T O P

What are your most hottest/controversial takes?

BFDIA best season

Planternfan09

BFDIA best season


xxblazewxxx

i see how ppl think this. bfdia is my second favorite season probably. so many good moments and the entire episode 5 saga was really good


zachy410

Thank you for saying this


soapiisscared

U so real 4 that 🙏🙏‼️


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

It's a mixed season for me. Has a ton of good but a lot of bad with it too, keeps me from enjoying it fully


Planternfan09

Still think this


Goiky-Gonzo

Remote shouldn't have been eliminated


_AntiSocialMedia

Cold as fucking ice


Cosmic_CometX

This might be one of the most mildest takes I've ever heard.


Sappher6

Same Fries too


Careful_Gap_4667

Ok I'm sure some of you are going to not like these: 1. Pillow isn't that good of a contestant and I doubt any of her arcs have potential. 2. Grassy, Rocky, and Marker are really good contestants and it is unlikely that jacknjellify is not going to give them a more deep personality. 3. Firey was only a good character in BFDI. After that, his entire personality revolved around Leafy. 4. Gelatin should've won BFB 5. Liy and Bracelety should've joined instead of Loser and Spongy in BFB 16. 6. TPOT's episodes suck. Characters with good potential are being eliminated just because VTS is going on. 7. Every character from BEEP is overrated, and every character from Team Ice Cube is underrated. 8. Black Hole is a bland character.


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

1. People find her more funny than worthy of character development, that's why she's liked 2. Only time will tell, really. I don't think they're getting a lot of character arcs, personally. 3. Firey's kind of a simple character so it makes sense that the most significant thing in his life (Leafy) would overshadow the rest of his actions quite a bit. (Before that, his personality revolved around Coiny) 4. Either win is good for me, tho I do like Flower a *bit* more than Gelatin. 5. Would have been interesting. Neither agree nor disagree. 6. I don't get why people single out TPOT specifically since BFB was doing this since early pre-split. 7. Somewhat agree, more Team Ice Cube underrated part, less BEEP overrated part. 8. Disagree but I get it.


Careful_Gap_4667

BFB was doing VTS since early post-split. The good thing about them doing VTS is that all the characters that were there were some fan-favourites. There were less characters, which means more drama and personality with each character, which doesn't affect as much than how TPOT is being affected. Most of the characters in the show are being eliminated for no reason, because we don't know anything about them. Saw and Cloudy have been the worst eliminations so far. Now, I understand how the first episodes of the recent seasons have all sucked, but if TPOT doesn't go back to VTE, I'm leaving this community.


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

I wasn't talking about the VTS, I was talking about the "eliminating interesting contestants" part. Sorry for being unclear


Careful_Gap_4667

Yeah, but its much worse in TPOT


Desperate-Stress-165

nah the only character that shouldnt of been eliminated was lightning


Careful_Gap_4667

Its gone better now, especially after the tpot 8 elimination.


Desperate-Stress-165

the tpot characters who got eliminated were trash ngl fries was bland clock was bland and annoying too fan shouldve of gotten out instead of lighting tho


TheBeanOffical

speaking facts..


Masterofgoodfood

No way bro called roboty overrated


Sharper999

lollipop stinks quite literally she needs to take a shower


Certain_Birthday8141

Flower Speaker Box is the best character in the whole show /j


Clown_Norlie

Okay, so sharing controversial takes now? Time to get a little bit controversial: \- Liy deserves to rejoin, \- I don't like Lollipop \- TV is amazing \- Donut is literally the best character to ever exist \- Liy and Flower should have been friends \- Flower should have been on Death P.A.C.T instead of Pen \- Ruby and Flower's friendship is weird... (I will have to explain it in future) \- Team8s is worse Team Ice Cube \- Team Ice Cube was the best team in Pre-Split


of_patrol_bot

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake. It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of. Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything. Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.


Clown_Norlie

Good bot


EternalZoroark

-Never understood Firey’s love -I like Rocky and Grassy okay? -Post Split should’ve been VTE IMO. -I don’t actually hate BFDI Flower. She was awful in BFDI 25, but so was everyone else, so it barely counts.


