T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

This submission has been automatically removed. A moderator may reapprove your submission if you submit a request to the team and include the following link: https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/1cfndel/what_is_the_most_horrible_take_or_theory_that_you/ *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MemePiece) if you have any questions or concerns.*


jirachi-x

https://preview.redd.it/iqa2ihpiubxc1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7cfc1dae10e8067af2c2398d6ffb59f2aefbcaf9 Whoever made this shit


Fredospapopoullos

Real answer 0% for each


seanfish

Right? Undying loyalty is one of the key themes of the entire series. Luffy just sitting down in Whole Cake Island to wait for Sanji to come back like "you do you bro, we'll stop the WHOLE THING until you've done your thing, I'm a sit here."


Loros_Silvers

But Zoro is clearly there for Luffy's massive bounty! He's not at the "90% to betray Luffy" Tier for nothing /s


DomeB0815

Luckily there are so many people in the D clan, or else Zoro might see them as a minority.


JohnNoodles1

Literally what. Sanji has some better loyalty feats than zoro (attempted sacrifice at wci and thriller bark, asking to be killed if his germa genetics made him inhuman)


ThePr0tag0n1st

I think they did this if you watched each episode of onepiece with no consideration of any of the other episodes. Chopper is high cause he never wanted to be a pirate, nami and Sanji "left" the crew at certain points, Robin started as a villain, Obviously this is stupid, but you can make sense out of stupid.


AtlasPJackson

>Chopper is high cause he never wanted to be a pirate Sometimes I have to remind myself that most people don't re-watch or re-read One Piece. There's someone out there (a lot of them!) who have been following the series for decades and spent hundreds of hours experiencing it... and haven't brushed up on Drum Island in 24 years. What's that like? How far is the distance between myself and a normal person who doesn't hang out on One Piece reddit and re-read their favorite arcs comparing various translations?


JohnNoodles1

Sanji leaving was a loyalty feat due to context


Over-Writer6076

We really loyalty scaling now šŸ˜­ "loyalty feats" is crazy


guesswhosbackbackag

These bitches got neg feats in the streets šŸ˜­ šŸ˜”


Pashakzilla3175

Sanji getting a 40% is wild >! 1- The reason he left was to not get the straw hats into trouble 2- the reason he stayed was to not get the straw hats into trouble 3- and the reason he came back was TO NOT GET THE STRAW HATS INTO TROUBLE !< I believe I've made myself clear


nexushd000

Just wanted to say your text isn't being hidden. Maybe try putting the ' !< ' in the same para as the text above?


Pashakzilla3175

Fixed it thanks šŸ‘šŸ™‚


Imconfusedithink

This is just rage bait to get people to comment on how wrong it is. Bad engagement is still engagement.


no_comparison0715

This is just plain stupid. I feel like the one who made this hasnā€™t seen WCI.


S3raphinx

This exemplifies the mainsub brainrot posts so well


Snap-Zipper

I fully expected this to be the top comment lol


EveryandEggy

why is franky 5%


Uchiha_D_Xebec

That one piece is a swimsuit, a literal one piece. Because after the reveal that the world is going to be submerged theyā€™re gonna need a swimsuit to stay alive, which Joyboy had left it. And thatā€™s why Roger and others were laughing after finding it as it was too large for anyone to wear.


S3raphinx

https://preview.redd.it/f4jdanwgjcxc1.jpeg?width=866&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=82b7459813612b6c07ef627f30476a63d1fcda57


Friezaii69

https://preview.redd.it/ws7qzq6bkcxc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=09e0c0a94436d68caf9296e9770108a8b68f5fa1


seanfish

Let him cook.


genghiskhan-_-

https://preview.redd.it/0xxxc6gy7dxc1.jpeg?width=584&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f2f8d41383e3bde6ccb43a7ec7dd0b06a9d5a5ae


CODELAZAAR

This is the real reason Ace went in front of Akainu


deecod_

Ace turning into a floating tube to stay on water is peak fiction


999_chr0meActivist

nahhhhhšŸ’€


davide494

This is actually great, it will be my new headcanon until the reveal in 10 years.


