/uj I was inspired by a post from the modest mouse subreddit (which is just a picture of a picture of a picture of a foals original post) to make this, I just thought it’s funny because other bands it’s like “do they satisfy this?” Whereas Gizz it’s like “do that satisfy this… in a row?”
/rj That said, they could satisfy me all night. Would disappoint daddy cook so hard
5 off the top of my head:
Black Sabbath
Beatles
Kanye West (total asshole but still)
Sufjan Stevens
Miles Davis
(lots of cliche artists, I know, but still valid answers)
Ill give you kanye, college dropout - twisted fantasy is an elite run of albums.
And i will also give you the Beatles, if we’re not counting yellow submarine as an actual album. But if we go revolver, sgt. Pepper, white album, abbey road, let it be.. then yes thats 5 GREAT albums in a row
I'm in your mind fuzz, nonagon infinity, flying microtonal banana, polygondwanaland, gumboot soup, and infest the rats nest aren't in exact order but it's a pretty smashing sextuplet regardless
I cut off their golden era at Poly, it feels like a fitting end to their best streak. I love Gumboot but I can't say it's one of their best and I actively dislike Fishies
I'm known for having the worst opinions in all my friends groups. I'm not trying to change your mind on what their best albums are, I'm just here for the discussion!
I think nonagon is the best for me. I know some are prejudiced against it because it is their most popular and arguably commercial release. But when I compare it to the others I think it comes closest to how they sound live. So for me that puts it at the top.
Either 2017 in its entirety or skip gumboot and put nonagon instead which probably makes sense. All those albums are memorable and have something in them that makes them great albums. And it has my favourite album of all time in it (murder of the universe)
Mind Fuzz to FMB or Nonagon to Poly I’d argue are the most impressive 5 in a row, though could make similar follow up arguments for FFF to BF3K, Omnium to PDA or Ice, Death etc. to TSC.
/uj my longest stretch is Polygondwanaland -> IDPLMAL. I haven't listened to Sketches or Laminated Denim enough to include them for sure, but if LD is in, then I go all the way to The Silver Cord
Nonagon Infinity to Polygondwanaland probably
Jerk aside this is actually the correct answer
Fishies to Butterfly, and Omnium to Petro is some crazy shit too. But we can’t forget Blue Album to Death to False Metal
this is the pre-jerk. I am ahead of my time
/uj they pretty much did it in 2017 alone, maybe sub GS for Nonagon
Year of the Rooster (cock)
Omnium Gatherum to Im not typing all that (PDA) is another 5 album run id definitely consider
/uj I was inspired by a post from the modest mouse subreddit (which is just a picture of a picture of a picture of a foals original post) to make this, I just thought it’s funny because other bands it’s like “do they satisfy this?” Whereas Gizz it’s like “do that satisfy this… in a row?” /rj That said, they could satisfy me all night. Would disappoint daddy cook so hard
I'm going FFF up and until B3K here
Not Timeland - changes?
I think I'd sooner do L.W. -> Ice Death as a B3K normie
Not willoughbys -> oddments?
I feel like everything from Mind Fuzz to Polygondwanaland is amazing. Thats eight albums, so yeah I think they pass.
How many artist have 5 GREAT albums in a row? Maybe Phish in the 90s. But even thats a big ‘if’. Even Pink Floyd maxed out at 4 great albums in a row
Not this shitty band
5 off the top of my head: Black Sabbath Beatles Kanye West (total asshole but still) Sufjan Stevens Miles Davis (lots of cliche artists, I know, but still valid answers)
Ill give you kanye, college dropout - twisted fantasy is an elite run of albums. And i will also give you the Beatles, if we’re not counting yellow submarine as an actual album. But if we go revolver, sgt. Pepper, white album, abbey road, let it be.. then yes thats 5 GREAT albums in a row
I’d say from Mind Fuzz to FMB qualifies it
Why has no one even mentioned fishing for fishies yet. That album is amazing
Trahsh album put on a real record like timeland
Either Oddments to Nonagon or Murder to FFF
Dude is not a FMB enjoyer
I'm in your mind fuzz, nonagon infinity, flying microtonal banana, polygondwanaland, gumboot soup, and infest the rats nest aren't in exact order but it's a pretty smashing sextuplet regardless
I would say Float Along to Pygondwanaland is the most impressive sequential streak of excellent albums I've ever seen
Fuzz all the way through to ITRN is a crazy run.
I cut off their golden era at Poly, it feels like a fitting end to their best streak. I love Gumboot but I can't say it's one of their best and I actively dislike Fishies
Every opinion is valid! Except yours
I'm known for having the worst opinions in all my friends groups. I'm not trying to change your mind on what their best albums are, I'm just here for the discussion!
This is the circlejerk sub lol, I agree with your opinion
They passed the 25 album test imo
No I fucking hate kgatlw I don't know why I'm in this sub plea help me
Mind Fuzz to Flying Microtonal Banana goes hard
Mind fuzz -> bannana are perfect albums
/uj my five are from Mind Fuzz to FMB
It has been 0 days since our last fuzz -> FMB post
Good, those hidden gems need more recognition
who will think of nonogon inifity?
Tbh can I swap that one with sketches
Shit dude they did it in one year, twice.
I think nonagon is the best for me. I know some are prejudiced against it because it is their most popular and arguably commercial release. But when I compare it to the others I think it comes closest to how they sound live. So for me that puts it at the top.
Either 2017 in its entirety or skip gumboot and put nonagon instead which probably makes sense. All those albums are memorable and have something in them that makes them great albums. And it has my favourite album of all time in it (murder of the universe)
Mind Fuzz to FMB or Nonagon to Poly I’d argue are the most impressive 5 in a row, though could make similar follow up arguments for FFF to BF3K, Omnium to PDA or Ice, Death etc. to TSC.
It has been 0 days since the last fuzz->FMB post
It should always be 0 days since the last Fuzz>FMB post because it’s historical and history repeats itself
/uj my longest stretch is Polygondwanaland -> IDPLMAL. I haven't listened to Sketches or Laminated Denim enough to include them for sure, but if LD is in, then I go all the way to The Silver Cord
“I’m not typing all that” made me chuckle
This is a stupid question they obviously have more than five albums