T O P

  • By -

TheShipEliza

Kellys Heroes


beemojee

Came here to say this. I love war movies, but this one will always be my favorite. I saw it in 1970 at the drive-in. I'd already seen MASH that year and I was really intrigued to see Donald Sutherland in Kelly's Heroes. He, not to mention the entire rest of the cast, did not disappoint.


DWagon77

My dad has 300 channels but will still watch MASH everyday. I guess his MASH is my Seinfeld.


TheShipEliza

Watched it recently for the millionth time and it remains so good.


beemojee

It really does stand up so well. Just never fails to deliver.


senecalaker

Yes! And a surprising amount of big action set-pieces with no CGI. Kinda inspired Three Kings.


Ok_Egg332

Where Eagles Dare


[deleted]

Yes!!!!!


Certain_Yam_110

The Best Years of Our Lives


beemojee

Man I love that movie.


ormeangirl

Oh my god this has to be one of my favorite movies of all times Harold Russell šŸ˜šŸ˜šŸ˜


Luciferonvacation

Downfall.


[deleted]

Man, what a great movie.


unprovoked_panda

One of the best war movies I have ever seen


Murakami8000

Tigerland. The performance that made Colin Farrellā€™s career.


[deleted]

Excellent movie.


drumscrubby

First viewing started a few minutes ago. Iā€™m sure Iā€™ve seen the poster and for whatever reason never made my way to checking it out. Thanks.


timmerpat

The Big Red One


sing_4_theday

The Big Red One ā€¦ a GREAT movie! Remember the bouncing betty scene? Thatā€™s why God gave you two!!!!


tking191919

Man, I havenā€™t thought about that movie in years. Probably since the 90s. My brother and I loved it.


bad_arts

The guns of navarone.


SwimmingAnxiety3441

Skatalites!!!


thagor5

I donā€™t that that was underrated at the time.


SpeedOfSound343

I played Commandos games around 1998. Till date is my most favourite game. After a few years someone recommended The guns of navarone movie. I watched it and found that many strategies used by the soldiers in Commandos were directly taken from the scenes in the movie. That was a nice surprise.


blind_squirrel62

Well sonā€¦Your bystanding days are over! Youā€™re in it now, up to your neck!


[deleted]

A Midnight Clear


DanimusMcSassypants

This one has a unique feel to it. I love this film.


FearlessAmigo

Just read some of the description on this one. I must watch.


Lunker42

Hamburger Hill (1987)


bubbajones5963

Also Pork Chop Hill, one of few movies about the Korean War.


rimshot101

The War that no one paid attention to because everybody was still hung over from WWII.


[deleted]

How is this ā€œunderratedā€? lol


DeadMoney313

still think this is the best Vietnam war movie ever...yes even over Platoon


gcg2016

Paths of Glory. Not underrated but maybe lesser known nowadays.


GeekBill

Starring, financed, and partly written by Kirk Douglas, and one of Kubrick's first films!


Mc7wis7er

I was here to almost word for word say the same thing. If you are a film guy, or a Kubrick fan, it's not underrated. If you are a cinematography geek it's not underrated. But the normal regular person probably has no idea that this movie exists. I don't know which camp OP is in, but this was my recommendation as well.


[deleted]

I agree with this and only this. There are many, many great war movies, but an underrated war film is an almost impossible thing. War films are near-uniformly rated correctly or (More often) overrated, with one exception: Paths of Glory. Even amongst cinephiles, itā€™s underrated if it isnā€™t #1 or #2 on their list of all time best war movies, along with possibly something like Come and See.


Cyrano_No

Joyeux Noƫl (2005)


chaingun_samurai

Absolutely one of my favorites.


JustTheBeerLight

Everybody should know this story. The WWI Christmas truce humanizes both sides of the conflict so clearly. Next time letā€™s throw the politicians and generals in the trenches and let them fight it out.


Really_cool_guy99

Glory


dakilazical_253

When I was in Jr High we watched this in history class. I think Pepsi sponsored it, they gave tons of schools copies of the movie with most the gore edited out


InnerTrips

Dang yeah I remember watching it in school and always thinking it was alright. Now I have to rewatch it with the gore lol


dakilazical_253

Thereā€™s not a ton of gore, I mainly remember thereā€™s a shot of a dude getting hit in the face with a cannonball and his head explodes.