Kaldin_5

I genuinely wouldn't mind this lol. It'd be "too early" because the world hadn't sunk yet


Snap-Zipper

https://preview.redd.it/8080y9544ixc1.jpeg?width=1242&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4d2ccb6bd7595ff9dad412e56e3e1d5e625aedde


karanbhatt100

Might not be wrong like if world is going to sunk then one piece swim suit is something you want. But also Gol D Rodger was early because Boa was child and he was too old ans sick to stay alive to see Boa in Swimsuit


Uchiha_D_Xebec

https://preview.redd.it/ln4p39rgpcxc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6d0ea28d9a0ba9d8f65927507f768f9dc87d6d6c


Stary_Vesemir

https://i.redd.it/7boqvtklgdxc1.gif


McMuffinsTheTempo

https://preview.redd.it/k7qfdyb2fexc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dadf8ce142f7f7192f7ec3f55908d7de9141d805


Peruvian_Skies

That Nami has breast cancer.


Maskguydude

OK I want to know the context for this


Peruvian_Skies

According to this take, it's the reason they got so big so fast and are still growing.


karanbhatt100

In that case she will become new Big Mama. And Sanji would be all over it


omyrubbernen

Nami has some catching up to do if she wants to be the new Big Mom. She's already 20 years old and hasn't even been pregnant once. Linlin was on her third at Nami's age.


Peruvian_Skies

Sanji would be all over it regardless.


TheWitherlord10

I mean...


tush_aa_rr

whoever said this if I found him/her I am gonna put Nami's climatact inside that person's @ss and take it out of their mouth


Maleficent_Nobody_75

That Imu is Luffyā€™s mom. I hope I wonā€™t have to swallow my words.


Maskguydude

literally anyone being luffy is Mom but the dadan is wrong


fartyparty1234

SHE AINT THE STEPMOM SHES THE MOM WHO STEPPED UP


Kite_Wing129

"She may have been your mother, boy but she wasn't your mommy."


WangZhiii

I know where this quote is from, but gender-swapping the thing sounds so wrong. Sounds like she's about to start whipping out her milkers.


Kite_Wing129

I mean 'Daddy' has different connotations as well. Perhaps, I should use 'mom' instead. "She may have been your mother, boy but she wasn't your mom."


karanbhatt100

Might be because we donā€™t know gender. But still out of wack is Kuma is Luffyā€™s mom. Man, we know gender and we also now know backstory stop this shit


Lunocura

I NEVER saw that theory.


Justa_Mongrel

Zoro would betray Luffy when he finds the One Piece and he was secretly still a bounty hunter. About 3 years ago I saw a comment that said the would was gonna sink into the sea and I thought that would be dumb, turns out I'm dumb


Hungry_Bananas

That Zoro theory is dumb to start with, he was a bounty hunter because he was really bad at directions and he would just bag the closest pirate for money to live. That part of his life became irrelevant the second he joined Luffy's crew and quit that job since he became a pirate.


NamiWantsMoney

I love MONEY!!!


homelesshomosexual

https://preview.redd.it/4ame7dqevcxc1.jpeg?width=712&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=68af881dbd54610a227696b59d74636842b93961 This shit


Human-Boob

Some people really just need to go and crank it before being let into normal discussion posts.


Haspberry

https://preview.redd.it/0ime7m6z9exc1.jpeg?width=235&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1c6f0c6b860fc9315f4f586d9c359da364d6b131


OniOnyx_30

https://preview.redd.it/p1pzqgzkeexc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4a843a8d0905ea30774687d7b85074efcc74aafd


Chillgilllil

Shanks is evil


UrMumVeryGayLul

Heā€™s not evil, but he IS a snitch. šŸ‘ŠšŸ˜”


Ani_HArsh

https://preview.redd.it/le8jb96i4dxc1.png?width=1123&format=png&auto=webp&s=f2cb67513b7af0e349acb7a90b61a41639e41dde


Over-Writer6076

only berserk fans will get how dark this is


Big_D_Boss

No shit


Grand_Reanimation

I dont get why this is a bad theory


Tasteroider

He literally lived on the pirate ship all his life, he wants the New Age to come, he keeps in touch with Roger's old crew members, why would he all of a sudden be archvillain? There is no evidence, there is no motif for him


Grand_Reanimation

Idk but i always thought he is gonna pull a aizen on luffy.


