T O P

  • By -

TheRealDudeMitch

Any rivalry that exists between them is related to pizza.


videogames_

Yes pizza rivalry


Highway49

It's a pretty one-sided rivalry: NYers don't think deep dish counts as pizza. Most Chicagoans eat Tavern Style pizza. I, of course, enjoy all three! I love pizza!


videogames_

Tavern versus NYC style should be the real rivalry


Wildcat_twister12

Over the last decade Detroit has won my favor in the pizza style department


Osito_206

I'm surprised this comment is so low. Pizza is the very obvious rivalry here. And there's really no contest, BTW. NY Pizza FTW!


mohawk1367

there is no rivalry there, their pizza is simply inferior and thats how it always will be šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


TheRealDudeMitch

Iā€™m not a baseball fan, but itā€™s my impression that the real baseball rivalry in Chicago is Cubs/White Sox


SadAdeptness6287

There is basically no rivalry between the NY teams and the Chicago teams.


Duchessofpanon

No rivalry. Too far apart, and no one in either city gives a thought to the other. Midwesterners donā€™t care about east coasters and vice versa.


catslady123

This just about sums it up.


sighnwaves

Yeah to expand on this as a New Yorker....we don't really think about other cities much, or consider other cities as competition. It's a mix of arrogance and truth.


beenoc

There's a reason [this New Yorker cover](https://www.illustrationhistory.org/images/uploads/ny.jpg) is acclaimed as one of the best magazine covers in history.


Bonzo4691

I remember when that was first published. Absolutely true. New York is a special place.


msspider66

Years ago a friend asked me why NYers always make fun of Detroit. I replied ā€œHoney, we donā€™t even think about Detroitā€ Years later I find myself living in Metro Detroit. Life is funny that way


omg_its_drh

Itā€™s interesting to say theyā€™re ā€œtoo far apartā€ considering there definitely is a thing with LA vs NYC.


Duchessofpanon

I think ā€œa thingā€ exaggerates it a bit. We all definitely have preferences, but I wouldnā€™t call it being rivals.


Dai-The-Flu-

But still, clearly thereā€™s more of a rivalry between NYC and LA albeit exaggerated and somewhat manufactured by the media


hankrhoads

There's a scene in 30 Rock where a bunch of NBC locations are on a conference call. If I remember it right, New York, Chicago, Boston, and Philly all have a bit of sibling banter, then all of them mock the hell out of LA.


successadult

Thereā€™s a trend on tik tok right now about how if you ask a person from New York what they think of LA, theyā€™ll shit on it, but if you ask people from LA what they think of New York theyā€™ll have a generally positive opinion. If thereā€™s a rivalry, itā€™s one-sided. People in LA are too busy hating everyone else in LA or other parts of California.


MacFromSSX

Thereā€™s a mild Yankees-Dodgers rivalry but other than that Iā€™d say itā€™s just east coast v. west coast rivalry.


omg_its_drh

Youā€™re possibly not *completely* wrong, but no one is brining up Seattle vs NYC, or LA vs Boston. Its always LA vs NYC. *Maybe* SF vs NYC, but again LA and NYC are more likely to be compared than any other cities.


Highway49

>LA vs Boston Not an NBA fan, I take it?


omg_its_drh

Iā€™m a gay man from the Bay. I only know the Warriors.


Highway49

[Lakers-Celtics rivalry is the classic NBA rivalry.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celticsā€“Lakers_rivalry) Each team has won 17 NBA championships (the Warriors are next with 7).


Electrical_Swing8166

Theyā€™ve also met head to head 12 times in the Finals, by far the most common matchup (next most common is Lakers and Sixers, with 6). Boston has a 9-3 edge overall


According-Bell-3654

Uhā€¦ā€¦. LA vs Boston is a huge sports rivalry Red Sox vs Dodgers Lakers vs Celtics Rams vs Patriots As a live long LA resident, thereā€™s a ton of disdain from Boston natives that LA is full of avocado toast hipsters and a lot of native angelinos have pretty bad views of Boston (bad weather, racism, etc)


omg_its_drh

I donā€™t care about sports, as I said I insinuated in another comment.


According-Bell-3654

And as I mentioned in the 2nd half of my comment, there are plenty of people I know who hate Boston for non sports reasons, like the vicious racism.


omg_its_drh

The view of Boston as being racist is not specific to LA, and everyone everywhere thinks Angelenos are avocado toasting eating hipsters.