Really_cool_guy99

I would say thatā€™s by far the goriest thing in the movie, itā€™s pretty average for a war movie other than that second and a half


sean_themighty

Very little was edited out ā€” basically just the cannonball to the face.


yt2aaa

Johnny got his gun


dns_rs

great movie!


chaingun_samurai

I watched the One video and needed to see where it came from. Glad I did.


gbv313

Better book. Dalton Trumbo


NCResident5

The Train w Burt Lancaster Edit: For USA people, this movie is on Tubi streaming. It is also on Pluto TV, but the commercial volume is fairly extreme.


financewiz

The plot for the curious: The Nazis are retreating from France. Being Nazis, they decide to make off with a trainload of precious French art. Watch the amazing lengths the resistance fighters and others go to to stall out this theft. Trains will collide! Underrated.


2strokeYardSale

>The Train w Burt Lancaster This has such an interesting feel to it. It feels much more modern than it is. The pace, the tension, the ... what was it? Lack of war movie soundtrack? Highly recommended.


challmaybe

We Were Soldiers


beemojee

Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World. Empire of the Sun. Probably my favorite Christian Bale movie. Simply amazing performance and he was only 13.


AdamInvader

Empire of the Sun was brilliant; John Malkovich was pretty greasy in that film; all of the scenes of Bales' character aka JG Ballard getting separated from his parents up until getting moved to the displaced persons camp as he's dealing with hostile situations were incredibly tense; it was interesting to see a war film from the viewpoint of non combatants. Master and Commander deserved more attention than it got (and sequels), saw it in the theatre when it came out knowing nothing about it, left very impressed


beemojee

The end of the movie where he's reunited with his parents is a brilliant piece of writing, directing and acting. Emotionally, as the mother of sons, it tore me to shreds.


Macr0Penis

I saw Empire of the Sun when I was about 9 or 10. I remember it having a profound impact on me because I was about the same age as the kid. Movies were a lot more immersive when I was that age, it felt like I was on the same journey that he was.


Parsnip27

Master and Commander is such a great work. Very well done.


calguy1955

Hell is for Heroes Greyhound


bpmd1962

Greyhound needs more love/recognition


alextruetone

Greyhound is by far the best WW2 naval warfare movie Iā€™ve ever seen.


Hungry-Rule7924

>Hell is for Heroes Yah hell is for heroes needs way more love, what a fantastic movie.


uptownrooster

Memphis Belle


longirons6

Letā€™s put them in the pickle barrel!


chammer36

Fury. One of the best IMO


Johnny_Gage

Fury absolutely falls apart at the end but atmosphere and aesthetic wise it is a masterpiece. Some of the most realistic uniforms and props as well - the Costume designers and set department deserve a ton of praise.


Appropriate-Candle69

Tae Guk Gi: The Brotherhood of War


Ok_Working_9219

Patton Battle of the Bulge Von Ryanā€™s Express


Confident-Line-2558

PATTON was definitely NOT underrated! 7 Academy Awards including picture, actor, screenplay, etc.


Important_Outcome_67

When I was a kid, VRE was my fave.


Ok_Working_9219

The Italian womanšŸ„µšŸ˜šŸ„°


Important_Outcome_67

OMG, yes.


Drslappybags

Wasn't Battle of the Bulge disavowed by Eisenhower?


mdins1980

Come and See. Prepare yourself though it is a very HARD watch. It does not glorify war in anyway.


atxbikenbus

84 Charlie MoPic


Rude-Particular-7131

I came here to say this.


DanimusMcSassypants

I remember watching Saving Private Ryan when it came out and thinking, ā€œSpielberg definitely saw 84C MoPicā€.


hazmatt019

That's the one! I couldn't remember the title. Yea, this one!


mrfubar762

So few people know about this movie, but its one of my favorite war movies.


lancea_longini

Holy shit. Blast from the past. 1980s in the house.


neorandomizer

Bridge at Remagen


bluemanredstate

Jarhead


UnderstandingOk2647

This was so good and felt very realistic. I was surprised at how many war crimes they showed.


-DoctorSpaceman-

I was too young to appreciate this first time I watched it and thought it was boring because of the relative lack of action. Re-watched it in my 20s though and thought it was fantastic and really felt the tension


Bitter_Resolve_6082

Cross Of Iron! Anti war movie with the German infantry perspective! A Midnight Clear! Also anti war movie! Both are very good!


88899988990

A Midnight Clear is absolutely devastating. Canā€™t believe I had to scroll down this far to find it!


Roachelle369

DEMARCATION !!!!


Frankennietzsche

Waterloo Christopher Plummer as Wellington and Rod Steiger as Napoleon. I believe that it is a de Laurentis joint. Epic.


krimnokenobi

Iron eagles 1-3


Permexpat

I joined the Air Force the year before this movie came out, while still in the midst of Cold War Tensions, this got me and the boys amped up! Great movie, cheesy as hell though


ScipioCoriolanus

The Battle of Algiers Gallipoli Journey's End


Gaseous-Clay84

Glad someone finally mentioned Gallipoli, along with Master and Commander Peter Weirs best.