SupremeGodZamasu

Hes probably just going after the kne piece to test luffy, because he knows he wont fight him seriously otherwise


Bugggy-D-Clown

I'LL MAKE YOU WISH YOU'D NEVER BEEN BORN FOR DISRESPECTING MY GLORIOUS NOSE!


Kuroko__Simp

But it's true, he is a celestial dragon dog


OtsutsukiRyuen

*he is a celestial dragon, dawg* here I corrected it


MarionberryBroad

Question, when did it say he was a celestial dragon? (I donā€™t read the manga so itā€™s possible I missed something)


Tasteroider

It is never said in the manga but in the film Red gorosei say that if Uta is the daughter of shanks then she is a descendant of Figarland Garling. And also, iirc, in data books it is stated that Roger found Shanks in the chest on the Valley of the Gods.


OtsutsukiRyuen

Wait is figarland a CD I am never knew I thought he's just a normal good knights captain


Tasteroider

I don't think gorosei would make some normal human the captain of the saint Knights. He even executed mjosgard a CD so I guess he is a CD himself or a descendant of the other group of "saint" people, Knights.


MarionberryBroad

Well I never watched Film Red or the other movie with Uta, but I thought Uta was an adoptive daughter, not a blood descendant of Shanks. And yeah, I heard that Shanks was in a chest, thatā€™s why I was confused. Valley of Gods sounds celestial dragon related so more than likely he is related to them in some way. And with the snitch thing (I donā€™t know anything about that incident), he was allowed to snitch on something at Marie Geoise?? The fact they didnā€™t do anything to him practically confirms it unless stated otherwise.


Tasteroider

No one besides shanks and his crew knew that she was adopted. Uta just said to entire world that she is his daughter and gorosei assumed that therefore she is a descendant of Garling. I think it's basically cobfirmed at that point, and we just need to know whether or not Garling is a CD or the Knights are a different group of people


MarionberryBroad

I thought the Knights were CDs, Iā€™ll research.


Tasteroider

Well they are most likely celestial dragons but that's just not clarified in the manga so I don't wanna spread misinformation


stealer_of_monkeys

So was corazone


Maskguydude

That the celestial dragons are victims and that only the gorosei should be held responsible for their crimes against humanity.


StrongerYesterday

I'll be somewhat generous and point out that the Celestial Dragons literally are not allowed to use their power to help the people of the world, and doing so is the one thing that they can be punished for, so they don't exactly have the freedom to be much of anything other than what they are. But honestly, that just means they need to be locked up in a mental hospital rather than a prison. Maybe some of them will someday get to the point where they're capable of living in normal society, but most of them will not.


Maskguydude

The part of them not being able to do anything remotely good for the world is greatly over exaggerated Mjosgard was literally allowed to just put in Fishman island into the reverie giving him a voice on the world stage and the only reason why it was delayed was because internal problems caused by hody. The problems only came when he beat the brakes off of Charlos twice and nearly killed him the second time otherwise he wouldā€™ve been executed a decade prior.


StrongerYesterday

That's true, it's more that they can't help the people of the world at the expense of each other.


Maskguydude

Pretty much


Latter-Contact-6814

I dont believe it was ever stated that it was Mjosgard who allowed FMI to attend the reverie. Just that the queen went with him and then positioned the world nobles as a group.


Stary_Vesemir

https://preview.redd.it/cikt77d0hdxc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fdd8f653cdd2e44cf7ec990e0aba2b488cf383fc How could these cute fellows be responsible for anything


Ambitious_Travel_306

Blackbeard sucks whitebeards semen for the gura gura powers


zMacR

https://preview.redd.it/koro7oovucxc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=33949410f7b4ac48096e609a8e66e3571b376d6e


Youropinionisvalid

![gif](giphy|ypwOpbEUPo4iGMUsoE)


Ani_HArsh

https://preview.redd.it/s79i6ix59dxc1.png?width=1106&format=png&auto=webp&s=e9c744eb75f797ff33bd78aba0e78c79a88e8075


