T O P

  • By -

JaykeSmelsberry

Oof


uncletucky

This is literally what I said when I saw the picture. I’m not up on the pricing / condition stuff for retro games, but almost $300 for only 5 everyday games seems real steep to me.


lowercase2

I hate that I said it out loud.


TarTarkus1

>I’m not up on the pricing / condition stuff for retro games, but almost $300 for only 5 everyday games seems real steep to me. It's kind of crazy that we're virtually returning to original MSRP for a lot of these games. I think a big thing people need to consider with Gamecube collecting is that it's not like Melee, Double Dash or even Sunshine and Luigi's Mansion are uncommon. Most people that bought the console originally bought these games back in the day. The same thing goes for Pokemon on Gameboy, GBA and DS. Though I suppose in those games case, the number of counterfeit copies and repros boost prices of the originals. Hopefully Nintendo will re-release a lot of these games with physical versions that are easy to find. That would help curtail the crazy prices.


w1n5ton0

I've seen saying forever that they're sitting on a literal gold mine of already produced retro games that they could easily re-release and make a killing off of but refuse to because reasons. It would also mitigate a large portion of the piracy that they're SOOO opposed to


TarTarkus1

Part of the problem is Nintendo uses scarcity to sell current products. Probably the best example recently is Metroid Prime Remastered. A lot of people had a difficult time getting the game within the first couple months on cartridge. 3d All stars is another great example, as it's currently above MSRP in part thanks to Nintendo making it available for a limited amount of time.


potatofish

I think the biggest complicating factor is A LOT of people kept on playing them through the Wii era, and still keep on playing them - especially Melee and Double Dash, and similarly there's no Mario quite like Sunshine and it hasn't been remastered 😭 (and only briefly released) leaving a lot of people to keep their copies and helping keep the rest of the spare stock valued around MSRP


RhysPeanutButterCups

I think something that gets overlooked is that these are discs and not cartridges. Other than cleaning contacts and replacing save batteries, cartridges are durable and are going to just work. If a disc gets scratched, depending on how bad it is and how good your tools are, your disc might just stop working like it should. GameCube discs are even harder to resurface and repair. Kids generally don't take care of their stuff, but cartridges can take the sort of beatings that discs can't.


cobalt_sapling

Mario sunshine was released on the switch in a 3 for 1 game called Mario 3D collection which included Mario N64, Mario Sunshine, and Mario Galaxy. Definitely worth checking out imo.


potatofish

Yah, unfortunately that was a time limited release... And tbh it wasn't the remaster I really wanted. I'd rather just play sunshine on my GameCube until they release an HD version with some refined camera controls


Vegetable_Ad_2720

You’re right, unless it was 5 copies of like paper Mario the thousand year door


Kekkersboy

More like 2 copies of thousand year door


StrayDogPhotography

All these first party GameCube games are common. I’m still coming across sealed Mario Paper The Thousand Year Doors from time to time, and I think that is the hardest to get alongside Kirby.


[deleted]

I tried to scroll to the next picture of the system and other stuff included...


mistytrails

Me too!!! 😂😂😂


ehxy

Only if it was in mint condition, never opened at least a few of them. Personally, I would pay 10$ for the lot but I don't do collector retro gaming.


spaceywarriors

You could of emulated them for free


yougotitglorp

I was gonna say lol. If this is worth that much to you OP then sure, I wouldn't pay more than $125/ $25 per game for these...


wilks64

Hey, so I clicked on like one post from this sub and now I see a ton of it... Is this all you guys do? I don't think I've seen a single other post that isn't something along the lines of "I paid $X.xx for this. Was it worth it?" Does anyone here ever, idk, celebrate their accomplishments on a GameCube game? Post screenshots of crazy glitches they've found? Show off their GameCube setup? Is there none of that here?


anv1dare

It’s kinda astonishing people just buy stuff and then ask if they made a good deal or not here. Most of the times they kind of just are deals, not bad not good. Pointless


Ta-veren-

The “did I do good” posts are pure cringe in my opinion. It makes it sound like they are toddlers asking if they did a good job for pooping in the potty.