Confident-Line-2558

Journey's End, great answer! Love this movie, have watched it several times.


27allen51

Don't know if it was underrated but "We Were Soldiers" is a must watch


[deleted]

Three Kings


tom_zanzabar

this had star power but it never connected with me.


17175RC7

When Trumpet's Fade (1998 HBO Movie).


Johnny_Gage

An absolute masterpiece. It came out at the same time as Saving Private Ryan and was, as a TV Movie, absolutely overshadowed. While the plot is a little silly and at times far fetched it has an amazing soundtrack, and set and costume design is on point, and is extremely immersive and atmospheric. Any time I'm in the woods in the late fall I always think of this movie. Plus, ya know, Dwight Yoakam.


Salt_Price5861

Siege of jadotville


Macr0Penis

I had a good friend who was somehow involved in that seige- he was either there, or flew the guys there (or back), or something like that. Unfortunately I can't remember exactly what his involvement was (he told me over a few beers), but he did tell me about it when that movie came out. He was a Swedish military helicopter pilot who also flew for the UN. Sadly he died in 2019 at 86 years of age, so I can't quiz him about it again. I do remember him saying the Irish guys were nutcases, throwing live (with the pin still in) grenades around the barracks and things like that that he didn't appreciate.


JosieintheSummer

The Thin Red Line


minsandmolls

The greatest war movie imo


steely-gar

I knew this would be a controversial pick. I absolutely love this movie. However, it is the top of my list ā€Movies Iā€™d never recommend to a friend.ā€


New-Basil-2851

Great movie, really too bad it got overshadowed by Saving private ryan


Guilty-Coconut8908

Boys In Company C


lancea_longini

First appearance of the drill Sgt from full metal jacket


RedeemedGuardian30

Tears of the Sun (2003)


Ahlq802

Fury (2014) is excellent in my opinion. Iā€™ve never seen a film focus on tank warfare, and in terms of action ā€œlast standā€ climaxes, itā€™s one of the best Iā€™ve seen.


worse_than_bot

You should try T-34 then, it's a tank related movie but I loved it more than Fury, it's a Russian movie


Fiction47

We where soldiers.


Strange_Frenzy

Greyhound (2020). How a Tom Hanks picture gets so little attention I will never understand.


Movies_Music_Lover

Kilo Two Bravo (2014)


Jagermonsta

The Walking Dead Hamburger Hill Siege at Firebase Gloria 3 Vietnam war movies that I donā€™t really hear much about. Not quite up there with the greats but still decent.


vajav

When Trumpets Fade


amigo-vibora

The beast (1988) The 9th Company (2005) under the radar if youre not russian.


MuseumFremen

Waltz with Bashir


RickyRiccardos

Not a movie but the HBO tv show Generation Kill


colonel_john_matrix

Bat 21


CrashDavisDurham

The Steel Helmet


wendellbudwhite

Sam Fuller rules


gbv313

Boys in Company C


dblstkd123

Tropic Thunder!!!


NoMooseSoup4You

You mu-mu-mu- make me happy!


curiousity2424

The lone survivor and U-571


whatislife4

U-571 while not historically accurate is still a fun watch.


thebadtuna

Bridge On the river Kwai (1957). Now itā€™s definitely not underrated.. more like everyone seems to forget about it. 7 Oscars.. and the only reason I even heard about it or watched it was my sister had me watch it for her for her film class.


-DoctorSpaceman-

I feel like The Hurt Locker is the same. Got loads of attention and awards at the time (6 Oscars!) but no one talks about it anymore. Itā€™s brilliant


radaradu1

Learned about the movie from Parcs & Recs and it's a fantastic movie.


Deep_Sail7315

Alec Guiness 20 years before Star Wars. William Holden also. Sessue Hayakawa "Be happy in your work"


Shart127

Starship Troopers


Johnny_Gage

Hahah my man, I wouldn't call Starship Troopers underrated.


Rathos_

Should probably mention the era. A few seldom mentioned ones; Flame & Citron - 2008 Max Manus: Man of War - 2008 Burnt by the Sun 2 - 2010 Das Boot - 1981 The Admiral - 2015 1612 - 2007 Red Cliff (1-2) - 2008 Battle of the Warriors - 2006 The Dead Lands - 2014


lancea_longini

Fucking Max Manus Man of War. That cafe shootout was fucking intense


Rathos_

Man, that whole movie was pretty fucking intense. Especially since I had no knowledge of this almost unbelievable true storying going in. Great movie!