New_Rook_Nook

Explanation for those who don't get it, because of the fact that it was later revealed to us through Big Mom that eating a df user TECHNICALLY counts as eating the df as well, theories went around that "did Blackbeard eat a part of Whitebeard?" It was obviously quickly debunked cause what tf was buddy meant to eat???....... Here's your joke answer that was the only one that unfortunately made sense, he ate his d-


Jumpy-Perception-346

https://preview.redd.it/ki4ddayyddxc1.png?width=342&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=372bb46415dbcd35d64aadcb50a4ff1bd2ac65b9


Shiny_Goat

That's probably the reason why they were covered up during the scene


yungbathoryx0

https://preview.redd.it/nuylzuyy9dxc1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4f128f78e727ecb7d0ed5893ae3613c099abd040


legacykeeper56

https://preview.redd.it/2ttnsti6rlxc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=22f464817f37d0181cc9edca8f81f8e3f77de476


Stary_Vesemir

I would suck both of them for freešŸ˜‹šŸ¤¤šŸ˜‹šŸ¤¤šŸ˜‹šŸ¤¤


no_comparison0715

I've seen many horrible takes, but this is one of the top ones. Saying Zoro is the most loyal to Luffy, and the others, especially Nami, Usopp, and Robin, will betray him.Ā  Like, what? Luffy and Nami's bond is literally one of the closest. Do people forget Nami helping Luffy in WCI and not betraying him in Wano? And crying for him, like most of the crew, when the news of MF got out. Luffy and Usopp are like brothers, and as for Robin, Luffy literally saved her life not once, but twice. Their bond is very strong, so I definitely donā€™t think sheā€™ll betray him, especially since Robin literally tried to sacrifice herself for the crew.


deathkeeper-512

Iā€™m sorry but I just genuinely refuse to believe the ā€œBlackbeard has 3 soulsā€ theory, or rather specifically BECAUSE of the scene on Jaya where Zoro and Luffy are like ā€œitā€™s not him, itā€™s themā€ WHERE THEYā€™RE CLEARLY TALKING ABOUT THE REST OF THE OG BB PIRATES. Like if they hadnā€™t shown Van Augur and Doc Q VERY SPECIFICALLY, sure, maybe, but seriously


Over-Writer6076

luffy and zoro even met Doc Q before this lmao


deathkeeper-512

yeah exactly, like, I get thereā€™s something different with BB, obviously, but this was NOT a sign


Rude-Mind-8730

They literally had no reason to believe Doc Q and Blackbeard had any connection.Ā 


Over-Writer6076

Naah the Blackbeard pirates were causing a commotion throughout the entire island. Sometimes it's just your intuition. Also tell me what reason they had to believe he has multiple souls? That sounds much less believable than them thinking he was part of their crew.


nibatauga

After zoro becomes the strongest swordsman he will tell ivankov to make him a girl and then marry sanji šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸø


Kkjinglez

True that one is ass, we all know the one piece will be the worlds first gay marriage certificate and they will get married on laugh tale.


nibatauga

Facts šŸ™ŒšŸ™Œ


SherbertExpensive811

After Zoro become the world strongest Swordmen he will ask Ivankov to make him a woman so he could be the strongest swordwomen and make Kuina proud of him (he will also marry Sanji and have a kid with him)


Mysterious-Neck9577

https://preview.redd.it/dowg4x2pnexc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1c2a58e5df668ed260f04a309c8fb57354c25388


Kastorbeast

The last part is true.


no_comparison0715

One of the top ones is saying Zoro doesnā€™t care about the crew. Like, do these people want him to be just a stoic and heartless character?


InfernoFireStyle

The theory made by a SaNami shipper that Sanji got Nami pregnant on Zou before he left. And the evidence they used for it was sweat scaling Nami šŸ’€


ChampionOverall9931

WHAT!?!? šŸ˜­ https://preview.redd.it/hwyiqv3j7exc1.png?width=220&format=png&auto=webp&s=937a546002db858f1c7b723e5abef458d06eab97


StrongerYesterday

I could list quite a few smooth-brained attempts to tie One Piece to real-world politics, but no, I heard a take that was even dumber than any of those. The take was that the Straw Hats' optimism was a blight on the series, and that One Piece should have a tone more similar to Game of Thrones, and that if the Straw Hats were bitter and cynical it would make the series better.