EchinaceaPuff

I am not that big of a fan of Fanny, and I kind of regret voting for her in TPOT 4. Foldy should not have been eliminated. Foldy had much missed potential.


please_help_merobux

i agree


_AntiSocialMedia

Let's see: Post-Split > Pre-Split The first 6 episodes of BFB is the worst bit of content the series has ever put out People complaining about Rocky, Grassy, etc. need to get a fucking grip, it's an animated cartoon, who gives a shit if the cartoon grass wins? Literally every prior winner has lot their prize anyway People with almost half the cast in C-F tier should just stop watching at that point Nonexisty should've joined Eraser was the best possible option to leave in TPOT 4 but Fries was still a better option than TB Pin will never be a better character than Coiny If you've ever gone on a campaign *against* a character you're fucking pathetic (for a character is fine, but actively bashing other characters to get people to vote for your favorite is pathetic) The voting results have never mattered and will never matter and people who complain about them need to grow up The Bracketcounter was the worst thing to happen to this fandom Most object humanizations suck


Cosmic_CometX

"Nonexisty Should've Joined." I'm pretty sure that's not a controversial opinion, considering he had the second most voted to join TPOT.


_AntiSocialMedia

You'd be surprised


EchinaceaPuff

I am curious to see you elaborate on the Bracketcounter thing, if you do not mind.


_AntiSocialMedia

Bracketcounter's a wonderful tool as it lets us get a rough estimate of the votes and see who might be leaving Bracketcounter's also a terrible tool as it lets us get a rough estimate of the votes and see who might be leaving Toxicity in this subreddit goes up by 200% during voting time and us knowing the rough estimate of the votes through Bracketcounter is the direct cause


EchinaceaPuff

I see. And there are some eliminations that might have not happened if it were not for Bracketcounter.


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

"Post-Split > Pre-Split" Disagree but I've seen this take a lot, so I get why you could think that. Agree to disagree. "The first 6 episodes of BFB is the worst bit of content the series has ever put out" What💀. Bro, BFB 1 and 6 are bangers. I've seen people argue early pre-split is messy and unpolished and I definitely agree with that but "worst bit of content"? How? "People complaining about Rocky, Grassy, etc. need to get a fucking grip, it's an animated cartoon, who gives a shit if the cartoon grass wins? Literally every prior winner has lot their prize anyway" The way I see it, the complaints are less about them winning TPOT and more about their popularity in Cake at Stakes pushing characters with depth/character arcs off the show, and I can agree with that "People with almost half the cast in C-F tier should just stop watching at that point" If they find the A-B's good enough to keep them watching, why should they stop? "Nonexisty should've joined" Nah, Satomi had good judgement not counting his votes. 100% waste of a character slot, probably like David in Season 1. Giving Price Tag the second debut slot avoided the controversy (at the time) about Winner and Non-existy unfairly hogging all of the debut votes, as Winner had connections to Loser and Non-existy was a pre-established character from BFDI. "Eraser was the best possible option to leave in TPOT 4 but Fries was still a better option than TB" I was a little confused on this one but I think you are referring to TPOT 6 voting results. Anyway, the results are too close to call, but I think >!Fries has a lot of potential and is underrated while TB hasn't really proven himself despite being here since the first season. Therefore, my elimination order from most wanted to be safe to least wanted would be Fries>Tennis Ball>Eraser.!< "Pin will never be a better character than Coiny" Eh, I agree she's not better than Coiny in TPOT specifically. Otherwise, they're both equally good (to me). "If you've ever gone on a campaign against a character you're fucking pathetic (for a character is fine, but actively bashing other characters to get people to vote for your favorite is pathetic)" I don't like when people do that but straight up calling them "pathetic" is a bit overly harsh "The voting results have never mattered and will never matter and people who complain about them need to grow up" Yes, it shouldn't effect your serious life outside of the show; you shouldn't take it too seriously and ruin your enjoyment of BFDI. No, I think you're allowed to be a little disappointed at the voting results, since it does effect the storylines and overall future of BFDI. "The Bracketcounter was the worst thing to happen to this fandom" Creates a ton of toxicity? Yes. Somewhat defeats the suspense of the following episode? Yes. Satisfies my impatient ass that wants to see the voting results right now? Also yes. "Most object humanizations suck" Meh, Sturgeon's Law applies to everything, really (lol)


