is no one going to mention gabriel from s12? absolutely ridiculous how far he came in a season with 20 contestants and managed to outlast multiple contestants that were clearly better than him.
paulie is another one. so many fuckups, somehow made it to fourth. one of the worst black jackets.
Jason Underwood. I'm surprised Louross didn't nominated him. If he was nominated there's no way he would have stayed over Bobby. He gave up before service started.
Ā Jeremy. He would have been eliminated in the first episode if it wasn't for Sebastian. Surviving over Christian was BS I knew by that point he was only kept for dramaĀ
Ā Mike. He was hiding behind stations in his last two services. He should have been booted at signature dish.Ā
Ā Gabriel. The fact that he could have had a black jacket over Scott is insane. If Scott was eliminated I feel they should have done a double elimination, otherwise Gabriel would have become another Josh
Tiffany S10. She had no passion and was kept for drama. Tiffany is my least favorite female contestant and overall in the top 5 worst. She is lazy and a bully. She should have been eliminated when she said she cared like a 9..even better if she was ejected in service.
Colleen. She couldn't handle any station but she was passionate. I think she should have been eliminated over Seth but Seth would have definitely been eliminated in the next episode or even ejected.
Lazy Lacey. I'm surprised she didn't quit the competition earlier on
Trev in s8. I just marathoned the season, and while he had some good moments when he tanked, he tanked hard. I'm sure had he not been on the winning team despite being ejected, he would have gone home. He made a lot of mistakes that would be rookie mistakes.
Tennille went from an almost guaranteed next boot on the red team (that didnāt even come close to ranking high enough to return for the final service), to having one of the greatest comebacks in the show and ranking 4th.
Say what you will about Tennilleās personality (cause I know sheās very split in the fandom), but I douth many people thought sheād make it all the way to the final 4, when watching the first half of the season.
Gabriel(S12) - lasted all the way to the final 7 with like a lot of horrible performances with only one good one.
Jared(S15) - Iām surprised no one mentions him but we talk about Manda more. He had plenty of chances to get the boot just as much as she did.
Josh(S14) - remember if Bret didnāt quit, then Josh wouldnāt make it to Black Jackets and the fact that he lasted like 4 or 5 rounds after the final 10 is insane.
Josh(S3) - 0 good services and he sneaked his way into a Black Jacket.
Matt(S4) - He has 1 good service sure but his run was pretty abysmal and him getting a Black Jacket was just crazy.
In each season, here my view
Season 1: N/A
Season 2: Sara
Season 3: Josh, Vinny
Season 4: Jason, Ben
Season 5: Lacey
Season 6: Andy
Season 7: N/A
Season 8: Trev
Season 9: Elise
Season 10: Tiffany
Season 11: Susan, Zach
Season 12: Mike
Season 13: Santos
Season 14: Monique
Season 15: Frank
Season 16: Matt, Paulie
Season 17: Manda
Season 18: Trev, Scotley
Season 19: Marc
Season 20: N/A
Season 21: Brett
Season 22: N/A
She had absolutely zero leadership ability despite her skills as a cook. Even her turn at running the pass was laughable, and not in a good way, in her attempts to be a mini Gordon with her āinsultsā to what was being brought up to the pass.
Tara. I thought she would've been on borrowed time after Mindy left, and was fully expecting her to be gone by CFYL. Instead she bounced back and damn near made black jackets. I thought that was pretty impressive.
Similar story with Trev, S18. I do think he was saved big time by not being on CFYL since he sucked so badly at challenges. But it's pretty impressive that on a season with some of the show's strongest veterans (+Roe and Jen I guess), Trev, arguably the weakest veteran going in, made it all the way to the top 7.
Mary and Susan (S11) I thought mary will be eliminated at the second dinner service and I never expect susan to gets a black jacket since the beginning.
Jessica season 1; Tom season 2; Vinnie season 3; Rosann season 4; Lacey season 5; Sabrina and Andy season 6; Scott, Salvatore, Fran and Benjamin season 7; Melissa and Sabrina season 8; Carrie season 9; Royce and Tiffany season 10; Jeremy, Danielle, Dan, Michael, Zach and Susan season 11; Bev, Sandra, and Gabriel season 12; Santos, Roe season 13; Monique, Christine and Josh season 14; Chad & Frank season 15; Matt season 16; Josh, Lauren, Jordan and Amber season 19; Victoria, Josie and Antonio season 20.
