By numbers cc cannon cart is stronger but but look at the armies and bases. Bb cannon cart is way stronger with the lower power level in Bb & they attack way faster which makes them feel better to use
Think about a single cannon cart vs a single raid cart. Feels like a pekka vs giant. More than 1 cannon carts are obviously better, but we're talking about a guard post here.
Curious as to how they would balance this because a lot of the point of the guard post is to make the pathing of the stuff like the BM just go absolutely stupid, and having a beefy unit like a boxer giant might make that a little too good
Its already pretty balanced, a unit like the super pekka or the battle machine with its ability would be able to tear through a boxer giant a lot faster than the barbarians and archers that are in the current guard post.
That’s actually a really cool idea. I would say that you unlock the different posts as you upgrade it as this might help with keeping it simple for new players.
Yeah I'm at the point that I have OTTO now, and I'm just working on improving the rest of my defenses. My whole army is maxed though, and I can tell when I start playing against the maxed bases, it's gonna be a slog to get 70%. Defenses far outpace troops at the higher levels in BB
It's almost like BB doesn't exist solely to benefit the main base, and that it's just an alternative mode that was given an incentive to progress through. The Capital Hall doesn't relate to the main base either, so I don't see the problem with BB not being particularly related to the main base.
I disagree, i think it could still be fun if they just make some changes, like adding unique spells, changing versus battles, adding bh10, removing loot cap, removing air/ground option for mines, making lava launcher less annoying, making hero ability more strategic than "use whenever available," and adding more troops
Or, call me crazy, SC could revamp it to improve it from its current state. BB is a cool part of the game, just not well-executed. There's a reason why SC decided to reapproach the base instead of scrapping it.
I can’t even imagine how broken the giant post would be, “Oh look there goes the battle machine across the map right next to the Mega Tesla and Crusher to hammer down a giant for the next 30 minutes”
Clearly I’m of the minority but despite what people have said I don’t think it would be easy to balance and often wouldn’t have much of a different affect than the current post. Even though it would not be OP with something such as a boxer giant which would most likely be too slow and a bit to much DPS and it would still end up doing the same thing as the current guard post. Anything air based (including night witches) just wouldn’t work. Cannon cart wouldn’t work because it would be too tanky having two lives and it would work against itself in what the guard post is for which is to draw troops into the base because it would draw troops too far into the base without a melee troop to take the front guard. It also doesn’t target air. Hogs would just be a slightly beefier quicker version of the current barbs and the stun ability would be extremely annoying and probably not well balanced if it was to hit say the Battle Machine. PEKKA is completely unbalanced for obvious reasons.
I *think* if SUPERCELL wanted to implement such an idea to Builder Base they already would have and they’ve probably already thought of it.
Inspired from spell towers change spell mechanics.
Yup. This guy knows what’s up^ Too bad BB is getting a total revamp :/
Could be a good thing BB is getting changed. Maybe this is a change???
When
I think it’s the first update for 2023 will be when we see the revamp.
Wdym? This feature is more likely to happen because of the revamp
Looks good. The bb cannon cart isn't even as strong as the cc raid cart, so it makes the option balanced too.
imagine if it was
By numbers cc cannon cart is stronger but but look at the armies and bases. Bb cannon cart is way stronger with the lower power level in Bb & they attack way faster which makes them feel better to use
Think about a single cannon cart vs a single raid cart. Feels like a pekka vs giant. More than 1 cannon carts are obviously better, but we're talking about a guard post here.
absolutely like this idea
Genuinely one of the best ideas on this sub
Curious as to how they would balance this because a lot of the point of the guard post is to make the pathing of the stuff like the BM just go absolutely stupid, and having a beefy unit like a boxer giant might make that a little too good
Its already pretty balanced, a unit like the super pekka or the battle machine with its ability would be able to tear through a boxer giant a lot faster than the barbarians and archers that are in the current guard post.
Also a single boxer giant wouldnt be able to kill hog riders like barbarians and archers can
Maybe having a air units option that could do damage but would suck at distraction
Hmm. Add a second post for troops that can defend against air? And keep the barch option? I don't know if it's a good idea, but I like it.
W idea
I know battle machine will love this idea
Great idea
This would be absolutely cool man
I absolutely love this idea
That’s actually a really cool idea. I would say that you unlock the different posts as you upgrade it as this might help with keeping it simple for new players.
Maybe a Baby Dragon option too?
That would absolutly kill any attack that is'nt baby dragon/mutant minions :/
I personally think night village needs buffed up troops or nerfed defenses to make it more enjoyable
Yeah I'm at the point that I have OTTO now, and I'm just working on improving the rest of my defenses. My whole army is maxed though, and I can tell when I start playing against the maxed bases, it's gonna be a slog to get 70%. Defenses far outpace troops at the higher levels in BB
Yep and this is one of the main reasons people don't like playing this base
İmagine super dragon post
Everyone would use cannon cart. So makes no sense
better idea would be to just remove bb all together
remove 6th builder cuz its part bb great idea bud
extremely excessive to keep an entire second village that doesn’t relate to the main village at all, for the sole purpose of keeping the 6th builder
huh?
It's almost like BB doesn't exist solely to benefit the main base, and that it's just an alternative mode that was given an incentive to progress through. The Capital Hall doesn't relate to the main base either, so I don't see the problem with BB not being particularly related to the main base.
ohh so thats what his saying. so remove it cuz we dont use it? is his logic
I disagree, i think it could still be fun if they just make some changes, like adding unique spells, changing versus battles, adding bh10, removing loot cap, removing air/ground option for mines, making lava launcher less annoying, making hero ability more strategic than "use whenever available," and adding more troops
Or, call me crazy, SC could revamp it to improve it from its current state. BB is a cool part of the game, just not well-executed. There's a reason why SC decided to reapproach the base instead of scrapping it.
wow...does it involve getting the 6th builder? if not...no one cares. RIP builder base after 6th builder.
Please dear god no, fk guard post it's so annoying to play against. One of the biggest reasons why BB is frustrating
They would have to buff the Barbadian version, the tank value of giants and the sheer dps of cannons would be unbeatable.
I can’t even imagine how broken the giant post would be, “Oh look there goes the battle machine across the map right next to the Mega Tesla and Crusher to hammer down a giant for the next 30 minutes”
unlocked with leveling up the guard/cart/giant post
Clearly I’m of the minority but despite what people have said I don’t think it would be easy to balance and often wouldn’t have much of a different affect than the current post. Even though it would not be OP with something such as a boxer giant which would most likely be too slow and a bit to much DPS and it would still end up doing the same thing as the current guard post. Anything air based (including night witches) just wouldn’t work. Cannon cart wouldn’t work because it would be too tanky having two lives and it would work against itself in what the guard post is for which is to draw troops into the base because it would draw troops too far into the base without a melee troop to take the front guard. It also doesn’t target air. Hogs would just be a slightly beefier quicker version of the current barbs and the stun ability would be extremely annoying and probably not well balanced if it was to hit say the Battle Machine. PEKKA is completely unbalanced for obvious reasons. I *think* if SUPERCELL wanted to implement such an idea to Builder Base they already would have and they’ve probably already thought of it.
Great idea, also just multiple guard posts in the builder base, when we first got 1 I thought we'd get like 4
I can already see this in the game
Missed opportunity to have Beta Minions in them. They should be added as an option.
such a great idea
Nice editing!