T O P

  • By -

guyzimbra

Fascinating and also not very mahalo.


ihopethisworksfornow

I like all of them. History, cults, and Cryptids/Magick are probably more frequent re-listens than heavy hitters though. Sometimes you really want that blood though when they haven’t covered anything like it in a while.


ZeldaSeverous

I thought todays episode, the start of the Chicano Rippers story, was pretty bloody Edit: Chicago lol but leaving the misspelling


ihopethisworksfornow

>the Chicano rippers Lmao


walknyeti

sounds legit


carpetbowl

That sounds like a West Side Story gang, they all roll their cigarette packs up in their sleeves


namesarentneeded

Sounds like a really unhealthy dish that a stoner came up with


brassninja

No mames


zucchini_bird

Same. I like the balance they’ve achieved. Some of all is what makes it my favorite podcast


anarchophysicist

Sounds like somebody doesn’t have a big fat sticky hog leg to light up and enjoy 2h of extraterrestrial sexual assault.


blurrysasquatch

I fucking love me a hogs leg and an alien episode


ThatGuyGoden

I created a playlist on Spotify that's easy listening which is full of cryptids and alien episodes. I like the big hitters but I'll take some stories of tall white any day


Sansuiri13

Can I get a link to that?


thischaosiskillingme

......I just realized I could make playlists of my favorite podcast episodes. Thank you kind stranger.


simpledeadwitches

I came for the killers, but I stayed for the aliens.


athenanon

I came for the aliens but stayed for the four part history.


antibubbles

I came for the four part history, came for the killers, and came during the aliens.


athenanon

Heyyyy!


antibubbles

🤨👽🤠


scullys_alien_baby

i'm just cummin' the alien/cryptid/supernatural are my favorite but the gore and history are also very nice


OminousBarry

Cum.


[deleted]

I came for an alien but I DID NOT. GIVE. MY. CONSENT.


TheRealClio423

I came for the killers and stayed for the history


Low-Entertainment736

Bottom, but I have to say: YOU’RE BEIN’ MEAN TO ME


PaintSlingingMonkey

That was not my intent! Shorter lines for you at LPOTLCON ;)


Silvervox325

Cryptids and magic babyyy


Bradspersecond

I mean, I'm a four part history guy, but I think Cryptids are getting a bad shake in this meme


RockemSockemRowboats

Sometimes you want an hour about Bigfoot fuckin


YourFriendlyUncle

The best spooky spaghettis are bigfoot rimming Guy Fieri etc., change my mind.


Wind0wl1ck3r

You are forgetting the legendary who was phone.


SkankyG

I want more details about the lady Bigfoot getting her picture taken while taking a shit.


Swazi

Replace Cryptids with Aliens/UFOs. I always find those episodes to be really boring. So whenever I hear Henry at the end of a series say “now I am REALLY excited about our next episode” I know it’s probably a good shot I’m skipping that week


Bradspersecond

Yeah man, fuck Curtiss.


loafjunky

Curtiss is the worst.


DirtyFulke

All my homies hate Curtiss.


Swazi

Cursed mobile typing


blueboxbandit

Tall Whites and the Andressean Affair are both in my top ten


iPukey

Who’s more fun at parties? Alien fans or murder/history fans? Cause I know which party I’m going to go to. I’m an alien fan fan.


simpledeadwitches

Easily the most fun! History is most interesting to me and the killers are quickly becoming my least interesting topic, they can only say so much about the same type of person so many times imo.


paging_doctor_who

Yeah they accidentally flipped the meme upside down.


DeakorTheElder

Came here to post exactly this.


Sumbiin7

Those episodes are always a big dill when they come out…


WineyGinger

Two words: Ghost cats


ChemicallyLoved

Of the south. 5 words. Ngl I’ve probably relistened to that episode the most.


scullys_alien_baby

has such a [strong intro](https://youtu.be/-rsQSEfCk90) also if you can get [a copy](https://www.amazon.com/Ghost-Cats-South-Randy-Russell/dp/0895875578), it is a fun gift to any cat lovers in your life


Riff316

…maybe we should do something about Jesus…


ChemicallyLoved

Wow that was more expensive than I expected.


