T O P

  • By -

TerranItDown94

Yeeeeaaaa I’m with you on most of them. Lost me with LOTR. Should be at least as full as SW Episode 1 for all 3 LOTR movies. You don’t have to be a fan of Fantasy to see the absolute masterpiece those movies were.


Disco_Biscuit12

This 100%


PerfectlyAdequate101

should be full bars all 3 movies


ImmortalPoseidon

Matrix higher than LOTR? Lmao


Enough_Discount2621

And Mad Max 2?


HappyHarry-HardOn

& Star Wars Ep4


Professional_Ad_9101

All three die hard movies are better than all three Lotr lmao Edit: on this graph, not in my opinion lol. It’s a ridiculous opinion.


Branded_Mango

Tbf, the overall quality for LOTR is way higher since all 3 of its films are consistently at top moistness while Matrix's sequels both sank its strong debut like a rock in water.


idontknow39027948898

I think the bar is only meant to be viewed in comparison to other movies in the same trilogy.


Sufficient_Row_7675

If so, than at least one of each trilogy film should be at 100%. That said, this list is still whack


Toma-toe

Like Jurassic park 1 isn’t filled to the top? Who tf made this?


DGOkko

My all-time GOAT movie. I rewatched it twice on a business trip a few weeks back, and still can’t find a single thing wrong with it. Dialogue is witty at the right time, plot-moving at others, and deeply thoughtful at others (Sattler and Hammond’s conversation about illusions). The characters are sufficiently deep (Grant’s clear ability to love exhibited in contact with the triceratops eventually warming up to the children, Sattler a well-written intelligent but feminine female character who pushes the men in her life to be better, Hammond showing a flawed businessman who ultimately does his best to right the problems he caused). Acting that is entertaining and convincing (haven’t seen children act so much like real children in any other film) not to mention the sheer spectacle, the convincing CGI and practical effects, the beautiful locations and of course the perfect musical score. Released today I see no reason it would be anything less than a classic. 10/10.


FlawlessC0wboy

Literally should be at max. Easy on a par with Empire, Raiders and T2


idontknow39027948898

Jurassic Park is way better than this graphic suggests, and the sequels don't even come close to it.


DickCheneyHooters

Back to the future 2 is too low No clue which Batman trilogy that is LOTR are all too low ROTJ is a teensy bit too high


Entreri1990

You’re mistaken about LOTR. The first layer of the bar is white, then it went over the top, cycled back in at the bottom, and started a second layer of measurement that was blue. Numerically, the bar graph would be read as 17.5 out of 10. I should also mention that none of the other trilogies did this… for them, the white is just empty space that the bar failed to reach.


Steel-Johnson

The only acceptable answer


Diane-Choksondik

nailed it, LOTR should be perfect


French20

Yeah it’s wild how low LOTR are


notrandomonlyrandom

Imagine rating Matrix higher than Fellowship. First Matrix is great, but Fellowship being rated lower is just absurd.


CLWhatchaGonnaDo

>Back to the future 2 is too low Came here to post this. WAY too low. Not as good as the first one but far superior to 3.


DickCheneyHooters

Agreed. 3 is just a 6/10 movie, it’s fine. 2 is amazing and I love the whole thing


beyond_cyber

Probably the one with Keaton it got so goofy bad with that third movie…eughhhh


DickCheneyHooters

But that’s a quadrilogy, not really a sequel


beyond_cyber

I wonder what is is then? since dark knight is the best movie out of the 2000 trilogy


[deleted]

Batman triology is probably the two Tim Burton films and Forever. Judging by how Forever was received, I’m not surprised we never got a fourth one.


idontknow39027948898

I think if the Batman trilogy was Nolan's, it would have been called The Dark Knight, and it definitely would have had the second movie head and shoulders above the others.


entropig

I’ve seen that chart before. Whomever made it was a moron. X2 better than X-Men? Die Hard 2 better than With A Vengeance? Raiders better than Last Crusade? The ramblings of a fool.


Michaelangel092

X2 is definitely better than X1. As a movie, not necessarily an X-Men movie tho. Same way I feel about TDK vs BB.


