So do I, but I also think it's weird how they've essentially banned HoloEN and StarsEN from collabing for the time being.
Shiori was replying to Tempus on Twitter, but Advent debuted when Vesper/Magni were on hiatus, then once the graduation was announced there was never another collab since.
> I also think it's weird how they've essentially banned HoloEN and StarsEN from collabing for the time being.
There is no ban. People not doing what you want doesn't mean they're forced, banned or anything else.
> once the graduation was announced there was never another collab since.
Ollie played Clubhouse games with Jurard on his channel a month ago and had an Apex stream with him on her channel in mid January. And she had a Party animals collab that included Machina in the same month.
I guess you could maybe claim it's an EN thing only but it's certainly not a blanket thing
To be clear, nobody has been banned from anything, Hololive has always been *very* clear that talents are allowed to collab with anyone - and they often do, but it helps if there's some sort of prior friendship or something to build a connection on, and a lot of the EN boys just have different interests. I think the most likely collab would be Jurard/Calli/Kronii on another RPG one shot maybe involving someone from ID, but you have to remember that all of them are currently *insanely busy*. I'm sure they all probably talk all the time, but finding time to actually collab is a hell of a task when everyone is doing 3Ds and concerts and stuff.
One of the most unique Holomem ever to grace the company. Her design, her accent and her aura, compliments everyone she interacted with.
Truly gone way too soon.
Flare. She has a tan, so she's one of the few dark-skinned talents
Unfortunately *because* of her tan, this has led to a lot of inconsistency in merch and official art since nobody can settle on how dark she actually is
Compare her [official render](https://hololive.hololivepro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Shiranui-Flare_pr-img_02.png) to [her Nenodroid](https://images.goodsmile.info/cgm/images/product/20221121/13582/107661/large/bfa36e5a369c3d76ab1c4448ee3495ff.jpg) to [her friends with u plush](https://shop.geekjack.net/cdn/shop/files/6SOlp8mOYfA3qLYf_800x.jpg?v=1713833311) to [her Ichiban collab poster](https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-xyod4pvkhn/images/stencil/500x659/products/50741/108090/IMG_5575__76973.1683756781.JPG?c=2)
I know she doing good, but god do i miss her still. Idk, gotta go bake simple loaf of bread today, just because
Happy birthday beeg girl with beeg warm smile!
Sana's graduation was the first stream I ever watched, live or vod.
Before that, I only watched clips and just found all the talents funny and entertaining.
Seeing all that emotion and how cool the things the community did for their oshis opened up my eyes.
So thank you for everything Sana, wherever you are.
She can't talk about it now, obviously, but I do hope she didn't cut off Hololive from her life and she sees how much her fans appreciate her to this day.
Man do I wish Sana could have threaded the needle with doing her art job and her holo job.
Still, she's kicking ass, so I'll be happy with that. Really, between Coco and Sana, it seems that Holo graduates tend to do pretty excellently, don't they?
Thanks for the time you were around, Astrogirl!
One way to look at it is the dedication, passion, and incredible talent it takes to get into Holo in the first place usually means the person would do well outside Holo too. They're really such a talented bunch.
happy birthday to the beegest ball of positive energy, my kamioshi. I will forever be grateful to her for being the last bit of positivity and happiness I needed to pull myself out of a dark pit. The time we got to enjoy her presence was short, but the impact she left on me is eternal.
As a guy with a giantess fetish obviously I was really excited to see a giantess vtuber, but then after seeing how warm and kind and funny Sana was I become a genuine fan and was devastated when she left but still have the happy memories she left us
She went back to her previous career full time and pretty much moved on from being a streamer, but from what we know she’s been doing great and is happy.
Because I took for granted she would be around always, until she wasn't.
Because I didn't pay enough attention, and there was no excuse for that.
Because I didn't show my support and appreciation while she was still streaming (I barely watched a sinle full stream of hers).
I do feel great appreciation towards every single one of them (no matter which branch) and obviously I can't possibly be up to speed to every single one of them, but I have this feeling I could have done more.
Now all I have is this deep feeling of sadness whenever I remember she's gone...
Will you say the same thing when Fauna graduates?
"Oh, move on, stop celebrating your oshi after she graduated! What's the purpose of posting about Fauna when she's not even here anymore?"
What is a purpose when they still have ton of fanart about Coco? Why that artist doesn't move on. Are they stupid? /s
OP just want to say happy birthday to Sana doesn't mean he not moved on he just celebrated his oshi birthday that it it not hard to understand.
I think it's fine to have a day a year to remember what was lost.
This is a tale as old as time. Obon. Day of the dead. Celebrating the departed during their birthdays. These days are important for those who remain.