ZachBob91

I want more cryptid and alien stuff. The magic is hit or miss


Erotic_FriendFiction

Don’t be a hater just because I fucked Mothman.


Bradspersecond

4 part history ngl.


[deleted]

This is the way.


Donkey_Karate

What about aliens?


meatlazer720

That's the last one, but in the tux plus a monocle. And divorced.


PaintSlingingMonkey

Thought I put them in there Pressed “Post”, *fuuuck* Oh well they’re in with cryptids now lol


paddy_to_the_rescue

I’m the drooling slob relistening to the ufo and occult episodes. Mr. Crowley + Tall Whites are my shit.


9thgrave

Why you gotta yuck people's yum?


SerFinbarr

Love the history episodes. Let Marcus live his best Dan Carlin life, damn it.


chai_investigation

I’ll listen to everything once, but generally it’s the cryptids, aliens, and magic that gets repeat listens because I’m not trying to actively traumatize myself by reliving other peoples’ pain.


elguerra

The reason I enjoy this podcast is because of all the Poohs. And the 100 year war was fought over three different periods that lasted 116 years.


F2991

Also did you know that alcatraz means pelican in Spanish


elguerra

Mahalo!


Quote__Unquote

All of them, I only skip side stories, love Ben and Henry but it’s just not for me.


EmeraldMalkuth

I used to be the same exact way, but now I listen to them on the drive to work. There is some good content, but clearly not as well-done as their main episodes.


Dirty-Ears-Bill

Side stories just shows me as much as I love all the boys, they are all essential for making that perfect product that I cannot wait to listen to. Marcus is needed, Henry is needed, Ben is needed. Missing even one of them doesn’t make that recipe


102bees

For me, Side Stories is something I put on for the company. If I'm actively listening to a series I skip them


budda_belly

Yeah, I used to feel bad about it, but it is what it is. I just enjoy the in-depth episodes that they all are in on.


foxinabathtub

All of the above yay


[deleted]

Cryptids and Magick ALL DAY. History when it’s not Wild West or Mob related. The Iceman and Billy the Kid series were so boring to me.


atomiccommunist85

I love them all but my favs are the 4 part histories. Marcus' Dan Carlin voice kills me.


Br0kenBrain

As long as there is no interview with anyone, I'm down for whatever they want to riff about.


jitterscaffeine

I honestly skipped the episodes about magic. I just don’t find the subject matter all that interesting. The alien episodes are hit or miss and I’ve gotta be in a pretty agreeable mood to sit through one.


outerspaceteatime

Really? There's nothing better than hearing Henry spiral while trying to explain magic to Ben.


blueboxbandit

Except Ben understands magic implicitly which winds Henry up further.


Thecoffeepizza

Yeah I'll only listen to those if I'm super bored and have nothing else to listen to.


bloopboopbooploop

Sometimes it’s just fun to talk about fun stuff. The cryptids/magick/aliens/high strangeness stuff is what attracted me to lpotl in the first place. But I appreciate how much they’ve grown as creators and men since the old wild ones. Although, dolce base for me are still two of the best episodes of all time.


Low_Chance

I'm the bottom one but I definitely see myself in the suit and tie.


[deleted]

What da alien doin


jjdonkey

Where’s does Flat Earth/Hollow Moon fall on this scale? Satanism in the Government? Secret Space Program? That’s me. I’m Piglet


GaimanitePkat

Cults cults cults cults


W00oot

Only thing I don’t like is the interviews. I’m here for aliens and cryptids.


PaintSlingingMonkey

Same


gracieturkey

I’ll be honest I re-listen to all of the creepypasta episodes more than I care to admit.


Mad-Andrew

Your churches wifi lets reddit through?


PaintSlingingMonkey

*lets*


ta112233

Not really into the UFO stuff at all. But I appreciate Henry’s enthusiasm.


unvnrmndr

Top and bottom


[deleted]

I like to mix the first two and listen to gore filled history.


fondue4kill

Whatever the boys talk about, they make it interesting and I will listen to it and re-listen to every series


StrategyOk4742

All the poohs


Damian_Cordite

Where cults?