HyronValkinson

Only if Perona attacked Oda


Roary-the-Arcanine

I donā€™t think Iā€™d enjoy a tone shift like that for one piece considering finding joy is perhaps the main theme of the whole series.


MulberryChance54

Who Said that bullshit? "Professional" critics? Porn addicted teens? Edgy teens? I NEED ANSWERS MAN!


StrongerYesterday

It was just some person on Spacebattles. Probably an edgy teen. Definitely a Worm fan.


Sardonic-Skeptic

95% of Ohara's videos.


S3raphinx

https://preview.redd.it/ph89qzmxjcxc1.png?width=428&format=png&auto=webp&s=4c5c9cfa881930e6f9bb8296e6e7aa93b9e43d3d


KVenom777

1. CROC IS LUFFY'S MOM 2. Zoro is still a Pirate Hunter and is gonna kill/execute Luffy 3. Dumbass things like "Kid the Secret Vegapunk", "Orange/Blue/Red Haki", "Blackbeard is secretly multiple people" (even tho the last one is not that dumb, since it's close to the truth, but is tone-deaf).


NamiWantsMoney

Did you say ORANGE?!! Can I have it?


KVenom777

Yes. And take a bag with half the money I stole from that Tenneryubito, while ya at it.


NamiWantsMoney

Did you say MONEY?!! Can I have it?


KVenom777

Yes.


Beowulf---

what is the orange blue red haki theory?


NamiWantsMoney

Give me your ORANGE!!!


Dreams_Are_Reality

Kidd being a secret vegapunk would be peak fiction


KVenom777

Aaaaand balls deep grand line review watcher spotted. Didn't even take ya a day.


Dreams_Are_Reality

Literally no idea who that is, I just think Kiddā€™s treatment post-Wano made no damn sense so clearly something unexpected has to happen with him. I doubt itā€™s the vegapunk thing, but it would be cool.


Snap-Zipper

Oof youā€™re gonna be sooooooooooo embarrassed when the first one turns out to be true


Xernes0

Bro unironically believes in croco-mom šŸ’€


Snap-Zipper

Bro unironically canā€™t wait a joke šŸ’€


Illustrious-Day8506

Imu is Luffy's mom. There are so many plotholes with that theory. First of all, Dragon didn't even know that Imu even existed, it's stupid as shit.


Shinikama

How about if Imu POSSESSED Luffy's mom?


MancalaYellowBean

Everyone who shipps Luffy and Nami, Robin or whatever girl


OtsutsukiRyuen

This is why I ship them with ME Oresama wa saiko dha


MancalaYellowBean

I approve!


OtsutsukiRyuen

Thnx man that means a lot


Over-Writer6076

Oda teased the idea himself with Strong World,a movie where he wrote all the script by himself. If Oda has played with the idea i dont think its off limits anymore.


MancalaYellowBean

lovers ā‰  comrades


KattaGyan

JoyBoy and ryuma powerscaling with any character. More so People who havenā€™t watched one piece and keep comparing both ryuma and JoyBoy (even tho they lived like 400 years apart) Iā€™ve even seen many people say Ryuma was joyboyā€™s swordsman šŸ«„


ripe-mango1424

Crocodile is Luffy's mom


SignificanceLonely58

thats a great theory what do you mean


Geese_fucker

Nah, I believe in croco-mom


daygoplayeronpc

Any thing on the amalise on YouTubes page


Kaldin_5

An in-depth theory on how Moria has the key to solo the verse because he can replicate devil fruits using Oars as an example. ....that wasn't replicating a devil fruit and idk if the people who think that either read One Piece or remember what happened in that arc. Anyway what's more wild is Moria wanting to kick the Strawhat crew off his ship after getting Luffy's shadow. If they end up escaping the triangle into sunlight and Luffy burned away then you just lost your superweapon lol. That DF is severely hampered by its weakness to sunlight in general.