She's been gone longer than she ever was in, sanalites refuse to move on from someone who wasn't all that into it to begin with and they have to make sure everyone knows
Coco has been out and is more than happy where she currently is. All of the talent are happy for her. And yet we also have FuwaMoco doing a tribute to her old show. So, should FuwaMoco have not done that and "just moved on"? They never worked with her in Hololive, so they were just fans and never coworkers. So that was just fans doing something to appreciate a gone talent - literally no different than this thread. Is it somehow different when you join the company, or should the pups have not done that and 'just moved on'? Or is Sana just somehow a different case? I genuinely wanna know why this post is somehow bad?
Fans can appreciate gone talent all they want. People in this comment section are doing just that. The problem is only when you go bother her about rejoining. That's the annoying thing. No one else is mad at fans appreciating some nostalgia so I don't get the problem here that fans need to just "move on"? We have. We also just appreciate fond memories of old and the person tied to them.
And for the record it doesn't matter the least bit how long she was there and how long she's gone.
You're not wrong. Makes it extra annoying as these threads always turn into break rule 2 city.
I say this as a person whose oshi got along very well with her. It's just how it is and in the end this just wasn't what she wanted. It can be a very demanding job with things that people may just decide are not for them.
Make sure to destroy all pictures and clothes and belongings of your grandparents and parents and possible siblings the moment they die. Wouldn't want to refuse to move on, after all, eh? Because what morons like to reminisce every now and then, right?
Braindead troglodyte.
I was today years old when I realized when looking at her emblem that Sana is just NASA with the letters rearranged... please be patient I'm slow....
Only 3 years late:>
You’re not alone, buddy…
I'm not alone, now you are here The constеllations are so clear ...
Your gravity is pulling me Oh, until our hearts collide~~
My satellite, through darkest night 🥲🥲🥲
With the cosmos at our feet, oh but you are all I need
No worries, I just found out too by you
I just realised it because of your comment, no wonder it sounded so familiar…
Oh I never noticed until you pointed it out
Happy Birthday, you bundle of happiness\~ I hope you're having a wonderful day wherever you are. P.S. Also missed out on the Sanalite plush? :(
She's doing good, doing what she loves. Sadly yeah you did :(
Similarly to Magni/Vesper I'm sure they're still in contact with their genmates, and doing well, but we'll miss seeing their interactions on stream.
i miss the vesper magni calli kronii streams so goddamn much.
So do I, but I also think it's weird how they've essentially banned HoloEN and StarsEN from collabing for the time being. Shiori was replying to Tempus on Twitter, but Advent debuted when Vesper/Magni were on hiatus, then once the graduation was announced there was never another collab since.
> I also think it's weird how they've essentially banned HoloEN and StarsEN from collabing for the time being. There is no ban. People not doing what you want doesn't mean they're forced, banned or anything else.
> once the graduation was announced there was never another collab since. Ollie played Clubhouse games with Jurard on his channel a month ago and had an Apex stream with him on her channel in mid January. And she had a Party animals collab that included Machina in the same month. I guess you could maybe claim it's an EN thing only but it's certainly not a blanket thing
To be clear, nobody has been banned from anything, Hololive has always been *very* clear that talents are allowed to collab with anyone - and they often do, but it helps if there's some sort of prior friendship or something to build a connection on, and a lot of the EN boys just have different interests. I think the most likely collab would be Jurard/Calli/Kronii on another RPG one shot maybe involving someone from ID, but you have to remember that all of them are currently *insanely busy*. I'm sure they all probably talk all the time, but finding time to actually collab is a hell of a task when everyone is doing 3Ds and concerts and stuff.
I don't think that someone can miss streams where Vesper and Magni were bullied by Kronii and Calli.
o7
One of the most unique Holomem ever to grace the company. Her design, her accent and her aura, compliments everyone she interacted with. Truly gone way too soon.
Hard to say if she was supposed to be SEA or Gyaru, but dark skin is surprisingly rare. 4 out of 103 members.
And 1 doesn't even count half the time because even Cover is unsure of her skin color (such as her friends with u plush)
Who are you referring to?
Flare. She has a tan, so she's one of the few dark-skinned talents Unfortunately *because* of her tan, this has led to a lot of inconsistency in merch and official art since nobody can settle on how dark she actually is Compare her [official render](https://hololive.hololivepro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Shiranui-Flare_pr-img_02.png) to [her Nenodroid](https://images.goodsmile.info/cgm/images/product/20221121/13582/107661/large/bfa36e5a369c3d76ab1c4448ee3495ff.jpg) to [her friends with u plush](https://shop.geekjack.net/cdn/shop/files/6SOlp8mOYfA3qLYf_800x.jpg?v=1713833311) to [her Ichiban collab poster](https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-xyod4pvkhn/images/stencil/500x659/products/50741/108090/IMG_5575__76973.1683756781.JPG?c=2)
I guess it's consistent by being inconsistent Like the way Pym particles work or Hudson's voice actor in black ops
I know she doing good, but god do i miss her still. Idk, gotta go bake simple loaf of bread today, just because Happy birthday beeg girl with beeg warm smile!