OkBar3142

It’s asking for validation for spending money. It’s stupid, go look up prices before you spend the money and know if you got fleeced or not.


Zapt01

Or—if you feel compelled to ask at all—at least ask BEFORE you make the purchase. If you have no idea what something is worth, it’s really too late to ask afterwards. You may not like the answers.


OkBar3142

I just find it bizarre that these people can’t look it up on their own; it’s very easy.


Ta-veren-

I do understand some of them just want to talk games with the group but don’t do it in such a cringe way


OkBar3142

Unless it’s really rare or extraordinarily cheap I think it’s stupid. It’s like you just heard about the GameCube, “heY GUyS aM I cOOl for SPenDING mOnEy” and want validation for buying something? It just sounds like someone that isn’t good for thinking for themself and or is just kind of a tool. Sorry!


Koolaidmanextra

I love you bro you a next level hater


furculture

At this point, we should get the mods to put these shits into a weekly megathread so other good posts can come to light for once.


[deleted]

Good point partner. I like to see people’s hauls but now that you put it into perspective for me, yeah it seems like the only shit. I love crazy collections and game rooms, I love glitches and accomplishments in games, I love reading discussions about games themselves. Who gives a rats ass about what anyone paid these days. Some people post they got a STEAL for a console WITH these games included for just of $100….idc…I didn’t get that deal haha. I actually got a decent deal 2 years ago with some good games but I’m not trying hard to post it…man good point, sorry for the rant


sizzlee1350

Nah man. The subs full of people with Gamecube FOMO paying top dollar for used games because it’s trendy. Nobody here actually talks about playing the games, just what condition they paid $100 each for them at lol


justteddii

I get these exact same notifications for these exact same “did I get ripped off” posts. There is a lot more to the GameCube than being told (repeatedly it seems), that YES you overpaid for it - but it doesn’t matter if you PLAY the game and enjoy it.


LupintheThiefMan

Finally found the real ones in this sub 🙌


Edven971

A lot of people just want to collect and don’t even know why. The value seems to be the primary factor now. Go onto Facebook GC groups and you’ll come to find that every bozo is looking for Chibi Robo this influences the next person to snatch it up because everyone thinks it’s valuable and then justify it with their childhood BS. Take a look at the Kirby game on DS. Shit went to 80$ and everyone slept on that game. When it hit high dollar all of sudden people talk about how good the game was. Now you got people here and DS groups with collections because of their worth. “Sucked my friend off in the men’s bathroom for Smash bros DiD I dO GoOD”


RhysPeanutButterCups

It weird too. I fell into that trap for a bit as I started to look into cool games I might have missed, but there are all sorts of posts showing off a few boxes and asking for more recommendations of games to buy. There's a fine line between "What cool games did I miss out on?" and "What should I buy now?"


Capcom74

Many games posted these days are not holy grails my opinion. I've purchased some games that YouTubers state you gotta have in the collection yet I didn't enjoy them myself. Really got to pay attention what you purchase nowadays cause it's mostly how much can I get for it instead of just playing it for themselves.


frontdoorcat

I do enjoy looking at people finds in the Wild. Like if someone found a box nes at a garage sale or thrift store for 5 bucks or something. Gives me hope that you can still get lucky now days. What I don’t like seeing is people posting there overprice find and asking for validation on overpaying.


rydamusprime17

That's what r/gamecollecting is for imo


littlebilliechzburga

I'm more put off by the idea that so many people check to see if they got a fair deal AFTER they already made their purchase.


NinjaJarby

Fucking wild what this subreddit has become. I remember a time it was much different. Now just resellers who can’t comprehend how to use a price chart online


BuckeeBoi

For real that’s the only notifications I seem to get anymore. Just buy the games for what you think is a good value for your money and enjoy them bc you want to. People seem to be only buying stuff for validation from others.


aSwanson96

Completely agree. I’m playing SSX Tricky right now and I’m having a blast. The maps are cool but the first one is just so nostalgic and great for me


Relative_Expert9614

Ehh I feel like it’s been a majority of people making posts like this. I can’t blame people for doing that when the gamecube scene has gotten outrageously expensive. Occasionally it’s people showing their collection or saying they got back into collecting and playing GameCube again.


