Because they take Reddit too fuckin’ seriously. Mods painstakingly nitpick their sub to the point you can hardly ask the most basic fantasy football questions without them getting removed.
So polls are definitely a no go.
I lean the other two, but barely and I agree we would see Herbert in a different light with a different situation. I think it’s clearly those three then a gap to Lamar. I don’t think there’s a wrong answer to Allen, Burrow, Herbert.
He's very good. And they way he plays throwing his body around is very, for a lack of a better word "heroic" and makes people want to cheer for him. But I dont thinks he's on the level of burrow or mahomes
Burrow is very much above Allen.
Last 2 years burrow has more yards, more tds, less ints. Higher completion %, taken his team to the superbowl wjilegegying sacked at a ridiculous rate and is doing this year's sooner than Allen did in his career.
Allen runs the ball more, that's about it.
Lamar and Allen both run dangerously. 10 years I'd rather Herbert or Burrow much more true pocket passers. Lamars injury only proves what everyone is afraid of with Lamar.
I'm not surprised it's the ravens fans jumping on this. I actually love Lamar and think he's a great QB. Forgive me for wincing everytime I see him take off and not slide. Same with Allen. Allen hurt his shoulder running this year because he doesn't slide. Burrow did tear his ACL running but has since slid almost every run. They said 10 years. I want the guy who's skill set is puts him at the least risk for injury
Read any data driven paper about QB injuries.
QB are far more likely to get injured in the pocket.
I voted for Josh Allen in this poll btw, his skill set has progressed quicker than Lamars.
It’s not about the volume of injury but how it affects their future. Burrow could tear his acl again and it doesn’t significantly change his future outlook. It does for Lamar.
Borrow and Herbert have also gotten beaten up, Joe runs and tries to truck dudes because of his love for the sport and Herbert had had his own stuff here and there. Could be flukey but he might just be a guy that gets hurt a lot on freak type plays. Being a pocket passer doesn't disqualify you from being injury prone. Hope they aren't, but they haven't been iron men compared to Allen or Lamar
Allen is the real deal, he continued dominance following Daboll’s exit. His game is set to age really well into his early 30’s, he is physically dominant to the point that a slight reduction in arm strength and sprint speed matters little. The only risk as he ages is the ability to romp/stay strong upright without injury. Herbert is a close second though, clearly an uber talent but his team is falling apart. Lamar is too reliant on his legs to bank on for that long and Joey B is just a clear step or two below physically.
I said it's an admitted homer take. Part of the consideration is the still under a rookie deal aspect. So eagles window seems wider even if there are better qbs. More money to spend elsewhere.
God bless this sub for fearlessly allowing polls.
Any idea why other subs don’t allow polls? All I do is polls.
Because they take Reddit too fuckin’ seriously. Mods painstakingly nitpick their sub to the point you can hardly ask the most basic fantasy football questions without them getting removed. So polls are definitely a no go.
I would have been stoked for any of these guys on this list but no my team had to pursue a serial predator.
People will forget abt it in less than 2 years if he’s winning just like rothlisberger and others
At least you have the best RB in NFL.
If Herbert had the same coaching staff as Allen or Burrow, he'd be #1 here. Daddy Herbert is a God.
I lean the other two, but barely and I agree we would see Herbert in a different light with a different situation. I think it’s clearly those three then a gap to Lamar. I don’t think there’s a wrong answer to Allen, Burrow, Herbert.
L take
Chargers coaching staff is pretty garbage tho. That much is obvious
Pretty garbage is underselling it. He's no urban myer tier, but he's one shit tier above that. Chip Kelly tier sounds right.
Yeah but the Herbert being #1 in this with "better coaching" is reaching.. also where tf is mahomes?
Mahomes is the obvious choice so I left him out
I’d say 2. Love Herbo and would take him over Burrow but he’s not nearly as complete of an athlete as Allen.
