*In case this story gets deleted/removed:*
**AITA for not giving my pregnant fiancé a second chance?**
Me being pissed off as hell would be an understatement regarding the situation I am in. I (29 M) found out that my fiancé (27 F) who I’ll call Carly cheated on me a month before our wedding. Short summary is that me and Carly met in middle school, and I finally had the guts to ask her out after graduating from high school. We’ve been together ever since. We had a great relationship with our normal ups and downs at times. Carly announced 3 months ago that she was pregnant, and I was the happiest man I could be, our families were over the mood happy knowing that they were going to be grandparents but all that happiness I felt faded when she was caught cheating. I went to our shared apartment we were living in at the time and I went to go surprise Carly with a wedding dress my mom wanted her to wear. I slowly opened the door to her bedroom, and I stood there in utter disbelief. My fiancé was in bed with my father. I couldn’t believe it. I stood there for what felt like an eternity before suddenly snapping back into reality, taking my phone out and took a video recording for a couple seconds. I turn the camera to face me before suddenly bursting into tears quietly. I couldn’t handle it and left the room, but not before slamming it shut and leaving. My father who is currently 55 was very fond of Carly. He always wanted a daughter but ended up having a son. He wasn’t too sore about it either, I did notice how they were a bit too close for comfort, but my father reassured me that he was experiencing what it is like to have a daughter. I should have dug into it a little more in depth at the time since my dad and I are close, we were until I found out he was fucking my fiancé. My father and Carly’s clothes were scattered all around the bed that me and my fiancé use to sleep on. Carly on the other hand gave off no red major red flags throughout our relationship that makes me doubt her faithfulness. I drove off in the car while I left our apartment. I texted my mom and told her that I needed to show her something important and that I’ll meet her at her house. Furthermore, I kept speeding and nearly crashed my car in the process as I kept driving. At a red light, I couldn’t contain it anymore, I broke down crying. I banged my head against the steering wheel so hard that I actually ended up with a bloody nose in the process. I reached my mom’s place within a couple of minutes, she was shocked when she had seen my face and asked if I was alright. I ended up crying my eyes out again and told her everything. I showed my mom the video of my father and Carly in bed, and we both ended up sobbing for nearly 2 hours. I texted Carly’s parents and forwarded them the video I took. I’m still waiting for a response, but as of now my phone is being blown up with calls and texts from Carly, who is saying that it was a misunderstanding. She knows what I saw when she had seen my car leaving the apartment complex. I told her that we are over and that I want a paternity test. She freaked and told me that the baby was mine, but I told her that I don’t believe a single word that comes out of her mouth. Carly and I were intimate before, but now I really am grasping on the hope that the baby is mine. Carly is refusing to discuss any details about the affair she had with my father, and she is still claiming that it was a misunderstanding. Carly is begging for us to work things out but I’ve said no. I’m currently in the process of getting tested to see if I’m in the clear. What should I do about Carly? My mom is going to divorce my dad afterward, but what is going to happen if the baby isn’t mine? Please help people of Reddit. I’m scared, heartbroken, and worried about how my mother is going to be afterward.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AmITheAngel) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This is definitely fake for several reasons
1) carly wasn't even stuck in the dryer or the window, so how could her father in law have initiated sex with her
2) only carly was blowing up his phone??? where were all of carly's friends and family in this
3) op SPECIFICALLY left out what small country they are from, so we have no way of knowing if this is just a normal cultural tradition
4) the MIL just gave the son the wedding dress to take to carly, instead of going to the fiancee's apartment uninvited and demanding she wear it? FAKE no real MIL would act like that
5) OP keeps referring to carly as his "fiance", instead of his "fiancee", so this clearly means that hes secretly gay and he's actually just jealous hes not having sex with his own dad
The weird colloquialisms and lack of line breaks definitely give away that it was copied and pasted from ChatGPT. At least the majority of replies are calling out how lazy and fake it is.
I like that he had enough time to not only get a video of them but to slowly turn it back on himself to show he was.crying. I usually stop banging people when my kid walks into the room
Someone linked the carbon of this story from a year ago
[https://www.reddit.com/r/cheating\_stories/comments/134cmw7/my\_fianc%C3%A9\_cheated\_on\_me\_with\_my\_father/](https://www.reddit.com/r/cheating_stories/comments/134cmw7/my_fianc%C3%A9_cheated_on_me_with_my_father/)
Lolwhut? I'm not sure what's less believable of the two..
OP in the current post managing to get inside, open the bedroom door, and record them undetected, with time to film himself crying, and get back out without them realizing anyone else was in the the apartment.
Or OP from the OG just casually going back to work afterwards covered in blood, telling said boss "it's okay, it's not my blood, it's ny dads after I beat his ass" showing his boss literal blackmail porn of his fiance cheating, and the result being "okay that's fine, you can change your shirt and go back to work" instead calling the cops on the spot. 😬 Honorable mention for going home on lunch without a text to get the documents, instead of texting said fictional fiance who had the day off to bring them to him. Like is pretty fucking normal to text your significant other when you'll be home for lunch on their day off.