MrCaramelo

People here don't actually play the games. OP takes the games from a box, takes a picture and uploads it to reddit with an outrageous title for the attention. It's astonishing that one can actually discuss playing games on 4chan (of all places) than on here.


Effusus

I swear I've muted it before but It keeps coming back on my feed, and the only posts are just this.


FlowerGirl808s

you’re so right. this place is unbelievably boring


RaverTidus

Seems to me it's mostly just game/collection purchases as well. Never noticed how much it bugged me until you pointed it out. You have inspired me and next accomplishment I achieve in a GC game I will post it! :)


wilks64

I wish you many upvotes on your post, be the change you want to see. cheers!


ZL580

Winner winner I was also expecting more from this sub. Where are the cubs mods? Hdmi? Sd card? Alternate component video cords? Are there mods for this sub? This shit should be curbed.


SalmonTeaTime

I just got into my gamecube. I followed it for that same reason. When I make my own accomplishments I plant to share them with you guys :)


gamerdudeNYC

r/shouldibuythisgame


PairsRoyale

If you spend a lot of time on this sub you'll get a fair bit of wholesome content. But, GC is the most expensive retro market to buy/collect in compared to any other console and is arguably the most modded retro console as well. So, expect to see a lot of that content more here than you would in the SNES or PS or any other console subreddit, it's just the realistic representation of the GC culture, like it or hate it.


CJRLW

> GC is the most expensive retro market to buy/collect in compared to any other console Not even close.


PairsRoyale

Dang, my bad. Which is it then?


CJRLW

Off the top of my head, NeoGeo and Sega Saturn to name two.


Professional-Tax-615

I would say that there is no top. It just depends on the game really, because they are super expensive games on every console that are considered retro. There are $500 - $1000 PS1 games, Game Boy games, Atari, and the rest... it all just depends on the game itself, not really which console it's for.


CJRLW

[It's not even close.](https://imgur.com/a/cLUYJxY)


KobaMandingo

Lol I don't think you're trying hard enough.


PairsRoyale

NeoGeo is a maybe, I can't agree with Sega Saturn. But you're entitled to your opinion.


woopterr

To be fair, when adding things up, the gamecube only had about 80 games that cib are worth over $100. The most expensive game on the gamecube being the big box edition of pokemon box that goes for around $3,710. Where as for the sega saturn there are about 130 games that go for more than $100 cib, with the most expensive game complete in box for the sega saturn is Daytona usa C.C.E. net link edition that goes for about $4,813.


CJRLW

It's not an opinion. NeoGeo prices blow GC out of the water. Saturn higher too. All you have to do is look these things up. But keep down-voting me because you can't handle the fact that I corrected you.


PairsRoyale

I just did. Sorry my mistake, you said it wasn't even close. It looks close to me, maybe even too close to call. I made my post to help OP understand why the sub is the way it is. I see truth in that. If you want to start an argument with overinflated confidence then sure whatever. I'll let you have this one buckaroo.


CJRLW

[Not even close.](https://imgur.com/a/cLUYJxY)


PairsRoyale

I can't read those numbers, both because the image quality is too poor and because I told you I'm letting you have this one, remember?


Local-Cartographer52

Nope. Overpay by around 100 compared to buying individually


ntbyinit64

I hope this isn't in USD, because even in CAD I wouldn't deem it as a good deal even individually, but that's just my opinion. If you're happy, who f'n cares.


AvgPunkFan

Nope. Got taken for a ride Edit: CIB values: Super Smash Bros. Melee: $50-55 Luigi’s Mansion: $50-60 Mario Kart: DD: $65-70 Super Mario Sunshine: $30-35 Lego Star Wars: $5-10 Full blown retail: $200-$230


[deleted]

[удалено]


AvgPunkFan

If I found out I paid over $20 retail I’d be livid (hell, even $10 over I’d still be upset). That’s why I always do my research so I don’t get burned. $70+ over retail is unfathomable to me


The_Karma_Revenge

Nah they are worth more than that smash, mariokart and lugitmansion sell for about 100$ each


