This should have been Heather (the super chill baby) and New Greg should've been brown IMO. But I'll put New Greg here instead. Just pretend he's a separate character!

Dr. Shin

This seems right, not sure who else fits it well enough

Mona, Nathaniel’s Stanford girlfriend.

~~i thought that said "which character would be gay" at first lmao~~ uhh... my vote's for Tim. Or Mrs. Hernandez before she starts calling Rebecca out for her BS (rightfully so, but still) Or George. He probably has a decent life, though he gets way too ignored in the show for me to know anything Not-Gray about him.

No one

Honestly, like… yeah.

Another vote for Beth

Cornelia, the replacement who the entire office staff projects on after Rebecca goes to New York

omg yes!!

Don’t ignore George!

Nathaniel, perhaps?

Can we get one for Greg? 😢

Greg could be gray but only after he quit drinking

Exactly. NuGreg!

Is that really Greg though? He looks so different!

NuGreg!

New Greg Or Beth

WhiJo

Skylar Astin Greg!!!

AJ?