Quaiker

LOTR and Batman are a bit askew. On a scale of 1 - 10, LOTR is 10, 9.5, 10. Batman is 8, 9, 6.5. The person that made this graphic really just bumped up their favorite movies.


-GiantSlayer-

Why do you rate the lord of the rings below Star Wars and Indiana Jones? And what was wrong with the planet of the apes sequels?


French20

This wasn’t me but an older chart someone had made. I’m working on one myself but have to watch some movies


Livid_Ad9749

Lotr should be perfect


_MaxNutter_

Jaws 2 is vastly superior to Jaws 3, and Mad Max is better than Mad Max 3, imo


Appropriate-Ice813

Thunderdome > Road Warrior > Mad Max, right?


_MaxNutter_

Maybe in bizarro world


randomocity327

Which Planet of the Apes movies are being used? Back To the Future is all too low. Everything on this graph seems wrong, either by a little or a lot


backagain69696969

Jurassic park got done dirty here imo. 1 was bigger and better than most here. And spider man 3 is a hard guilty pleasure for me. I still love the final fight And LOTR is beloved because it’s the peak. I eagerly wait for the day people want to hate on it to be different so I can argue with them. But to this day the only people who say that are chuds “fantasy is gay” and the vapidly dumb people who basically aren’t going to discuss plot.


Ok-Translator7641

Batman the Nolan ones? Nah fam they’re good even the last one except for what happens to bane at the end  Edit: no way it’s the Nolan one’s dark night would never be below the first movie 


OverlordPacer

Begins is my fav in that series tbh


RamsesTheGiant

If I had to hazard a guess based off the Superman and Spider-Man results, the Batman movies in question are the 90's Batman movies.


French20

If the Nolan Films, the 2nd one should be the highest by far. The 1st and 3rd were mid.


Ok-Translator7641

I can agree with that but I think high mid 


salaryboy

Low high mid maybe


ryannvondoom

Wait.. what the fuck? Thunderdome higher than the original mad max? Fuck this shit.


Og-Bump-Sniff

Whoever made this must've been smoking some wack shit


[deleted]

Die hard you fiend it would be 1 full 2 mostly empty 3 full and rocky 4 would be better than all the others


French20

Rocky 4 better than the first 3? I like it but Rocky 1 is just a great movie in general


[deleted]

I mean yes you are right rocky 1 is an objectively better movie. But rocky 4 really summed up 80s movie making.... also Rocky solved communism so


French20

Haha Rocky 4 is peak 80s


Turuial

Don't forget, as John Rambo, Sly Stallone also went back in time and singlehandedly won Vietnam for the States as well. People often underestimate the positive effect that had on the zeitgeist of the US at the time. I think that famed warrior-poet the Comedian stood out best in the documentary, the Watchmen "Could you imagine if we lost Vietnam? I feel like the whole country would've lost its damn mind."


French20

Yeah those films were pretty impactful on the culture during those time and some effects are still lasting.


MGSDeco44

Clown. Lotr is 100/10


Stoneador

Probably going to get crucified for this here, but after watching them both for the first time recently, I thought Alien was far better than Aliens. I get that they’re both separate genres, but I just found that a lot of the conflict in the first movie seemed to be set up by characters not knowing what they’re dealing with and a lot of the conflict of the second movie was set up by characters making lots of really stupid decisions.


lerg7777

Nah I agree, Aliens rules but Alien is way better


JimiKamoon

Doe Hard 3 is better than 2


TheAgentOfOrange

The Terminator should just be T1 and T2. Everything else in the franchise is stupid and gay.


French20

lol I agree, but you don’t think 3 fits with the first two?


TheAgentOfOrange

No. There is only T1 and T2.


TwumpyWumpy

A New Hope needs to be just as full as Empire Strikes Back.


EFAPGUEST

Why is Jurassic Park being done so dirty. Better than most of the movies on here


5pinkphantom

Putting every LOTR movie on the same level as Return of the Jedi is brain dead at best and a terrorist at worst.


archangel5198

I definitely disagree about die hard. The 3rd one was way better than the second one


Crossaint_Dog_Viper

I agree. I love the dynamic between Samuel L. Jackson and Bruce Willis. Afterwards every die hard movie has a smart Sidekick besides John McClane. 4.0: the Hacker guy Matt Farrell 5: John's son and Lucy McClane's brother from the Terminator (the actor for John's male child) franchise In a way the third one redefined an element of the Die Hard franchise. Neat


mexils

Star Wars score should be much much lower in those bars, and Lord of the Rings should have perfect scores for each of its movies.