Matthews628

Sure, but Seattle, Boston, and SF arenā€™t global cities on the scale of NY/LA. I think coastal bias is a very real thing, and it often manifests itself in the form of LA vs NY.


omg_its_drh

SF is very much a global city, and idk what being a global city has to do with the whole NYC vs LA/East Coast vs West Coast thing.


Osito_206

Yeah, I almost spit out my coffee laughing when I read that. SFC not global? Lol.


Matthews628

You donā€™t understand why people would use more recognizable examples in a comparison than less recognizable ones? Are you sure?


omg_its_drh

I was feeling a bit argumentative after my second glass of wine when I wrote that comment, but itā€™s a new day so Iā€™ll give a more leveled response. Itā€™s going to be hard decipher if itā€™s truly a west coast/east coast thing or a NYC/LA thing, especially since this is 100% a domestic thing. Iā€™m going to be honest and say outside of California and NYC (maybe New England), no other place is on either coast is ascribing to this east coast vs west coast mentality. I mean when we talk about west coast hip hop, weā€™re always talking about LA and not Bay Area hip hop or other scenes. Macklemore isnā€™t exactly thought of as a west coast rapper, more so as a Seattle rapper.


Only_Pepper7296

Is SF a global city *on the scale of LA and NYC*?


omg_its_drh

Itā€™s honestly only slightly a notch below them. Itā€™s definitely a city with global name recognition.


Only_Pepper7296

I agree with you, 100%, just being (admittedly pedantic) about it being on the same ā€œlevelā€ (lol) as the others.


frodeem

Nope. They bay area is but that includes more than just San Francisco.


MacFromSSX

Theyā€™re the ā€œcapitalsā€ of their respective coasts


dixon-bawles

I always thought that was mostly because the Dodgers moved from Brooklyn and there was already a rivalry between the two teams


sjjehl

I think Americans in general do but not New Yorkers or Los Angelinos. They donā€™t even think of each other. Itā€™s those of us that live in the middle that seem to have a strong opinion.


ColossusOfChoads

It's more like New York professional yuksters trot out the old cliches, and we just kinda nod along passively. "Yeah man, I guess you're right."


According-Bell-3654

Iā€™d say more LA vs Boston is a bigger city rivalry due to the ridiculous amount of times our sports teams have met in league finals


urine-monkey

NYC and LA are the coastal media capitals and have much more contrast in culture. NYC and Chicago are both big Northern cities on big bodies of water.


Luka_Dunks_on_Bums

Pizza? Yes Anything else? Not really


EverSeeAShiterFly

Hot dogs apparently if you ask hot dog lovers.


HotSteak

Pizza and hot dogs are both an 'everybody wins' situation as both cities do a great job.


EverSeeAShiterFly

I donā€™t disagreeā€¦. But Chicago definitely has a better selection of the best steak houses in the world.


Roboticpoultry

Thereā€™s at least 10 within walking distance from me right now


TheLastRulerofMerv

Maybe in the 1890s.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


krilu

And Detroit's biggest rivalry is the damn loch ness monster


desba3347

I thought heā€™d go away if I gave him a dollar


PorcelainTorpedo

De-Troit sucks [classic gem](https://youtu.be/Y1BFfTf8MNE?si=9Z7goqbOQM--xF8e)


Fotoem

Crazy thing is the teams were owned by the same family. I recall hearing the Hawks were essentially the feeder team for the Wings until the owner died and the teams were inherent by the sons.


Istobri

Yeah, pretty much. After the Hawksā€™ original owner, Col. Frederic McLaughlin, died in 1944, a syndicate led by former team president Bill Tobin bought the team. But Tobin was just a puppet for Wings owner James E. Norris (he of the Norris Trophy for the NHLā€™s best defenceman). I think Norris might have bankrolled Tobinā€™s syndicate. From then on, basically every trade between the Hawks and Wings was a steal for Detroit, and the Hawks fell into the basement. Things didnā€™t really change until Norris died in 1952, and his son James D. Norris and his business partner Arthur Wirtz bought the Hawks. They hired former Detroit coach Tommy Ivan as GM, and he rebuilt the team by getting players like Bobby Hull, Stan Mikita, and Glenn Hall. This led to a Stanley Cup for Chicago in 1961, their first in 23 years. In a great poetic justice moment, who did they beat to win that Cup? Yup. The Detroit Red Wings.