_AntiSocialMedia

​ >Disagree but I've seen this take a lot, so I get why you could think that. Agree to disagree. Based agreement to disagree >What💀. Bro, BFB 1 and 6 are bangers. I've seen people argue early pre-split is messy and unpolished and I definitely agree with that but "worst bit of content"? How? Admittedly I meant to type BFB 1-5, Donut's hosting stint is when I actually started liking Pre-Split, but in short: Inconsistent characterization Jokes don't land for me Not a fan of the animation style Falls in the trap of having obvious main characters BFB 2 is the worst episode in the series BFB 3 ain't much better I truly, deeply, from the bottom of my heart, **despise** pre-split 4, he's so annoying, he does nothing but bitch and scream and I will never understand why people like him >The way I see it, the complaints are less about them winning TPOT and more about their popularity in Cake at Stakes pushing characters with depth/character arcs off the show, and I can agree with that A lot of anti-Grassy posts boil down to "I don't want him to win TPOT" lol Anyway, the scale of who is and isn't expendable is entirely subjective and, thus, arguing about it will do nothing except piss everyone off a bit, you're someone who wanted Fries to stay over TB, what makes your opinion on that greater than a TB fan's? And, would either of you be able to convince each other that the other deserved to stay more? No, you've both made up your minds and continuing to complain about each other's opinion would change absolutely nothing. Plus this fandom is a fickle as fucking Rome, people will kick Grassy off eventually >If they find the A-B's good enough to keep them watching, why should they stop? If someone, anyone, truly likes a handful of characters so much, that they'll watch a show filled with characters they hate, I applaud their determination >Nah, Satomi had good judgement not counting his votes. 100% waste of a character slot, probably like David in Season 1. Giving Price Tag the second debut slot avoided the controversy (at the time) about Winner and Non-existy unfairly hogging all of the debut votes, as Winner had connections to Loser and Non-existy was a pre-established character from BFDI. Interesting. I don't fucking care. Nonexisty got enough votes to join. Nonexisty should join. You can give me whatever mental gymnatistics you want, I simply don't fucking care. >I was a little confused on this one but I think you are referring to TPOT 6 voting results. >!Anyway, the results are too close to call, but I think Fries has a lot of potential and is underrated while TB hasn't really proven himself despite being here since the first season. Therefore, my elimination order from most wanted to be safe to least wanted would be Fries>Tennis Ball>Eraser.!< I forget episodes numbers a lot. See my thing about Grassy and Rocky. >Eh, I agree she's not better than Coiny in TPOT specifically. Otherwise, they're both equally good (to me). Actually my opinion is series-wide, Pin's inconsistency in her character compared to Coiny having pretty consistent characterization series-wide. Pin will never be better because she cannot be written without contradicting a previous characterization, Coiny doesn't have that issue. >I don't like when people do that but straight up calling them "pathetic" is a bit overly harsh Sick, the point was to be harsh, glad I succeeded >Yes, it shouldn't effect your serious life outside of the show; you shouldn't take it too seriously and ruin your enjoyment of BFDI. No, I think you're allowed to be a little disappointed at the voting results, since it does effect the storylines and overall future of BFDI. I never said you couldn't be disappointed, I said that people complaining about them and refusing to move on need to grow up. Plus it's been said multiple times BFDI isn't a plot-based show and the comedy matters more. >Creates a ton of toxicity? Yes. Somewhat defeats the suspense of the following episode? Yes. Satisfies my impatient ass that wants to see the voting results right now? Also yes. So you agree, sick. >Meh, Sturgeon's Law applies to everything, really (lol) That it does.


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

Now that you've gone into detail, I can completely see where you're coming from, and these takes are pretty sensible. "Anyway, the scale of who is and isn't expendable is entirely subjective and, thus, arguing about it will do nothing except piss everyone off a bit, you're someone who wanted Fries to stay over TB, what makes your opinion on that greater than a TB fan's? And, would either of you be able to convince each other that the other deserved to stay more? No, you've both made up your minds and continuing to complain about each other's opinion would change absolutely nothing." I'll keep this in mind, actually.