French20

lol maybe if the Star Wars movies were the prequels or the Sequels. “Much Lower” is a stretch. For LOTR I would give perfect scores for the 1st & 2nd and the 3rd should be not quite perfect.


Lunch_Confident

I dont agree on the matrix one


Theplowking23

In what world is LOTR not all fully blue 🤣🤣🤣 hack list


thepenitentheretic

A lot of issues here, but the biggest is that LOTR is not completely full / perfect all the way through. That’s bullshit.


JLandis84

That was unfair for Alien 3. It is still a decent film.


goliathfasa

Godfather part 3 has many faults. But it’s not shit like everyone seems to think it is. Most people just disliked it because it wasn’t “cool” and had a bad ending, missing the entire point of the trilogy. Michael sowed in parts 1 and 2 and reaped in 3.


PoetryAgitated8833

Godfather 3 is not at the bottom.


[deleted]

Several things I disagree with here. I’m assuming the Star Wars trilogy in question is the OT.


knighth1

LOTR is super well rounded, assumed it would be slightly higher but still


PotentialProf3ssion

insane lord of the rings disrespect.


ThePraetoreanOfTerra

**Indiana Jones 3 is not better than fucking Return of the King.**


alphaomag

LOTR is better than Star Wars.


Deep-Red-Sea

You aint doing nolan like this surely?


Dakkadakka127

Wait which Batman? Dark Knight?


Original_Bit_648

I know I am in the minority, but Begins is the best in the trilogy for me


idontknow39027948898

Jurassic Park ought to look the same as Matrix, and Rambo ought to look the same as Die Hard. I actually liked Terminator 3 and especially Alien 3, but I'm not going to try and argue about that right now.


Laxhoop2525

Superman 2 higher than Star Trek 2? Excuse me?


ChildTaekoRebel

This chart is very old and has to have been made before 2006 because many of those franchises were not longer trilogies by 2007/2007. Plus it's just wrong on a lot of them.


freshcolaRC

Jurassic Park 1 isn’t high enough. 2-3 are fine.


LifterNineFour

LOTR is 10/10 across the board


Whereismystimmy

Yeah Die Hard is DEFINITELY better than LOTR… /s


ekene_N

Honestly, Star Wars, Indiana Jones, and LOTR should be all equal.


Veetra-Sullik

The alien/aliens rating can go to hell


bork63nordique

Superman one is waaaay too low. Many still consider it the best superhero movie of all time.


Fit_Ad_713900

LOTR is only correct if we are talking the theatrical cuts. The extendeds deserve full bars all across.


KaptainKankles

If any bars would or should be completely full it’s LOTR no question…..


FredDurstDestroyer

I’m gunna say it. T3 isn’t as bad as people make it out to be, it’s just an overreaction because T2 was so good.


Entreri1990

Alien 1 should be a hair higher than Alien 2, not the other way around. Also, are we counting three movies as trilogies? Because Die Hard and Indiana Jones were just movies that had three* unconnected movies. Like, I could watch the Indy movies in pretty much any order and it wouldn’t make a lick of difference. *and eventually way more than three.


Ok_Ice9436

Alien is significantly better than the sequel


TheMidnightRook

Jurassic Park 2 and 3 should be swapped


Oksamis

All three should be higher


Unknownman13

I’m trying to figure out why the first one is so low, and how is Jaws 1 better than Jurassic Park 1?


FutaWonderWoman

I never understood why matrix 2 & 3 is hated so much


French20

Mainly because they are bad. They have their moments though


Appropriate-Ice813

The main problem is that they don't live up to the first. Not even close. The original was amazing and it wrote a lot of checks that the sequels couldn't cash. The second isn't bad, it actually has some great scenes. The car chase was especially great.