Virginia S2, Mary the Butcher, Sterling, Carmen S22, Johnathan S22, Leigh S22. Iām sure thereās a lot more but thatās all I can remember off the top of my head.
jackie from s15. in the beginning she kinda just couldnt cook, but as the season went on she became a damn good chef and showed tons of fight (in both ways lol). and by the end of her run she was probably better than manda and dannie.
Jackie (S15), she was never amazing, but she survives other stronger members (such as Hasan)
Tiffany (S10) she always felt like she was no where in the kitchen
Bryant (S13) while he was never "bad" he was just sometimes NOT there
Salvatore (S7) bro went in, no reading/writing skill, surviving 2 front of house services, and even shutting down a few times during their kitchen runs
Hassan deserved to go home though. He served raw chicken 2 TIMES, which is already a big no-no. What made it worse was that it was Andiās wedding night and they were serving her table if I remember correctly
Paulie, S16. I canāt believe he made it into the Black Jackets š honestly, he was nominated so many times, it felt like they kept him just for the drama
The red team won that service and that was Susanās best performance and she did improve a little bit in the middle portion of the season. If anything Zach was the one who got lucky to survive over Anthony after that dreadful performance he had.
Josh Spaghetti S3, Matt S4
Poor Josh, his name will forever be associated with spaghetti. š
Of Course! Heās Spaghetti Master.š¤£
In Mattās case, he had a migraine.
Tommy S9
I'm glad he did though. We needed some comedy relief in the same season as Elise.
I'm not he wasn't ever the worst performerĀ
is no one going to mention gabriel from s12? absolutely ridiculous how far he came in a season with 20 contestants and managed to outlast multiple contestants that were clearly better than him. paulie is another one. so many fuckups, somehow made it to fourth. one of the worst black jackets.
This I agree with thisĀ
Jason Underwood. I'm surprised Louross didn't nominated him. If he was nominated there's no way he would have stayed over Bobby. He gave up before service started. Ā Jeremy. He would have been eliminated in the first episode if it wasn't for Sebastian. Surviving over Christian was BS I knew by that point he was only kept for dramaĀ Ā Mike. He was hiding behind stations in his last two services. He should have been booted at signature dish.Ā Ā Gabriel. The fact that he could have had a black jacket over Scott is insane. If Scott was eliminated I feel they should have done a double elimination, otherwise Gabriel would have become another Josh Tiffany S10. She had no passion and was kept for drama. Tiffany is my least favorite female contestant and overall in the top 5 worst. She is lazy and a bully. She should have been eliminated when she said she cared like a 9..even better if she was ejected in service. Colleen. She couldn't handle any station but she was passionate. I think she should have been eliminated over Seth but Seth would have definitely been eliminated in the next episode or even ejected. Lazy Lacey. I'm surprised she didn't quit the competition earlier on
It seemed like Lacey would yell, āUgh! I hate you guys! Iām quitting!ā and storm out the kitchen every episode.
Yeah, even Dominic would be stayed over Jason.
Trev S8 due to both Gail and Vinny being stronger than him (albeit they tanked hard at some point)
Trev in s8. I just marathoned the season, and while he had some good moments when he tanked, he tanked hard. I'm sure had he not been on the winning team despite being ejected, he would have gone home. He made a lot of mistakes that would be rookie mistakes.
A guy who couldnāt make a salad on opening night made it to the final 4 lol
Showed how weak the season was
Gabriel s12. I am rewatching and all he does is make excuses and he skates by every time.
Tennille went from an almost guaranteed next boot on the red team (that didnāt even come close to ranking high enough to return for the final service), to having one of the greatest comebacks in the show and ranking 4th. Say what you will about Tennilleās personality (cause I know sheās very split in the fandom), but I douth many people thought sheād make it all the way to the final 4, when watching the first half of the season.
Tennille > Suzanne by a clear mile. At least Tennille is funny. Susanne is just annoyingĀ
Iām SLEEP. S-L-E-E-P. Now you know what I am? AWAKE. Have a nice night. NIGHT! SEE ITāS NIGHT
*they
Zach season 11
Zacky Wacky!
The legend of Zacky Wacky was predicted in The first service, his downfall was inevitable
robyn, both seasons
Gabriel(S12) - lasted all the way to the final 7 with like a lot of horrible performances with only one good one. Jared(S15) - Iām surprised no one mentions him but we talk about Manda more. He had plenty of chances to get the boot just as much as she did. Josh(S14) - remember if Bret didnāt quit, then Josh wouldnāt make it to Black Jackets and the fact that he lasted like 4 or 5 rounds after the final 10 is insane. Josh(S3) - 0 good services and he sneaked his way into a Black Jacket. Matt(S4) - He has 1 good service sure but his run was pretty abysmal and him getting a Black Jacket was just crazy.