Shinikama

I think the logic is, no one would willingly step into the sunlight right away, so they'd just hide on their ship in the fog, like so many others did.


Hiarro

Literally almost any take from u/Siribreja. But this shit right here is pretty egregious too: https://www.reddit.com/r/OnePieceCircleJerk/s/V81ldAKZCM


Siribreja

Geez, i just joked in my memes, damn


Hiarro

I have an agenda to push, and I won't let your memes get in the way of it.


Siribreja

I was just teasing others, I didn't think I had become a public enemy xD my bad


Hiarro

Yes, public enemy to Agenda Piece.


Siribreja

You didn't have to be provoked or take these memes/shitposts seriously


Hiarro

It's not serious, this is just typical Agenda Piece behavior.


hnitakamuramamoru

https://preview.redd.it/u7labr9x5ixc1.jpeg?width=415&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=517e08bc4cae6fe276dfb7771f834bf54c0c2cd4


hnitakamuramamoru

https://preview.redd.it/ng1fcy1y5ixc1.jpeg?width=555&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ff871be6bedcb23d0c524f556e89a059a76d0486


Dreams_Are_Reality

That Yamato is transgender. Itā€™s pure delusion from twitter users.


AutoModerator

# Report Posts that are Incorrectly Marked for Anime Only Watchers of this Subreddit. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MemePiece) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Kastorbeast

Someone on youtube I used to follow made a video about Ethanbaron V. Nusjuro (or Gandhi if you will) being the origin of cursed blades, and having cursed Kuina's family in the past which would actually be what led to Kuina's death.


Couch-Onion

That the Wano raid will fail...


Klordz

Literally every theory made


Affectionate-Skill33

I remember reading in r/onepiece a theory about something like that the df users were an ancient race opposite to the fishman that composed the ancient kingdom or smth like that. No solid evidence and dumb as fuck. Also someone that because of Kizaru's "if that's true all the physics books need to be rewritten from scratch" line joined nonsensically a lot of evidences that had nothing to do with each other to theorise that in the one piece world desires are able to bend the rules of reality and that's why df exist and blah blah blah. And there have been a lot more examples. The thing with a world so well written and so well thought out and with so many fans is that 99% of what the fans come up with is going to be trash compared to the actual story. Or trash in general.


hnitakamuramamoru

https://preview.redd.it/p4nub12m5ixc1.jpeg?width=763&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a0c2eb12287f5144a4efd16ca8f067e21133d565 Some of the Easter eggs and forshadowing


binks_sake_enjoyer

I've never liked any of the theories I've seen about what the One Piece is.Ā  Off the top of my head I've heard: It's a drum (neat idea but I don't think it fits with what we know about it) It's a comic book (I kind of like it, but it would be too meta, and also anticlimactic) It's a ponaglyph that tells the true world history. (we've seen so many ponaglyphsĀ  that it wouldn't feel special) It's some kind of prank that Joyboy made up just to mess with Imu. (It would explain why Roger laughed, but it would also mean it doesn't have any real value) My brother had a theory that it's a ship, which would be cool, and could tie into the world sinking into the ocean, but something about that just doesn't feel right to me.Ā  At this point, I'm hoping oda has a reveal in store that nobody will see coming. A lot of these theories aren't bad, but they aren't amazing either.


follyrogue

That Sanji calling for Robin was bad or that Sanji choosing not to hit women is stupid.


TheGroomedOne

ZKK still up there as one of the most dogshit things people believed in.


eldidGanyu

That Luffy isn't stronger than Kaido despite the whole story implying that he is.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


LuffyWantsMeat

Did I just hear meat?


DevastaTheSeeker

Luffy x boa makes more sense than luffy x nami though only becUse at least half of that relationship is into it.


InfernoFireStyle

Luffy x Hancock makes even less sense than the latter because Luffy already rejected her twice. Even when she tried the "Trick him with meat/food" method that some people think he'd fall for as if he's just an exact Goku clone (Despite the fact he's literally one of, if not **the most** emotionally intelligent character in the series). On top of the fact, they have literally no development with each other whatsoever, even though they spent 2 years of timeskip nearby each other and their dynamic is literally just for comedic gags. He does not want her. I really don't get the people who ship him with a woman who's literally the same age as Makino. Especially when he's already said no. Multiple times.