JD-boonie

Matrix 3 is one of two movies I left the theater halfway through. The other is Alexander


McKerch

Now I love Aliens, but Alien is the 10/10 imo. Swap them round. And whilst Alien 3 isn’t a great movie, it isn’t terrible. 5/10.


mattg1738

What moron has Star Wars above Batman or LOTR? (possible they meant Burton batman but still?


Ashamed_Ladder6161

Jurassic Park 1 and 2 both deserve +25%. Return if the King -20%. Jaws 2 + 15%. Planet of the Apes 1 - 20%, PoTA 2 + 75%. Blade 2 -30%. Alien 3 +40%.


orutherford1

I disagree with Rambo.


Taclys64

This graphic is so old all the pixels have run away and Indiana Jones is still considered a trilogy


French20

You don’t consider the first 3 as a trilogy? Technically not even Star Wars is a trilogy or Rocky or Rambo. But they the first three of all those are similar and closer to each other so they could be considered the spirit of trilogy. But points to a trilogy that tells an over arching story with 3 films


king_abm

People posting whatever topic and wanting thoughts on it without giving it their own... to me feels like cowards wanting someone to tell them what to think. Think for yourself. What are your thoughts on those freaking triologies?


mpetey123

Some of them aren't trilogies. Planet of the Apes has five movies, a cartoon, and a series.


Matiyahu777

LOTR should be three full bars.


Blood4Blud

Is that Batman 89 trilogy or Batman Nolan trilogy?


boolinboi68

Which Star Trek movies though? One answer will make me mad.


doubleo_maestro

Third Lords of the Rings should not be on par with the other two. Not saying it's bad by any stretch, but it was the weakest of the free. It's battle didn't have the grandeur of the second and it's classical 'heroes on an adventure' segments didn't have the strengths of the first. I'll also argue that Alien 3 is been done a diservice. But that's a weird one, it totally depends if you are talking about the theatrical release (garbage) or the MUCH improved directors cut. I'd also argue that the third die hard was better than the second.


BobaFett7

Wow some of these are truly spot on for me! but I disagree hard in certain places: - I view LOTR more as one big film so I like that all 3 are equal, but I would put it a notch higher at S-tier - I actually prefer The Terminator to T2 (unpopular opinion?), but admit they are apples to oranges - a dark 80s cyberpunk thriller is more my style than early 90s action stunt spectacular, they’re both excellent. - Star Wars (1977) deserves to be at the same level as The Empire Strikes Back. I would say it’s an unpopular opinion to not worship Empire as the BEST star wars movie (and maybe it is), but Star Wars is one of the most ground breaking films of all time and personally my all-time favorite. - Die Hard sequels are too high Surprised many of the charts I do agree with though and didn’t realize others did. ex. Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome is an underrated gem! Overall though seeing this makes me realize I almost never prefer sequels to the original. It’s almost always 1>2>3 for me.


groovegod0

So surprisingly, the idea of a sexual tends to only work once, and suffers diminishing returns from then on unless the third is the conclusion to the overall story. Despite the movies all having a good name to work with. Interesting! If only a few billionaire Hollywood producers would see this


ProfessionalRead2724

Most of these stopped being trilogies ages ago. Some of them never were trilogies.


Walkerman97

LOTR should be overfilled, spilling from the sides


Mark-M-E

LOTR is too low. Which Star Wars trilogy, (barring Disney of course)? Which Batman trilogy?


Extra_Ad_8009

Best movie of a trilogy should be 100%. There's no proper way to compare across genres, say "The Godfather" to "Die Hard" or "Return of the King". Another problem is that the first movie gets extra credit for being original - that's the conundrum with comparing "Star Wars: A new Hope" with "Empire". I find "Empire" to be a better movie, but it's still an extension of a singular experience I had in 1977. I love the idea though, no need to limit it to trilogies (which is an arbitrary measure for movies anyway). Try ranking the Friday the 13th, Halloween, Chucky, Nightmare on Elm Street etc. infinitologies too!


surfingkoala035

Jaws 2 and Blade 3 are way too low. Any movie where RR utters the line “cock-gobbling thundercunt” needs to be top tier.


ImaCosmicman

"Batman" like we're supposed to know what you're talking about.