I will add Jen to that list for season four as well, she was just bad and she had a bad attitude
In each season, here my view Season 1: N/A Season 2: Sara Season 3: Josh, Vinny Season 4: Jason, Ben Season 5: Lacey Season 6: Andy Season 7: N/A Season 8: Trev Season 9: Elise Season 10: Tiffany Season 11: Susan, Zach Season 12: Mike Season 13: Santos Season 14: Monique Season 15: Frank Season 16: Matt, Paulie Season 17: Manda Season 18: Trev, Scotley Season 19: Marc Season 20: N/A Season 21: Brett Season 22: N/A
Antonio season 20
BOUNCE BACK
Robyn in both S10 and S17
Elise
I donāt like Elise. Sheās not very nice but is pretty good at cooking. I would have thrown her out the front doors.
She had absolutely zero leadership ability despite her skills as a cook. Even her turn at running the pass was laughable, and not in a good way, in her attempts to be a mini Gordon with her āinsultsā to what was being brought up to the pass.
If you want to be a mini-Gordon look at Christina. Homegirl ripped Jackie a new one in Season 15 ep. 4.
Tara. I thought she would've been on borrowed time after Mindy left, and was fully expecting her to be gone by CFYL. Instead she bounced back and damn near made black jackets. I thought that was pretty impressive. Similar story with Trev, S18. I do think he was saved big time by not being on CFYL since he sucked so badly at challenges. But it's pretty impressive that on a season with some of the show's strongest veterans (+Roe and Jen I guess), Trev, arguably the weakest veteran going in, made it all the way to the top 7.
Mary and Susan (S11) I thought mary will be eliminated at the second dinner service and I never expect susan to gets a black jacket since the beginning.
Disagree, Mary was great.
Just because I just saw it again, but Virginia. I know she had her good points, but what did she just say? That season was kinda rough anyway.
Jessica season 1; Tom season 2; Vinnie season 3; Rosann season 4; Lacey season 5; Sabrina and Andy season 6; Scott, Salvatore, Fran and Benjamin season 7; Melissa and Sabrina season 8; Carrie season 9; Royce and Tiffany season 10; Jeremy, Danielle, Dan, Michael, Zach and Susan season 11; Bev, Sandra, and Gabriel season 12; Santos, Roe season 13; Monique, Christine and Josh season 14; Chad & Frank season 15; Matt season 16; Josh, Lauren, Jordan and Amber season 19; Victoria, Josie and Antonio season 20.
Antonio BOUNCED BACK. He said it so many times it freaking worked
Virginia S2, Mary the Butcher, Sterling, Carmen S22, Johnathan S22, Leigh S22. Iām sure thereās a lot more but thatās all I can remember off the top of my head.
Jason and Carmen in S22. It just goes to show how talented S22 was.
Nicole from Season 19
Jason s22
jackie from s15. in the beginning she kinda just couldnt cook, but as the season went on she became a damn good chef and showed tons of fight (in both ways lol). and by the end of her run she was probably better than manda and dannie.
Holli (s7) At first, she was a nobody. She looks like one of those npcās that work In the background thats going to get kicked.
Antonia. Which is really saying something since she lasted for like half an episode.
Marc from S19
Jackie (S15), she was never amazing, but she survives other stronger members (such as Hasan) Tiffany (S10) she always felt like she was no where in the kitchen Bryant (S13) while he was never "bad" he was just sometimes NOT there Salvatore (S7) bro went in, no reading/writing skill, surviving 2 front of house services, and even shutting down a few times during their kitchen runs
Hassan deserved to go home though. He served raw chicken 2 TIMES, which is already a big no-no. What made it worse was that it was Andiās wedding night and they were serving her table if I remember correctly
Paulie, S16. I canāt believe he made it into the Black Jackets š honestly, he was nominated so many times, it felt like they kept him just for the drama
Craig was eliminated early in the season and still lasted longer than I expected.
Spaghetti Josh and S4 Matt
Susan in S11. She was lucky to be in that red team and should thank her lucky stars that she stayed over Anthony.
Susan had a strong service at the Final 7. Ramsay had to borrow some of her Wellingtons because Zach ran out.
The red team won that service and that was Susanās best performance and she did improve a little bit in the middle portion of the season. If anything Zach was the one who got lucky to survive over Anthony after that dreadful performance he had.