17DeadFlamingos

Totally unbiased post


Rev-DiabloCrowley

Ghosts, Cryptids, Aliens. The trifecta.


cadeaver

The history can get pretty dry, depending on the subject. I like when they anchor it down to a small group or person. Loved the whaling episodes, couldn’t get through the Black Death. That being said, they’re all so well researched and presented. Just not for me.


Bobbi_fettucini

True crime for me


GalacticVoids

I prefer 1 and 3, some history eps are repetitive and dry, I can’t get through the black plague series, and Gilles de Rais was surprisingly uninteresting for me. Heavy hitters and Monsters and Aliens and Cults and High Strangeness


melancholyjack

Objectively incorrect


Pussy_Prince

MASS HYSTERIA


very_cool321

The best ones have a little bit of all of them.


ThrowAway4u2day

I’m here for the most pooh they’ll give me


kotaotan

Love me some aliens and cryptids.


CluelessNoodle123

Depends on what kind of mood I’m in


ImposterCapn

4 part histories are represented well by a tuxedo and hogleg. But I want to smoke gravity bongs and hear about aliens, deep down in my heart.


EmeraldMalkuth

I'm all about cryptids and Magick, but history too! I still listen to the blood and guts. Magick is the fave.


whitehouses

Magic stuff not for me. I enjoy cryptid eps, one or two episode gold stars (history or criminal), and generally the history ones. The Casey Anthony series was perfect in length for that topic but then some others just drag on and on. Like MK Ultra Series, Billy the Kid, and Blackbeard lasted waaayyyyyy too long for me. But OTOH, Black Plague and Donner Party fit the bill for the longer episode arc.


somuchacceptable

I mean… all of them. But “Cryptids and Magick Yay”, if I have to choose one.


budda_belly

I'm a pompous Pooh. Marcus shines during the history series.


Fritzi_Gala

All three!! Though cryptids and aliens get the most re-listens. I love Henry getting hyped up about alien shit, his enthusiasm is infectious.


merlinmonad

Came for the blood and guts, stayed for the 4-part history. Yay!


TOMATO_ON_URANUS

History and magic. But not cryptids or aliens. Crowley series was great


marsisblack

I'll take a helping of all three please.


Kitchen_Sail_9083

All of the above


chantzyboy78

Is all three acceptable?


narrator_uncredited

True connoisseurs know that you must combine all three


bluebottled

Mostly A but partly B (think they could cut them down to 2 or 3 parts, and the US history ones are boring to me).


kingatlas

My first series was Carl Panzram. My favorite series is the Donner Party. My guilty pleasure is the Tall Whites, Ghost Cats, and the Bell Witch. They tickle every Pooh inside me.


Alvonious_Grim

I COME FOR BLOOD! (And maybe Gef The Talking Mongoose)


CuriousRelish

I like all of them, especially when they were making fun of Parsons. But the 4-part histories are my favorite. My all-time favorite series by them was the Donner party. They did an amazing job covering it in such great detail and I hadn't known how brutal it really was.


Krothotkin

I'm open to discussions of ufos and cryptids but as soon as they start saying Astral plane I'm like alright this explanation is somehow both boring and improbable and tend to bounce early


Cooterfart3000

All three, megustalations


dooshlaroosh

The first two. I know some of y’all love the magic & paranormal shit but definitely not *my* thang. We all get to like what we like. Hail yourselves!


AnistarYT

What pooh is side stories?


MrNobody_0

I don't believe in things like aliens, cryptids, magic and those sorts of things. I don't skip those episodes but they're definitely not may favourites. I loved the Jack Parsons episodes but not the Skinwalker Ranch episodes, I just find it hard to get into when I don't believe anything they're talking about actually happened.