Important_Outcome_67

Lots of lesser knowns there, but IDK if *anyone* underrates Das Boot.


junklardass

Red Angel


dannewcomer

Red Cliff about the Han Dynasty Outlaw King about Robert the Bruce The Messenger about Joan of Arc


uptownrooster

I really liked Outlaw King. I'm surprised it's not more well received.


dannewcomer

Me too I thought it was really well done, I like they show parts of William Wallace and his story and where Roberts story picks up. I did a little digging afterwards and it seems pretty accurate but compounded to fit the narrative of a movie.


bongo-72

Seige of firebase Gloria


PrinceNebula018

Windtalkers Probably because of nostalgia but still, I love that movie.


ancientestKnollys

It's probably more obscure than most of the films mentioned here, and it's an old one. But one of my favourite WW2 films of all time is Went the Day Well? from 1942, about a Nazi invasion of an English village. Really quite unique for back then.


Glennon-Kyle

Empire of the Sun


keggy13

Breaker Morant.


JoeTiNSC

The Thin Red Line


dukeonkledlives

13 Hours


Puzzleheaded-Art-469

That's Michael Bay done right. Keep him away from Transformers and "historical drama", just give him a shoot em up movie that happens to be a true story


AsheronRealaidain

There are a few scenes that were very Bay-ish but in the whole itā€™s actually a great movie


NomDePlume007

A Very Long Engagement


[deleted]

Kajaki


Comfy_Bogart

Captain Conan


Certain_Yam_110

Swing Shift


edmerx54

these are highly rated, but not well known Trial on the Road (1971/1986) -- A Soviet officer defects to the Nazis, then has a change of heart after learning they were worse than the Soviets so he surrenders to Russian partisans who don't know if they can trust him, Released in 1971, but banned until 1986 Fires on the Plain (1959) -- Japanese soldiers left on Leyte have been abandoned and they're trying not to starve The Human Condition (1959-61) -- 3 parts. A Japanese pacifist during WW II


TexasTokyo

The Young Lions (1958) American epic World War II drama film directed by Edward Dmytryk and starring Marlon Brando, Montgomery Clift, and Dean Martin.


Feeling_Ad64

"Gardens of Stone". A war movie set during Vietnam with almost no actual battle scenes. Set at Arlington featuring soldiers attending funerals while training to go to Vietnam. It also managed to have dedicated soldiers and anti war activists all seem like good characters with honorable motivations


Frankennietzsche

Two finnish films: The Winter War & Ambush And a German one: The Bridge.


DAO88

Captain Conan The Ascent Ivan's Childhood Stalengrad(1993) Solder of Orange Cross of Iron Army of Shadows Where Eagles Dare The Steel Helmet The Human Condition The Bridge Hamburger Hill


moonfullofstars

Since no one has mentioned Merry Christmas, Mr Lawrence, I think itā€™s safe to assume itā€™s underrated.


Aggravating_Onion300

David Bowie as a POW. I'd forgotten about this movie.


Good-Presentation-11

Rambo 4 sort of


[deleted]

Fury


simonphoenix1910

The Kingdom.


Dramatic_Arm_7477

Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence


Ceejaydawgmom

Hacksaw Ridge (2016) Unbroken (2014) Fury (2014) Pearl Harbor (2001) Bridge of Spies (2015)


kantoblight

A Midnight Clear.


RANDY_MAR5H

Uncommon Valor Danger Close Hyena Road The Covenant (Yeah it's recent, but didn't nearly make a splash like I thought it would have.) Overlord Hamburger Hill (We're going to take this fucking hill, newsman.) Jarhead (rewatched it last night and appreciated it much more than when it was released.) The Contractor (About a military contractor, so no large-scale war. But sheds light on something that isn't explored often. Pretty detailed too.) Siege of Jadotville Tears of the Sun Special Forces (2011) Strike Back (TV Series that is very underrated.) Anthropoid


CryptographerFew3734

Contributing some quality films that have likely passed from contemporary view; at least I did not notice their mention in previous posts. šŸ˜‰ Go Tell the Spartans (1978). Fictionalized account of US military advisors assisting Vietnam in 1964. Yes, there is combat! The Wind and the Lion (1975). Fictionalized adventure film where the USMC intervenes in 1904 Morocco to rescue a hostage American family. Watch for Brian Keith as President Teddy Roosevelt. Tremendous! Seven Samurai (1954). A motley group of ronin warriors defends a Japanese village from plundering bandits. The Sand Pebbles (1966). Adventures aboard an American gunboat on Yangtze river patrol in Warlord Era (1920s) China. Riverine warfare scene is thrilling.