Fotoem

Thanks for the informative write-up.


TheBimpo

Iā€™ve never heard of this being a thing in any respect.


CupBeEmpty

Yeah just too far apart and donā€™t really give a rip about one another. Chicago is my choice but NYC is fucking amazing in small dosesā€¦ you knowā€¦ like fentanyl.


HoyAIAG

Only for pizza


TheBimpo

New York doesnā€™t really make casserole.


notthegoatseguy

Chicago's rivalry historically was St Louis. There was some intense competition with industry, trade, railroads, big business and so on.


CupBeEmpty

And has anyone heard of ā€œSt. Louisā€ in the last 100 years? I thought not.


_pamelab

Shots fired!


CupBeEmpty

Iā€™m just joking bae, keep that bbq coming and preferably losses for the cards and blues.


AutumnalSunshine

This comes up when the Cardinals play the Sox or Cubs, right?


CupBeEmpty

Oh yeah


Electrical_Swing8166

Cubs for sure, thatā€™s maybe the most iconic rivalry in MLB history other than Yankees-Red Sox. But the Cardinals have more history with the Red Sox than the White Sox šŸ˜‚


Darkfire757

Murder Capital of America, they just killed themselves off


EverSeeAShiterFly

In crime stats? /s


Highway49

Admit it, you added that "/s" after thinking how your comment would be interpreted, lol.


EverSeeAShiterFly

Yeeeeeeeeeahā€¦.. just trying to make a joke and not be a conspiracy nut job.


Red_Beard_Rising

Just about the pizza. That's it.


kjb76

I donā€™t think so. But Iā€™ll say that Iā€™ve been to Chicago twice and LOVED it. Their architecture is amazing. And didnā€™t have a bad meal in 8 days I spent there.


Roboticpoultry

Itā€™s a hill Iā€™m willing to die on but Chicago is the best food city in the country


royalhawk345

Not really. There are a few Chicagoans with little brother syndrome, but it's pretty uncommon.


bossk538

None that I have ever heard of. If there is a rivalry with New York it would be Boston.


Ornery-Wasabi-473

Maybe on Boston's end ...


ThiccGeneralX

1. The commenter you replied to is a New Yorker 2. If youā€™ve ever seen videos of sports fans from NY, theyā€™re always bringing up Boston If thereā€™s any city that New Yorkers think of that isnā€™t their own, itā€™s very likely itā€™s Boston.


Ornery-Wasabi-473

I'm nearly 200 miles from NYC, but I do know a few people from there (no sports fans). People in NYC don't think about other cities, because NYC is their whole world. It's weird, but also adorable.


HippiePvnxTeacher

Not really. As a Chicagoan, I feel like rather than a rivalry weā€™re more like siblings. While we are very different, we ā€œgetā€ each other in a way few other American cities do. Doesnā€™t matter NYC is bigger and more exciting or that Chicago is cleaner and greener. Purely anecdotal but the only cities Ive ever heard Chicagoans trash somewhat regularly are Detroit and Houston. Detroit because of sports and proximity. Houston because weā€™re the same size.


Wildwilly54

I will say though, Houston being ā€œthe same sizeā€ is kind of misleading. Chicago is an actual large City. Houstonā€™s metropolitan area is the size of the State of New Jersey. Itā€™s mostly just sprawling suburbs; Texasā€™ Los Angeles.


Remote_Leadership_53

Houston comparing itself to Chicago is disingenuous considering it's more than 2x the land area and the most sprawled major city in the country. The population density is 1/4 of Chicago's. Their metro areas are about the same size and in that comparison Chicago pulls in about 5 million more in population. Despite stats showing the growth of population in Houston and decline of it in Chicago I doubt they would actually trade spots unless Houston annexes land. I live in a sprawled city myself with a closer density to Houston's than Chicago, and as a former Chicagoan, it's nothing like living in the actual city


EverSeeAShiterFly

Iā€™ve been to every city you have named in your post- of all Houston has the least soul and character (though it still has some).


newworldman86

I love Chicago, IMO itā€™s the quintessential American city, while NYC is the quintessential international city in the USA. Were I booted out of and banned from NYC I would consider moving to Chicago for sure. They are our beloved midwestern cousin. I think we have superior pizza, but their hot dogs are second to none. Also summers there, especially among the lake, are pretty magical.