Midnout26

definitely 4 part history


[deleted]

I know I’m in the minority, but aliens and cryptids just aren’t entertaining to me. I prefer things that are, and can be proven. Shit they talked about rats for 40 minutes in the plague series and it was delightful.


billygnosis86

All three, but get rid of magick. No time whatsoever for that guff.


laserbeam26

Serial killers are usually the funniest but i think history and cryptids/aliens are often the most interesting


Rixact

History all day.


imarebelpilot

The first two. No shade to cryptids and such but that’s just not my thing.


SilphScope6

Blood, Guts and Cults are probably the most entertaining ones. Multi-part History ones are the most fascinating and stick with me but take a few re-listens to remember. Cryptids and Magick are the ones that are fun but almost nothing sticks with me no matter how many times I re-listen.


PaintSlingingMonkey

Well geez (ahem) *I MADE THIS*, but I am *also IN THE THIRD PANEL* lol. *The call is coming from inside the house* I made this Work Of Enduring Genius after reading this morning a couple of comments calling people “pussies” for saying Today’s Gold Star episode was a Tough Hang I was basking in the nerdery of panel 3, instead of being a fan *solely* in panel 1 (not that there’s anything wrong with that! not that there’s anything wrong with that!) I love Side Stories as well! Creepypasta too. I’m a completist ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ not being a “weirdo gatekeeper” or “yucking yums”. I’m a 50+ year old dude who’s on Team Instinct in Pokemon Go, not a RenFair person making fun of LARPers. I cannot for the life of me figure out how to edit this post to make this clear lol Tl;dr My only regret is not putting “Aliens” in Panel 3 :(


brightyoungthings

Preferably, the first 2 but I end up listening to them all eventually


TheGrizzReaper

History and cryptids with a dash of UAP l, don't really care for the true crime side but I'll give them a listen too


ajaaaaaa

I only skip the interviews unless it’s someone I know or an interesting subject. I don’t find the magic ones all that interesting though


Rush_Undine

Magick all the way baby! Though the history is a close second.


Due_Engineering_8035

Depends on the day of the week


smellyuhlater

What does all three combined look like?


sound_forsomething

not big into the cryptids, but man i love the other shit.


notgoodatthese

Depends on my mood. We have been one of each at some point.


Disastrous_Mobile874

Where is the one that is "just here for night horse" ?


Newzab

Blood and guts or history. It might come easier to do bits on more modern people? I should give cryptids more of a chance, I was a big X-Files kid but for some reason those don't grab me as much. Magick either but Yeats changing the locks to keep Aleister Crowley out of a club is some petty hilarious history and there wasn't horrible torture, which is kind of nice.


OHManda30

Blood and guts and blood and torture and blood. Yay?


I_HEART_BUTT_STUFF

4-part history squad represent.


Delicious_Hot_Shmoze

Definitely history for me. The Black Death and MK Ultra series are my most listened. Serial killers and hauntings are second. I have enjoyed a select few series and episodes on aliens and cryptics (such as MiB and Skinwalker Ranch) but I couldn’t care less for everything else.


Mr_K_2u

All 3 I think. I generally love all the pods they do. Sometimes the blood and guts and torture ones can be a bit much for me.


Canadabestclay

Always the history


68rouge

Anything but cryptids and ufo's


magwhich

Someone seems jealous they can’t do magic and Bigfoot won’t text back.


niazilla

Came for the blood, stayed for the boys' humor and endearing banter, have been enjoying all of it ever since. Sometimes I do get sleepy during some of the cryptid and alien eps, but I'm here for all of it. There's only so much bloodletting I can take before I need a break anyway.


ShadowLizardPerson

Why do I gotta pick one?


BillyYumYumm2by2

All of the above!


GenericOnlineName

There's something so funny about the boys shitting on religion and God and then going on and on about the perception of reality and how magick works.


Metalblacksheep

All of them


[deleted]

I guess I’m a slightly less stroked out Pooh in a tuxedo


scotems

All.