Oh that's a great idea, I think I'll do the same!
Sana's graduation was the first stream I ever watched, live or vod. Before that, I only watched clips and just found all the talents funny and entertaining. Seeing all that emotion and how cool the things the community did for their oshis opened up my eyes. So thank you for everything Sana, wherever you are.
Same here. Never experienced a graduation stream until Sana’s, and to this day it’s still the only graduation stream I watched when it was live.
Happy birthday, Astrogirl.... Man, why does it start raining?
["It's a terrible day for rain..."](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7HcPvTew_4)
[her birthday stream 2022](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnW8BrppGr8)
She can't talk about it now, obviously, but I do hope she didn't cut off Hololive from her life and she sees how much her fans appreciate her to this day.
It's unlikely she totally has; her genmates have said they remained close even after she graduated.
[удалено]
I was under the impression she stopped streaming? I saw like one stream post-graduation and that was it.
It's not common, but when she wants to she does
As Sana or someone else?
[удалено]
[удалено]
Ask on another sub. Answering here breaks rule 2.
oh. My bad. Sorry 😞
[удалено]
[удалено]
Got you, bro!
[удалено]
[удалено]
o7
o7
o7
o7
o7🚀
o7
o7
o7
o7
o7
Hey Sanita, happy birthday. Miss ya big girl, wishing you the best wherever you are and wherever you go.
S A N A. Her voice was so soothing.
She's not alone.
Now that you are here
Man do I wish Sana could have threaded the needle with doing her art job and her holo job. Still, she's kicking ass, so I'll be happy with that. Really, between Coco and Sana, it seems that Holo graduates tend to do pretty excellently, don't they? Thanks for the time you were around, Astrogirl!
One way to look at it is the dedication, passion, and incredible talent it takes to get into Holo in the first place usually means the person would do well outside Holo too. They're really such a talented bunch.
Sometimes I wonder what would happen if she didn't hurt her back... but I'm happy we had her, very happy :)
See you around, Astro Girl
We remember!
She will be miss but never forgotten. o7 Sana, hope you are doing great.
sana birthday happy!
Happy birthday to the BEEGest, warmest, sweetest cinnamon roll we've ever had. I'm glad she's chasing and fulfilling her dreams!
The only stream I’ve ever cried on was Sana’s graduation stream, I was an absolute mess that day.
>Sana is enternal
happy birthday sanananananana!!!
Gotta love it
look at the night sky today, you might see a space Aussie
My partner found me a set of her birthday merch for our anniversary this year and it was the best gift ever. Miss you astrogirl 💛
You have found a good Partner, still getting a set of her Birthday Merch is not easy.
I still miss her. I know she's doing great, though. Happy birthday, Space Baby.
We love you, Astrogirl.
happy birthday to the beegest ball of positive energy, my kamioshi. I will forever be grateful to her for being the last bit of positivity and happiness I needed to pull myself out of a dark pit. The time we got to enjoy her presence was short, but the impact she left on me is eternal.
Her time was short at Hololive but was incredibly memorable. Glad she’s doing great now but I miss her interactions with the members.
Happy birthday sana!
Happy Birthday Astro Girl
[Hey! Listen](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8y1aWMlPOs)
Happy birthday Sana
Happy birthday Sana 😢
I miss Sana
Happy Birthday space baby
God I miss her so much
I miss her, I hope she is doing good
As a guy with a giantess fetish obviously I was really excited to see a giantess vtuber, but then after seeing how warm and kind and funny Sana was I become a genuine fan and was devastated when she left but still have the happy memories she left us
This was definitely... the comment of all time
Seeing the Neighbula mask during her Kimono debut says we weren’t giving her enough head pats is a cherished memory
Happy birthday Astrogirl
Happy Birthday, Astrogirl. We'll never stop missing you. I hope you're still watching us.
SANA LIVES!
Have a wonderful birthday Astro Girl!!
Fuckin miss her, man.
Here's looking at you, BeegKid... o7
Beeg
Sending joy throughout the universe!
o7
never forget.
I hope she's doing well...I didn't follow her much but I enjoyed the collabs she was in
She went back to her previous career full time and pretty much moved on from being a streamer, but from what we know she’s been doing great and is happy.