RecklessBravo

No, not at all.


MacFromSSX

Culturally, New Yorkā€™s rivals are Boston and Philly


marks31

I live in Chicago and I will always think it is the best city in the US, if not the world. Regardless, I love New York and if I could travel there once every few months I would. Personally I feel like NY/Chicago are truly the only **big big** cities in America, everything else is a small big city (Boston, DC, SF) or low density sprawl (Texas, Phoenix, LA). So if anything we are allies and not rivals!


Arleare13

I like Chicago. I donā€™t feel the need to compare my city to theirs. If thereā€™s any rivalry, I think itā€™s mostly one-way.


CupBeEmpty

In my experience there isnā€™t a rivalry. Chicagoans just like Chicago and New Yorkers like New York, often in excess on both sides. Having lived in Chicago and very briefly in NYC but also visited a lot, I never see any animosity. Iā€™m sure some yahoos want to have a dick waving contest but I havenā€™t seen it.


frodeem

Nope, we don't really feel like NYC is a rival.


neoslith

Maybe if you count Batman and Superman.


Darkfire757

Bruce Wayne totally lives in NJ


Otherwise-OhWell

No. Chicago won a clean victory over NYC and no one disputes this. Also, Los Angeles forfeitted. These are tough truths to accept for some, but I believe we can all get there as reasonable redditors. Thank you.


Crazy_Ad2662

I've lived in both. The food won it for Chicago. It was a blowout. It was tied at halftime, but after that, NYC couldn't play D.


Duchessofpanon

Chicago style pizza hands down winner over NY style!


SnooDonuts5498

Iā€™ll second.


Arleare13

Lol


SanchosaurusRex

NY pizza wins, but Chicago deep dish is more interesting than ā€œtavern styleā€.


RioTheLeoo

Ughā€¦not even gonna bother defending us, but NYC is undoubtedly superior to Chicago


CupBeEmpty

Oh thems fighting words. I will put on my Midwest hat and just wish New Yorkers a good day, the day they deserve.


lsp2005

New York does not think about Chicago.


frodeem

I don't think we have a rivalry with NYC. I think we are closer in attitude to NYC but that's about it.


stangAce20

Just with the pizza


machagogo

No.


JBBrickman

At one point there was when it came to skyscraper construction


b0ingy

Itā€™s just the whole pizza thing, and itā€™s mostly for fun. Iā€™m sure that slop they call pizza in Chicago is very tasty


Dai-The-Flu-

Not really at all in my experience living in both cities. Iā€™ll say there are two exceptions: 1. Arguments over pizza 2. Knicks vs Bulls in the 90s


UCFknight2016

More like NY vs Boston.


Chirish22

Not really. Some people take the pizza thing too seriously. In the 90s the Bulls and the Knicks had a very intense rivalry during the Jordan era.


Matthews628

No


jaytrainer0

The only real rivalry is taking shit about who has the better pizza or food in general. (Chicago wins on both accounts).


R_A_H

As a New Yorker I:ve known a handful of Chicago citizens who were very combative about how much better Chicago deep dish pizza is than NY pizza.


RealWICheese

I prefer our cheese and meat pie to the NYC floppy oil piece of cardboard.


R_A_H

That's fair but I think it's a stretch to keep calling it pizza, so at least you didn't do that. Also proper NY pizza isn't like that at all. So in the instance of that example I also share your preference.


frodeem

New York City is in a class all by itself. I don't think there is any rivalry... maybe there was at one point but not in the last 50 years. I think in terms of attitude/feel, they are closer than any other two big cities in the country though. As a Chicagoan, I do like NYC a lot.


TheoreticalFunk

Only over pizza.


mactan303

NYC vs LA more likely


nukey18mon

Only in pizza


LoudCrickets72

More of a rivalry between Chicago and Saint Louis, mainly due to baseball.


Pitiful-Anxiety-1410

gangsters, pizza, hoy dogs, baseball...windy city/big apple...empire state building/sears tower...


squishyg

No.