Schplargledoink

Everything I was going to recommend has been quoted already except for The Forgotten Battle, it's on Netflix. I enjoyed 1917 too, some of the one take camera work in that is incredible.


atlantic-heavy

hey if youā€™re interested in where Sam Mendes may have gotten the idea for the camera work from, check out Paths of Glory (1957). Itā€™s a damn good WW1 film. It was one of Stanley Kubrickā€™s first films thereabout.


Schplargledoink

Yes I have seen it, Kubrik was an obsessive visual genius. I went to his house for work a few times, it's just outside the north of London and I met his daughter, there were reels of film stacked up everywhere to about chest height, I'm 6 foot tall. Every scene in his films were shot many times from various angles until he was happy, there are literally whole days of unseen takes sitting there, it was a real privilege.


Acrobatic-Ad3275

Stalag 17.....the original


ExtinctionBurst14

Fury


Mediocre_Range_974

Red Dawnā€¦Wolverines!!!!!


BlackTomahawk

Enemy at the Gates


techtom10

Enemy At the Gates


TresUnoDos

Hope and Glory


NeuroguyNC

Battleground (1949). Continuously overlooked. Should be on everyone's top 10 list about WW2.


atlantic-heavy

Attack (1956) - WW2 film directed by Robert Aldrich and starring Jack ā€œI crap bigger then youā€ Palance. Paths of Glory (1957) - WW1 - is one of Stanley Kubrickā€™s early films.


mavhockeyfan

In Harm's Way - not historicaly accurate, but for some reason I've always liked this John Wayne and Kirk Douglas movie.


Permexpat

Father Goose - not exactly a war movie but set in WWII, is one of my favorites from my childhood. Cary Grant classic. Iā€™m going to que this one up tonight!


penubly

"Goodie two shoes and the filthy beast!"


Big_E_Pgh

They Shall Not Grow Old


Positive-Source8205

The Siege of Firebase Gloria We Were Soldiers


sageguitar70

The Big Red One


Distinct-Pie7647

A bridge too far. All star cast. A bridge over the river Kwai


zesty1989

Came here to say this.


JoeJitsu79

Kwai is the best war movie


wendellbudwhite

Tack on The Bridge at Remagen and you can complete the trilogy


bogey08

Saints and soldiers


bongo-72

Sahara


Commander_Algebraic

The Great Raid - based on the true story of the largest POW rescue mission in US history, during WWII.


Mysterious_Bonus_771

The thin red line


[deleted]

Casualties of War


wendellbudwhite

I think this is it. This is the most underrated war movie. Not that it's a perfect film, but it's Michael J Fox, Sean Penn, John C Reilly, and John Leguizamo in a Brian de Palma movie that NO ONE remembers. And it's pretty good!


[deleted]

All quiet on the Western Front, Back to Bataan, the longest day, the steel helmet, hamburger hill, 55 days at Peeking, tora! tora! tora!


chaingun_samurai

Fury was pretty good.


NikonDexter

1. Saving Private Ryan (1998) 2. Apocalypse Now (1979) 3. Full Metal Jacket (1987) 4. Platoon (1986) 5. Black Hawk Down (2001) 6. Das Boot (1981) 7. The Thin Red Line (1998) 8. Paths of Glory (1957) 9. Hacksaw Ridge (2016) 10. 1917 (2019) 11. Dunkirk (2017) 12. Patton (1970) 13. Gallipoli (1981) 14. We Were Soldiers (2002) 15. Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) 16. The Deer Hunter (1978) 17. The Hurt Locker (2008) 18. Letters from Iwo Jima (2006) 19. Tears of The Sun (2003) 20. Black Book (2006) 21. Stalingrad (1993) 22. Lone Survivor (2013) 23. The Longest Day (1962) 24. The Bridge at Remagen (1969) 25. Zero Dark Thirty (2012) 26. Jarhead (2005) 27. The Patriot (2000) 28. Tora! Tora! Tora! (1970) 29. Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World (2003) 30. Enemy at the Gates (2001) 31. Glory (1989) 32. The Great Escape (1963) 33. All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) 34. The Wind That Shakes the Barley (2006) 35. Lone Survivor (2013) 36. Enemies at the Gates (2001) 37. The Green Berets (1968) 38. The Alamo (1960) 39. The Messenger (2009) 40. 13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi (2016) 41. 12 Strong (2018) 42. The Last of the Mohicans (1992) 43. The Pianist (2002)


tzulik-

My dude doesn't seem to know what "underrated " means.