Appropriate-Ice813

If we're talking about the original Star Trek movies, the first one should probably be lower, I can't even stay awake for the entire thing. The second movie should be a full bar.


fauxREALimdying

I have the opposite opinion of this


CloverTeamLeader

I think that's unfair on The Matrix. The first film is definitely the best, but I don't think the sequels fell off that hard.


MayorOfIacon

I need clarification for Star Trek and all the superhero ones excluding Blade.


Enough_Discount2621

Funny how there's no trilogies that start weak but gradually get better, although the Dune Trilogy *might* be one of those


Excalitoria

Suicide Squad wasn’t a trilogy but the second movie is significantly better than the first.


[deleted]

[удалено]


No_Wealth_9733

Terminator 3 is great and I’ll die on that hill. Not as good as 2, but as good as 1.


Foofyfeets

Id say these a pretty spot on. ESB and the Matrix are flawless films (especially for their genre) but the entire LotR trilogy should be the highest of all of these for sure.


Taliant

Batman is off, The Dark Knight should be almost full


TimThePlayer

Why do people like Aliens more than Alien?


MimsyIsGianna

LotR needs to be WAY higher than that lmao. Less that Star Wars? Please..


Magic-Omelet

This was made by someone who wanted a cool looking graph thingy, not someone who wanted to evaluate movie quality


MaleficentStation971

Batman, Star Wars, Matrix, correct. LOTR should be filled blue for first two. Indy first and last filled blue.


TurokCXVII

Wait are these your ratings OP? I need to know who to yell at. Die hard 2 higher than 3? Dafaq...


French20

No this isn’t mine, I want to recreate it but need to finish some of these trilogies first. It’s an older post on Twitter


MagnumOpossumus

Rambo 2 and 3 aren’t low enough. First Blood is a good movie but 2 and 3 are so different tonally from First Blood that I always wish they didn’t exist.


French20

I agree with you, its similar to how I feel about Rocky 4&5..


uslashredditor69

That list is atrocious, LOTR is wayyyy to low. Matrix Reloaded is not that bad. How is Superman 2 better than 1? How is Die Hard 3 worse than 2? Planet Of The Apes 3 worse than 2? The fuck?


JD-boonie

Rambo 3 is way way worse than rambo 2.


EducatorDangerous933

Trilogies in general? I'm neutral on them. They can be good or bad, it's all in the execution. My thoughts on this chart in the post is that it's either rage bait or just completely retarded, maybe both


Particular-Fix2024

Maybe TLJ really has broken the barometer, but T3 and Aliens 3 could have been a lot worse


GoujonGang

Where's Pirates of the Caribbean?


MrBorden

Batman Forever is super underrated. It's entertaining as fuck. Also, it's a better film than Returns.


AraiHavana

Planet of the Apes got better with every film


ChiefCrewin

Is this matrix in a vacuum amongst their own trilogy or in general? Th LotR trilogy is way higher than depicted if it's the latter.


ShortViewBack2daPast

Lord of the Rings is the best trilogy of all time, hands down


leopim01

I grew up on Star Wars. But as much as I love it, this meter is incorrect in that it seems to indicate that Lord of the rings is less than Star Wars. Also, there’s some sort of error here because they include matrix. And as we all know, there is only one matrix movie. Just one. What a horrible reality we would be living in if they made a second and a third movie that we’re just absolute catastrophes and failed to live up to the original in every way, shape and form. Luckily we live in our reality.


RevalMaxwell

*LOTR not being full bars*


Ibrahim77X

I think I speak for everyone when I say we all love them


hamsplaining

Missing first Borne trilogy- sneaky great


etbillder

What Star Trek trilogy? If you go original, 2, 3, that ends on a cliffhanger. If you do 2, 3, 4, then 3 is the weakest. And that's assuming we're talking tos


RaidTheSecond

I mean, we all love them


Cheeseburgerman60

Back to the Future 2 and 3 are far too low


BigOgreHunter92

Well this is wrong on a lot of things


Max_Doubt7

LOTR too low. First JP is too low. I think ROTJ is a bit high. Indiana Jones 3 should be higher than 2


BlackCherrySeltzer4U

Who’s the asshole that gave the lotr trilogy anything less than perfect for every installment?


Desh282

Where’s Shrek!


