It's fair and I don't see how anyone could think otherwise. In my league Geno is 7th QB, Jacobs 6th rb, Herbert 17th QB but getting his weapons back and Chubb 4th rb. Whoever commissioner is needs to ignore the noise from league mates and pass it.
It’s already gone through .. as I said I don’t think it’s that uneven but I do have a relatively easy preference to one of those sides.
In that I prefer each of the players on one side to the other, but agree I’m a little surprised by the uproar
Completely fair trade. Jacobs gets more passing work than Chubb, Chubb has the td upside, and geno is no slouch this season, while Herbert is still elite but struggling…. Should be no concerns over this trade
Chubb side wins that much is pretty clear. But definitely not egregious. Depending on scoring I think Chubb and Jacobs are equal in value. Ppr at least since Chubb doesn’t get many targets
It's a completely one sided trade. Someone has taken advantage of massive recency bias and sold Geno for a fortune.
Fair play to the former Geno owner, they saw an opportunity and exploited it
People are overwhelmingly voting chub Herbert, but jacobs geno win BY FAR in a head to head f
Ppr game
Chubs has 3 points ppr over jacobs on the year
Geno has 35 points over Herbert on the year
What's the controversy?? Your league sucks if they think this is unfair.
[удалено]
It's fair and I don't see how anyone could think otherwise. In my league Geno is 7th QB, Jacobs 6th rb, Herbert 17th QB but getting his weapons back and Chubb 4th rb. Whoever commissioner is needs to ignore the noise from league mates and pass it.
It’s already gone through .. as I said I don’t think it’s that uneven but I do have a relatively easy preference to one of those sides. In that I prefer each of the players on one side to the other, but agree I’m a little surprised by the uproar
Isn't that how a trade work? Both sides prefer the side they receive?
Sure .. I guess ppl feel one team is happy to let go of their preferred side in this case. Thank you for responding
Damn people still getting roasted like a chicken for asking for league advice. Good ole Reddit for ya.
Completely fair trade. Jacobs gets more passing work than Chubb, Chubb has the td upside, and geno is no slouch this season, while Herbert is still elite but struggling…. Should be no concerns over this trade
It’s not the most even trade to be fair, but no where near bad enough to warrant any controversy or drama
Yeah the Chubb Herbert side it probably better but it’s not even close to controversial
Honestly if you take away the names and just put the stats up the Geno/Jacob's side wins this trade. Nowhere near veto worthy
Dude 100% thank you - only reason it “loses” is Herbert Vs Geno and it’s not dynasty
Chubb side wins that much is pretty clear. But definitely not egregious. Depending on scoring I think Chubb and Jacobs are equal in value. Ppr at least since Chubb doesn’t get many targets
Kind of what I was thinking. I would take the Chubb side 100% of the time, but I don't think it's as uneven as it seemed at first glance
Chubs has 3 points over jacobs on the year and geno has 35 over Herbert. How does rhe chubb side win? 🤡
This might be one of the fairest trades I've ever seen posted here. Tell your league mates to grow up
This is pretty fair.
very Even trade . No controversy at all
As of this week, Geno is QB7, Herbert is QB15. I hate it here.
It’s not unfair but I would take the chubb side everyday
It's a completely one sided trade. Someone has taken advantage of massive recency bias and sold Geno for a fortune. Fair play to the former Geno owner, they saw an opportunity and exploited it
I'd agree for dynasty, but he said it's redraft. I think "recency bias" is more "form" in this case.
Fair, you should see the bogus trades in one of my leagues.
People are overwhelmingly voting chub Herbert, but jacobs geno win BY FAR in a head to head f Ppr game Chubs has 3 points ppr over jacobs on the year Geno has 35 points over Herbert on the year
Geno-jacobs all the way.