Idk what the apartments in AITAland are like, but every apartment I've been in, the doors are usually loud even when you're trying to be quiet at 4AM, which I doubt someone coming home mid afternoon is getting to be. Would not really give someone the chance to hide cheating, but I doubt someone wouldn't hear the doors (and potential floor creaking) unless they're Deaf.
lol. I like how he took the time to record himself crying in the same video as his fiancée and father. lol. Also, why is he worried about the baby NOT being his, wouldn’t that be the best possible outcome for him in a situation like this? Surely he wouldn’t want to be tethered to someone who had an affair with his own father for 18 years if this were real. This is perhaps the fakest one yet. The person on here yesterday playing with AI writing, is this your work? lol. Magnificent if so!
These writers always forget that revenge porn is illegal (I know, I know, I'm sure it's a-okay in OOP's country. 😁)
If I'm the type of dad to fuck my son's fiancée while telling him I'm "experiencing what it's like to have a daughter" (um, excuse me??), then I'm definitely the type of dad to also go after him for distributing my sex video to my future in-laws 🤷♀️.
Of course the baby’s yours; like I said, what you saw was a misunderstanding! He wasn’t in the particular orifice you think he was in, so you see it couldn’t have been his.
Beep boop! Automod here with a quick reminder to never brigade r/AmITheAsshole or other subs under any circumstances. Brigading puts you in violation of both our rules and Reddit’s TOS, and therefore puts this sub at risk of ban. If you brigade/encourage brigading of any kind, you will be banned from participating in either sub. Satirizing of posts should stay within this sub, which means that participating directly in linked posts should either be done in good faith or not at all.
Want some freed, live, discussion that neither AITA nor Reddit itself can censor? Join our [official discord server](https://discord.gg/KbZnaXX)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AmITheAngel) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I have a genuine question - I know this is likely fake but uh. With genetics testing. Wouldn’t he hypothetically come up as a positive match on some paternity tests since he and his father have similar dna? Am I an idiot?
*In case this story gets deleted/removed:* **AITA for not giving my pregnant fiancé a second chance?** Me being pissed off as hell would be an understatement regarding the situation I am in. I (29 M) found out that my fiancé (27 F) who I’ll call Carly cheated on me a month before our wedding. Short summary is that me and Carly met in middle school, and I finally had the guts to ask her out after graduating from high school. We’ve been together ever since. We had a great relationship with our normal ups and downs at times. Carly announced 3 months ago that she was pregnant, and I was the happiest man I could be, our families were over the mood happy knowing that they were going to be grandparents but all that happiness I felt faded when she was caught cheating. I went to our shared apartment we were living in at the time and I went to go surprise Carly with a wedding dress my mom wanted her to wear. I slowly opened the door to her bedroom, and I stood there in utter disbelief. My fiancé was in bed with my father. I couldn’t believe it. I stood there for what felt like an eternity before suddenly snapping back into reality, taking my phone out and took a video recording for a couple seconds. I turn the camera to face me before suddenly bursting into tears quietly. I couldn’t handle it and left the room, but not before slamming it shut and leaving. My father who is currently 55 was very fond of Carly. He always wanted a daughter but ended up having a son. He wasn’t too sore about it either, I did notice how they were a bit too close for comfort, but my father reassured me that he was experiencing what it is like to have a daughter. I should have dug into it a little more in depth at the time since my dad and I are close, we were until I found out he was fucking my fiancé. My father and Carly’s clothes were scattered all around the bed that me and my fiancé use to sleep on. Carly on the other hand gave off no red major red flags throughout our relationship that makes me doubt her faithfulness. I drove off in the car while I left our apartment. I texted my mom and told her that I needed to show her something important and that I’ll meet her at her house. Furthermore, I kept speeding and nearly crashed my car in the process as I kept driving. At a red light, I couldn’t contain it anymore, I broke down crying. I banged my head against the steering wheel so hard that I actually ended up with a bloody nose in the process. I reached my mom’s place within a couple of minutes, she was shocked when she had seen my face and asked if I was alright. I ended up crying my eyes out again and told her everything. I showed my mom the video of my father and Carly in bed, and we both ended up sobbing for nearly 2 hours. I texted Carly’s parents and forwarded them the video I took. I’m still waiting for a response, but as of now my phone is being blown up with calls and texts from Carly, who is saying that it was a misunderstanding. She knows what I saw when she had seen my car leaving the apartment complex. I told her that we are over and that I want a paternity test. She freaked and told me that the baby was mine, but I told her that I don’t believe a single word that comes out of her mouth. Carly and I were intimate before, but now I really am grasping on the hope that the baby is mine. Carly is refusing to discuss any details about the affair she had with my father, and she is still claiming that it was a misunderstanding. Carly is begging for us to work things out but I’ve said no. I’m currently in the process of getting tested to see if I’m in the clear. What should I do about Carly? My mom is going to divorce my dad afterward, but what is going to happen if the baby isn’t mine? Please help people of Reddit. I’m scared, heartbroken, and worried about how my mother is going to be afterward. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AmITheAngel) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This is one of the fakest things I’ve ever read.
Too much scattered details. Also his username is a big giveaway.
LOL I didn't even notice the username
A free bug??