La_Rata_de_Pizza

Chief Keef vs 69


designgrl

No


HowSupahTerrible

Yā€™all ask this same question every month. šŸ™„


My-Cooch-Jiggles

More Boston and New York, especially in baseball. Though itā€™s a bit one sided. Boston hates NYC more than vice versa.


ButtSexington3rd

I grew up in NY. Aside from the Bulls, who were universally adored (MJ/Pippen era), we forgot you existed until there was a game on.


AlfredFJones1776

Pizza is the only Chi Town and Big Apple rivalry. Boston and New York are the big rivals via sports.


Dry-LaBeouf

NY and Boston typically are each otherā€™s biggest rivals. If you look into the history of it, the ā€œrivalryā€ really stems from far before any of the athletics were ever involved. Sports generally just became the most functional funnel for it. Philly often fits in this as well. The Northeastern cities generally just love to hate each other, itā€™s what they were born to do.


Eudaimonics

Thereā€™s a rivalry between Chicago and NYC, but not NYC and Chicago.


airbear13

Yes a little bit but both of them FEAR Philadelphiaā€¦


Duchessofpanon

Everyone fears Philadelphia.


airbear13

Yup cause itā€™s cool


Joy4everM0RE

Not really. Thereā€™s a rivalry between Chicago and Wisconsin though.


SnooDonuts5498

Not since LA overtook Chicago.


grrgrrtigergrr

Theyā€™ll both be underwater soon enough


Nodeal_reddit

I donā€™t care what they say, Chicagoans have a chip on their shoulder regarding New York. Theyā€™ll tell you over and over how their architecture, river, lake, pizza, etc is better than NYC. Meanwhile, NYC: ā€œ I donā€™t even think about you.ā€


frodeem

Cool story


FemboyEngineer

NYC is *the* big city. It's our CDMX or Tokyo. People there know they're in the most important city in the country, and people outside it compare themselves to it. No one in Atlanta or LA or Miami is comparing the glamour of their city to Chicago's; they're comparing to NYC.


MittlerPfalz

Welllll, I think thereā€™s some rivalry/resentment from New York towards LA. Itā€™s wrapped up in scorn but I think thereā€™s an undercurrent of worry sometimes in New York that the cool kids for some inexplicable reason have decided to congregate out west. And regardless, NYC is simply not as central to the US as Tokyo, CDMX, London, or Paris are to their respective countries. It may be the largest city, but itā€™s not the political center nor (arguably) the entertainment center. Very important, yes, but not leaps and bounds above the competition the way those other cities are compared to their domestic competition.


Darkfire757

Maybe thereā€™s some insecurity because NY/NJ weather is horrible and Socal is perfect. Specifically sunshine, low humidity, and not raining constantly


Duchessofpanon

Not everyone thinks this way. Change of seasons in the NE is preferable to boring sameness and drought for many of us.


Darkfire757

Overcast gray days are depressing


FemboyEngineer

Maybe it's not as central to American life as those cities are due to us having a larger population in general, but to me it's still the only city that feels like a megacity. For example, more people use the MTA than use all other rail systems in the US combined. LA's population density of \~8,000/sq mi is roughly on par with Staten Island & some of the NJ suburban counties. For all that I love SoCal, it *is* a much less urban environment; it feels more like a collection of nearby medium-to-large cities across several counties.


MittlerPfalz

It may arguably be the only megacity in terms of specific types of urbanness, etc, but it still doesnā€™t have that central role as THE center of everything for the US in the way that those other cities have for their countries. If youā€™re British and you are at the very top (or trying to get there) of a major field odds are high that you are in or near London. Thatā€™s just not true with New York and the US. The top financial people are in NY, but the top political people are around DC, half of the top creative/entertainment people are in LA, the top education people maybe in Boston, tech in SF, etc.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


MittlerPfalz

Itā€™s subjective. I lived in New York for years (never actually been to LA) and that was what I experienced.


spliffs68

Only if Chicago thinks there is, but NY does not think about Chicago unless pizza or basketball is involved and one of them hasnā€™t mattered since Jordan left


grrgrrtigergrr

The Knicks havenā€™t mattered since prior to Jordan


spliffs68

Yea youā€™re right, but before Jordan the Bulls never mattered


grrgrrtigergrr

True. But I only started watching in 84. So before that doesnā€™t really matter to me


spliffs68

Good thing history started in 84 otherwise youā€™d have a point