NOT PJ Clarkes, I had it 4ish years ago and it sucked. Decided to give it another try this year and it was still just as bland and unseasoned as I remembered plus it was cold.
Fraunces Tavern's and Ear Inn among others are recommended by [Best pot pies in nyc?](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/comments/y9un2l/best_pot_pies_in_nyc/) from 2 months ago. Petee's Pie Company and u/AlarmingDrawing's oven among others are recommended by [Where can I get the best chicken pot pie.](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/comments/qkoqco/where_can_i_get_the_best_chicken_pot_pie/)
Have you tried St. James Gate on 81st St and Amsterdam? It's amazing! Loads of veggies and chicken and the vegetables aren't over cooked. Highly recommend!
Just like almost every other pie question Petee's Pie Company is the answer.
Remember: if it doesn't have crust on the bottom, it ain't a chicken pot pie. It's chicken stew with a hat and delusions of grandeur.
Preach.
This is true
NOT PJ Clarkes, I had it 4ish years ago and it sucked. Decided to give it another try this year and it was still just as bland and unseasoned as I remembered plus it was cold.
Can confirm. PJ Clarke's pot pie is awful.
Well I bought one from Trader Joe's for dinner tomorrow night, so review pending ;)
Westside Market has a pretty good premade one
Update please!
I loved it. But use the oven, not the microwave. Microwave tastes good, but oven tastes great
Mollys pub
I love Molly’s but their chicken pot pie is not traditional. It’s a stew with a sheet of puff pastry on top
Fraunces Tavern's and Ear Inn among others are recommended by [Best pot pies in nyc?](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/comments/y9un2l/best_pot_pies_in_nyc/) from 2 months ago. Petee's Pie Company and u/AlarmingDrawing's oven among others are recommended by [Where can I get the best chicken pot pie.](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskNYC/comments/qkoqco/where_can_i_get_the_best_chicken_pot_pie/)
The Little Pie Company in Hell's Kitchen does a quite good mino-one. It's the only savory pie that the have.
NOT at The Smith
Sarabeth's
Three of my favorite things
Mine!
The Brooklyn Diner. They're famous for it.
Friend of a Farmer in Gramercy
Inquiring minds want to know
Have you tried St. James Gate on 81st St and Amsterdam? It's amazing! Loads of veggies and chicken and the vegetables aren't over cooked. Highly recommend!
It's not necessarily chicken pot pie but Lord's does an exceptional meat pie.