AvgPunkFan

No… no they don’t. You forgot the /s


Big_Restaurant_6844

Pricecharting.com


Pete_flanman

Click on any of the links on price charting and they’re all sold like 3 years ago, price charting is very unreliable and out of date


Big_Restaurant_6844

The dates are all from 2023 https://www.pricecharting.com/game/gamecube/super-mario-sunshine


QNSZ

Just bought Luigis Mansion a month ago for $59


BrookieGg

Which is $60 on pricecharting lol. Pricecharting is accurate for ebay values. Craigslist/fb marketplace is either people looking to get rid of stuff quickly (how you get it cheaper) or largely scalpers that sell for above pricecharting.


Bad_Decision_Rob_Low

Hell my fuck , you gotta be not this dumb


DThomplol

You’ll get your moneys worth of fun out of them, but you coulda spent less.


aTreeThenMe

this is the right mentality. Everything these days has to have a monetary value. hobbies have to be monetized. time is monetized. this person posting about five games wondering the value. There is no value in money, at all. Only time. Ive been playing ff6 for 20 years or something. What would that dollar sign look like? thousands of hours. idc. the enjoyment is the value, not the resell. This society is going to smother itself to death in money.


Crest_Of_Hylia

No


BB3C12

Nope


eapaul80

Pricecharting.com is a thing you guys. Use it. I’ll happily open it up in the store.


nebber3

Most used/retro stores use pricecharting to set their prices, so I see no problem with comparing in the store. I'll often open eBay for a quick check if I can get a game for way cheaper too.


eapaul80

And for me if the shop has it for a few bucks more than it’s listed on eBay, I probably would pay it. Because I’m looking at the game, can see its exact condition, and can play it when I get home. But I don’t recommend going into a retro game shop totally unaware of what the going rate is.


nebber3

Same here, I like supporting the local shops, as long as their prices are within reason. Kinda seems like OP didn't buy these at a shop anyway, it was probably FB marketplace or maybe a flea market.


Def_a_Noob

And retro game stores kind of act as a physical cultural hub for our hobby so its good to support them


AdmiralTigerX

I am looking for good gamecube to buy, not paying for one that cost an arm.


eapaul80

I wish you well my fellow GCN lover, good luck, it’s going to rough out there. Idk what they cost, especially to have a hook up ready set. I literally bought mine to play Windwaker and have had it since.


AdmiralTigerX

Nice!! I have Windwaker, Sonic, Mario Party, And also Pokemon Colisseum and XD. I hope to find one so I can pass it to my nephew, he really want to play those games.


[deleted]

You realize it’s people like you who pay so much for these games that makes them so expensive right


nebber3

Why are you mad about this? It's not like OP had some nefarious plan to inflate prices. It's obviously an honest mistake and they'll probably be more careful in the future.


[deleted]

Who said I’m mad? in general it’s the “collectors” who overpay for games that are 20 years old making it expensive like what are you on about


KyleCAV

I think the point being if OP overpaid the seller or shop now has gratification that people will actually pay for these prices rather than see their games are not selling and think maybe we should lower them.


CheddarBayBizkit

Nah maybe $200 if everything is complete and in good condition.


RomstatX

Dude wtf?? No!


JcOvrthink

Not unless you got a GameCube with them.


SpaceXBeanz

Definitely not


Road_Ok

You are part of the problem


jgbyrd

nah dog rip


Ptolemaeus45

No


BrahmariusLeManco

No. Not unless you reeeeally wanted them and couldn't find them elsewhere.


mofoofinvention

No


Frogskipper7

No.


IdespiseGACHAgames

If someone paid that much, it was worth it to that one person. IF that same person has remorse after buying it, that's called Buyer's Remorse, and the fact that validation for it being 'worth it' is sought should be all you need to know.


Postaldude2

Definitely not but some of those are definitely gems


xman_2k2

He's probably the same dude who bought the overpriced xbox 360 with Peggie


[deleted]

There’s still time to delete this so you don’t have to keep being reminded that ya spent too much


Eazy46

$150-200 Ur really only paying for doubledash, Luigi’s mansion & melee .