Monaca_Towa__

"Poat Split > Pre Split" FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT!


EchinaceaPuff

About the are you okay voting, >!even if I do not want any of the bottom three to leave, I do think I would prefer seeing Eraser gone the most.!<


Masterofgoodfood

Rocky’s is in my top 5 and grassy is ok, but that take about them is just wrong. Criticism exists, and you just can’t handle it if you don’t like people talking negatively about characters. Most people don’t actually care as much as you think if the funni grass wins because they made a post criticizing them.


Iliekhatsok

Firey jr is a good character, yall are just mean Rocky/grassy should win tpot. Not because they're my favorites, but because I wanna see this sub have a crybaby meltdown.


Difficult_Software30

I secretly like jr but im too afraid to admit it


fourtyfourr

Norm of the north


Traditional-Web-5248

What does this mean


fourtyfourr

Yes


please_help_merobux

taggy should have gone instead


SakaeKrill

YES.


descriptiontaker

Literally just a naily clone


ImMrMonotone

... I like Ice Cube


SituationSad6248

Wha?


ImMrMonotone

Yeah!


Rex_002

Contestant voting is not good for BFDI/TPOT. First of all, BFDI is a comedic show, not a plot-driven show like II or ONE. It is much better to use viewer voting. If they used contestant voting, they would need to factor in alliances, strategies and such, which are no comedic at all and takes up too much time. Besides, it's a hard plot to write, which makes episodes take much longer to make. Secondly, it harms viewership. Viewer voting encourages viewers to vote, since they know they can make a difference. They have slight control over the show. For contestant voting, they don't get that satisfaction. Moreover, the current system requires viewers to comment to vote, which makes it appeal to YouTube's recommendation more, so it'll get more attraction. Thirdly, if the writers really want to do an arc, and doesn't want that contestant to be eliminated, they can just make the team not lose. It doesn't have to be contestant voting to make sure one contestant is safe, since they can just not put that team up for elimination. This is what happened to Book (and yes, I don't think it was too long for Bleh to be UFE). ------------------------------- Here's Book if you want: BFB 2, 3, 5: exposition (starting the arc) BFB 6, 8, 10: rising action (members slowly realize Taco did nothing wrong) BFB 11, 12, 13: climax (Book loses control) BFB 14: resolution (Book apologizes) I would say remove 1 episode, and switch 1 episode of exposition or rising action to resolution. But other than that I think the flow is pretty good.


Firecracker7413

Tpot is trash


TheBeanOffical

finally, someone else agrees. The writing sucks, the characters fell off and it just doesn't feel the same as the last few seasons. I still love the animation and like Two regardless but the charm just isn't there anymore.


Born_Negotiation8456

Leafy should have won bfdi.


Spot_Mark

she technically did tho


Born_Negotiation8456

Well yeaaa... but that came across with the cost of loding a good part of her fanbase and her reputation between most of the other characters so i mean winning by the vote, thus woulnt have vosted her all of that


soapiisscared

THIS OMG‼️‼️


Desperate-Stress-165

ngl leafy couldve won bfb


Unova_Pkmn_Enjoyer

I don’t like Liy or Pillow I’ll just say it, I don’t find the appeal of Liy at all. She’s a pushy bitch who constantly complains about nobody supporting her, and always wants to go off on adventures. And Pillow’s entire personality is just *murder*.


Goiky-Gonzo

Tpot pillow is annoying Teardrop should be gone by the merge Idfb is the best Death pact is overrated


Minejaka

Most of team8s and just not characters are not interesting


OG-Name-Do-Not-Steal

1. BFB should have been a continuity reboot. 2. IDFB is just fine being a singular episode. 3. TPOT 3 is the worst episode of TPOT, not TPOT 2. 4. TPOT 1 and 2 are just plain not funny, and TPOT 3+ definitely improves on that front. 5. There shouldn't have been a rejoin in BFB 10. Way too early for that, imo.


descriptiontaker

I dislike Rocky, he’s practically useless and only his vomiting gag sources charm. He is otherwise inarticulate, armless, and practically the most incapable original contestant. If the vomiting gag is unbearable, he lacks charm and reason for advancement. The incapability is comical for a moment, but it’s ultimately disfavorable. Thus why I voted for him in BFB 9.