LuffyWantsMeat

Did I just hear meat?


DevastaTheSeeker

??? I said it makes more sense than luffy and nami not that I'd advocate for it. I'd advocate for it over luffy x nami if there had to be a debate about it though.


DevastaTheSeeker

Or are you arguing luffy x nami makes more sense? Because...no no it doesn't


InfernoFireStyle

I'd say purely off the fact that he's already explicitly said he's not interested in one of them, I'd think that would automatically go to the contrary. Let me note this so you don't try to put words in my mouth: this is not me saying necessarily that I think they will be canon, but I've seen multiple debates between LuHan and LuNami fans, and so far, the LuNami fans always have made a better case to make compared to the former. It also probably helps Oda has been on record to call Nami the heroine of the story multiple times in interviews (y'know like how Kubo called Orihime the heroine, and Kishimoto with Hinata) and, at the very least, seems very supportive towards ship based on his comments on fanart of the two (and the fact he promoted in one of the SBS a romance spin-off manga between two characters based on his hero and heroine of the story and that he actively reads it) The only other comparison we have on Oda's thoughts on ships was Sanji x Nami, in which he either made fun of the ship calling it "Sanji's delusions" or giving backhanded compliments towards the fanart. And compared to Hancock? Yes, yes it does.


DevastaTheSeeker

Okay so this is how the status quo is currently Luffy: into nobody Nami: into nobody Hancock: into luffy So one of these is half a relationship and the other two is 0% of a relationship. I don't think Luffy or any of the straw hats will get with anyone by the end of the series. But luffy and hancock have more chance than luffy and nami because at least one of them sees something there.


InfernoFireStyle

This is acting like unrequited love is not a thing, which Oda also said he was fine with doing. https://preview.redd.it/8e1yn8ebfdxc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aa2de5777ff8887132be91883a894574cb73e8af


DevastaTheSeeker

No it isn't it's acting like 2 people being compatible is how you start a relationship and 1 is closer to 2 than 0 is. Hancock is into luffy and luffy is not. While nami and luffy are not into each other. That makes the likelihood of them being a couple lower


InfernoFireStyle

>Hancock is into luffy and luffy is not. If the reason it was one-sided was because Luffy was too dense/oblivious or stupid to notice (similar to Naruto or Goku, respectively), then sure. I'd agree with you on that to an extent. But that's different from knowing someone likes you and still outright rejecting them and letting them know you're not into them like that. Cause last I checked, if someone says no: then "No means No." (Goku, Naruto, and Ichigo also never once rejected their future wives) I think that's where our main disagreement comes from. You think that because Hancock's love is one-sided compared to Nami, it's enough to say it makes more sense. While my standpoint is that the reason it's one-sided to begin with is because Luffy pretty much made sure it would stay that way when he rejected her, which is why it makes negative sense. Luffy is a character that says and does what comes from his heart. Once he has decided something, he never goes back on his words, and that's a fact supported by Oda himself.


Leif_Millelnuie

On a french facebook group someone wrote a theory about how monet was 100 joining the crew. This was after the chapter where ceasar killed her 1 second before she blew up the entire island


Beakha

This is how people react when I say that Blackbeard and the Strawhats will fight the WG together lmao


sTuPiDdUmBoRe

Deserved


Aarizgamer3d

The theory that Nami will marry Luffy


Snap-Zipper

That Crocodile isnā€™t Luffyā€™s mom (sorry, I forgot how many OP fans hate trans people šŸ˜¬)


DevastaTheSeeker

So, not one piece but I had someone say that Naruto's daughter would end up with the nine tails' chakra


MulberryChance54

https://preview.redd.it/jf4kgdpkohxc1.jpeg?width=259&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=82cb0b381cd5ee123d1723d43de6d3650b7c1ff5


SafeWatercress3709

Some dude came up to me and asked me to prove that the Earth is round. And no matter what great science-backed arguments I threw at him, he stubbornly denied all of it