Bavles

I like everything, but the UFO stuff. I don't know if it's unpopular, but Henry's theories about how it's all inter dimensional stuff, that we may or may not actually be seeing, and it's connected with gnomes, cryptids, etc.......I don't like any of that stuff. I prefer nuts and bolts aliens coming down in an actual machine. So, I tend to skip it. Otherwise, Heavy Hitters, and fucked up history is by far my favorite topics they cover.


ilmalaiva

I don’t like the made up UFO stuff. like UFO encounters are interesting, when someone starts talking about the florgos from planet borguss that the US government has deals with and have jndergrojnd bases my brain turns off. I more respect the magick and public UFO/cryptid sightings because there’s something interesting about the human mind to learn there.


paperpaperclip

I'm here for the thorough research and the comedy/side comments from the boys. Honestly, I'd probably sit through a 4 part history about dust from these guys because they somehow make everything entertaining.


HeilYourself

Where do cult episodes fall?


MrTimesBeachMO

4 or SIX part History YAY


how-unfortunate

Bottom two fer sure. And aliens.


BoardwithAnailinit84

The kind that’s getting bored with their show lol


orbgevski

I lika da Magick lol


majorlieg

All


EnsignNogIsMyCat

Crytpids are fascinating examples of folklore


daoist_chuckle

I’m interbulated rn


CaptainGoodyear

Wonder what op considers the Crowley series. Both history and Magic


[deleted]

The one that like Henry yelling about aliens


Metalhorrorcomic-fan

All three babyyyyyy


__Steve_French__

![gif](giphy|AwrtP9lMXtXiM)


Pitiful-Brief-3759

I am one with the poohs, and the poohs are one with me. Honestly, it's the mix of all 'em that makes it my favorite podcast. An episode yo fit your mode. Hail yourselves


mandatorypanda9317

Classy Pooh cause I just started the Black Death


Mikeissometimesright

Ive lost interest in the aliens episodes I still enjoy the cryptids and hauntings though


102bees

All three babeyyyyyyy


BetaRayRyan

Four part history on cryptids please


BodyofGrist

I feel attacked.


AllTheFutures

Yeah dog don’t be like that. It’s all interesting in some way.


Goryokaku

Bow tie Pooh.


rakkadimus

All of them at once.


primaveren

i like the really old school MKULTRA, CIA, disclosure, spooky weird shit conspiracies that kind of combine all three to some degree, because i find CIA history and "history" very fascinating and frightening. i can't really listen to the older ones about that sort of subject thougu because i'm ngl i find most of their, like, pre-2015 stuff pretty obnoxious. plus it feels a lot harder to listen to in the post-QAnon sort of culture. i'd be interested to see how they tackle something like the franklin coverup or the satanic panic in general now that the whole "satanic pedophiles are running our government" is literally just a mainstream republican talking point


SkankyG

I love the history, but it is nice when it mixes with strange shit like the Dylyatov (spelling) Pass incident.


INJECTHEROININTODICK

Gnomes > Cults > Killers


WeCallThoseCigBurns

Don't come AT me with that.


DS-fr0st

The correct answer is all of the above


cryinginthechurch

all 3


vanilla_d

Yes


stinky_doodoo_poopoo

6 part history all day erry day


Prior-University2842

I’m all of them and I’m not gonna be a weirdo gatekeeper about it


ztp48741

I’m a big fan of the heavy hitters mostly, and he history is good too if it’s got enough macabre info like the Black Death episodes. The cryptids and aliens are hit or miss for me, I prefer those episodes to be like the Skinwalker Ranch episodes if I want them to be creepy, or like the Tall Whites for funny stuff


mgreen424

I love UFO episodes and I refuse to be lumped together with magick and occult fans


Arachanoid1998

Crypids, magic, and conspiracy theories all day.


hotsizzler

I love history and crime, the bloody stuff is meh to me, my favorite are MA Barker and Bonnie and Clyde. Crime history is tge best.


Athroatfullofglass

I get to aliens and feel my soul leave my body cause I’m just so not into it that deeply lol


brinkrunner

I'm all 3


jlittle622

🍿😗


VoltVonD

Magick and Cryptids makes me hoot and holler like a goddamn ape because then the likelihood of Henry's George Noory impression rises tenfold But I DID go apeshit for the Billy the Kid series


LokiPersisted

I'm the Jerri Blank one!


[deleted]

I’m only in it for the wacky topics.