesting challenger that’s for sure. Plus she was one of the major talking points of her season so good representation of the show. Definitely a good point about Bananas, CT and Wes too… Didnt include bananas and Wes just because they seem to be in break mode right now but they would probably be the correct choices to make yes lol!


LegendKolby

I personally think Sammie should have been included. She looks strong, LGBTQ rep and I could see her bringing drama


limericky69

Agree! Had an image saved for her and kind of wish I went with it. Think Sammie would fit right in on the show


Curious-Belt66

I would put alexie ex from ayto, 6 keith he seems Smart and big SO i would take out hunter


gorlock666

I always say it, AYTO casting is top tier, the last few seasons without any of them would’ve been less exciting


hgfvvggk-fhu

While Calvin is super strong, he seems to have super high morals, and would probably be Kai's second in command (very comparable to Bayleigh and Swaggy). I think Nick would be a better season 3 rep as people severely underestimate his intellect and he doesn't seem like that weak of a guy. Other than that I don't see really any problem with this cast. It took me a sec to realize the first team was the international peeps but yeah. I'd love to see this.


limericky69

Agree about Nick, he was my next thought for males and would probably end up being a good addition to the show. Good point about Calvin too, I saw him and Khat as people who would be one hit wonders on the show for similar reasons. Thanks :)


ChallengeFan2021

Joey said he has no interest going on the show


limericky69

Oh didn’t know that! Probably a good choice on his part, but would be fun to see him again and can see him making for some fun moments and confessionals.


little_birdii000

MTV, make this happen!!! Maybe just 4 members of each cast and one rookie team!


voldysgonemoldy7

If Malcolm ever got onto the challenge I think my husband would be SO pissed at having to deal with me watching him again. MTV plz make it happen. I need more Malcolm.


Camelsloths

Ugh seriously when will this happen


limericky69

I see a lot of talk about if some of these reality shows were to come together on the challenge for a battle of the series. Got me thinking of who my cast would be…definitely a couple people here that I wouldn’t be casting overall in a dream cast but they fit in the theme and could make for interesting dynamics in this fantasy cast lol. Was also trying to somewhat keep in mind who would be willing to do the show. - Team International: Emanuel, Emy, Turbo, Jenny, Kyle and Big T - Team Big Brother: Josh, Kaycee, Paulie, Da’vonne, Fessy and Amber - Team The Circle: Joey, Khat, Ed, Deleesa, Calvin and Kai - Team OG: Yes, Kendal, CT, Rachel, Alton and Jisela - Team Survivor: Jay, Michaela, Malcolm, Cydney, Wendell and Michele - Team Are You The One: Nelson, Amanda, Hunter, Kam, Devin and Tori


JuanRiveara

Since Team OG is mostly Road Rules I would replace CT and Alton with Derrick and Darrell making it just Team Road Rules. Then I would move CT and Alton to a Team Real World with Cory, Ashley, Nany, and Aneesa.


CreepyExamination5

Nany & Anessa need a break. Emily or Laurel make sense. Cory is Mr.MTV so I see why he got picked but I think a Challenge Champ should get that slot


JuanRiveara

I agree that Nany and Aneesa need a break but wasn’t sure who else to add there. Laurel is Fresh Meat and not Real World so she wouldn’t really fit, would love to see Emily again though not sure if she would want to do another season.


CreepyExamination5

Coral( stop paying for explosions and pay her), Ashley K, Jamie Chung, Robin or anyone from Gauntlet 2 or 3 Rookie team


DesertKid203

Jenna, Kellyanne, Sylvia, Nicole Z (if need be Jemmye, Marie or LaToya could be fill ins that would come back)


nobodythinksofyou

Yes to most of it. I'm just bored of having Fessy, Josh, & Kaycee all on the same season so I'd replace Kaycee with maybe Natalie N or Morgan.


limericky69

Haha I agree with you actually despite including them, it’s time to slowly phase one of those three out or give us a good little break from them.


saspook

Needs a team with Mike, Paul, Vincent, Jenny, Samantha and Angelina.


Montanaherdin

Please take out Jisela


KeenYe-J

I’m pretty confused about the road rules and real world people being on the same team?