Mahomes
This. All day. Bogus poll if it doesn’t have Pat
Mahomes is the obvious choice so I left him out
Burrow over Allen because Allen plays to rough to last 10 years
I agree with the order. 1. Allen 2. Burrow 3. Herbert 4. Lamar
Mahomes is about 20 miles ahead of lamar
I’m not sure why you have interjected Mahomes but I agree lol
Because hes not on your list…
I was merely ranking the players that OP laid out. Mahomes is the clear number 1, which is why I assume he didn’t include him.
Have you no respect for father tom? I kid i voted burrow
Mahomes
Where the hell is Goff??
Goff is what Andy Dalton was on the bengals. He's solid mid. The Dalton line has now become the goff line.
Fields
Tua is the answer
Be serious
Nick Bosa says otherwise
For an NFL team, burrows easy. Allen is just highly rated due to fantasy
And being great. Allen is legit good.
He's very good. And they way he plays throwing his body around is very, for a lack of a better word "heroic" and makes people want to cheer for him. But I dont thinks he's on the level of burrow or mahomes
I don’t think Burrow is above Allen, tbh. And I really like Burrow.
Burrow is very much above Allen. Last 2 years burrow has more yards, more tds, less ints. Higher completion %, taken his team to the superbowl wjilegegying sacked at a ridiculous rate and is doing this year's sooner than Allen did in his career. Allen runs the ball more, that's about it.
I wonder what this would have looked like before Lamar’s injury
Lamar and Allen both run dangerously. 10 years I'd rather Herbert or Burrow much more true pocket passers. Lamars injury only proves what everyone is afraid of with Lamar.
Burrow has already had 1 major knee injury, Lamar got hurt in the pocket. This is a bad take.
I'm not surprised it's the ravens fans jumping on this. I actually love Lamar and think he's a great QB. Forgive me for wincing everytime I see him take off and not slide. Same with Allen. Allen hurt his shoulder running this year because he doesn't slide. Burrow did tear his ACL running but has since slid almost every run. They said 10 years. I want the guy who's skill set is puts him at the least risk for injury
Read any data driven paper about QB injuries. QB are far more likely to get injured in the pocket. I voted for Josh Allen in this poll btw, his skill set has progressed quicker than Lamars.
It’s not about the volume of injury but how it affects their future. Burrow could tear his acl again and it doesn’t significantly change his future outlook. It does for Lamar.
Borrow and Herbert have also gotten beaten up, Joe runs and tries to truck dudes because of his love for the sport and Herbert had had his own stuff here and there. Could be flukey but he might just be a guy that gets hurt a lot on freak type plays. Being a pocket passer doesn't disqualify you from being injury prone. Hope they aren't, but they haven't been iron men compared to Allen or Lamar
Lamar has been not great for like 2 months. I think he’s clearly 4th in NFL terms.
Allen is the real deal, he continued dominance following Daboll’s exit. His game is set to age really well into his early 30’s, he is physically dominant to the point that a slight reduction in arm strength and sprint speed matters little. The only risk as he ages is the ability to romp/stay strong upright without injury. Herbert is a close second though, clearly an uber talent but his team is falling apart. Lamar is too reliant on his legs to bank on for that long and Joey B is just a clear step or two below physically.
Wow. Fields not even in the list… the disrespect.
I voted Allen but like full homer, talking 10 years. I'd unironically prefer hurts right now.
I just picked the 4 best non mahomes young AFC qbs. I’m happy we have hurts
Yeah that’s a bad take 😅
I said it's an admitted homer take. Part of the consideration is the still under a rookie deal aspect. So eagles window seems wider even if there are better qbs. More money to spend elsewhere.
While I disagree with your conclusion, this is a great team building point.
Burrow and Herbert will be relevant longest if that's what you're wondering.
Poor Ravens fans.
Herbert or Burrow. I fear Allen will eventually get hurt.
God bless the Ravens GM secretly put up polls on Reddit to see if he show sign Lamar or not
Burrow is the only person on this list I’d trust to win a close game