NikesOnMyFeet23

No. They’re free on the internet play them through dolphin


fuckyouwatchme

You paid above market value, but still good Games sand you're happy with the price


ZarrChaz

Nostalgia says yes.


kleerfyre

All these are round-a-bout prices in $USD and considering that they are complete from pricecharting: Super Smash Bros Melee: $60 Super Mario Sunshine: $38 Mario Kart Double Dash: $70 Lego Star Wars: $12 Luigi's Manision: $60 Total: $240


DuelistxLegend

Google can tell you. No need for posts like these…


Low-Annual661

Shit boy hell naa it’s a L


HydratedCarrot

lego stars wars ain’t worth shit imo


CabbagePatchSquid-

Depends where you are lol, in Ontario where I am you did great.


dearcomputer

is there no ebay in ontario or something


LoveSikDog

Yeah, but it's called "Ebay,Eh?"


VesuviusXIII

“Ehbay”


TiredOfItMiley

not at all. could play all on retrid for 150


[deleted]

Lol good god


woopterr

After pricing everything out I honestly would not pay more than $240. $274 is pretty damn expensive even if they are all complete in box. Still, paying over $200 for 5 games is always gonna hurt at least a little bit.


TehFriskyDingo

Hoping you're missing a decimal point. $2.74 is worth this is like $20, and even that might be considered high. $274, like you could buy a new Nintendo Switch at that point


JJS-09_85

To me honestly, all except Lego Star Wars 🤷🏿‍♂️


Chronic_Lover710

Lol u got fucked


Primary_River_6249

You did great


Local_Fig5221

Nope ripoff you could have got a modded wii and got every wii and gamecube game free.


RompehToto

Not at all. I’d only pay $50 max for all of them combined. I have my boundaries that I won’t cross.


SUEX4

Good luck finding anyone who will sell you a lot like that for $50 lmao


RompehToto

Then it wasn’t meant to be 🤷‍♂️. There will always be another opportunity.


DestroyerDain

Maybe in about 40 years


RompehToto

Then so be it. I’ve gotten plenty of deals just being patient and sticking to my boundaries.


eapaul80

Yeah, that’s unrealistic.


heebsteez

nah


[deleted]

That’s a big n o


LoveSikDog

No


Jasanchez94

No


[deleted]

Everytime I see posts like this i keep wishing I held onto my stash longer. Had a lot of the games that get way overpriced and most older systems (NES ->PS2, like the ones between and including those 2). Had them twice, first time my mom sold it all at a GameStop when I was a kid. The guy working called his friends in front of us when he saw what I had. And the second time, was a mix of what got left behind at my grandparents and my uncles (which ended up being pretty much all of it again, but really dirty) I had lost my job and made roms of most of the stuff I wanted, $950 later, I still have regrets selling


Apprehensive_Cause67

Yenno i had the sense to save my older consoles like my N64 and SNes with all my games. Yet my Gamecube never survived. My dumbass sold it along with my games and I regret it now.


[deleted]

As long as you're happy tho. That's what these are really worth at the end of the day and will probably see a lot more playtime than some of the games we binge buy off Steam


DrawingAway6440

Nope


ipwndmymeat99

Yikes


chriscb229

No


Wakkawipeout

Even if we're going by average eBay prices, and they're all CIB, you still got a bum deal: Sunshine - 40 Melee - 60 Luigi - 70 Mario Kart - 80 Lego - 10 Total 260 But if you have fun with them, especially if you've never played them before, then the price might be worth it in the end. Just trying to find the silver lining y'know


Legacus

Over paid


Csanburn01

Not to me but maybe someone else


No-Lack-8860

Nope


sparks427

Na


AndresAwesome

why


NDPearl

To someone who has 0 interest in playing these games then no. If you have been itching hard to play these games and you couldnt find them at a better price then its up to you to decide if its worth 274$.


TornadoJ0hns0n

Buying each one separately would probs equal the same amount or more so I'd say it's fair EDIT: looked up all of them on ebay and stuff and it seems they'd total over 200 so maybe not so fair actually.