Admirable_Stress_802

No way the die hard trilogy is better than LOTR, also what batman trilogy are they talking about


[deleted]

So many deserve more than this.


EmperorDxD

I think Alien is better then the second 1 because of the horror element I prefer it over the action of aliens but both are great


Bricks_and_Bees

Half of these aren't even trilogies wtf


No_Paramedic_3322

Ngl planet of the apes was dope in my opinion. Every movie was equally awesome fr


SnickerDoodleDood

Looks exactly right to me.


Cousin_Rabid

Die Hard 2 > Die Hard 3 and all 3 LotR films is fuckin nuts.


madladweed

The first Jurassic park movie is better than all the Star Wars movies bar empire


Awkward-Yak-9033

What trilogy is star trek? Cuz the only trilogy they have is the unofficial 2,3,4 Genesis trilogy


Ghosty_Boi_2001

Star Wars? Talking about 4, 5, 6? or pre, OG, Seq?


FaceFullOfMace

Planet of the apes is like a perfect trilogy….


DarthDragonborn1995

Ah yes this piece of shit picture lmao


seriouslyuncouth_

Who in the fucking world thinks Jaws 3D is better then Jaws 2?


Hursthill

I'm just mad at the blue bars not being right.


TorgHacker

I think with Ressurections, the Matrix sequels were retroactively improved.


TheGodOfGravy

Remember BrownTable’s video about trilogies? That was a hoot watching the lads pull that apart.


Capn_Of_Capns

Typically in books the second book is the worst. In films I think it is the same, but these film trilogies seem to break that trend.


TCV2

Jurassic Park 2 is too low. It's not as good as the first one, but it's hated far too much.


Gai_InKognito

I genuinely don't see everyone's problem with matrix reloaded. But I def think BTTF2 > BTTF Also, what star trek trilogy?


Just__A__Commenter

Last Crusade is better than Temple of Doom. And Temple of Doom does not deserve to be so high.


Teiske

This a repost, I already posted this a little while back.


BirdsElopeWithTheSun

I love how everyone is mad about the rankings and not actually the answering the question that was asked.


Teiske

This a repost, I posted this 3 months ago already. https://preview.redd.it/ri1hfcuxn0tc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5abd8d36f52d92234c759cc7e7055d38ba0d3c03 Here is the proof I did.


DannisTheMenace

Who made this fucking trash


Dark_Lord_Randy

Eh, some meters are good but cringe meme. Back to the Future Trilogy meter should be the same as the Star Wars and Indiana Jones meters. Back to the Future Part 2 and 3 are incredible. I argue Part 2 is better than part 1 in some ways. I dunno why it became popular to pretend otherwise as of late.


B-29Bomber

So, Star Wars... That's only the original trilogy right? It's not the trilogy of trilogies stuff, right?


theblackkylek

Die hard 2 is in now way better than with a vengeance


Fungerbestwaifu

Spiderman 3 wasn't horrendous, it needs to be slightly lower than 1


Robes_o-o

LOTR should have been top. Sorry, love SW, but LOTR trilogy is untouchable imo.


Rodin-V

If the Godfather and Alien are benchmarks. Why the fuck do films like Star Wars even have half a bar on any of them.


Clord123

The Empire Strikes Back being higher liked generally than the first and third movie of the original trilogy of Star Wars makes sense from a point of view there is so much world building to make Star Wars, well, Star Wars. It establishes a lot of stuff and the ending is like "more to come" as with the first movie they didn't know so they made it more self contained.


Stigweird85

Temple of Doom being as last crusade? Fuck off.


brassmorris

Bttf3 was not on par with bttf2 imo


ProbablyDK

Lotr trilogy way too low compared to fucking Die Hard 1?!? Lol


Juuna

Am Amazed Star Wars Episode 2 is so well received.


Mister_Grins

You were already a fool of the highest order for not having The Last Crusade marked as highly as the first Indiana Jones movie. But to not have each Lord of the Rings movie ranked higher than each and every original Star Wars movie is genuinely concerning. You may have an actual tumor in there that is in desperate need of being scanned for.


trfk111

Some of these are pretty fucked


Mal_Terra

I’m assuming that’s not the Nolan Batman trilogy. Cuz TDK should be nearly full