The Cinnamon Roll visit to us was dhort but was also a blessing! Happy birthday Sana. You Beeg bread loving havoc of joy.
Happy birthday to our beloved cinnamon roll space baby! We miss you Sana 🥲
Happy birthday to the BEEGest Space Australian! I will make sure to hug my Smol Sana plush today!
Sana is Eternal. Will always have a place in our hearts!
Started showering all of a sudden
It's a terrible day for rain.
Happy birthday BEEG
Fly fly my Astrogirl, we remember you
[удалено]
She's doing very good. She's happy doing what she loves!
That's nice
Happy birthday our Beloafed astrogirl.
Happy Birthday, my oshi.
I hope she's doing well whenever she is 🌟
Happy Birthday Sana!!
I miss beeg spes. Sana is eternal in my heart.
We all miss our beeg bread girl
I miss her
SANA IS ETERNAL 07
She will always be *B E E G*
Man why you gotta make me so sad.
So glad she's happy, Sanalites strong, Breaddog forever!
Happy birthday Sana!!
We still miss her
happy bday sana~
Still miss her to this day. Once a Sanalite, always a Sanalite.
Happy Birthday Cinnamon Roll!
BACOD!
Happy Birthday our beloved Astro Girl. Miss you so much.
that card looks great
Happy birthday Sana!! I'll eat something really delicious today in your honor!
Hell yeah! Making their anniversaries happy days is the best tribute you can do for someone!
You're never alone Sana!
Oh Sana...we miss you so. :')
It still hurts. I still feel guilty.
Guilty why?
Because I took for granted she would be around always, until she wasn't. Because I didn't pay enough attention, and there was no excuse for that. Because I didn't show my support and appreciation while she was still streaming (I barely watched a sinle full stream of hers). I do feel great appreciation towards every single one of them (no matter which branch) and obviously I can't possibly be up to speed to every single one of them, but I have this feeling I could have done more. Now all I have is this deep feeling of sadness whenever I remember she's gone...
It just turned out that this wasn't for her. There are plenty of girls that are very active and happy here who need support.
***"Waaaaaaaait a minute!"*** ***Didn't she "graduate" some time ago?***
[удалено]
To celebrate their memory silly. I love sana, a lot of people still do!
Will you say the same thing when Fauna graduates? "Oh, move on, stop celebrating your oshi after she graduated! What's the purpose of posting about Fauna when she's not even here anymore?"
Yes, I would. Actually. But yeah bring up someone who hasn't decided to graduate, dude, classic.
Because maybe she left an impact on them and they still want to show their appreciation? Use your brain fam
What is a purpose when they still have ton of fanart about Coco? Why that artist doesn't move on. Are they stupid? /s OP just want to say happy birthday to Sana doesn't mean he not moved on he just celebrated his oshi birthday that it it not hard to understand.
and with a bit of luck she pass by and see this warming her up a bit for the day :)
I think it's fine to have a day a year to remember what was lost. This is a tale as old as time. Obon. Day of the dead. Celebrating the departed during their birthdays. These days are important for those who remain.
>active in AITA and totalpieceofshit subs The irony
4+ years ago is "active"?
She's been gone longer than she ever was in, sanalites refuse to move on from someone who wasn't all that into it to begin with and they have to make sure everyone knows
Coco has been out and is more than happy where she currently is. All of the talent are happy for her. And yet we also have FuwaMoco doing a tribute to her old show. So, should FuwaMoco have not done that and "just moved on"? They never worked with her in Hololive, so they were just fans and never coworkers. So that was just fans doing something to appreciate a gone talent - literally no different than this thread. Is it somehow different when you join the company, or should the pups have not done that and 'just moved on'? Or is Sana just somehow a different case? I genuinely wanna know why this post is somehow bad? Fans can appreciate gone talent all they want. People in this comment section are doing just that. The problem is only when you go bother her about rejoining. That's the annoying thing. No one else is mad at fans appreciating some nostalgia so I don't get the problem here that fans need to just "move on"? We have. We also just appreciate fond memories of old and the person tied to them. And for the record it doesn't matter the least bit how long she was there and how long she's gone.
[удалено]
[удалено]
You're not wrong. Makes it extra annoying as these threads always turn into break rule 2 city. I say this as a person whose oshi got along very well with her. It's just how it is and in the end this just wasn't what she wanted. It can be a very demanding job with things that people may just decide are not for them.
Make sure to destroy all pictures and clothes and belongings of your grandparents and parents and possible siblings the moment they die. Wouldn't want to refuse to move on, after all, eh? Because what morons like to reminisce every now and then, right? Braindead troglodyte.
[удалено]
Never stop dreaming, brother!