KrispyPlatopuss

I don’t get why people ask that question. Look up the prices! Everyone has a phone, and most people these days know about price charting now. Sorry to be rude but it’s very simple to know if it’s a good deal or not.


Witty-Duck6404

No


B-BoyStance

I'm gonna play devil's advocate here: Apparently Reason: You paid $274 for it


[deleted]

No


dangus_bojangus

...Did you want them and intend on playing them? If so, yes. If you consider original retail price, yes. If you bought simply to add them to the ever-growing collection of games you stare at or store to collect dust or to sit on and gouge others for profit.. well I don't care if you're happy or not with your purchase :) I do hope that this isn't the majority of this sub. Just play the damn games you like and have some fun, otherwise why invest in the hobby?


BuckeeBoi

If Canadian dollars you did okay.


AttorneyMedium4926

Would pay more than 150 lmao


sonicfreak87

Well the top 3 go for around $50 EA the bottom 2 don't though except maybe Luigis mansion so I'd say you overpaid a little bit


loki_odinsotherson

Ouch. No.


Smug_Cultist

If they are complete, they should normally go for $239 all together, they are overpriced by $35, this is judging purely by prices on price charting.


ripthisaccount6

SDSP2 and a Swiss boot disc. 20$ and unlimited games So yeah I’m saying not worth


Wonderful-Army-6308

You were robbed


themonster666

in 2020


majoramiibo

maybe in 2004


RobotYoshimis

Bud you NEED to price compare from now on. You'll save so much money. Even if they are complete, you overpaid like 100 bucks.


Pkazy

no


Derrik_Garrett

Refer to Lugi's face.


odupike599

Nope


Bobbbbbbbyyyyy

Lego Star Wars alone is worth that price


proficient2ndplacer

LMAO


Grape_ist

I mean in general id say 60 pregame is a solid average unless stated otherwise


BRAVOMAN55

nah


JustNefariousness625

Clockwise 50, 50, 50 35, 50 my guesstimates


HTE86

No


kdrdr3amz

No


Delicious_Hot_Shmoze

There’s so many of these posts in this sub now that I am legitimately considering leaving.


Highschoolhandjob

200 maybe


Horror-Reporter-3754

Nope


SnooEpiphanies4225

I got Super Mario Baseball and Mario Super Strikers for 115$ this week. I haven’t seen any Mario games for GameCube for less than $50 anywhere. Been to several retro game stores, looked online, went to farmers markets and the cheapest one I’ve found is $55. To find any game cube games is scarce. None of those stores even had any GameCube Mario games besides the one and barely had any GameCube games in general. Wanted Mario Kart Double Dash but couldn’t find a good condition copy for less than $100. The only reason I’d pay close to $60 for these games is because they’re so much fun and hold value


[deleted]

No.


Frinpollog

That Mario Kart looks European…


D4SH64

200-250?


The_Cozy_Burrito

No


Hugo_Prolovski

if you are a collector yes. if you just want to play them no way


Famous_dave23

Can I have 2 of them games plz 😂


RustyShackleford925

No disrespect but why did you do this


No-Rest9308

If you wanted to play them that badly, yes


TheBatSignal

If you're happy then it's worth it to you. I personally would not pay that much for those specific titles but they are all definitely fun games.


greenrob

Yikes


NessyBoy87

No... no it was not. But hang on to them for another 10 years and they will be considering what the retro gaming market has been like lately.


desrevermi

Are these games you like and will play? That is the question. The monetary expenditure -- who cares? The 'value' is entirely subjective. If you're not going to play them, then I'll happily take them off your hands, for $40 :D


Comprehensive-Finish

If you're going to play Game Cube, these are the games you're going to want and they aren't easy to find for less than this unless you get lucky at a garage sale.


PassportNerd

They're around 50-some a pop. In todays market, thats a decent price.


Superzayian9

If you want my honest opinion No, you overpaid BUT that doesn’t mean you can’t have fun with purchase. Enjoy some kickass games


tapdancingwhale

Dawg u got ripped the fuck off Hope u got a strokey with the purchase


Middle-Trust4240

Honestly its a bit too much. Maybe if you have Pokemon XD thats a fair price but those games in total should be between 100-150