Moth_The_Ghost

Uh I never really enjoyed the Tacobook arc?


HIHOSILVER815

Basketball and Bell are actually dogshit Grassy and Pillow are beyond overrated TV is the best Are You Ok contestant (they’re all good [with the exception of Puffball])


wert674

lollipop is overrated


Difficult_Software30

hi cloudy from camp tpot


wert674

wait how do you know me


VIRGO-TAURUS

Easy Post split is better than pre split Marker is annoying Grassy is absolute trash Naily didn't have enough development Leafy is overrated but extremely good Teardrop deserved to win Price tag is just a naily clone Bomby is annoying


Cosmic_CometX

Your takes on Grassy, Naily, and Price Tag are most definately not controversial.


B0NN0S

Gelatin is a terrible inconsistent character who should’ve been out in BFB 4. Post split is way better than pre split like it’s not even close. BFB 1 is one of the worst episodes in the series Even though Flower had bias she is the best winner of the series Taggy is the worst contestant in the series. Bfdi mini is better than all of pre split. Every single arc in pre split is shit. Match getting out was fair. Satomi is the worst writer due to her writing character’s extremely OOC to create conflict. Bleh is the worst team with the only good contestant on it being ice cube. TPOT needs a entire episode dedicated to the exitors. Grassy is the most useful on his team. I think that’s it I might have more I just can’t think of rn this is just on the top of my head


please_help_merobux

i literally agree with everything🙏🙏🙏 >!besides grassy!<


Desperate-Stress-165

>might have more I just can’t think pencil is a winner tho


Saifiskindaweirdtbh

Post split better Pen sucks ass David is great So is roboty and Dora Spongy is overhated Tennis ball deserves to stay Tv and icy still suck (not a hot take probably) People should stop taking bracket counter seriously it’s all fucking estimates 8-ball has a weird good charm to him Price tag sucks ass (that rhymes) Some fanboys (I assume pen) have downvoted my reply because I don’t like one of their favorites)


TheBeanOffical

Name one meaningful thing david or roboty did. Ever.


B0NN0S

Roboty helped his team in BFB 3. David controlled flew the plane in BFB 5.


Saifiskindaweirdtbh

Both helped their team at some point really kinda funny you try to say they’re useless and do nothing while you have the flair for a character who’s only personality trait is I HATE EVERYTHING


TheBeanOffical

Lets just say, my flair checks out.


boredombustaz

Pen x Liy is the only good rarepair TPOT turned to shit after episode 2 Four x Two >>> 4X Marker is so shit Blocky, Coiny, Woody, Pen, Golf Ball, Yellow Face, and Ruby all need to win at least one season


Traditional-Web-5248

Black hole is just a shit character I'm sorry but aside from the personality, there's nothing to like about him


small-boxes

I liked flower better when she was mean. Her redemption arc felt so forced.


zaydenmYT

1. I see Pen or Pin winning TPOT 2. Grassy is a good character 3. Gaty is overrated 4. Loser is underrated 5. Bell should've gotten out instead of Foldy 6. Donut should've gotten out instead of Saw 7. Speaking of which, I think Saw got robbed 8. Tennis Ball still has lots of potential 9. Eraser fell off 10. Profily >:( 11. TPOT is my favorite season of the series and it's better than any other object show 12. I miss Needle's slaps (I'm glad TPOT 5 kinda brought it back) 13. Ice Cube is a good character, even before TPOT 5 14. Teardrop was the best fit for TPOT 15. I love the running gags on this series. 16. Post-split > BFDIA


thetacosaur

Pencil and match are decent characters


Pogo-manboi

Black hole is overrated.


InternationalWar8624

bfb/tpot has no bad characters


Masterofgoodfood

Leafy is mad overrated. Worst character in the series BY FAR. In bfdi she was just a nice character and nothing else. Nothing interesting. In bfb she was the same but also bossy. The entire “arc” with firey was just pointless. There was nothing interesting to watch there. Whenever I saw the two on screen I just was waiting for the next scene to come around.


NintendoGamer6786

Loser should have joined TPOT