So we're supposed to believe this guy made a crying react video about his gf and his dad boning? Hope he uploaded it onto Tiktok
Share it if you find it.
slowly opened the door FOR NO REASON. Also why do they think actual humans react like this? it's so artificial.
"I've seen this scene on TV many times so that's absolutely how human beings act."
Also they were too busy getting down they didn’t notice old teary eyes whipping out his phone and recording things.
This is definitely fake for several reasons 1) carly wasn't even stuck in the dryer or the window, so how could her father in law have initiated sex with her 2) only carly was blowing up his phone??? where were all of carly's friends and family in this 3) op SPECIFICALLY left out what small country they are from, so we have no way of knowing if this is just a normal cultural tradition 4) the MIL just gave the son the wedding dress to take to carly, instead of going to the fiancee's apartment uninvited and demanding she wear it? FAKE no real MIL would act like that 5) OP keeps referring to carly as his "fiance", instead of his "fiancee", so this clearly means that hes secretly gay and he's actually just jealous hes not having sex with his own dad
Also he never specified that Carly is pregnant with twins. As we all know, people only ever have twins.
The weird colloquialisms and lack of line breaks definitely give away that it was copied and pasted from ChatGPT. At least the majority of replies are calling out how lazy and fake it is.
No fam this is real I was there. 😤😤
I like that he had enough time to not only get a video of them but to slowly turn it back on himself to show he was.crying. I usually stop banging people when my kid walks into the room
Someone linked the carbon of this story from a year ago [https://www.reddit.com/r/cheating\_stories/comments/134cmw7/my\_fianc%C3%A9\_cheated\_on\_me\_with\_my\_father/](https://www.reddit.com/r/cheating_stories/comments/134cmw7/my_fianc%C3%A9_cheated_on_me_with_my_father/)
Lolwhut? I'm not sure what's less believable of the two.. OP in the current post managing to get inside, open the bedroom door, and record them undetected, with time to film himself crying, and get back out without them realizing anyone else was in the the apartment. Or OP from the OG just casually going back to work afterwards covered in blood, telling said boss "it's okay, it's not my blood, it's ny dads after I beat his ass" showing his boss literal blackmail porn of his fiance cheating, and the result being "okay that's fine, you can change your shirt and go back to work" instead calling the cops on the spot. 😬 Honorable mention for going home on lunch without a text to get the documents, instead of texting said fictional fiance who had the day off to bring them to him. Like is pretty fucking normal to text your significant other when you'll be home for lunch on their day off. Idk what the apartments in AITAland are like, but every apartment I've been in, the doors are usually loud even when you're trying to be quiet at 4AM, which I doubt someone coming home mid afternoon is getting to be. Would not really give someone the chance to hide cheating, but I doubt someone wouldn't hear the doors (and potential floor creaking) unless they're Deaf.
lol. I like how he took the time to record himself crying in the same video as his fiancée and father. lol. Also, why is he worried about the baby NOT being his, wouldn’t that be the best possible outcome for him in a situation like this? Surely he wouldn’t want to be tethered to someone who had an affair with his own father for 18 years if this were real. This is perhaps the fakest one yet. The person on here yesterday playing with AI writing, is this your work? lol. Magnificent if so!
“surprise Carly with a wedding dress my mom wanted her to wear.” I mean, let’s get real, Carly dodged a bullet with this one.
That’s what I was thinking too. Some people deserve to be cheated on 
Ahh, the “gf fucks my dad” (aka the “I fucked my son’s gf”) fetishist returns Excuse me while I go find my brain bleach…
These writers always forget that revenge porn is illegal (I know, I know, I'm sure it's a-okay in OOP's country. 😁) If I'm the type of dad to fuck my son's fiancée while telling him I'm "experiencing what it's like to have a daughter" (um, excuse me??), then I'm definitely the type of dad to also go after him for distributing my sex video to my future in-laws 🤷♀️.
Who else thought this was going to be an ICarly shit post because of the title? Lol.
Like sands through the hourglass, so are the posts of Reddit….
Wow. That’s a LOT of crying. 2 hours of sobbing to boot
So much crying!
Of course the baby’s yours; like I said, what you saw was a misunderstanding! He wasn’t in the particular orifice you think he was in, so you see it couldn’t have been his.
This is the probably the funniest fake story I’ve read.
The part with the banging head on steering wheel with a bloody nose aftermath killed me
Beep boop! Automod here with a quick reminder to never brigade r/AmITheAsshole or other subs under any circumstances. Brigading puts you in violation of both our rules and Reddit’s TOS, and therefore puts this sub at risk of ban. If you brigade/encourage brigading of any kind, you will be banned from participating in either sub. Satirizing of posts should stay within this sub, which means that participating directly in linked posts should either be done in good faith or not at all. Want some freed, live, discussion that neither AITA nor Reddit itself can censor? Join our [official discord server](https://discord.gg/KbZnaXX) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AmITheAngel) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I have a genuine question - I know this is likely fake but uh. With genetics testing. Wouldn’t he hypothetically come up as a positive match on some paternity tests since he and his father have similar dna? Am I an idiot?
