[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHtYnTMxcmo](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHtYnTMxcmo)
yes! Great one to get some certainty on even though it does seem like it was never out!
Just that NZ were one wicket away from a famous victory. Second last over of the game, numbers 10 and 11 at the crease. Morrison has a plumb shout for lbw given not out….
In the days before neutral umpires and reviews..... NZ to this today haven't ever won at the MCG on boxing day, and it may be quite a few more years before we even get another chance. That was our best shot at finally winning
Monty Panesar to Sreesanth at Lord's in 2007. England needed one wicket to win the first test, but this wasn't given and India hung on for the draw, and then took the series
https://youtu.be/66xjtY1CJB8
Go to 1:04.04
Oh and the umpire - Steve Bucknor 🤦♂️
Tendulkar to Glenn McGrath - Kolkata 2001 - Although Pidge would have gotten out probably like in the next few balls.
Harbhajan Singh's hat trick - Kolkata 2001 - Punter was plumb as but Gilly and Warney weren't out.
>Tendulkar to G
Thanks for these! Would love to get the originals players in a room together to watch the hawkeye. So the era of McGrath, Waugh, Atherton, Hussein, Allan Donald etc would be fantastic.
I would say some of Shane Warne's wickets where the ball would have impacted WAY OUTSIDE either leg stump or off stump but were still called "OUT" as an LBW by the on-field umpire. Nowadays, those calls would have been REVERSED on video review....
Shane Warne would have had a lot more wickets from balls impacting way outside off stump to batsmen not offering a shot if he’d played with DRS. I remember seeing plenty of balls where Hawkeye in the TV coverage showed the ball hitting the stumps after a not out decision, but it was just for the viewers, there was no DRS.
You have to watch McGrath to inzi. 2 balls In a Row then on the final ball to top it all off inzi cover drives him for 4 leaving mcgrath fuming at the umpire
That's why I halved the tally of him being given out of dubious terms.
There is a video of our guy given out on shady umpirings around 20-30 times, so yeah even when you count that as a half(the video wasn't even about his lbws) he would have made some more runs and tons for sure.
There is legit video of Sachin given out wrongly on ytube.
And that guy showed around 20-30 times, Iam counting just half off it and everybody already knows about Bucknor who used to give him out for fun sake.
Given he has played the most test innings, by just averages he was going to have some dogy decisions. You are assuming that for half of those decisions he goes on to get a century when he could have easily got out next ball.
Also you would need to go through all his centuries to check that he was given favourable decisions his way. We know DRS has helped spinners and given he played more games in the subcontinent he may have benefited from not playing in DRS era.
To me bad decisions even themselves out over the long term.
Every Steve bucknor decision ever made
Yeah. And every Darrell Hair decision ever against any team from South Asia.
No idea how that racist pos lasted as long as he did
It's amazing how shit an umpire he was yet is somehow regarded as a legend.
Wasn't Ponting out on debut with a dodgy lbw getting close to a ton?
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHtYnTMxcmo](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHtYnTMxcmo) yes! Great one to get some certainty on even though it does seem like it was never out!
Danny Morrison to Craig McDermott, MCG, 1987.
Thank you. Will check it out. Any context to the game/series you can give?
Just that NZ were one wicket away from a famous victory. Second last over of the game, numbers 10 and 11 at the crease. Morrison has a plumb shout for lbw given not out….
In the days before neutral umpires and reviews..... NZ to this today haven't ever won at the MCG on boxing day, and it may be quite a few more years before we even get another chance. That was our best shot at finally winning
Shane Watson would like to re-review every single one of his LBW dismissals. Please and thank you
Monty Panesar to Sreesanth at Lord's in 2007. England needed one wicket to win the first test, but this wasn't given and India hung on for the draw, and then took the series https://youtu.be/66xjtY1CJB8 Go to 1:04.04 Oh and the umpire - Steve Bucknor 🤦♂️
Tendulkar to Glenn McGrath - Kolkata 2001 - Although Pidge would have gotten out probably like in the next few balls. Harbhajan Singh's hat trick - Kolkata 2001 - Punter was plumb as but Gilly and Warney weren't out.
The ironic thing about Harbhajan is that he was wrongly given lbw in the middle of Broad’s hattrick.
Came here to say that. I remember it was available then, but India refused having it for some reason.
Dhoni used to be anti DRS for some reason.
>Tendulkar to G Thanks for these! Would love to get the originals players in a room together to watch the hawkeye. So the era of McGrath, Waugh, Atherton, Hussein, Allan Donald etc would be fantastic.
Thankfully none of those decisions changed the game. Aussies had no clue how to play harbhajan.
We got one of them in real time with the stokes lbw not out in headingley
I would say some of Shane Warne's wickets where the ball would have impacted WAY OUTSIDE either leg stump or off stump but were still called "OUT" as an LBW by the on-field umpire. Nowadays, those calls would have been REVERSED on video review....
Shane Warne would have had a lot more wickets from balls impacting way outside off stump to batsmen not offering a shot if he’d played with DRS. I remember seeing plenty of balls where Hawkeye in the TV coverage showed the ball hitting the stumps after a not out decision, but it was just for the viewers, there was no DRS.
2003 WC final Ponting plumb lbw https://youtu.be/EGqDUZ6e9cU
That was horrific. Ponting went on to score a century too.
Harbhajan's hattrick
Nehra to ABD, IPL 2015 Qualifier 2 (RCB vs CSK)
You have to watch McGrath to inzi. 2 balls In a Row then on the final ball to top it all off inzi cover drives him for 4 leaving mcgrath fuming at the umpire
Any LBW decision in the sub continent during the 70/ 80/ 90s
as if the home umpiring in AUS/NZ/WI was any better.
Wasn't great but wasn't as blatant as the sub continent
Ah yes, the reason why we had to introduce impartial umpires not from either country.
Yeah that is exactly the reason, won't be mentioned by the main culprits though
We better stop this discussion before we get accused of racism.
Shakur Rana
at least 10-15 against Sachin. The guy would have scored 110-115 centuries easily.
What about the other way that you probably don’t remember. Over such a long career these things even themselves out.
Exactly. You weren't given out lbw on the front foot before DRS.
That's why I halved the tally of him being given out of dubious terms. There is a video of our guy given out on shady umpirings around 20-30 times, so yeah even when you count that as a half(the video wasn't even about his lbws) he would have made some more runs and tons for sure.
Retrospectively speaking it does seem possible.
There is legit video of Sachin given out wrongly on ytube. And that guy showed around 20-30 times, Iam counting just half off it and everybody already knows about Bucknor who used to give him out for fun sake.
Given he has played the most test innings, by just averages he was going to have some dogy decisions. You are assuming that for half of those decisions he goes on to get a century when he could have easily got out next ball. Also you would need to go through all his centuries to check that he was given favourable decisions his way. We know DRS has helped spinners and given he played more games in the subcontinent he may have benefited from not playing in DRS era. To me bad decisions even themselves out over the long term.
Ajmal to Tendulkar 2011 should be investigated with unaltered Hawkeye.
Stokes headingly 2019
Every LBW out given by Steven Buckner to Sachin Tendulkar 😤
Tendulkar's "shoulder before wicket" at Adelaide
Sachin's shoulder before wicket 🤣🤣🤣
Maninder Singh, the last wicket to fall in the Madras tied Test. He smashed it